Author: Madeleine

  • Debate ’08: Obama Girl vs Giuliani Girl

    You have to see this to believe it!

  • Fruit not Drugs?

    Today I returned from a trip to Sydney. As I exited customs and headed for my taxi I kept feeling like I had missed something, some step in security – maybe I had taken a wrong turn?

    You see when I flew to Australia I had to fill in a card answering a number of questions about what I was bringing into the country. You know the ones, you just mindlessly fill them in and get on with your trip. This time though the questions around drugs were particularly prominent for me as I had brought with me some prescription pain killers for my neck (hurt it blowdrying my hair recently – long story) and I realised I had to declare them which was a bit of a pain as I ended up getting separated from my colleagues.

    On the way home I wondered if I should just not declare them so as to not risk the separation thing again but resolved to do the right thing. Imagine my surprise on filling in the NZ entry card, as I ticked each box and came to the end having answered questions about mud and wood items and fruit only to find that there was no question about drugs at all!

    Surely they must ask me in person as I go through customs… I listened intently for my opportunity to confess to the drugs in my handbag, “No, I don’t have any fruit in my hand bag, just some eclipse mints and a biscuit I didn’t eat on the plane.” I was waived on and the next thing I knew I was outside heading for my taxi.

    The Aussies want to know about your criminal convictions and the drugs you might be carrying, the US wants to know both of the above and your Nazi party affiliations but all NZ cares about is whether you are carrying any fruit!

  • Violence is NOT a Disease.

    I am so sick of listening to everyone’s two cents of the causes of violence in our families, in our communities, sick of it because they are complicating the simple and putting band aids on broken legs.

    Responsibility for ones actions – that is what is missing in this ‘whats the cause of violence’ blather. Its not your skin colour, your culture, your colonisation, your government benefit – its your decision to put your fist in someone elses face that is the problem. Violence is a choice. People need to stop making excuses.

    All this talk of the root cause of violence is a crock. If violence has a cause, if it is some disease then actions are not free. No matter how crappy you feel, no matter how broke you are, how colonised you might be, no matter what your skin colour, no one makes you pick up your fist, you decide to do that.

    Plenty of poor, colonised, maoris on benefits do NOT beat their kids and plenty of rich, liberated, employed europeans do. The fact that there is more in one racial group than another is irrelevant. The demarcation lines need to be drawn down ethical lines and not skin colour or income type.

    Some people choose to beat their kids, other people wouldn’t dream of it no matter what – its a lack of character, a lack of responsibility, a lack of desire or inclination to do the right thing, to be the kind of parent that they know they should be.

    I don’t think many people who physically hurt the people they love actually think what they are doing is right, I would think most would know that it wasn’t even if they deceive themselves at times, but they just don’t care about doing the right thing enough to stop, seek help or control themselves.

    The solution to this problem is that people need to develop character. They need to commit to doing the right thing and to expressing censure on those who do not. Our government and our society has privatised morality and then fails to hold people properly to account – if everyone who beats a child to death was executed, if every parent found guilty law for beating their child had every one of their children taken off them and were thrown in jail for life, if people got that we took this seriously, that we expect a higher standard and that we value children it might start making a dent.

    Madeleine

  • Correspondence from Dr Bill Cooke

    I received the following last night:

    Dear Matthew

    Thank you telling your readers you apologised for not seeking my side of the story with regard to the Visiting Associate
    Professor imbroglio. I appreciate your honesty there.

    However, I was dismayed to read a new litany of innuendo about this. I am depressed that you should spend so much time on ad hominem attacks. Surely we can communicate in a more civil way?

    Having read your accusations I am not even sure what crime I am supposed to have committed this time. I am a philosopher in the same way you are. Your PhD is in theology, is it not? We are both philosophers in the sense of being interested in how the world works and seeking coherent answers. I have never made any other claim.

    I recognise fully that the Visiting Associate title was entirely honorary, and have never used it inappropriately. I have
    mentioned it on my CV and in publications written during the timespan of the Visiting Professorship. All this is perfectly normal use of a title like that. I have certainly never described myself as a Professor, let alone a Professor of Philosophy in the formal sense. And once the lifespan of the position expired, I stopped using it. Where is the crime in any of this?

    The way you spun the story allowed some of your readers (hiding behind pseudonyms) to jump to their own conclusions and decide beyond reasonable doubt as to my dishonesty.

    I’m not making any specific request of you beyond asking that this ad hominem campaign come to a close. Please,
    let us converse, and contest ideas if it comes to that. But this muck-raking is a waste of our time and does your cause little credit. We may not agree on how the world works, but that does not mean we have to dispute in an uncivil manner, does it?

    If you want to add this letter to your blog, feel free.

    Yours sincerely

    Bill Cooke

    I need to thank Dr Cooke for his civil and conciliatory tone in sending this. I will make only a couple of comments about this.

