Last night I was part of a discussion panel looking at the Ethics of War; I defended classical just war theory. Speaking in defence of pacifism was one of the Waihope three who offered the argument that you cannot use force against an oppressor because of the Golden Rule, typically stated as: ‘do to others as you would have them do to you.’ His idea seemed to be that if you were an oppressor you would not want force used against you so therefore no one should use force against oppressors – this is what the Golden Rule teaches.
This struck me as odd. One problem with this line of argument is that it interprets the Golden Rule as stating we should do to others what we want them to do to us. This interpretation is obviously problematic. I want a million dollars, does it follow that therefore I should give a million dollars to everyone? I want a nice car does it follow that I should give nice cars to everyone? What the Golden Rule says is that there should be consistency between what we think that people are morally required to do for us and to us and what we are morally required to do for and to others; if I object to someone stealing from me in certain circumstances and condemn that person’s action in doing so as wrong then I am committed to not stealing from that person.
Once this is understood, I do not think my fellow panellist’s argument works. I am quite happy to accept that if I was trying to kill or seriously maim another human being that others (including the state) would be morally permitted to use force to stop me; I may not want them to but that is not the issue. The issue is whether I think they are are required not to and the answer I think is obviously no.
In fact, anyone who recognises the government as legitimate must accept that the state can use force against them if they violate certain rules. I would have thought that the laws against assault and homicide would be paradigm examples of this.