In my last post âResponse to William Lane Craigâs Question 225: âThe âSlaughterâ of the Canaanites Re-visitedâ Part Iâ I discussed William Lane Craigâs position on the Canaanite Conquest account (in light of the fact that Craig referred to my argument in his question of the week: âQuestion 225: The âSlaughterâ of the Canaanites Re-visitedâ). I clarified the delineations as to where he agrees and disagrees with the position I presented at the Evangelical Philosophical Societyâs session at the Society for Biblical Literature Meeting in Atlanta last year and I established that the point of divergence in our agreement rests on 1 Samuel 15.
In my Atlanta paper I argued that Nicholas Wolterstorffâs reading of the Canaanite conquest accounts in Joshua can also be applied to the account of Saul exterminating the Amalekites in 1 Sam 15.
First, the so-called âgenocide accountsâ in 1 Sam 15 are part of a broader context that includes the rest of Samuel and also other canonical books, such as 2 Samuel and the book of Chronicles. When one reads the whole sequence, one observes that while 1 Samuel 15 describes Saul, at Godâs command, exterminating the Amalekites, later passages in Samuel and Chronicles proceed on the assumption this never literally happened.
The key passage is Godâs command to Samuel, âstrike [nakah] Amalek [the Amalekites] and utterly destroy [haram] all that he has, and do not spare [hamal] him; but put to death both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.â[1] The text goes on to explicitly state that the Amalekites were all wiped out:
âSo Saul defeated [nakah] the Amalekites, from Havilah as you go to Shur, which is east of Egypt. He captured Agag the king of the Amalekites alive, and utterly destroyed [haram] all the people with the edge of the sword. But Saul and the people spared [hamal] Agag and the best of the sheep, the oxen, the fatlings, the lambs, and all that was good, and were not willing to destroy them utterly; but everything despised and worthless, that they utterly destroyed.â [2]
A few verses later (15:33) the text records that Agag, the sole survivor, was executed. So, read literally, this passage states that all the Amalekites were killed and all their livestock were either destroyed or taken as plunder to be sacrificed to God at Gilgal.[3]
Now the language of âdefeatedâ (or struck), âutterly destroyedâ, the reference to âsparingâ and to livestock parallels the language of the command in 15:3. Given this, it seems implausible that we should interpret the command in verse 3 as literal but the fulfilment, just 4 verses later, as hyperbolic; the text requires that the command and fulfilment be read in the same sense.
That said, when one reads this passage as part of as a single narrative a literal reading appears untenable; the proceeding text states quite emphatically that the Amalekites were not, in fact, literally wiped out. In 1 Samuel 27:8-9 David invaded a territory full of Amalekites:
âNow David and his men went up and raided the Geshurites, the Girzites and the Amalekites. (From ancient times these peoples had lived in the land extending to Shur and Egypt.)Â Whenever David attacked an area, he did not leave a man or woman alive, but took sheep and cattle, donkeys and camels, and clothes. Then he returned to Achish.â
Not only does this text affirm that the Amalekites still existed but the reference to Egypt and Shur states that they existed in the very same area that Saul âutterly destroyed every single one of themâ in in the previous passages. Moreover, David took sheep and cattle as plunder; again, livestock was another of the things Saul was said to have already eradicated.
After the text has told us that Saul âutterly destroyed all the peopleâ, including King Agag, and despite the text telling us that when David attacked an area (the very same areas as Saul) he did ânot leave a man or woman aliveâ, three chapters later we read that a sizeable Amalekite army attacked Ziklag![4] David apparently pursued this army and fought a long battle with them and 400 Amalekites fled on horseback!![5] Where are all these Amalekites coming from?
These are not the only examples. In 2 Samuel 1:8 an Amalekite took credit for killing Saul âbut didnât Saul âutterly destroy all the peopleâ? In 1 Chronicles 4:43 Amalekites were still around in battle-ready numbers during the reign of Hezekiah who reigned after Saul and David.
Read literally, the narrative affirms both that the Amalekites were and were not totally wiped out. This apparent contradiction in the Samuel narrative is (more…)