Tag: San Francisco

  • Blogging as a Supplement to Peer Review: My 2011 SBL & ASOR Paper

    At the 2011 annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature and the American Academy of Religion in San Francisco I gave a paper in the Blogger and Online Publication session entitled “Blogging as a Supplement to Peer Review“. It occurred to me today that I have never published it on MandM so here it is.

    This paper will not be a normal academic paper. Normally, when I present one of them, I have a specific thesis I try and offer an argument for it and rebut arguments against it. Today however I will present more of a narrative based on some reflections from my own experience as a blogger and scholar and someone who blends the two.

    Peer ReviewI began engaging in “biblical blogging” with great reluctance.  One of my biggest reservations was that blogs are not peer reviewed. Anyone can, and does, write anything at all and get it published on the internet – even, if it’s complete nonsense. One only has to surf the net for a few minutes to see the problem.

    Further, the readership of blogs is not restricted to scholars. Many blogs feature a person writing on a subject with little or no understanding of it who have a following of devoted readers who are equally ignorant, but nevertheless read and comment on the same topic as if they were knowledgeable. My impression was that blogs on theological topics were no less immune to this problem than blogs on other topics.

    So my first reservation was that a blog post really carried no stature; I felt it would be embarrassing to be known as a blogger – I was seeking to be a scholar.

    My second reservation based on my experience with online communication. There are subtle social constraints on face to face communication. If I have to stand up and speak in front of an audience at a conference I will be nervous.  If I say something stupid publically others will laugh at me and I will be embarrassed. If I get really nasty and cross a line someone might get physically threatening and even hit me if I provoke them. There are social consequences to what I say. Online, however, many of these social constraints are muted, one can be completely anonymous or communicate from a fictional personae. People can say things they would never say saying in public without facing the normal social consequences of such comments. This means that online discussions can be counter-productive. Most bloggers will be familiar with the phenomena of “trolls” people who enter into online discussions simply to insult, attack and distract the discussion. I could not see the attraction much less the benefit of engaging in a medium like that.

    I think both these reservations have some merit. However I now believe that, despite them, blogging can serve as a supplement to peer review. It is hard to not believe that given what blogging has done for me but before I get into that, note that I said supplement, my suggestion is that it can supplement not replace peer review.

    Some Challenges of Traditional Peer Review
    In 2006 I graduated with a PhD in Theology. The prospects in the job market were bad in New Zealand – my part of the world – particularly for an unknown fresh graduate. An immediate goal of mine was to establish myself as a credible theological scholar which, of course, meant getting my work known. I resolved that I needed to be published. If I developed a series of publications, others in my field will read my work, and as a result my work will become known. I began by following the usual route of submitting articles to journals for publication and I found it hard going.

    Let me note two challenges I found with this:

    First, almost no one reads your article until it gets published, and this can affect you (more…)

  • Hear Matt’s EPS Apologetics Conference Paper in Advance & Eat 3 Courses for $10 – This Weekend in Auckland

    We are going to the United States in November to, between us, give 4 talks to 4 different conferences that we have been invited to speak at (details below). We need to raise the funds to get there and so far we have raised about half of what we need thanks to the generosity of readers of this blog 🙂

    Sticky Date Pudding with Maple Butterscotch Sauce - recipe at Mad | FoodMassey Presbyterian Church (“MPC”) has offered to help us put on a fundraising night where both of us will utilise our talents to bring you a three-course meal for $10 cooked by me (I cook see my cooking website Mad | Food) and a talk given by Matt “Can God Command Evil? The Problem of Apparently Immoral Commands” – this will be a slightly abridged version of the very same talk Matt will give to the EPS Apologetics conference in November so make sure you don’t miss it or you’ll have to fly to San Francisco to hear it!

    This event is happening this weekend at the MPC Night Church Service on Sunday 2 October. The starter and main will be served to your table before the service and the dessert will be served after. So please arrive at 6pm to be seated if you are coming for dinner; the service will start at 7pm.

    Menu

    (Diners choose 1 from each category)

    Entree:

    Creamy Tomato Soup – home made, mildly spiced (gluten free)

    MPC Bread – fresh-baked individual loaf with hummus

    Main:*
    White Chilli Chicken Enchilada – chicken, cannellini beans and mild mexican flavours in a delicious sauce wrapped and baked in a tortilla (Gluten free option: served without the tortilla on rice)

    Beef Lasagne – tasty beef mince, layered with pasta and topped with a cheese sauce

    Empanadas – mildly spiced, creamy vegetable and chickpea curry encased in flaky puff pastry topped with poppy seeds, served with chutney on the side (vegetarian) (Gluten free option: served without the pastry on rice)

    * All mains served with your choice of crunchy slaw or steamed winter vegetables

    Dessert:
    Berry Bombe with Boysenberry Coulis – Home made ice-cream with crushed meringue, marshmallows and berries topped with home made boysenberry sauce. (Gluten free)

    Chocolate Tiramisu – layers of coffee-rum flavour infused chocolate sponge and cream (alcohol free)

    Sticky Date Pudding with Maple Butterscotch Sauce – light, fluffy and so delicious!

