Author: Madeleine

  • Bovine Faeces and the Sexual Proclivities of Rocks: We are all Selective Literalists

    Jónathan Mark Deundian sent us the following correspondence,

    You addressed the following paragraph to a blogger named RyogaM. This one and actually the one right above it was so common sensible but so completely profound. I read it to my wife and it was as if shutters fell from her eyes. Best thing since Molinism! lol

    When I looked at the exchange Jónathan referred to I realised I had not seen it before. It was buried in a pile of comments on Matt’s post, Joshua and the Genocide of the Canaanites Part II. Anyway it made me laugh so much and it was so good that I have decided it warrants its own post.

    Context is important, of course, so here we go.

    Over at Driving the Peterbilt: Bible Critique by Ryoga M, RyogaM wrote a sarcastic rendition of the battle of Gibeon, which is found in Joshua 10. Here are some highlights of that rendition:

    [Asterisks not original]

    AT GIBEON, AGAIN

    Adoni-zedek king of Jerusalem: Well, now, let’s see. I suggest we attack…holy [****]! What’s that?!

    Hoham king of Hebron: That’s a big f[***]ing rock!

    Piram king of Jarmuth: And it’s falling on our heads!

    Japhia king of Lachish: Run away! Run away!

    Debir king of Eglon: Well, this is going to suck.

    AT THE HEBREW CAMP

    Messenger: Message for Joshua!

    Joshua: Yes?

    Messenger: God has attacked with big f[***]ing rocks, sir. He’s slain them with a great slaughter at Gibeon, and chased them along the way that goes up to Beth-horon, and smote them to Azekah, and to Makkedah. he’s killed a lot of them, sir. Squished like bugs.

    Joshua: Well it’s about time he did something useful. I guess we should kill everyone left, huh?

    Joel Watts commented that RyogaM was being excessively literalistic in his reading of the text and referred RyogaM to Matt’s Joshua and the Genocide of the Canaanites series. RyogaM was not impressed he made several points of critique on his blog, which he repeated on ours. The relevant parts are below:

    The purpose of my blog is to explore what the Bible actually SAYS, not what one wishes it to say, not what one would expect it to say if one presupposes the existence of an all-knowing, all-loving, all-power god, not what one can rationalize away because the concept of slaughtering every inhabitant of a town, including every old man, woman and child, goes against every enlightenment value we have.

    And the reason I do this is because even your average, non-fundy, modern Christian takes certain parts of the Bible literally. I assume, for example, Christians take literally the idea that Jesus Christ was the son of god, that he died and rose again. Which is as equally absurd, if not even more absurd, idea, than the idea that Joshua and his people engaged in total warfare against the country he and his people invaded at the command of god. I hope, by taking the Bible literally, and pointing out why to do so is absurd, Christians such as yourself feel free to reject the entire concept of reading any part of the Bible literally and free themselves from superstition.

    Now, looking at your blog, I think you are one of those selective literalistic, Christian. You presuppose that no god who calls himself just could ever order the slaughter of innocent old men, women and children, and you are right. So, you have to assume that god didn’t really mean what he very clearly said. Then you choose other parts of the Bible which are clearly in contradiction and think it resolves the question to say it’s all hyperbole….You refuse to accept what it says on its face and instead engage in mind-reading of the authors.

    Matt’s response to these particular comments caused me to erupt into fits of laughter (and apparently caused shutters to fall from Jónathan’s wife’s eyes),

    RyogaM, you state that I am a “selective literalist” and that not even “non-fundy, modern Christians takes certain parts of the Bible literally.”I agree. I read some parts literally and other parts non-literally. That’s a sensible approach to any form of communication.

    Another sceptic told me they thought that “the Bible was bull[****], because it was full of contradictions.” No sensible person would interpret this entire passage literally, to do so would mean it would be easily refuted. One could show that most bibles are composed of thousands of pages of ink and paper. One could note that ink and paper are different substances to bovine faeces and that the term “bull[****]” is, in English, a metaphor for falsehood. Similarly, no one would interpret this passage as entirely figurative; the reference to the Bible, for example, is not a metaphor nor is the reference to contradictions.

    The sceptic is literally referring to the Bible and literally attributing contradictions to it and metaphorically describing it as bull[****] in the same sentence. A sensible interpreter who is honestly trying to interpret the sceptics’ comments will interpret “bull[****]” figuratively and the rest literally. This is for two reasons: (a) taken literally, the comment is clearly absurd and it is unlikely an intelligent person would mean it to be taken this way; (b) the word “bull[****],” in English, is a well-attested metaphor for falsehoods in contexts like this.

    These same two reasons are precisely what we see present in Joshua: (a) taken literally, the statements are absurd (they contradict the rest of the text); (b) the language is well-attested in ANE writing of this sort as hyperbole for victory.

    Most literature and communication involves both literal and figurative language and any sensible communicator will attempt to discern both. If you disagree with me then I think your own blog post is easily refuted.

    Big Rocks

    You, after all, talk in your own post about “big f[***]ing rocks.” Now this is clearly stupid, rocks cannot engage in sexual intercourse and only a complete moron with no knowledge of the sexual proclivities of rocks would say this. On the face of it, you clearly stated that rocks “f[***].” Of course I could contend (sensibly) that the word “f[***]ing” in this context should not be taken literally, that you used the word “f[***]ing” in a hyperbolic manner to emphasise the size of the rocks and the might of God. But then you are a selective literalist, you clearly do not want me to take everything on your blog as figurative. To do so would involve me “reading your mind,” it would involve me assuming you would not intend to say something obviously stupid. Seeing you think people should not do that then I have to conclude that you are a moron.

