Tag: David Farrar

  • The Theology of the Declaration of Independence

    As I write this it is just beginning to be the 4th of July in the United States now, though its been 4th July for some time here in New Zealand.

    The 4th of July is, of course, Independence Day. Typically in New Zealand, those members of the secular blogosphere, who consider themselves to be classical liberals, have an annual rant on the 4th of July about the Declaration of Independence, praising the philosophy expounded in this document.

    Declaration of IndependenceNot PC’s Peter Cresswell, for example, states in Happy July 4th! that “with the exception of just a few words, the words could hardly be bettered today;” the declaration is, “A wonderful, wonderful anthem to freedom that rings down through the years.”  He bemoans, “if only the real meaning of those words could be heard and understood.”

    A few years ago Kiwiblog’s David Farrar made similar claims, he stated he would often “marvel at those marvelous words, written in the heat of oppression…Marvelous, absolutely marvelous.”

    I agree. I would simply point out to my secular, liberal, country-men what the words in this document actually say, and some of the philosophical ideas they expound.

    First, the declaration refers to God; it does so four times. Maverick Philosopher has an excellent analysis of the theological content;

    In the initial paragraph, we find the phrase “…Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God….” This phrase rules out pantheism: God is distinct from Nature. In the second paragraph, there is the phrase, “…endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights….” Putting these two references together, we may infer that the God being referred to is not merely a deistic initiator of the temporally first segment of the physical universe, but a being involved in the creation of the human race. For if God endowed human beings with rights, this endowment had to occur at the time of the creation of human beings, which of course occurred later than the beginning of the physical universe. In traditional jargon, God is a creator continuans rather than a mere creator originans. He is not a mere cosmic starter-upper, but a being who is continuously involved in maintaining the universe in existence.

    …

    The other two references are in the final paragraph. There we find the phrase, “…Supreme Judge of the World for the Rectitude of our Intentions….” near the beginning of the paragraph, and near the end, “…a firm Reliance on the Protection of divine Providence….” Now if God is the Supreme Judge, then he is more than a mere metaphysical cause responsible for the universe’s beginning to exist; he is also the supreme moral arbiter. And since he endows human beings with rights, as opposed to being merely a judge of rights antecedently possessed, then it seems we may infer that God is the source of moral distinctions (as opposed to a mere judge of them).

    The reference to divine providence is further evidence that the conception of God in the Declaration is non-deistic. For if God provides and protects, then God has an ongoing involvement with the world and its inhabitants such as would be ruled out by a deistic view. It should also be obvious that talk of providence (from the Latin, pro-videre) implies divine foreknowledge which implies intelligence and perhaps omniscience on the part of the deity. The God of the Declaration is not a blind metaphysical cause posited to explain why the universe began to exist, but a being with such attributes as moral goodness and intelligence…. So if by ‘deism’ is meant the doctrine that God is a mere metaphysical cause of the universe’s beginning to exist who is thereafter uninvolved in its continuing to exist, then the God of the Declaration is non-deistic.

    Second, the declaration claims that belief in a creator is self-evident; that is, it is a properly basic belief, which is rationally acceptable to hold in the absence of any proof.

    We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.

    Third, the declaration makes political pronouncements about public policy on the basis of these theological claims and expects these pronouncements to be taken seriously.

    Fourth, the declaration says that various rights, such as the right to life and liberty, are unalienable. That is, a person cannot alienate one’s life or freedom as they can legally alienate a piece of property. You can’t take my property if I do not consent to you having it but if I do consent, you can take it; property is alienable, life and liberty are not. The argument of the declaration reflects John Locke’s argument in the Second Treatise of Civil Government;

    To understand political power right, and derive it from its original, we must consider, what state all men are naturally in, and that is, a state of perfect freedom to order their actions, and dispose of their possessions and persons, as they think fit, within the bounds of the law of nature, without asking leave, or depending upon the will of any other man.[1]

    …

    But though this be a state of liberty, yet it is not a state of licence: though man in that state have an uncontroulable liberty to dispose of his person or possessions, yet he has not liberty to destroy himself, or so much as any creature in his possession, but where some nobler use than its bare preservation calls for it. The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one: and reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions: for men being all the workmanship of one omnipotent, and infinitely wise maker; all the servants of one sovereign master, sent into the world by his order, and about his business; they are his property, whose workmanship they are, made to last during his, not one another’s pleasure[2]

