Tag: NZ Government

  • Dear Mr McCully,

    The law criminalises smacking, the best and most faithful reading of the law deems any use of force for the purposes of parental correction criminal; experts in legal interpretation agree on this. The people have objected loudly and all you have done is issue a promise to not enforce the law; a promise that can only be kept for as long as you govern, a promise that offends the duty of a government to ensure that the law is enforced.

    Your so called “safeguards” offer no long term protection. What happens to those safeguards in the future if the Greens hold the balance of power? Or is that what is really going on – you won’t change the law because you want it to be easy to eradicate smacking long term in New Zealand?

    I am not fooled. Courts are primarily directed by the black letter of the law not promises to not enforce it made by past governments. This government has a chance to offer parents protection that a future government will find harder to undo and it will fail if these “safeguards” are all it does.

    Promises to not enforce a law that criminalises smacking are not good enough. If the government does not wish for parents who lightly smack their children for the purposes of correction to be prosecuted then it must change the law now, before the possibility of a new government arises.

    Regards,

    Madeleine Flannagan

    The Hon Murray McCully emailed me (I suspect generically) this morning in response to my first email, Dear Cabinet,. The above is a response, sent to all members of Cabinet, to Mr McCully’s email to me which is pasted below,

    The Prime Minister has announced that the Government is introducing safeguards to give parents comfort they will not be criminalised for lightly smacking their children.

    The safeguards follow the Citizens Initiated Referendum on smacking. The referendum result reinforces the message that New Zealanders do not want to see good parents criminalised for a light smack.

    To give parents comfort that this will not happen, Cabinet has agreed on a number of measures. These are:

    The Police and Ministry of Social Development chief executive will lead a review of Police and Child, Youth & Family policies and procedures, including the referral process between the two agencies, to identify any changes that are necessary or desirable to ensure good parents are treated as Parliament intended. The Commissioner of Police and Ministry of Social Development chief executive will seek an independent person to assist in the conduct of the review and will report back by 1 December 2009.

    We will be bringing forward the delivery of the report from the Ministry of Social Development chief executive on data and trends and the effect of the law change from the end of the year to late September/early October. The Minister of Social Development will table the report in Parliament.

    The Government will invite Police to continue to report on a six-monthly or annual basis for the next three years on the operation of the law, and invite Police to include data on cases where parents or caregivers say the force used on the child was reasonable in the circumstances.

    If future Police data indicates a worrying trend, the law will be changed to ensure that good New Zealand parents are not criminalised for lightly smacking.

    The Government believes the law is working as intended, but we want to give parents an assurance that a National-led Government will continue to monitor the way the law is being implemented.

    RELATED POSTS:
    Dear Cabinet,
    Fisking Margaret Mayman: The Flawed Moral Theology on the Smacking Referendum
    Fisking Ian Hassall: The Arbitrary Ethical Reasoning on the Smacking Referendum
    No Defences Permitted for the Accused
    MandM Smacking Label

  • The New Lineup

    The new Cabinet has been announced:

    John Key
    Prime Minister
    Minister of Tourism
    Ministerial Services
    Minister in Charge of the NZ Security Intelligence Service
    Minister Responsible for the GCSB

    Bill English
    Deputy Prime Minister
    Minister of Finance
    Minister for Infrastructure

    Gerry Brownlee
    Leader of the House
    Minister for Economic Development
    Minister of Energy and Resources
    Associate Minister for the Rugby World Cup

    Simon Power
    Deputy Leader of the House
    Minister of Justice
    Minister for State Owned Enterprises
    Minister of Commerce
    Minister Responsible for the Law Commission
    Associate Minister of Finance

    Tony Ryall
    Minister of Health
    Minister of State Services

    Nick Smith
    Minister for the Environment
    Minister for Climate Change Issues
    Minister for ACC

    Judith Collins
    Minister of Police
    Minister of Corrections
    Minister of Veterans’ Affairs

    Anne Tolley
    Minister of Education
    Minister for Tertiary Education
    Minister Responsible for the Education Review Office

