Tag: Aspergers Syndrome

  • Bullying Update

    For those of you following our bullying issue you will be pleased to know that we have finally withdrawn Christian from his school and today he started at a new school with a very tough bullying policy. It has been a very difficult time as we have navigated the issues and helped Christian, who has Aspergers Syndrome, to come to a place where he felt he could cope with change on top of being serially bullied and often let down by his teachers failure to protect or seek justice for him.

    While our preference was that he would come home and be home schooled this was not what he wanted and as he is 14 we felt it was important he got some say in what form his education took. His new school has been really understanding of his fear of change and have allowed him visits to the school to get his head around the concept of moving, so hopefully this is the beginning of a new chapter for him.

    This morning after I dropped him off I headed to his old school with his textbooks, his library books and a letter for the principal and a lengthy formal complaint for the Board of Trustees. Thus begins the formal battle – though hopefully it will not be a battle and we will get the refund of his fees that we have asked for and they will formulate an effective bullying strategy for the sake of their current students.

    Now that we have the complaint written and Christian installed in his new school, we hope to start picking up the pieces of our lives, including this blog which we have neglected somewhat this month. Apologies for their being no Sunday Study yesterday – Matt just could not get to it as we had so much we had to get done this week for Christian and then Matt had to drive to Tauranga for a one week intensive last night and won’t be back until Friday. Hopefully things will be back to normal here at MandM soon!

  • Good Friday: Why Celebrate Easter?

    Good FridayLast Sunday Christian, my eldest son, asked me “what is the point in baptism?” In the ensuing conversation it became clear that his real struggle was with the idea of ‘ritual ceremony’ and the symbolism involved.

    Christian has Aspergers Syndrome and is quite literal (which is is a typical Aspie trait). Ceremonies  are often metaphorical; symbols are repeated each time the ritual is enacted. Symbols have meaning only because they point to something literally correct that they symbolise. If this is the case, Christian would ask, why not just grasp the literal reality? Why go through all the bother of a symbol and a ritual? In the case of baptism, why not just live a life of repentance, faith and piety? Why do you need to have an elaborate ceremony symbolising cleansing, death Resurrection and new life? Can’t I just be a Christian?

    “For a brief moment it was like I could directly experience or perceive something of the glory of God and the deep cosmic significance of Christ’s death.”

    Christian’s observations came back to me strongly yesterday. For the last four weeks I have been teaching Ethics and Introduction to Philosophy for the religious studies faculty at St Peters College. This is part of my teaching diploma. I have to work in unpaid for a period of time so I can ‘learn the ropes.’ During the free periods I have tried to focus on research and publishing in various areas of the relationship between religion and morality (something readers of this blog will know is a keen interest of mine). My day, then, has been focused on teaching philosophy and ethics to college aged students (US readers note that ‘college’ in this New Zealand context means high school) and researching and writing for my field. At the days end I have been coming home and blogging, often on the same topics.

    Yesterday the head of faculty at St Peters invited me to go to the annual St Peters Easter liturgy. As a Protestant working at a Catholic College it is not compulsory for me to attend. However, he thought I might like to see how the college celebrates Easter. I stopped my writing for an hour and went down to the assembly hall to watch the liturgy. Much of it was traditional Catholic veneration of the cross, I should note that Anglicans do this as well, thrown in with some time of meditation and reflection on the passion of Christ. Now as a Protestant I have qualms around veneration of objects and symbols such as the cross; however, in the middle of the meditation I was struck again, as I am almost every Easter, with the reality of the events these rituals reflect on. For a brief moment it was like I could directly experience or perceive something of the glory of God and the deep cosmic significance of Christ’s death.

    This was not just the abstract grasping of true propositions about God and Christ, though this is certainly a valid part of it. It was deeper; one becomes consciously aware of the reality in a manner in which one can almost literally feel it. Rudolph Otto described such experiences as the sense of the numinous. There is a sense of awe, mystery, majesty, involved one becomes entirely quiet and almost sad yet the experience is one that is deeply attractive and compelling, one that you would not mind continuing for a significant length of time.

    Easter SundayFrom my late teens through to now I have had moments like this when the reality of God has become apparent and sometimes I have had literally hours where I have simply been struck with the awesome, majestic awareness of a sacred presence brooding all around me, one calling me towards a goal which I cannot see and yet am aware is there and also one that speaks to me out of the historical events of the death and Resurrection of Christ. It struck me at the time that this is why ritual is important. As an excessively cerebral person (or at least this is how one of my thesis supervisors once described me) Christianity can become simply an intellectual project, a research program where I simply expound and defend a philosophy. Rituals force me to focus and refocus over and over again on the realities behind what I do. Rituals force one to quiet one’s soul and really reflect at a level beyond the mere intellectual. It strikes me, also, that rituals like baptism are powerful because they engage the full senses. One sees, hears, there are dramatic symbols that one can use as opposed to mere abstract concepts.