    …

    This freedom from absolute, arbitrary power, is so necessary to, and closely joined with a man’s preservation, that he cannot part with it, but by what forfeits his preservation and life together: for a man, not having the power of his own life, cannot, by compact, or his own consent, enslave himself to any one, nor put himself under the absolute, arbitrary power of another, to take away his life, when he pleases. No body can give more power than he has himself; and he that cannot take away his own life, cannot give another power over it.[3]

    The point here is that because your right to life and liberty are from God, no one can legitimately enslave or kill you, even if you consent to it. This was not a mere incidental addendum idea, it was central to Lockean political philosophy, which maintained (as the declaration does) that the government derives its powers from the consent of the governed. If a person can consent to be killed or enslaved then they can consent to the government enslaving them also to having the arbitrary power to kill them and hence tyranny can be legitimate. The reason tyranny is illegitimate is because, “No body can give more power than he has himself; and he that cannot take away his own life, cannot give another power over it.”

    The declaration then makes a metaphysical claim: God exists. It makes an epistemological claim about faith and reason: that belief in God is rational independent of proof. It makes an implicit claim of political philosophy: religion is not a private thing that should not influence public life but rather, theological claims should influence public life. Finally it makes a moral claim; that consenting adults do not have a right to do whatever they like with their own bodies, rather there are “Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God” that bind all human beings, that they are compelled to follow even if all parties consent otherwise. Governments are legitimate to the extent in which they respect these laws.

    I agree with PC, it is hard to improve on this philosophy; I have defended it in several places on this blog.

    Ironically, however, the militant secular liberals in NZ who parrot the declaration seem committed to attacking these ideas and rejecting them on every point. They argue that belief in God is irrational because it cannot be empirically proven, they claim that the public square should be secular, that religion should be private and not influence public policy and they argue that liberty means consenting adults can do whatever they like with their own bodies and lives. Far from being unalienable, a person’s life and freedom is his property to alienate as that person sees fit.

    It is also hard to disagree with PC’s sentiments that the declaration is “A wonderful, wonderful anthem to freedom that rings down through the years. If only the real meaning of those words could be heard and understood.” “Indeed, if only.”

    [1] John Locke Second Treatise of Civil Government Section II 4.
    [2] Ibid II6.
    [3] Ibid IV 23.

  • Mentionables

    Flat out busy as the end of semester approaches and deadlines and exams loom we thought we’d link to some blog posts we’ve recently found interesting rather than actually write anything ourselves:

    Wintery Knight has a video for which his blog post title sums up the content: MUST-SEE: Megyn Kelly of Fox News exposes the truth about ACORN

    Cactus Kate has posted one of the more sensible yet moving blog posts we’ve read on the Samoa Tsunami: It’s A Long Way Back – Alofa Samoa

    Bethyada posts a timely quote from Cicero: Random quote

    The Prosblogion’s account of a recent conference at the University of Notre Dame where leading theistic philosophers and leading sceptics discussed hard texts from the Old Testament and their relationship to theistic belief: Thoughts from the Notre Dame conference, “My Ways Are Not Your Ways”

    Kiwiblog has an excellent piece on Voluntary Student Membership responding to Jacinda Arden’s account of what happened at Waikato University when membership of the campus students association briefly ceased being compulsory. Given that Matt and I were President and Vice-President respectively of the then voluntary Waikato Students Union and helped to make it voluntary, we are very glad to see that the facts are being put straight faster than the left can invent new fantasies on blogs other than our own: Fisking Jacinda

  • ACORN, Planned Parenthood and the Power of One (Well Two Really)

    When the officials don’t care or are turning a blind eye and the media are not interested, the average citizen can feel a bit powerless in the face of injustice and corruption at the state level. One often wonders what one do do? In the age of the blogger it turns out one can do quite a bit actually.

    Some of you might have followed the ACORN controversy in the US. ACORN is an acronym for the Association of Community Organisations for Reform Now; it is a liberal left advocacy group that has advocated in favour of gun control, better housing, assistance for hurricane Katrina and has endorsed Democratic Candidates including Barack Obama. Controversially it pushed for voter registration and has been associated with some scandals involving voter fraud in support of democratic candidates. It also held a lucrative state contract helping economically disadvantaged people into their own homes. It was this service that was at the centre of the controversy; a controversy that has seen ACORN lose much of its state funding at the hands of two bloggers and a video camera.

    The Washington Times summed it up nicely,

    Do you think your tax dollars should be used to help those who want to open a house of prostitution [note: illegal in the US] and illegally bring underage girls into the United States as “sex workers”? As you may have seen on television over the last few days, the taxpayer-funded ACORN (Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now) has been doing just that.

