I once caught 5 minutes of Oprah discussing religion. She made the comment, in a very sage-sounding tone, that she believed all religions are true. The audience immediately interrupted her with resounding applause; camera shots caught audience members nodding in approval, clearly impressed with the wisdom of the claim just made.
This commonly heard platitude may sound clever, wise and sensible but let’s unpack it:
- All religions are true;
- Christianity is a religion;
- Christianity claims to be the only true religion;
Therefore:
- If all religions are true, Christianity is the only true religion.
[The same line of argument works with any religion which rejects the first premise.]