Tag: Elections

  • The Special Votes Give a Seat to the Greens

    The Special Votes have been counted, the official result of the New Zealand 2008 Election is in; see the effect they have made on the provisional results:

    Final results in bold, (provisional results in brackets)

    National 44.93% (45.45%) – 58 (59) seats
    Labour 33.99% (33.77%) – 43 seats
    Green 6.72% (6.43%) – 9 (8) seats
    ACT 3.65% (3.72%) – 5 seats
    Maori 2.39% (2.24%) – 5 seats (overhang)
    Progressive 0.91% (0.93%) – 1 seat
    United Future 0.87% (0.89%) – 1 seat

    Basically National loses a seat, the Greens gain one. What is with kiwi’s overseas and nostalgically voting Green? Its all right for them, they don’t have to live here.

    No change to the reigns of power or anything dramatic as the confidence and supply agreements are more than adequate but as David Farrar said on applying the St Lague formula:

    National was at massive risk of losing a second seat as they hold Spot 120. Labour are in 121. National’s quotient is 9160.0 while Labour’s quotient is 9159.5.

    If Labour had 40 more voters turn up (that is less than one voter per seat), then Damien O’Connor would be back in Parliament and Aaron Gilmore would have missed out. Or if 22 people who voted National had voted Labour, then Labour would have 44 seats and National 57.

    This does raise the risk of Labour seeking a recount somewhat, though of course, there is no guarantee that’d help them.

  • The New Lineup

    The new Cabinet has been announced:

    John Key
    Prime Minister
    Minister of Tourism
    Ministerial Services
    Minister in Charge of the NZ Security Intelligence Service
    Minister Responsible for the GCSB

    Bill English
    Deputy Prime Minister
    Minister of Finance
    Minister for Infrastructure

    Gerry Brownlee
    Leader of the House
    Minister for Economic Development
    Minister of Energy and Resources
    Associate Minister for the Rugby World Cup

    Simon Power
    Deputy Leader of the House
    Minister of Justice
    Minister for State Owned Enterprises
    Minister of Commerce
    Minister Responsible for the Law Commission
    Associate Minister of Finance

    Tony Ryall
    Minister of Health
    Minister of State Services

    Nick Smith
    Minister for the Environment
    Minister for Climate Change Issues
    Minister for ACC

    Judith Collins
    Minister of Police
    Minister of Corrections
    Minister of Veterans’ Affairs

    Anne Tolley
    Minister of Education
    Minister for Tertiary Education
    Minister Responsible for the Education Review Office

    Christopher Finlayson
    Attorney-General
    Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations
    Minister for Arts, Culture and Heritage

    David Carter
    Minister of Agriculture
    Minister for Biosecurity
    Minister of Forestry

    Murray McCully
    Minister of Foreign Affairs
    Minister for Sport and Recreation
    Minister for the Rugby World Cup

    Tim Groser
    Minister of Trade
    Minister of Conservation
    Associate Minister of Foreign Affairs
    Associate Minister for Climate Change Issues

    Wayne Mapp
    Minister of Defence
    Minister of Research, Science and Technology
    Associate Minister for Economic Development
    Associate Minister for Tertiary Education

    Steven Joyce
    Minister of Transport
    Minister for Communications and Information Technology
    Associate Minister of Finance
    Associate Minister for Infrastructure

    Georgina te Heuheu
    Minister for Courts
    Minister of Pacific Island Affairs
    Minister for Disarmament and Arms Control
    Associate Minister of Maori Affairs

    Paula Bennett
    Minister for Social Development and Employment
    Minister for Disability Issues
    Minister of Youth Affairs

    Phil Heatley
    Minister of Fisheries
    Minister of Housing

    Pansy Wong
    Minister for Ethnic Affairs
    Minister of Women’s Affairs
    Associate Minister for ACC
    Associate Minister of Energy and Resources

    Jonathan Coleman
    Minister of Immigration
    Minister of Broadcasting
    Associate Minister of Tourism
    Associate Minister of Health

    Kate Wilkinson
    Minister of Labour
    Minister for Food Safety
    Associate Minister of Immigration

    OUTSIDE CABINET:
    Maurice Williamson
    Minister for Building and Construction
    Minister of Customs
    Minister of Statistics
    Minister for Small Business

    Richard Worth
    Minister of Internal Affairs
    Minister for Land Information
    Minister Responsible for Archives New Zealand
    Minister Responsible for the National Library
    Associate Minister of Justice