    There is also an important time factor. One can draw a line in the sand and say here and now at this point in time I have committed to this. This is evident perhaps clearest in marriage. One could simply make an implicit commitment to be in an exclusive monogamous relationship with a member of the opposite sex and I think in principle this could constitute a valid marriage. However, the symbolism where you decide that today, at this time, you will make the commitment publicly before witnesses who will hold you accountable to that decision – accompanied by the symbolism of rings, an aisle, veils, etc – all these things, especially when the symbolism is interpreted correctly by those engaging in it, make the commitment that much more more powerful.

    A whole host of factors, visual, intellectual, social, are brought in and focused in one time and place enabling the event to be invested with a solemnity that is appropriate for its nature. My experience yesterday at St Peters reminded me vividly of the importance of rituals at a time like Easter.

    God created us as intellectual beings and one of my biggest criticisms of New Zealand evangelicism is the intellectual and cultural mediocrity which it often triumphantly celebrates in the name of “being a heart Christian” or in the name of a superficial emotional and devotional piety. But God also created us holistic persons with a mind, emotions and a will. We need time regularly to refocus ourselves and orientate our entire person on the realities on which our faith is founded. Some people with autism or Aspergers Syndrome may perhaps have a special gift whereby their whole person can be focused with just their intellectual awareness but most people are not like this.

    For myself, a philosopher/theologian whose faith is undeniably at times quite intellectual, this is the real value of Easter. Once a year there is a time when everything stops and there is time to focus, meditate and reflect with the whole person on what is central. While, I do not accept some aspects of the Catholic rituals I saw on Thursday the realisation of this need, the importance of ritual and repetition that engages the whole person, is the real strength of Catholic spirituality – one that Protestants can and should learn from and often neglect to their detriment.

  • In Dread Response, Misheard Lyrics and our son Christian

    On the video box of the Bebo page of the lead vocalist of New Zealand band In Dread Response, there currently features an animated You Tube clip, made by our son Christian, for the lyrics of Scarecrows in the Sky.

    Christian has Aspergers Syndrome and sees things very literally which makes his interpretation of the lyrics to this song particularly funny (even though there were one or two frames where he got a parental glare – he is 14).

    While In Dread Response is not the sort of music I want my teenagers listening too (gosh I sound like my parents), I can see the appeal of this song as the lyrics are kinda crazy and knowing Christian’s sense of humour, I can see why he chose it to work with (he makes a lot of animations). It is nice to know the band appreciated his work enough to display it on their page.

  • Bullying and Aspergers

    Bullying is something so pervasive in our society that almost everyone has some experience with it. As such, I was not surprised to read a Family First release claiming that New Zealand kids almost top the world in the most bullied stats, suffering bullying at a rate of almost 50 per cent above the international average. The release refers to a Herald article on the report at the source of the stats and touches on some of the strategies schools are adopting to overcome bullying and the criticisms the new government minister, Anne Tolley, has made of them;

    The previous Government has made half-hearted attempts at addressing the issue, with a series of checklist cards released last year. But it’s action we need. And holding up a card while you’re being bullied – well, that’s not going to work.

    All year we have battled bullying as our 13 year old son, Christian, has completed his first year in high school. Christian has Aspergers Syndrome and has a very high IQ when it comes to analytical and spatial reasoning, genius level – he is amazing, but struggles with what he calls “the irrational and inconsistent way adults relate to each other.” The textbooks say he has a ‘social disability so struggles with social issues’ but having raised Christian I am not sure that “disability” is the right term, I would say he is just more perceptive than most of us.

    When he was 4 he asked me why adults lie to each other so often. I asked him what he meant and he said that they say they like someone’s dress or their cooking but they don’t really. He explained, that when someone gives him a present for Christmas and they ask him if he likes it he gets in trouble if he tells them he doesn’t, that it is a dumb present.

    Further, when you go to someone’s house for dinner you always ask what you can bring even though you know that they will answer they don’t want you to bring anything. When you get to dinner you offer to clear away the dishes and to wash them but you know when you offer that they will tell you not to. Your offers are token gestures that you don’t really mean and worse than that, every adult you say them to also knows you don’t really mean them because they know that you know that the correct answer is to refuse the offers of help but if you don’t offer you are not a good guest. Why is it good manners to lie and pretend to be sincere? Isn’t telling the truth more important than hurting someone’s feelings or not being a good guest?

