The Secular Education Network (SEN) has been in the news of late, complaining about religious education in schools. My view is that whether a religious education programme should exist at a given school is something individual schools should decide for themselves and parents should be free to choose whichever school they want to send their child. However, I won’t argue for that position here. Instead, I wanted to comment on something I noticed about SEN. When SEN began getting media attention, I went to look at SEN’s website to see what the organisation was about. Here is the introductory paragraph:
Religious Instruction has no place in New Zealand public schools.
Religious Instruction means teaching and endorsing a faith in its own right, for example, the practiceof Church volunteers ”leading children to a faith in Jesus”. There is a significant difference between religious instruction and religious studies. Religious Studies teaches a comparative overview of the major world religions, taken by qualified teachers in a neutral manner. New Zealand does not currently have this program.
Notice what SEN say here; First, they distinguish between religious instruction which involves church volunteers “leading people to faith in Jesus” and Religious studies which involve “a comparative overview of the major world religions, taken by qualified teachers in a neutral manner”. Concerning the latter, they say “New Zealand does not currently have this program.” The insinuation is that religious education in New Zealand consists only of the first type of practice.
To be honest, this is an astounding claim because it’s patently false. Those who know me personally will be aware I am a religious studies teacher at one of New Zealand’s largest public Catholic high-schools, our department teaches Philosophy, Theology, and religious studies at both Cambridge and NCEA level. Note what I just said here, New Zealand’s official qualification, The National Certificate of Educational Achievement (NCEA), has a Religious Studies Programme
This can, in fact, be found out by visiting the New Zealand Qualifications Authority website which lists subjects which currently exist in New Zealand schools. You’ll see religious studies listed under R. Moreover, one can examine the standards which NZQA lays down for this subject:
Level 1: (year 11)
1. Describe the purpose of a sacred text within a religious tradition.
2.Describe a significant development within a religious tradition.
3.Describe the application of the key ethical principle(s) of a religious tradition to an issue.
4.Describe key beliefs of a religious tradition.
Level 2: (Year 12)
1.Explain a significant theme in a sacred text within a religious tradition.
2.Explain the changes in an expression(s) of a religious tradition
3.Explain how a contemporary social action derives from the ethical principles of a religious tradition
4. Explain the key beliefs within two religious traditions in relation to a significant religious question
Level 3: (Year 13)
1.Analyse the meanings in a sacred text within a religious tradition
2.Analyse a religious tradition(s) in Aotearoa New Zealand
3.Analyse the response of a religious tradition to a contemporary ethical issue.
4.Analyse the key beliefs of a religious tradition and a secular world view in relation to ultimate questions.
Note what these standards require, in level 1 students have to accurately describe significant developments within, doctrines of, how texts function within a religious tradition. In level 2 they have to explain these things. Notice what’s being required here, understanding. Students need to be able to accurately describe and understand religious doctrines, moral reasoning, and history. Finally, in level 3 they have to analyse them. The assessment criteria for NCEA spells this out in more detail often describing involves such things as understanding the origins, the significance, to get merit excellence students often have to do things like evaluate the claims explore their implications and reflect on the significance of these answers. Note also each of these tasks can be done with any religious tradition at all and in several standards, they are required to compare more than one. Level two, for example, requires one to explain the answers of two different religious beliefs and in level 3 they have to compare and analysis secular and religious worldviews.
This is the religious studies standards for NCEA, consequently, New Zealand does have a programme for this. Moreover, I know that NCEA is used in lots of schools, most Catholic integrated schools in New Zealand I know of follow the NCEA programme as part of their religious education programme. I also know of state schools where it is used. I have taught at secular public schools for example where different religions are used in different standards as part of a course in philosophy. Even in Catholic schools, it’s not unusual for students to study Hinduism, or Islam, or Judaism under some of these standards so that students learn the diversity of religious views and how to compare them asses them and so forth. I was at a PD of Catholic schools a few months ago where several teachers mentioned they use Buddhism as an example in some of the standards. I know that there are PD’s on offer for religious education teachers on comparative religions because this is a growth area.
What’s significant is that nothing I say here is news to anyone remotely familiar with education in New Zealand’s secondary sector. Almost every religious education teacher I know of is aware of this, as will almost any child that attends one of the many integrated public schools that do NCEA religious studies and there is a reasonable number that does.
The reason I raise this issue is that it triggers in me a question. Why does the Secular Education Network not know this? You have to wonder about how much research the Secular Education Network has actually done on religious education in New Zealand when blurb on their website contains a pretty obvious falsehood. A falsehood almost anyone involved in religious education in New Zealand is aware of, and which almost any student in the many of NZ’s integrated Catholic schools knows is incorrect. To not know this they would have to have never looked at or examined most of the religious education that takes place every day in NZ schools. Moreover, this falsehood creates an obvious insinuation about religious education in New Zealand which is inaccurate and false. But of course politically expedient and useful to them.
Of course, none of this addresses the concerns SEN has about what it calls religious instruction when it occurs in the primary schools. But granting this, surely SEN have an obligation to not misrepresent the sector when they voice these concerns and to actually have researched and know what they are talking about rather than pandering to stereotypes. As I am sure they will agree we can’t have uninformed bigots who don’t know what they are talking about involved in education now, can we?