    John Carter
    Minister of Civil Defence
    Minister for Senior Citizens
    Minister for Racing
    Associate Minister of Local Government

    Rodney Hide
    Minister of Local Government
    Minister for Regulatory Reform
    Associate Minister of Commerce

    Heather Roy
    Minister of Consumer Affairs
    Associate Minister of Defence
    Associate Minister of Education

    Pita Sharples
    Minister of Maori Affairs
    Associate Minister of Corrections
    Associate Minister of Education

    Tariana Turia
    Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector
    Associate Minister of Health
    Associate Minister for Social Development and Employment

    Peter Dunne
    Minister of Revenue
    Associate Minister of Health

    SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE:
    Lockwood Smith

    I will not be giving stats on the number of women or breaking down the portfolios races as this is irrelevant; ministers should be chosen on the basis of their ability.

    No major surprises really, the only thing I would comment on is the sheer number of portfolios on issues the government has no business touching or that are just dumb or paternalistic – women’s affairs is particularly grating as is broadcasting and arts, culture & heritage and the rugby world cup? does the government really have to run that?

  • And United Future’s Baubles Are…

    National and United Future’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Peter Dunne gets Minister of Revenue and Associate Minister of Health.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • Maintain the policy, research and advocacy role of the Families Commission whilst seeking to achieve administrative efficiencies between the operations of the Families Commission and the Office of the Children’s Commissioner.
    • Reducing elective surgery waiting lists by greater utilisation of private hospital capacity, in a planned way where this cannot be met by the public hospital system;
    • Progressing the long-term medicines strategy for quality use of pharmaceuticals in the health sector, Medicines New Zealand, including the role Pharmac should play in that strategy.
    • Support Public Private Partnerships for major roading infrastructure developments where these are deemed to be the preferred options regionally and nationally, such as the Transmission Gully highway.
    • The government notes that United Future has been committed to income splitting as a key part of their tax policy and agrees to support appropriate legislation to First Reading in Parliament.
    • Proceed with the establishment of a Big Game Hunting Council as part of a national wild game management strategy with a view to it becoming a statutory authority.
    • And the government acknowledges United Future’s ongoing support and interest in the development of the Seniors’ Gold Card, the Community and Voluntary sector, and advancing the interests of the disability sector.

    Most of it is the usual centrist stuff *sigh* but I will comment of the standouts.

    The Families Commission was a dumb idea and it has been a dumb bureaucratic nanny-state money-gobbler, just like the Children’s Commission, ever since. So ugh! to that policy.

    Income splitting is a positive move to lowering taxes but it adds complexity to the tax laws and does not benefit enough people. Lowering the top tax rates as the government are planning to to 30% would make the need for income splitting largely redundant.

  • And the Maori Party gets…

    National and the Maori Party’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Two Maori Party MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:

    Dr Sharples gets Maori Affairs Minister, Associate Education Minister and Associate Corrections Minister.
    Tariana Turia gets Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector, Associate Health Minister and Associate Social Development Minister.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • National offered a review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act to see if was working and whether there were any better alternatives.
    • National will drop its opposition to the Maori seats and in turn, the Maori Party would drop its pursuit of entrenching the Maori seats and a group will be formed to look at constitutional issues including Maori representation.

    Good on the Maori Party for pushing the Foreshore and Seabed Act issue. It is a shame to see that National has not framed the issue in terms of the affront to due process and instead is talking about all New Zealander’s being able to access the beach, as if that is somehow more important than human rights.

    I am relieved to see there is no deal to entrench the Maori seats. The status quo of race based representation is abhorrent enough.

  • The Deal is Signed: New Zealand Has a New Government

    The hoardings have barely had time to gather dust and National have just announced they have stitched up a deal with ACT, United Future and the Maori Party. Surely this is the fastest confidence and supply stitch up in the history of NZ MMP.

    National and ACT’s confidence and supply agreement is available here online. Highlights are:

    Two ACT MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Rodney Hide gets: Minister of Local Government, Minister of Regulatory Reform, Associate Minister of Commerce and a member of the Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee.

    Heather Roy gets: Minister of Consumer Affairs, Associate Minister of Defence and Associate Minister of Education.