    Christopher Finlayson
    Attorney-General
    Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations
    Minister for Arts, Culture and Heritage

    David Carter
    Minister of Agriculture
    Minister for Biosecurity
    Minister of Forestry

    Murray McCully
    Minister of Foreign Affairs
    Minister for Sport and Recreation
    Minister for the Rugby World Cup

    Tim Groser
    Minister of Trade
    Minister of Conservation
    Associate Minister of Foreign Affairs
    Associate Minister for Climate Change Issues

    Wayne Mapp
    Minister of Defence
    Minister of Research, Science and Technology
    Associate Minister for Economic Development
    Associate Minister for Tertiary Education

    Steven Joyce
    Minister of Transport
    Minister for Communications and Information Technology
    Associate Minister of Finance
    Associate Minister for Infrastructure

    Georgina te Heuheu
    Minister for Courts
    Minister of Pacific Island Affairs
    Minister for Disarmament and Arms Control
    Associate Minister of Maori Affairs

    Paula Bennett
    Minister for Social Development and Employment
    Minister for Disability Issues
    Minister of Youth Affairs

    Phil Heatley
    Minister of Fisheries
    Minister of Housing

    Pansy Wong
    Minister for Ethnic Affairs
    Minister of Women’s Affairs
    Associate Minister for ACC
    Associate Minister of Energy and Resources

    Jonathan Coleman
    Minister of Immigration
    Minister of Broadcasting
    Associate Minister of Tourism
    Associate Minister of Health

    Kate Wilkinson
    Minister of Labour
    Minister for Food Safety
    Associate Minister of Immigration

    OUTSIDE CABINET:
    Maurice Williamson
    Minister for Building and Construction
    Minister of Customs
    Minister of Statistics
    Minister for Small Business

    Richard Worth
    Minister of Internal Affairs
    Minister for Land Information
    Minister Responsible for Archives New Zealand
    Minister Responsible for the National Library
    Associate Minister of Justice

    John Carter
    Minister of Civil Defence
    Minister for Senior Citizens
    Minister for Racing
    Associate Minister of Local Government

    Rodney Hide
    Minister of Local Government
    Minister for Regulatory Reform
    Associate Minister of Commerce

    Heather Roy
    Minister of Consumer Affairs
    Associate Minister of Defence
    Associate Minister of Education

    Pita Sharples
    Minister of Maori Affairs
    Associate Minister of Corrections
    Associate Minister of Education

    Tariana Turia
    Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector
    Associate Minister of Health
    Associate Minister for Social Development and Employment

    Peter Dunne
    Minister of Revenue
    Associate Minister of Health

    SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE:
    Lockwood Smith

    I will not be giving stats on the number of women or breaking down the portfolios races as this is irrelevant; ministers should be chosen on the basis of their ability.

    No major surprises really, the only thing I would comment on is the sheer number of portfolios on issues the government has no business touching or that are just dumb or paternalistic – women’s affairs is particularly grating as is broadcasting and arts, culture & heritage and the rugby world cup? does the government really have to run that?

  • And United Future’s Baubles Are…

    National and United Future’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Peter Dunne gets Minister of Revenue and Associate Minister of Health.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • Maintain the policy, research and advocacy role of the Families Commission whilst seeking to achieve administrative efficiencies between the operations of the Families Commission and the Office of the Children’s Commissioner.
    • Reducing elective surgery waiting lists by greater utilisation of private hospital capacity, in a planned way where this cannot be met by the public hospital system;
    • Progressing the long-term medicines strategy for quality use of pharmaceuticals in the health sector, Medicines New Zealand, including the role Pharmac should play in that strategy.
    • Support Public Private Partnerships for major roading infrastructure developments where these are deemed to be the preferred options regionally and nationally, such as the Transmission Gully highway.
    • The government notes that United Future has been committed to income splitting as a key part of their tax policy and agrees to support appropriate legislation to First Reading in Parliament.
    • Proceed with the establishment of a Big Game Hunting Council as part of a national wild game management strategy with a view to it becoming a statutory authority.
    • And the government acknowledges United Future’s ongoing support and interest in the development of the Seniors’ Gold Card, the Community and Voluntary sector, and advancing the interests of the disability sector.