    Who exposed this latest bit of corruption at ACORN? — The FBI? The local police? A congressional investigating committee? The mainstream media? No, no, no, no. It was a 20-year-old-girl named Hannah Giles and a 25-year-old law student and investigative journalist named James O’Keefe. [The bloggers]

    The article went on,

    Ms. Giles suggested to Mr. O’Keefe that she pretend to be a prostitute and that he play the part of her pimp to see if ACORN would help them set up a house of prostitution. Mr. O’Keefe liked the idea and agreed to work with Ms. Giles.

    Using a hidden mike and camera, they first went to the ACORN office in Baltimore, and were quite stunned that the ACORN officials offered to help them — even though they made it very clear that they wanted to set up an illegal house of prostitution and bring in underage girls from Central America to work in the house. (The video tapes of their meetings in ACORN offices can be found on www.biggovernment.com.)

    Emboldened by their first success and wanting to make sure the Baltimore ACORN office was not a fluke, they then went to ACORN’s office here in the District, then to Brooklyn, San Bernadino, Ca., and other cities around the country. They were given detailed legal instructions on how to avoid problems with the police and tax authorities while running an illegal operation in each location, and even made other offers of help. They funded all of their travel and other expenses out of their own pockets without any organizational support.

    Lawyers, who have reviewed the tapes, believe the ACORN officials may have violated dozens of laws and regulations, and perhaps even the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) statutes against racketeering …

    The full transcripts of this investigation are here and are worth a read as the ACORN staff members are caught giving all sorts of advice as to how to break the law and cheat the state scheme. The pair broke the story on their blog and initially it looked like it was going to flop because ACORN ran with the hang-the-staff-member-out-to-dry-routine, you know ‘that staff member was new,’ ‘they don’t represent our law abiding position,’ ‘that’s not how our trained staff operate’ and so on.

    Smartly the pair had not played their full hand; they had only released the footage of the first sting, so they were able to respond with the ‘oh really’ routine, releasing the next lot of footage from the next office and then the next and the next and so on, systematically destroying ACORN’s credibility. The upshot was a huge controversy and ACORN lost most of their funding and suffered a major setback. Score one for the bloggers and the taxpayers.

    What I found interesting when I first heard about it from David Farrar at last weeks bloggers drinks is that the story seemed familiar. It reminded me of the sting Matt referred to in Genocide ! Who Cares? Tell them about Crazy Falwell and Tinky Winky, a post he wrote about a year and a half ago.

    In that story, a couple of student journalists did an investigation into Planned Parenthood to see if they would accept donations for abortions that were earmarked by race on racist grounds. They chose to do this because they had read up on Planned Parenthood’s eugenicist founder Margaret Sanger and had heard the claims floating around to this day that the organisation still secretly has a eugenicist agenda.

    They phoned several Planned Parenthood offices, spoke to a range of staff in authority, they  asked if they could make donations specifically to help black women obtain abortions as they wanted to “lower the number of blacks in America”, “to reduce the number of black babies”, to “fight affirmative action” and so on. Not one Planned Parenthood representative in all the different branches expressed a flicker of concern at the racism behind donations; all happily accepted them. What was worse, was that the staff members expressed agreement with the racist sentiments being expressed!

    They taped the phone calls and placed the transcript and the calls on You Tube. At that time we linked to the You Tube clip but it has since taken down. The New Zealand media did not pick up the controversy but the US media did, you can still find remnants if you google. So when David Farrar told us about the ACORN scandal, we wondered if the two were connected. Today I checked and sure enough, one of the people responsible for exposing ACORN is the same person behind the Planned Parenthood tapes, James O’Keefe.

    I read up a bit about O’Keefe and his friends other escapades over the years (there were not the only two) and the thing that really comes through is just how much smarter and savvier they have learned how to play their stings as they have gone on and how powerful something as simple as an internet connection, a computer and blog can be.

    No editors to bypass to achieve publication; as long as you package your news smartly and clearly you can get picked up anywhere – look at kiwi blogger, Trevor Louden, whose blogpost ended up travelling from his computer in Christchurch the scalp of Barack Obama’s most recently outed bad choice in appointee, Van Jones.

    Hat tip: David Farrar

  • VSM Bill off to Select Committee

    The VSM Bill has passed its first reading and is off to Select Committee. Predictably the student associations have freaked out and David Farrar has an interesting fisk of the various press releases they’ve issued in response here.

