In the discussion following last week’s Fallacy Friday topic, Ad Populum, LJ asked about the ad ignorantiam fallacy. In particular she wanted to know about its relationship to creationism. I suspect LJ was being sarcastic but despite this it is worth exploring this issue a bit.
First, we should recall that a fallacy is not simply a false position on some subject. The fact that someone expounds a mistaken view in theology, philosophy, science, law, ethics or any other subject does not necessarily mean that that person has committed a fallacy. A fallacy is a common mistake in reasoning. A fallacy occurs when one attempts to infer a conclusion from a premise in an invalid manner. I noted in Assessing Arguments that an argument can be valid even if it has false premises and false conclusions. So the fact that someone believes in or propounds contemporary evolutionary theory or creationism or something else does not, in and of itself, mean that that person has committed the ad ignorantiam fallacy.
What is an Ad Ignorantiam?
So what exactly is the mistake being made when one commits an ad ignorantiam fallacy and how does one commit it? The ad ignorantiam fallacy is as an argument from ignorance. It occurs when a person argues that a conclusion is false because no one has shown it to be true or when a person argues a position is true because no one has shown it to be false. Applied to evolution, the argument has the form:
1. No one has shown that evolutionary theory is true;
Therefore:
2. Evolutionary theory is false.
Similarly, with creationism:
1. No one has ever shown creationism is true
Therefore:
2. Creationism is false.
What the person who makes this inference fails to appreciate is that the failure to provide a reason for affirming a conclusion is not the same as providing a reason for thinking the conclusion is false. It is possible, and probably actual, that there are many things that are true which we do not yet know about. In such situations, no one will have shown these things to be true and no one will be able show them to be false yet they are true; we simply will not know that they are.
An example from history might illustrate this; consider the heliocentric hypothesis, (more…)


![Dear Sir: As a mother of nine children I would like to speak out about the draft everyone is talking about. I am one that is very much against it. I lost a husband in Korea and if they draft from age 18 to 26 I stand to loose four sons and one daughter. As a mother in poor health, I don’t think I could take that. Why can’t [The President] leave well enough alone and try and find our boys missing or being held some place? Mrs L T Dear Sir: As a mother of nine children I would like to speak out about the draft everyone is talking about. I am one that is very much against it. I lost a husband in Korea and if they draft from age 18 to 26 I stand to loose four sons and one daughter. As a mother in poor health, I don’t think I could take that. Why can’t [The President] leave well enough alone and try and find our boys missing or being held some place? Mrs L T](http://www.mandm.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/Draft.png)
