Tag: Enviro Myths

  • More Swamps than Christchurch: The Liquefaction of the Left

    "Scientists say that by 1984 we'll be up to our ears in horse dung if we don't reduce our reliance on horsepower.""One of the most destructive carnards concreted into the mind of greenism and environmentalism is the proposition that natural resources are fixed, finite, and limited. Once gone, they are gone forever. Therefore, conservation of said resources is a moral imperative.

    Statists warm to this proposition reflexively, that is, without thinking. To conserve on a grand scale requires big government: to regulate, limit, control, restrict, order, prescribe, proscribe, and ban. Without such a big intrusion into the lives and endeavours of citizens, disaster will fall upon the entire race. Therefore, statists join the moral crusade. Advocating for big-brother government suddenly makes one morally good. Saving the planet and saving humanity has a nice moral ring to it, making big government itself a moral imperative.

    Socialists likewise find the proposition of limited resources needing to be conserved a convenient doctrine. It justifies pre-emptive property rights of the state over private citizens. It also gives moral cover to advocating for more government taxation and expropriation to fund things like “green industries” and “green energy”. You just have to take a glance at President Obama’s “new” energy strategy. Instead of “drill, baby drill” it is “spin, baby, spin”, referring of course to the windmills he is spending billions of dollars worth of citizen’s property to manufacture and deploy.

    So, we have the ideological Grand Coalition of our times: greenists, environmentalists, statists, and socialists. Ladies and gentlemen put your hands together for “the Left”.

    There is one small problem. This monumental intellectual and political construction is built upon a simple fallacy, known as the fallacy of composition. It beggars belief that in a world self-proclaimed to be so smart and so rational that the very same wise-in-their-own-estimation are actually operating with a grand intellectual and political edifice built on more swamps than Christchurch, or more volcanoes than Auckland.

    The fallacy of composition assumes or asserts that the attributes of the parts must sum to the attribute of the whole. In this case, since each specific natural resource is clearly finite, natural resources as a whole must, therefore, be finite. Once you explode this childish error (more…)

  • Not Surprising . . . Gog and Magog are Showing Signs of Life

    Desperate times call for desperate measures. Greenists believe that these are desperate times–acutely so. The future of mankind is at stake. Therefore, it is not surprising that they are calling for desperate measures. We are not now talking about the lunatic fringe of the movement. We are referring to those in the Greenist mainstream, the card-carrying members, who know all the right people, sit on all the right committees and are deeply involved in the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

    Eco-ReligionEnter one Professor David Shearman, MD, Emeritus Professor of Medicine, University of Adelaide and a Visiting Research Fellow at the University’s Department of Geography and Environmental Sciences and Law School. Professor Shearman was an Assessor for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Third Assessment Report and the Fourth Assessment Report. He is a mainstream Greenist.

    The enlightened professor has co-authored a book which addresses the question of what needs to be done to combat global warming so as to achieve planetary salvation. He is convinced that democratic governments are not up to the task. Presumably he has attended too many Copenhagens. (A “Copenhagen” is a UN talk-fest, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.) Copenhagens are not producing the desperate measures required. Apparently, what we need is truly authoritarian government (he is serious.)  According to Hauntingthelibrary:

    Shearman has penned several books on global warming, such as ‘Climate Change as a Crisis in World Civilization: Why We Must Totally Transform How We Live‘ and ‘The Climate Change Challenge and the Failure of Democracy‘. His argument is that overpopulation and industrialization are causing an ecological disaster which requires a total change of lifestyle for everyone on the planet. As democracy isn’t up to the challenge, an authoritarian government must (obviously) be imposed to save us from ourselves.

    Here are some excerpts from a recent book co-authored by the Professor (The Climate Change Challenge and the Failure of Democracy). They reveal desperate measures indeed. 

    Government in the future will be based upon . . . a supreme office of the biosphere. The office will comprise specially trained philosopher/ecologists. These guardians will either rule themselves or advise an authoritarian government of policies based on their ecological training and philosophical sensitivities. These guardians will be specially trained for the task. [p. 134]

    Plato must be rubbing his hands with glee.

    The good Professor acknowledges that religion is an important element for social control. It is required to keep people in line (more…)

  • Stop Worrying So Much! Some Enviro Myth Busting

    I heard Leighton Smith talking about this article on Newstalk ZB this morning so I looked it up and it is worth sharing – especially the top 6!