    Given that Madeleine and I were involved in the move to make student associations voluntary in the late 90’s we will follow this debate with interest.

    UPDATE:
    The Hansards debate on the VSM Bill is now online here. It makes for interesting reading, you can really see the left/right ideologies coming through. The left MP’s rubbish the concept of freedom of association and conscience as right wing inventions and talk about collective rights, rights to free education and so on.

    We also noted Labour MP Chris Hipkins revealing objection to the Bill:

    “the real driver behind this bill—which, of course, we heard already from Roger Douglas and Anne Tolley—is that it is designed to silence critics of the Government.” [Emphasis added]

    Note the assumption that all tertiary students oppose National, ACT, United Future and Maori Party [Government] policies.

    Funny, I recall some CM Research being done when I was a student at Waikato University that showed that in fact 60% of tertiary students vote right of centre, a study that NZUSA commissioned, paid for with money taken from all students, and then refused to release the study when the results didn’t come out showing all students being lefties.

  • The 2009 Forum on the Family: A Review

    On Friday Madeleine and I attended the Forum on the Family and the following is our long awaited (and long) review of it.

    The Forum kicked off with an impassioned talk from Bev Adair. Bev gave a harrowing account of her own story of childhood physical and sexual abuse and subsequent encounter with God that transformed her life and character and enabled her to break the cycle in her own life, heal and bring her own experience into her work with the Family and Child Trust. She stressed that the solution to child abuse was that people stopped blaming others or their social context for what happens to them; that they must cease demanding solutions from the state and being reliant on welfare; she called for individuals and communities to take responsibility for their own actions and for an end to the silence; abuse is not invisible, people who see it must act. Bev stated that voluntary organisations that were not funded by the state were doing some of the most effective work in the community and the consensus from them was that poverty does not make people hurt their children, she pointed out that countries with real poverty don’t brutalise their children or have stats like New Zealand’s.

    What was interesting was that later in the program the children’s commissioner, Dr John Angus, gave a much drier facts and figures type talk that reinforced what Bev stated. Relying on data compiled by CYFS, Angus noted that abuse tended to be more correlated to drug and alcohol abuse than poverty and that while reports of child abuse are on the increase, the actual cases are not. Like Bev he also suggested that the solutions were at the family, individual and community levels as opposed to government. Angus noted that one of the biggest problems was that when people were worried about a friend or family member’s conduct they rang CYFS rather than actually confronting or addressing it at a family level. Angus argued that real progress is made when families and communities own the problem and openly confront the issues family members face and offer constructive help instead of just looking to the state. It was at this family/community level, that real change can be made.

    In contrast to this, Labour Leader Phil Goff gave a speech about how poverty and economic hardship were the key issues in child abuse. Goff spoke of the need for a society where no children missed out on health care, education or basic necessities due to economic deprivation. He noted the historic Christian motivation behind the original welfare policies of Labour and suggested a need for all parties to work towards helping families in need. While I am not generally a fan of Labour, it is hard to dispute Goff’s claim that we should work towards having a society where no child misses out on basic necessities due to poverty and God clearly would want Christians should to be committed to achieving such a society, that said, none of this speaks to the question as to how this should be done and what the just and appropriate means of bringing it about are (I have discussed the issue of sustenance rights in a previous post). In the Q&A when I questioned Goff further on this he made it clear that he specifically saw this support as primarily coming from the state and not from the voluntary sector on the grounds that “the state has the money.” (Ironically Goff also justified high taxes on the grounds that it was needed for the state to play this role making his position somewhat circular.) These criticisms aside, Goff is to be commended for being the first Labour leader to front up and address the Forum on the Family and for attempting to build bridges with conservative Christians instead of trying to “marginalise them out of existence.”

    One unfortunate feature of Goff’s talk was the focus in the Q&A on the smacking issue. Goff suggested this was a side issue, not as important as child abuse and that people should focus their energy and passions on more important issues. That is, of course, correct and the fixation by members of the audience on this issue did seem disproportionate. However, at the same time, as members of the audience noted, a large number of the audience were from voluntary organisations that were dealing with domestic violence and child abuse at the coal face; hence, the suggestion they were not addressing this or were not as committed to these issues is inaccurate. Moreover, opponents of the current s59 of the Crimes Act had repeatedly told Labour that laws about smacking had nothing to do with child abuse in the past. Proponents had justified the decriminalisation of reasonable force for the purposes of parental correction on the grounds that it would help to stop child abuse and some had, in fact, equated smacking with child abuse. The previous Labour government’s support of this line of argument was the reason that there was now a Bill before the house, John Boscawen’s Crimes (Reasonable Parental Control and Correction) Amendment Private Member’s Bill. So for Phil Goff to now claim now that concern around s59 was a side issue and the question of child abuse was a different, more important issue that Labour was deeply committed to was more than a tad disingenuous, which is what evoked the scathing (and justified) attack from Christine Rankin that David Farrar referred to on his Facebook page.