    Christian gets bullied because he is different and at times annoying to the other teenage boys he goes to school with; he finds teenagers as frustrating to understand as most adults do and often says things deliberately designed to expose the stupidity of their reasoning and he still has not mastered a good way to express frustration publicly, so he can make irritating noises at times when he is not sure how to respond appropriately.

    His take on the anti-bullying strategies the ministry has in place is perceptive. During children’s programming after school there are TV commercials about bullying put out by whichever government Anne Tolley was referring to. Christian says of them:

    The ads on TV tell you what bullying is and that you should not have to put up with it, but what they should be doing is telling people not to bully in the first place. Their focus is wrong.

    Christian has made the same observation and criticism of his school’s attempts to manage the bullying he has suffered all year. The school’s focus was all about what Christian could do to minimise the bullying. Yes, he is annoying and he should work on that and yes strategies should cut both ways; Christian accepted all this but he still felt that the primary focus should be on the unacceptability of the behaviour.

    Christian was not bullied as horrifically as the cases that make the news but this year he has been hit, shoved, knocked to the ground, attacked with a screw driver, shoved into a wall, been surrounded by a group of kids unable to escape, had his property taken, been made the butt of school jokes and filmed on someone’s cell phone camera having his pants pulled down which led him to weeks of internet searching after school for the footage. He has come home with cuts, bruises and has lived in fear of returning to school and with self-doubt. Yet no one got stood down or expelled for hurting him all year and to our knowledge, no one’s parents were contacted over their treatment of him. There were very few repeat offenders over the year, it was more there was a culture of bullying that many kids engaged in.

    The school, following the ministry’s guidelines, instead had multiple meetings with us and worked hard with their staff putting strategies to protect Christian in place – they even waived their policy of waiting for a year of knowing the child and put him in one of the top streams mid-year after I suggested that the brighter kids might not respond with their fists so readily. The kids did get detentions, were talked to and told off and made to apologise and most did not re-offend against Christian but none of these, we and Christian felt, were sufficient consequences as none of them countered the culture problem the school and Christian faced.

    What we want is an end to the focus on what the victim should be doing and the need to understand the bully and a return to the message that bullying is unnaceptable and will not be tolerated. Zero tolerance sends a very loud and clear message but zero tolerance is not govt approved. Let’s hope that that changes under National.

  • Home Education

    Recent reports of parents being jailed for home schooling their children in Germany have made me think how greatful I am for our government (a rather rare moment).

    Six years ago we removed our children from school and began home educating them. We did this because at the time our eldest son who has Aspergers Syndrome was not coping with school and school was not coping with him. The RTLB’s solution was to assign him a teacher aid who basically took him into the library where Christian would roll around the floor all day. By age 8 Christian could not really read, refused to write and never drew pictures.

    Knowing that Christian was bright, the children’s psych department had tested his IQ and told us he scored in the genius range, we were not happy with this at all. Equally we were not happy that our eldest child, Sheridan (then 11), was often pulled out of her class to calm Christian down because she was the only one in the school who could; she was be teased horribly for having the retard brother. Christian would hide in his wardrobe and quietly cry after school about how bad he was. He was horrified at his own behaviour and quite depressed. Sheridan developed an eating disorder. It was heartbreaking to watch. So, to the horror of the psychiatrist, psychologist, RTLB and our family members who were state school teachers (but I suspect to the relief of Christian’s teachers) we removed Christian and Sheridan from school and began home educating them.

    What about their social skills? Someone with Aspergers desperately needs social interaction. How will you teach them science and maths and english at high school level? How will you cope having these apparently difficult and irritating children around you 24/7?

    We didn’t know the answers to those questions when we first began but we knew that we would find them. All we knew for sure was that the situation at school was doing far more harm than good and that our children needed their parents.

    The home education community told me to give both kids a break of at least 6 months to recover, that many peer reviewed studies show that it only takes 2-4 years to learn enough to enter life. I thought they were insane. Both kids were “behind” so I did not listen to begin with.

    For the first 6 months Sheridan acted like she was in state of relief, liked she had survived a near miss. I had not fully appreciated the stress she was under at school until I pulled her out. She threw herself into all the work I set her and never looked back. However, Christian would scream and throw his work accross the room if I asked him to do anything and seemed to be going backwards so I decided to take the home educator’s advice.

