Year: 2009

  • Auckland Bloggers Bash

    The lovely Annie Fox has called for Auckland bloggers, and any others who happen to be in Auckland, to mark the first Thursday of every month in their calendars for B3 – (Bloggers Bar Bash).

    The next B3 will be on 2nd of April (my birthday!) from 6.30pm onwards at Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland.

  • A Bill to Amend the Anti-Smacking Law

    Family First have just released that a private members bill is set to go into the ballot to amend the anti-smacking law. Assuming it is well drafted, ACT’s John Boscawen is the MP parents across the country can thank.

    While we do not buy into the notion that this law should be changed because the majority want it to be (the majority agreeing with or wanting something is not, in and of itself, a good enough reason to change the law as the fact a majority support a policy does not entail that the policy is just or right; the majority can and often are mistaken) nevertheless, we do share Family First’s concerns “that parents are hugely confused over the legal effect of the law.” We also agree that “parents have a right to know whether they are parenting within the law or not.”

    The law has been made confusing by virtue of the political football this issue has become; so much disagreement as to how it applies makes relying on any one opinion risky, it doesn’t help that the law is drafted like a dogs breakfast either. These factors mean that people are unable to find out what the law actually means; hence, it becomes impossible for them to alter their behaviour to comply with the law.

    This is an unjust situation that needs rectification. Criminal laws threaten people with loss of property, liberty and parental rights if they are not complied with further they set public expectations of behaviour. To be told you must conduct yourself in terms of X or else and then not be told clearly and unequivocally what X is is unjust.

    But there is another issue which struck me yesterday; the law actually effects third parties.

    Earlier this week I was at a supermarket and I observed a woman shopping with two children. One of whom, a pre-schooler, was going out of his way to play up. I heard them coming around the aisle before I saw them as he was being loud and argumentative demanding to go home immediately and was repeatedly trying to run off. He had a big grin on his face as he loudly taunted his mum and sibling and kept wriggling to get away from his mother who was holding his hand and pushing the grocery laden trolley, with a baby in the front, with the other hand (and struggling with both tasks).

    The little boy twisted his hand out of his mother’s grasp and ran away from her laughing. She called him to come back, he yelled no, then grinned and laughed, clearly taking delight in her frustration as she said it again and he kept running.

    She had to give chase with the laden trolley and baby as he ran between two big freestanding displays. I ducked around one end in an attempt to head him off, as I knew only too well the place she was in having parented a supermarket runner of my own, but he was too quick for me.

    In the end she ran after him and I watched her baby and trolley. The whole time he was defying her requests to stop and come back and gleefully enjoying misbehaving. When she caught him she said “I told you to not run off, I asked you to come back, we have talked about this before, your behaviour is not ok” and she gave him an open handed smack right in front of me. She then finished her groceries in peace.

    The point of this story is not to make some claim that smacking is ok because it worked in this instance; such an argument is flawed for at least two reasons, first it suggests that the only relevant issue in assessing the morality of a punishment is its effectiveness, and secondly it makes a claim about a class of actions on the basis of one observed instance. I shared this story as I want to share my reaction to seeing her smack her child.

    The minute I saw her do it I knew she was breaking the law. According to the law she was engaging in assault against her child and in the absence of a defence she was legally a child abuser. Normally, when I witness someone breaking the law I feel duty bound to inform the appropriate authority; particularly if I witness assault or child abuse. However, I felt conflicted.

    I knew I was not witnessing child abuse, yet (assuming the claims about the law are correct which is a big assumption) I was not the police so it was not my place to use discretion. Further, I have strong, reasonably held objections to the law. So I chose to not report her, instead I chose to put myself in the position of failing in my civic duty to report a violation of the law.

    My point is that the law not only made the mother in this situation a child abuser but that all of us who fail to report it are like those people who know of and witness domestic violence and refuse to report it. The principles that I hold regarding my duty to report law breaking that I witness have been violated and are no longer clear despite my being certain I did the right thing.
    I look forward to reading the Bill and I congratulate Family First for keeping this issue current and John Boscawen for doing what National has not.

  • Hone’s Inconsistency

    Hone Harawira has called for the men who assaulted Prime Minister John Key to be not dealt with by the courts because the assault was minor and understandable.

    This is the same Member of Parliament who voted to criminalise parents for giving their kids a light smack who now wants adults who (allegedly) lightly assaulted the Prime Minister to not face criminal prosecution.

    One rule for citizens, one rule for relatives of MP’s.