    Most of it is the usual centrist stuff *sigh* but I will comment of the standouts.

    The Families Commission was a dumb idea and it has been a dumb bureaucratic nanny-state money-gobbler, just like the Children’s Commission, ever since. So ugh! to that policy.

    Income splitting is a positive move to lowering taxes but it adds complexity to the tax laws and does not benefit enough people. Lowering the top tax rates as the government are planning to to 30% would make the need for income splitting largely redundant.

  • And the Maori Party gets…

    National and the Maori Party’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Two Maori Party MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:

    Dr Sharples gets Maori Affairs Minister, Associate Education Minister and Associate Corrections Minister.
    Tariana Turia gets Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector, Associate Health Minister and Associate Social Development Minister.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • National offered a review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act to see if was working and whether there were any better alternatives.
    • National will drop its opposition to the Maori seats and in turn, the Maori Party would drop its pursuit of entrenching the Maori seats and a group will be formed to look at constitutional issues including Maori representation.

    Good on the Maori Party for pushing the Foreshore and Seabed Act issue. It is a shame to see that National has not framed the issue in terms of the affront to due process and instead is talking about all New Zealander’s being able to access the beach, as if that is somehow more important than human rights.

    I am relieved to see there is no deal to entrench the Maori seats. The status quo of race based representation is abhorrent enough.

  • Sometimes the Left are Right: The Right-Wing 5 Headed Monster

    One of the things I am loving about not being affiliated to any party is that I can criticise my own ‘side’. It is a liberating thing.

    I stumbled accross this on The Standard and I have to say I agreed with it.

    Well, most of it.

    Definately did not agree with the last line…

    And of course John Key was right that a government without a clear direction being pulled all over the show by competing agendas would not be good for the country, especially in a time of economic uncertainty and there is the fact that what he was speaking of and what the Standard are referring to do differ somewhat, in that he only needs a two headed monster to govern and one of the 5 heads is really a two headed monster in its own right, but Tane does have a point….

    Moving right along.

    Taken from: Careful of them monsters, John by Tane.

    It’s amazing to see how quickly John Key got over his fear of five-headed monsters once it came time to cobble together a government, and more amazing still how quickly the media chose to forgive and forget.

    You’ll recall that just two weeks ago the media couldn’t get enough of John’s line that having a government composed of:

    “all sorts of different parties” with “competing interests” would not be in the best interests of New Zealand during a period of “difficult economic times to manage”.

    But, silly me, they bought that one when it was Helen Clark’s coalition options in question. Now that it’s John Key, it turns out what was irresponsible just two weeks ago was actually “smart” and “inclusive” all along.

    They’re a funny bunch, our right-wing media.

    [I am sorry but if the media is “right-wing” then what on earth am I? Maybe a better question is what does that make The Standard?!?!?]

  • The Voting is Over

    Curiablog‘s final results:

    National 59 (46.8%)
    Labour 44 (34.6%)
    Green 10 (8.1%)
    ACT 3 (2.6%)
    Maori 4 (2.4%)
    United Future 1 (0.5%)
    Progressive 1 (0.2%)

    There will be an overhang so the magic number to chase is a majority of 122 seats.

    Most likely formulae are:

    National+ACT+United Future = 63 seats
    Labour+Prog+Greens = 55 seats

    Other possibilities could happen. The next days will tell.

    Of note:

    • John Key is New Zealand’s new Prime Minister
    • Helen Clark is standing down
    • Labour will be in opposition with a new leader
    • NZ First and Winston Peters are gone
    • Roger Douglas is back
    • National List MPs include up to Conway Powell number 59
    • Labour List MPs include up to Stuart Nash number 36

    (Special votes may affect some of the above a little)