    They said to limit his TV and computer time and to make sure that I read to them and talked to them and did fun learning actitivities with them where I integrated learning into life experiences. Pretty soon car trips would involve discussions about the different cloud formations we could see and the purposes of farming and forestry. Shopping would see me getting the kids to help calculate the discount in percentage off sales and I would have them calculate the best value in terms of price and quantity in the supermarket. I began to notice that Christian was trying to read billboards and would say things like “oh, now I know what that word looks like written down.” Sheridan’s eating disorder disappeared as we worked through the latest studies in nutrition.

    Christian had begun reading thin books with pictures but would not progress to chapter books. One night Matt pulled out the Magician’s Nephew, first book in CS Lewis’s Narnia series, and read the first chapter. In typical Asperger style Christian appeared to not have been paying attention at all but we knew by then to ignore that and hope that he was. We put the kids to bed and watched a movie. As we were tidying up the kitchen and locking up, Christian walked into the lounge with the Magician’s Nephew in his hand, he said, “I’ve just finished it.” From there we couldn’t keep his head out of books.

    We went on from there to develop our home education method in the following way, borrowing from the Trivium. Up til age 10 we encourage phonics based reading, basic facts in maths and critical thinking/logic and we foster a love of learning accross a broad range of subjects by talking to them about it and reading to them about it and doing practical things like science experiments. We also teach them to ask questions and how to find out the answers. We work with the child’s readiness and we do not stress if they are 8 and cannot read. The term “behind” is not used. We find that the kids will spontaneously write stories and push themselves.

    Between 10 and 12 we get them doing some written work, we focus on punctuation and sentence structure and we begin to really up the logic/critical thinking stuff and we start doing maths exercises written down. We teach them how to find answers from primary sources and encourage them to read widely and all sides of a position. No other subjects are formally covered beyond English, Maths and Critical Thinking/Logic. Our phisosophy is that if you can structure and understand an argument and can clearly express yourself and you know how to research you can study anything.

    By 13, if they want to, they can choose 1 or 2 other subjects that they find interesting. We found with both our teenagers that they had gravitated towards different subjects anyway; Sheridan is into Ancient History/Archeology and Biology and Christian is into Computer Animation and Science.

    Since moving to Auckland we have put 3 of our kids back into school. As Matt’s mother was dying we needed the babysitting that school afforded and now as we both work we can really only have Sheridan at home as she is very self-motivated and will go through her work on her own whereas Christian, being Aspergers, likes his days to be structured by someone else and the other two children are too young to be home alone anyway. Hopefully in the near future we will be in a financial position to remove them all from school again but in the meantime school is it.

    This is where each of them are at currently:

    Noah, aged 6, has struggled to settle into school, he really is not a kid for whom school is a good option as he is a bit of a rascal and like a lot of boys he has taken a while to be ready for school but he is a very bright kid whose curiousity constantly has him in trouble and now his reading is coming on (thanks to us pulling our phonics readers out and largely ignoring the ‘guess it from the pictures books’ the school sends home).

    Brittany, aged 8, was promptly put up a class where she is the youngest in the room. She too is a deep thinking, bright cookie. She has settled well and is the sort of kid who settles easily into any environment.

    Christian, aged 13, is academically doing very well. We received a letter home from his science teacher informing us that after exams he was the top student in his form. His maths teacher tells us he has to set Christian harder work than the rest of the class and he is doing great in art and technology and in his other subjects. The guidance counsellor is incredibly impressed with his social skills as he is now well ahead on that score than most Aspergers kids his age.

    Sheridan, turned 16 in May (the only one still homeschooled), has just this week been accepted by Auckland University despite her lack of NCEA or Cambridge qualifications. She will complete a foundation certificate and then go on to do an undergraduate degree. As she is really into Ancient History and Archeology so a BA seems to be the way to go but she really enjoys Biology too so she may do a double degree.

    We turned to home education not because we wanted to shut our kids away from the world, far from it. We always believed that home education was the superior form of education because it meant you could open the world up to your children, that due to the one on one nature of home education you could really help your children learn at a pace suitable to their ability and to a depth that the dumbed down education system in NZ just does not go to.

    When the education system failed out special needs child (though Aspergers is really more of a gift than a disability) we were able to step in an help him to excel. I am horrified to think that families who observe their children stuggling with the school system or who have bright kids that the school system does not cater for enough do not have the option in Germany to assist their children. Worse of all though is the blatent disregard for human rights that the German government is exercising in denying parents the right to educate their children.

    Madeleine