    10 Things to Scratch From Your Worry List

    For most of the year, it is the duty of the press to scour the known universe looking for ways to ruin your day. The more fear, guilt or angst a news story induces, the better. But with August upon us, perhaps you’re in the mood for a break, so I’ve rounded up a list of 10 things not to worry about on your vacation.

    Now, I can’t guarantee you that any of these worries is groundless, because I can’t guarantee you that anything is absolutely safe, including the act of reading a newspaper. With enough money, an enterprising researcher could surely identify a chemical in newsprint or keyboards that is dangerously carcinogenic for any rat that reads a trillion science columns every day.

    What I can guarantee is that I wouldn’t spend a nanosecond of my vacation worrying about any of these 10 things. (You can make your own nominations in the TierneyLab blog.)

    1. Killer hot dogs.

    What is it about frankfurters? There was the nitrite scare. Then the grilling-creates-carcinogens alarm. And then, when those menaces ebbed, the weenie warriors fell back on that old reliable villain: saturatedfat.

    But now even saturated fat isn’t looking so bad, thanks to a rigorous experiment in Israel reported this month. The people on a low-carb, unrestricted-calorie diet onsumed more saturated fat than another group forced to cut back on both fat and calories, but those fatophiles lost more weight and ended up with a better cholesterol profile. And this was just the latest in a series of studies contradicting the medical establishment’s predictions about saturated fat.

    If you must worry, focus on the carbs in the bun. But when it comes to the fatty frank — or the fatty anything else on vacation — I’d relax.

    2. Your car’s planet-destroying air conditioner.

    No matter how guilty you feel about your carbon footprint, you don’t have to swelter on the highway to the beach. After doing tests at 65 miles per hour, the mileage experts at edmunds.com report that the aerodynamic drag from opening the windows cancels out any fuel savings from turning off the air-conditioner.

    3. Forbidden fruits from afar.

    Do you dare to eat a kiwi[fruit]? Sure, because more “food miles” do not equal more greenhouse emissions. Food from other countries is often produced and shipped much more efficiently than domestic food, particularly if the local producers are hauling their wares around in small trucks. One study showed that apples shipped from New Zealand to Britain had a smaller carbon footprint than apples grown and sold in Britain.

    4. Carcinogenic cellphones.

    Some prominent brain surgeons made news on Larry King’s show this year with their fears of cellphones, thereby establishing once and for all that epidemiology is not brain surgery — it’s more complicated.

    As my colleague Tara Parker-Pope has noted, there is no known biological mechanism for the phones’ non-ionizing radiation to cause cancer, and epidemiological studies have failed to find consistent links between cancer
    and cellphones.

    It’s always possible today’s worried doctors will be vindicated, but I’d bet they’ll be remembered more like the promoters of the old cancer-from-power-lines menace — or like James Thurber’s grandmother, who covered up her wall outlets to stop electricity from leaking.

    Driving while talking on a phone is a definite risk, but you’re better off worrying about other cars rather than cancer.

    5. Evil plastic bags.

    Take it from the Environmental Protection Agency : paper bags are not better for the environment than plastic bags. If anything, the evidence from life-cycle analyses favors plastic bags. They require much less energy — and greenhouse emissions — to manufacture, ship and recycle. They generate less air and water pollution. And they take up much less space in landfills.

    6. Toxic plastic bottles.

    For years panels of experts repeatedly approved the use of bisphenol-a, or BPA, which is used in polycarbonate bottles and many other plastic products. Yes, it could be harmful if given in huge doses to rodents, but so can the natural chemicals in countless foods we eat every day. Dose makes the poison.

    But this year, after a campaign by a few researchers and activists, one federal panel expressed some concern about BPA in baby bottles. Panic ensued. Even though there was zero evidence of harm to humans, Wal-Mart pulled BPA-containing products from its shelves, and politicians began talking about BPA bans. Some experts fear product recalls that could make this the most expensive health scare in history.

    Nalgene has already announced that it will take BPA out of its wonderfully sturdy water bottles. Given the publicity, the company probably had no choice. But my old blue-capped Nalgene bottle, the one with BPA that survived glaciers, jungles and deserts, is still sitting right next to me, filled with drinking water. If they ever try recalling it, they’ll have to pry it from my cold dead fingers.

    Leighton’s favourite was 3. as he “found it cute for obvious reasons.” Mine is number 1. the reference to not stressing about eating saturated fat resulting in more weight loss and better cholesterol levels is something I have been saying for years – its the high GI carbs you wanna watch for!

    Please post any other enviro myths you have to hand in the comments section.