    First a clarification, Cooke notes that my PhD was in Theology that’s correct. As I note in my profile my area of specialisation within Theology is ethics and philosophical theology. These subjects are subfields of both Philosophy and Theology and hence areas where the two disciplines overlap. In this respect I am like a law lecturer who works in the area of philosophy of law, or a physicist who works in philosophy of science. Moreover, my master’s degree was in Philosophy and I have taught philosophy at both Waikato and Otago University and my PhD thesis was on a Philosophical topic and examined by Philosophers.

    This aside however, I agree with Cooke that dialogue between evangelical theologians (like myself) and Humanists (like him) should be civil and not a series of ad hominem arguments and muck raking. The reason I posted on the whole “professorship issue” was because I perceived the debate was not being conducted in this way. A few years ago NZARH published a newsletter, which was circulated in the media, this letter stated following “We will pass over Flanagan’s rather odd notion of the ‘law of nature;’ he is, after all, a PhD candidate in Theology, not a real subject like Law or Biology”. This was an unprovoked attack upon my academic credentials. NZARH also published attacks on Bernie Oligvy because he used the term Dr and yet only had an honorary doctorate and NZARH attacked Maxim because one of its members engaged in plagiarism. I could cite other examples.

    The point I wanted to make regarding these comments was that if this line of argument is valid (which it is not) then Cooke’s claim to being a professor and Litterick’s continual reliance on the research of Craig Young provide an argument for rejecting the position of NZARH. I was reluctant to post any more on this question and only did so because one of Cooke’s supporters stated I was “a cheap blogist who has disinterest in nor sought counter argument in defence of cheap accusations that fact would spoil his pitch” when I did not respond to Cooke’s counter argument .

    Cooke however clarifies his position, he is a religious historian with an interest in the philosophical debate regarding religion and he has received an honorary professorship and never been on faculty. Moreover, he like I, is committed to civil dialogue and is interested in discussing issues of philosophy and religion. In light of this I will take up his offer and post no more on the issue of his professorship. I hope that under Cooke’s guidance NZARH will lay off similar attacks against me and other Christians . I look forward to dialogue with NZARH on these more civil terms in the future.

  • Not Madeleine Setchell

    I wish to clarify that I am not Madeleine Setchell.

    My maiden name is Richards.

    Apparently, after I commented on kiwiblog the other day under my usual posting name which is simply ‘Madeleine’ a lot of people jumped to the conclusion that I must be the Madeleine in the story. Whilst there have been instances of David Benson-Pope lying about his staff doing things he in fact did involving me, I am not the Madeleine in the current instance of his fabrication.

    It should have occurred to me to post as ‘Madeleine Flannagan’ in this instance as the leap is a rather obvious one to make – apologies for the confusion – its just that as a ‘Madeleine’, I am not used to being confused with other people, I have met very few Madeleine’s in my life so it simply did not occur to me.

  • Benson-Pope – Lousy Staff or Just a Liar?

    Here is a list of the instances I can recall where Benson-Pope has blamed one of his staff members for something he did:

    • Leaked content of Police Report over Tennis Ball saga – staff member leaked it without his knowledge. (Later turned out it was with his permissison/instruction)
    • Having the police collect a $35 cleaning bill – staff member went to police and made request without his knowledge. (Official Information Act request showed his signature on the police forms)
    • Playing a part in ending Madeleine Setchell’s employment – staff member made calls without his knowledge. (Turns out he forgot that he did intervene)

    Are there any more?

    Benson-Pope clearly has really crappy staff.

  • Benson-Pope

    Benson-Pope is someone that the more closely you observe him the more his slimy, smarmy, bullying, bullet-dodging just pisses you off.

    Until recently I used to live in Dunedin so I have had a few encounters with Mr Benson-Pope a.k.a. panty slut boy and have crossed swords with him politically and know other people who have too. I find him an unpleasant person and a liar.

    The hit he has taken is well deserved. About time. But what annoys me is that he escaped just desserts over so many other issues. But oh well, at least this hit didn’t bounce off.

    The beehive website is not up with the play though cause they still have him on their site as a Minister.

    Interestingly Ian Wishart has re-released his findings on Benson-Pope’s involvement in the Dunedin Bondage and Discipline scene with the rather interesting addition:

    “[Benson-Pope] went to the trouble of ringing a senior Otago Daily Times journalist at home that evening, expressly to ensure that the newspaper was not quoting him as denying the story. “

    This was always a story I felt certain should have had a lot more air time by the media than it did.

    It had the now familiar to us all ring of Benson-Pope’s dodging the truth.

    Add to that our own experience of Benson-Pope’s lies. He told the media when he used the police to collect a $35 cleaning bill (the police were his first line of request for this bill – most people would use a 45c stamp first…) that it was not him who utilised police resources as his personal debt collection service but his secretary without his permission (sound familiar?). In fact when we used the official information act to get the files on this incident whose signature was on the request to the police to do the debt collecting? NOT his secretary’s but his!