Tag: Probability of the Resurrection

  • Guest Post: Tim McGrew defends “The Argument from Miracles: A Cumulative Case for the Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth”

    Tim McGrewA little while back we published a post linking to some talks by Tim McGrew on Undesigned Coincidences in the Gospels. For some bizarre reason this post of ours prompted fellow kiwi blogger Deane Galbraith to write a post on the Bulletin for the Study of Religion, linking to our post, on the separate topic of Tim and his wife Lydia McGrew’s article “The Argument from Miracles: A Cumulative Case for the Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth” which was published in the The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology.

    Here is a snippet of Galbraith’s post from the beginning:

    There are quite a few academic and quasi-academic studies in which statistical analysis seems to be employed as a substitute for thinking. It is, perhaps, fairly understandable why some people are tempted by the allure of numbers. Those mysteriously complex formulae, mindnumblingly boring statistics and obscure mathematical notations lend a magical aura of scientific objectivity and plausibility to even the most patently absurd claims.

    What gets me talking about this at this moment is my dumbfounded reading last night of an article published by Timothy McGrew and Lydia McGrew, entitled“The Argument from Miracles: A Cumulative Case for the Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth” (2009). In this article, the McGrews utilize Bayesian probability in order to argue to the “scientific” conclusion that the probability of the resurrection of Jesus is a “staggering” 100,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,
    000,000,000,000,000 to 1.

    Are you staggered? overwhelmed? swooning? Were you previously skeptical about the Christian claim that Jesus was resurrected, but now you’re feeling pretty silly? Perhaps not.

    The post goes on in the same vein to accuse the McGrews of trying to trick people into belief in the resurrection. It is littered with terms like “flimsy basis”, “populist apologetics”, “fanciful” and “deeply and unavoidably farcical” and is illustrated complete with a giant white-robed Caucasian Jesus wistfully looking heavenward as he steps out of the tomb. It finishes with Galbraith laying out his understanding of their mathematical reasoning, the tone at this point is dripping with lashings of smug, self-congratulation at how easily he, PhD student from Otago whose research area is giants in the Old Testament narrative, had dispatched two of the top philosophers of religion working in this field, both specialists in probability theory.

    Not being qualified remotely in Bayesian probability theory myself, and therefore not wanting to presume anything beyond assessing the tone as exceedingly arrogant, I passed on Galbraith’s criticisms to the McGrews on Facebook. Well it turns out that Galbraith isn’t the only non-qualified liberal/atheist to take a punt at their reasoning on this piece. Tim McGrew explains that straw men have been popping up all over.

    Straw Men Burning: Misinterpretations of our Article on the Resurrection

    One of the hazards of writing technical philosophy is the risk that someone who lacks the appropriate expertise will attempt to critique it. In the case of the article on the resurrection that Lydia and I wrote for The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology, this has already happened. It is hard enough to correct misimpressions of this sort on a relatively neutral topic; when the subject rouses passions of the sort that, as Hume reminds us, religious disputes are apt to generate, then the difficulties are redoubled.

    But one thing that we did not anticipate is that (more…)

  • Podcasts on Christian Physicalism and The Probability of Christianity

    Matt and I have been listening to podcasts in the evening lately. These two, featuring two of our friends, who are both philosophers and bloggers, are really worth a listen.

    Glenn on Physicalism
    Glenn Peoples, of Say Hello to my Little Friend: The Beretta Blog and Podcast, recently spoke at the University of Oxford at the annual conference of the European Society for the Philosophy of Religion on the topic “Raising the Justificatory Hurdle: How to Make Sure Religion Stays Out of Politics No Matter What” and while he was there he appeared on the UK’s Unbelievable? radio show to debate the issue of physicalism with John Haldane.

    Listen to: Christian Physicalism: Do we have a soul? – Unbelievable? 04 Sep 2010

    Christians have traditionally held that humans comprise two things – a body and a soul. Christian Philosophers have written in defence of the soul against a reductive atheism that claims we are material beings alone.

    But a new movement in Christian philosophy claims that the atheists are correct, at least when it comes to humans.

    Dr Glenn Peoples is a Christian philosopher who subscribes to physicalism – that humans are only physical and they have no immaterial soul. He explains how he arrived at that view from Scripture and how he defends it philosophically, without giving up an evangelical Christian view.

    Prof John Haldane is a Christian philosopher at St Andrews University in Scotland. He believes that Christian faith and Philosophy bear witness to an immaterial soul – though his “Thomistic” view defends it differently to the prevailing trend.


    Lydia on The Probability of Christianity
    Dr Lydia McGrew, of What’s Wrong With the World and Extra Thoughts, has recently co-authored a Bayesian defence of the historicity of the resurrection in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology, and so Luke Muehlhauser, of Common Sense Atheism, interviewed her for his podcast, Conversations from the Pale Blue Dot.

    Listen to: Lydia McGrew – The Probability of Christianity – CPBD episode 071

    Lydia describes herself as ‘a homemaker and home schooling mum who does analytic philosophy in some of her spare time.’ She is very good at it, as you will quickly pick up in her discussion with Luke. They talk about, among other things:

    • The probability of the Resurrection v the probability of witchcraft at Salem and the Hindu milk miracle
    • The practice of Christian philosophy
    • The fine-tuning argument
    • God as an explanation

    Listen carefully to work out which blogger from this blog gets cited in an example 😉