    Areas of Co-Operation Are:

    • Law and Order
    • Climate Change
    • Controlling Government Expenditure
    • Tax
    • Regulation
    • Resource Management Act
    • Education

    Policy Concessions include:

    • An advisory group to look at ways of closing the income gap with Australia by 2025 with the aim of stopping the exodus.
    • Pursuit of a sustained lift in New Zealand’s productivity growth rate to 3% a year or more and the establishment of a high quality advisory group to investigate the reasons for the recent decline in New Zealand’s productivity performance
    • National will, within 6 months, send ACT’s Taxpayer Rights Bill to the Finance and Expenditure Committee of Parliament as a government measure with the aim of passing into law a cap on the growth of core Crown expenses.
    • National agrees to introduce ACT’s “Three Strikes Bill” and support it to Select Committee.
    • The implementation of the Emissions Trading Scheme will be delayed until a review of New Zealand’s response on Climate Change with agreed draft terms of reference is completed, and the thermal generation ban will be repealed.
    • An agreement that a medium-term goal be set for the top rate of tax to be 30 percent so NZ has a government that will reward and celebrate success – not punish it.
    • National will explore the concept of a New Zealand Productivity Commission associated with the Productivity Commission in Australia in order to support the goals of higher productivity growth and improvements in the quality of regulation.
    • An agreement to work together over time to increase education choices so that pupils and families have more freedom to select schooling options that best meet the individual needs of their children.
    • Ongoing discussion is agreed to on ACT’s most excellent 20 point plan.

    Sounds promising. I was worried that Key’s pursuit of Dunne and the Maori Party meant something far more centrist would be announced. I dislike all the bureaucratic committees that will be funded and set up to talk about everything but hopefully something positive will come out of it. Its better than what we had anyway.

    Details on United Future and the Maori Party’s baubles are yet to be announced – I hope the Maori Party have stood firm on some aspect of the Seabed and Foreshore as ACT should support them on that and there will be those in National who were appalled at that particular affront to due process too.

  • Just How Far Will the Left go?

    We all know the left will stop at nothing to win in politics; see what they did to Stephen Franks in Wellington Central – systematic election hoarding defacement, abuse on his blog (too numerous to link to any one example), You Tube videos twisting out of context comments into scary hate filled messages against Christians and gays [note it was only called homophobic]. The threats and abuse we received for Fisking Grant Robertson, the critique of the latter You Tube Video, to name a few examples from one electorate.

    But who phones 111 when they realise, on election night, that the left have lost and that National will lead the country?!?!?

    And WHY???!!??

    What littany of lies and propaganda about the right would have had to have been put up such people by the left to make them do this? (or are they just incapable of understanding the political process and the policies of the right?)

    Liberty Scott’s comments are on the button; extract from: What DID leftwing campaigners tell some people?

    This report that some people rang the Police when the election results were coming through is alarming in several ways:

    1. That people thought their benefits would disappear because National was being elected. What sort of untrammelled nonsense have the left been spreading about such a situation? How despicable are those who promote such lies among people who are clearly rather unhinged? How many were persuaded to vote Labour or Green or else their benefits would dry up?

    2. What do people think the Police will do? Arrest John Key and Rodney Hide? Call an end to general elections? Do they think when things don’t go their way the Police should be called in? How scary is that?

    3. Most disconcerting is the helpless dependency of such people who think the only way forward is to remain dependent on money taken by force from others. How insipid has the welfare state become that there are people terrified at the prospect of having to earn themselves a living?

    Sorry folks, it’s when the word Libertarianz replaces National that you might be worried, but by then the culture would have to have changed so radically that you wouldn’t be scared anymore.

  • The Impact of the Special Votes

    I sat down to work out how the special votes, which are yet to be counted, might impact the seats with the St Lague formula and saw David Farrar had already done it so I am going to be lazy and steal his post – I am tired, went to bed around 2am got up at 6am – Sherry had a One Day Event this morning, they start early, and Troggy bit me, so my arm hurts when I type… anyway, hat tip Kiwiblog, taken from What might happen on specials?

    The allocation is:

    National 59
    Labour 43
    Greens 8
    Maori 3 (+2 overhang)
    United
    Future 1
    ACT 5

    Now who is most at risk from specials? They are the party that is in List Spot 120. And that is National.

    The quotient for National is 951145/117 = 8129.4. And who is in spot 121? Labour with 706666/87 = 8122.6.

    Very roughly if Labour pick up 600 more votes relative to National, then they get one more List MP, and National loses one. That is not at all impossible.

    But could someone else grab it off National. The Greens have spot 124, being 134622/17 = 7918.9. They would need to gain an extra 3,600 votes (on top of their existing proportion of votes) from specials. That is a bit of an ask, but they have done well on special traditionally.

    The next candidate on each relevant list is Conway Powell for National, Damien O’Connor for Labour and Kennedy Graham for the Greens.