    Please learn a bit more about sexual reproduction and its relationship to rocks before you write in future.

  • “Set Forth Your Case” The Promo Video

    Here is the promo video, featuring William Lane Craig, for the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s “Set Forth Your Case” conference (one of the two conferences Matt is speaking at in Atlanta Georgia in 3 weeks):

  • Submit Now for the October Edition of the Biblical Studies Carnival

    The final call for posts for the October Edition of the Biblical Studies Carnival has gone out. You can submit your nominations by email or by commenting on the original call post at ξἐνος.

    The September Edition is here in case you want to take squiz and check out what it’s all about. There is apparently still room for more posts in every category but especially in the Old Testament category (other categories are New Testament, Systematic Theology, Christian History, Curmudgeons and Other). You can nominate other people’s posts as well your own but they must have been published during October 2010.

  • Desperately Seeking Sid

    Does anyone have a Sid the Sloth toy from the Ice Age movie series? Sid is our son Noah’s favourite character and his McDonalds Sid toy is his favourite toy.

    SidWhilst away at Mt Maunganui this weekend, Sid has vanished. He was last seen flying off the top of the 6 storey apartment building we are staying in but mysteriously he has not appeared in the landing area as he was expected to.

    Noah has Autistic Spectrum Disorder and his McDonalds Happy Meal Sid toy is his favourite toy so you can imagine how upset he is for Sid to be missing, let alone at the prospect of us driving back to Auckland tomorrow without Sid…

    Does anyone have a spare Sid toy they would be willing to part with? We are happy to pay for it, to pay for postage. Please email us if you can help.

    UPDATE:

    Sid is now found!

    I went outside and happened to glance in the leaves of nearby tree with yellow and pale green leaves and saw Sid caught up in the tree. He was very well camouflaged being yellowy-green himself.
    Major relief all round! Thanks everyone who located places we could buy a Sid, we really appreciated it.


  • Moderation

    Apologies everyone, it has become necessary to turn comment moderation on. There is a limit to how much time we want to spend removing off-topic, sexually loaded and personally abusive comments left by school-boys each day.

    We will try to clear and release comments a few times a day. I am working through my Certificate in Professional Legal Studies online at the moment so I am online a fair bit and it only takes a minute to log in here.

  • Podcasts on Christian Physicalism and The Probability of Christianity

    Matt and I have been listening to podcasts in the evening lately. These two, featuring two of our friends, who are both philosophers and bloggers, are really worth a listen.

    Glenn on Physicalism
    Glenn Peoples, of Say Hello to my Little Friend: The Beretta Blog and Podcast, recently spoke at the University of Oxford at the annual conference of the European Society for the Philosophy of Religion on the topic “Raising the Justificatory Hurdle: How to Make Sure Religion Stays Out of Politics No Matter What” and while he was there he appeared on the UK’s Unbelievable? radio show to debate the issue of physicalism with John Haldane.

    Listen to: Christian Physicalism: Do we have a soul? – Unbelievable? 04 Sep 2010

    Christians have traditionally held that humans comprise two things – a body and a soul. Christian Philosophers have written in defence of the soul against a reductive atheism that claims we are material beings alone.

    But a new movement in Christian philosophy claims that the atheists are correct, at least when it comes to humans.

    Dr Glenn Peoples is a Christian philosopher who subscribes to physicalism – that humans are only physical and they have no immaterial soul. He explains how he arrived at that view from Scripture and how he defends it philosophically, without giving up an evangelical Christian view.

    Prof John Haldane is a Christian philosopher at St Andrews University in Scotland. He believes that Christian faith and Philosophy bear witness to an immaterial soul – though his “Thomistic” view defends it differently to the prevailing trend.


    Lydia on The Probability of Christianity
    Dr Lydia McGrew, of What’s Wrong With the World and Extra Thoughts, has recently co-authored a Bayesian defence of the historicity of the resurrection in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology, and so Luke Muehlhauser, of Common Sense Atheism, interviewed her for his podcast, Conversations from the Pale Blue Dot.

    Listen to: Lydia McGrew – The Probability of Christianity – CPBD episode 071

    Lydia describes herself as ‘a homemaker and home schooling mum who does analytic philosophy in some of her spare time.’ She is very good at it, as you will quickly pick up in her discussion with Luke. They talk about, among other things:

    • The probability of the Resurrection v the probability of witchcraft at Salem and the Hindu milk miracle
    • The practice of Christian philosophy
    • The fine-tuning argument
    • God as an explanation

    Listen carefully to work out which blogger from this blog gets cited in an example 😉

  • And the Winners of the Best Biblical Blog Post are…

    The winner of the best blog post from a biblical blogger has been announced and it is a clean-sweep for the kiwis (even the nominees were all kiwis!):

    First Place: Contra Mundum: The Flat-Earth Myth – by Matthew Flannagan

    Nominated by (in order of nominations received):

    Madeleine Flannagan
    Phil Middlemiss
    Ropata

    Second Place: John Milbank’s Atavistic Orthodoxy – by Deane Galbraith

    Nominated by:

    Erepphun

    The prize for first place is a $50 USD Eisenbrauns Gift Certificate
    The prize for second place is a $25 USD Eisenbrauns Gift Certificate

    [There is also a $25 gift certificate for the nominees though I am not clear on how that works whether it is only for first place or for second too and I am not sure how the fact Matt’s piece got 3 nominations will be dealt with…]

    Well done the kiwis and thanks to all who nominated and voted.