  • Dr Matthew Flannagan on Belief without Proof

    You are invited to the next Thinking Matters Auckland seminar:

    What: Dr Matthew Flannagan speaking on Belief without Proof
    When: Tuesday 31th March – 7:00pm
    Where: Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format: Talk followed by questions, answers and discussion.
    Cost: Free!

    MattDr Flannagan will address the objection that Christianity is irrational in the absence of proof. He will unpack this claim and offer an alternative method of looking at faith and reason demonstrating that lack of evidence does not make faith in God irrational.

    Dr Flannagan holds a PhD in Theology, a Masters degree in Philosophy. His area of expertise is the interface between Philosophy and Theology, Applied Ethics and Worldviews. He is an adjunct lecturer in Philosophy for Laidlaw College, writes for the MandM blog and has nearly 15 years experience engaging and challenging secular culture both in New Zealand and internationally.

    He has formally debated the Abortion Law Reform Association of New Zealand’s Dr Zoe During and the New Zealand Association of Rationalist Humanist’s Dr Bill Cooke; he has been published in several international journals of philosophy and has a personal reference from the then President of the Evangelical Theological Society in his resume.

    Mark it in your calendar now, advertise it on your blog, tweet it and tell your friends!

  • Any Requests?

    We ponder issues to blog on that we hope you might be interested in but we would love to hear from our readers – what issues do you want to hear out thoughts on for future blogs?

  • And the 12th Most Popular Blog in New Zealand is…..

    Just spotted HalfDone’s Half-March blog stats – check out who is sitting at number 12 !!!!

    HalfDone ranks “all [New Zealand] blogs that post items interesting to the general public” and ranks more New Zealand blogs than Tumeke does.

    Of course this is not the official March result, but for MandM to have reached the position of 12th most read blog in New Zealand for the first half of March is still awesome. As we have said previously, we don’t blog simply to attain a ranking but we know that rising on the rankings shows that what we are blogging on is being well received and there is a demand for it.
    This result would never have happened without all of you – so thankyou for reading and linking and please keep doing so!
  • St Patrick’s Day: A Protestants’ Musings

    Today is St Patrick’s day. Many tonight will find themselves dressed in green, possibly slurring slightly, with a handle of green Guinness in one hand and most won’t really be certain as to why.

    Now one wonders why so many people who are not Catholic or Irish feel the need to celebrate a saint on 17 March. Some might say the cause for celebration is the excuse to consume Guiness – any excuse to drink… but the green? Who looks good in bright green and who wants to drink green food colouring?

    I thought it would be interesting to look into Patrick and see if there is something there beyond the green Guinness and the saint commemoration, which is more a Catholic thing, that protestants might find interesting.

    It was difficult to find anything concrete about the man; obviously the internet didn’t quite go back that far so I couldn’t just go and read his blog. Apparently historians haven’t fared much better as centuries of legend make sifting through the facts confusing and only two documents appear to have survived, a confession he wrote and a letter of excommunication he wrote to Coroticus.

    What does survive when one sifts through the legend and the documents is interesting.

    Patrick lived around 400 AD and when he was 16 he was kidnapped by Celts and taken to Ireland where he spent 6 years before escaping and returning to his family.

    At some point Patrick trained in the Church and then returned to Ireland as a missionary though apparently no one can associate him with any particular parish. Many accounts speak of his evangelistic approach as being that of an equal, someone who just got alongside his countrymen, rather than holding himself out as someone holding a special place in the church. It also seems apparent that he adopted Paul’s tactic of using the culture around him in his promotion of Christianity.

    St Patrick's DaySome credit him with lighting the Paschal Fire at Knowth to bring Celtic culture’s emphasis of fire together with celebrations for Easter; It is said he made the Celtic cross by combining the sun, another prominent feature of Celtic culture, with the cross. He used an object lesson of the shamrock (3-leaf clover) to explain the trinity to the then heavily Arian culture. It is also said he raised the dead, chased the snakes out of Ireland (though this could have been a metaphor for chasing the druids out instead).

    He claimed to have had visions including the one claimed as the earliest example of God having a joke with an Irishman; he claims God told him to leave Ireland (a journey of around 200 miles) and once he left he then had another vision telling him to return.

    How much is fact or fiction is historically uncertain and disputed but it all makes good legend.

    I did find it interesting to discover that originally the colour blue was associated with Patrick but around the 1750’s, probably due to the shamrock-trinity thing and Ireland’s rejection of paganism and adoption of Christianity, the association switched to green. If this is the case then protestants can wear green today without worrying about saint worship or aligning themselves with drunkeness; we can wear green to remember a man who served God and brought Christianity to pagan cultures.