    Moreover, with a Bill before the house, Labour really do need to take a stance; it is fine to say s59 is not their main focus but when the bill is actually put before them they will need a position. Their opinion on the now, apparently separate and unrelated to light smacking, issue of child abuse, while commendable, is not what they will be asked to vote on. When Madeleine pressed Goff on this he stated that Labour will be voting against Boscawen’s Bill.

    Not all the speakers spoke on child abuse and s59, Greg Fleming, CEO of the Maxim Institute, gave a good talk entitled “Right Wing, Left Wing. What Does it Mean? Does it Matter?” Fleming made essentially three points; first, he noted that the terms ‘right wing’ or ‘left wing’ often function as labels that are used to pigeon hole or brand a person so as to summarily dismiss their position without actually addressing it or considering its merits. Fleming’s contention that such dismissals often reflect a kind of unjustifiable intellectual laziness is undoubtedly correct and occurs far too often.

    Political SpectrumFleming’s second point was to suggest that the labels ‘left’ and ‘right,’ when understood correctly, do have a useful descriptive function in highlighting where a person sits on a particular spectrum. For Fleming, this spectrum constituted a horizontal axis whereby equality was at one end, the left and inequality at the other, the right. In addition to the horizontal left-right spectrum is a vertical spectrum with freedom at the top and authority on the bottom. These axes lead to communism being on the bottom left, totalitarian authority to maximise equality; fascism on the bottom right, totalitarian authority to maintain inequality; social democracy on the top left, limited government focused on achieving equality; finally, classical liberalism on the right, limited government for the sake of maximising individual freedom.

    One criticism I have of this is that (more…)

  • Pulse Check

    We have not fallen off the face of the earth, just too much on. Auckland Bloggers drinks was very cool, extremely packed out and seriously a who’s who of blogging – for a list of who may or may not have been present see Ryan Sproull’s write up of the night.

    We then went straight into the Family First Forum on Friday followed by dinner and drinks with a few bloggers, bloupies and others at the forum.

    Then we hung out with Andy Moore who stayed with us til last night. Then we began writing blog posts but then it was 1am and we were not finished… church now so check in later.

    If you want some Family First Forum tidbits, Big News has a few posts, Andy Moore has done a write up and if you are friends with David Farrar on Facebook he has half a dozen cryptic comments about things MP’s said on his front page, things said to MP’s that he Facebooked from the Forum (not that he conceded where he was):

    David Farrar Just met a young guy from Destiny Church. Asked him his role there and he said he was bodyguard for Brian Tamaki. Hope he is paid well!

    David Farrar Heh. Someone inro’d themself to a MP as the No 1 NZ Christian Blogger. [No idea who that might have  been…] I quipped that must make me the No 1 hedonistic blogger 🙂

    David Farrar Goff has just said he used to smack his kids

    David Farrar Rankin just attacked Goff big time. Not sure that is wise for a Families Commissioner.

    David Farrar My name twin, David Farrier, is sitting next to me. Still can’t believe people sometimes confuse us!

    David Farrar Heh John Key just said that he is happy to announce they are keeping the H in Helensville 🙂

    David Farrar Six questions so far to John Key – all on smacking so far. There are other issues!

    We’ll get our official report on the forum up later today.

  • Auckland Bloggers Drinks Feat. David Farrar – This Thursday!

    This week a number of non-Auckland bloggers will be in Auckland for the Forum on the Family. So, Annie Fox and I have conspired to hold an impromptu Bloggers Bar Bash this Thursday and David Farrar has confirmed his appearance.

    What: A social gathering of bloggers and bloupies (those who read, comment on and hang out with bloggers)
    When: Thursday 17 September from 5.30pm – note the earlier than usual start!
    Where: Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland

    Open to anyone who happens to be in Auckland. Regular blogger attendees include those from Annie Fox, Not PC, Interest.co.nz, Lolly Scramble and MandM, others have been known to stop by so don’t be shy.