    Non-alcoholic beverages will also be available.

    Donations towards our trip gratefully received 🙂 

    (If you can’t eat a whole three-course meal or you want two of something individual prices are: entree $2, main $5, dessert $3)  

    Please use the Facebook Page to RSVP and invite others.

    (more…)

  • Next Stop America: An Update

    On 8 November, about 7 weeks from now, Matt and I will board a plane heading to the United States of America. Whilst there we will attend 5 major conferences and, between us, speak at 4 of them. We view this as an opportunity to serve God and the body of Christ, contribute to our fields, learn and grow, meet people, make friends, network, pursue employment options, publication options and represent New Zealand and we are really excited and humbled to have been invited.

    It is a real challenge for us to get there in terms of finance, my pain disability and the logistics of leaving our children for two weeks but we are determined to find a way. Our teens have stepped up and reassured us they can hold the fort and family and friends will back them up. I continue to work furiously at physical rehab to continue my snail’s pace gradual improvements, we have planned in rests and other pain management tactics. We have fantastic friends who have so far donated us $2,233 towards our goal and other friends who have offered us accommodations within the US that cover the bulk of our time there.

    Will give Apologetics, Law and Philosophy papers for food, lodging & transportOne of the things we are keen to do is to pick up a few more speaking events – be it in the form of faculty seminars, campus lectures, church and community talks – we don’t mind. We do not charge speaking fees, it is not really the New Zealand thing to do and we want to make sure that we are accessible but we do accept koha – donations towards the costs of our trip would be much appreciated.

    To that end, whilst we have booked our flights to and from the US and we are locked in to the various conferences we are speaking at/attending we have tried to keep the remainder of our time in the US flexible meaning that we have not yet booked our internal flights and train tickets so that we can stay a few days longer in Indiana or head to San Francisco early or perhaps go somewhere else. We are going to need to book those tickets soon though or the prices will climb too high so if you are keen to organise something contact us.

    Our Itinerary

    8 Nov – Los Angeles
    Staying at least 1 night for a pain rest
    9 Nov –
    10 Nov – South Bend, Indiana
    “Confronting the Challenge of Secularism” Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture begins in the evening.
    11 Nov – South Bend, Indiana
    “Confronting the Challenge of Secularism” Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture – all day
    12 Nov – South Bend, Indiana
    Madeleine’s paper “No Privileges, No Penalties” and the De-Privileging of Secularism” at Confronting the Challenge of Secularism” Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture.
    13 Nov – ?
    14 Nov – ?
    15 Nov – ?
    16 Nov – San Francisco
    Annual Meetings of the Evangelical Theological Society and Matt’s paper “Can Traditional Theism Provide an Adequate Foundation for Morality? A Reply to Walter Sinnott-Armstrong‘s Critique of William Lane Craig?” to the Annual Meeting of the Evangelical Philosophical Society.
    17 Nov – San Francisco
    Annual Meetings of the Evangelical Theological Society and the Evangelical Philosophical Society and the Evangelical Philosophical Society Apologetics Conference.
    18 Nov – San Francisco
    Annual Meetings of the Evangelical Theological Society and the Evangelical Philosophical Society and the Evangelical Philosophical Society Apologetics Conference.
    19 Nov – San Francisco
    Matt’s paper “Can God Command Evil? The Problem of Apparently Immoral Commands” at the Evangelical Philosophical Society Apologetics Conference and Matt and Madeleine’s paper “Blogging a Short-Cut to Peer Review: How to do it Effectively” the Annual Meeting of the Society for Biblical Literature.
    20 Nov – San Francisco
    Annual Meeting of the Society for Biblical Literature  (we’re flexible)
    21 Nov – San Francisco
    Annual Meeting of the Society for Biblical Literature (we’re flexible during the day but are flying home in the evening.
    22 Nov – will be consumed by flying over the international date zone
    23 Nov – Brisbane
    From 8:00 am we have 10.5 hours of stopover time to kill (please only consider using Matt here)

    Costs
    (In NZ Dollars for both of us) 

    Airfares to and from the US: $2,946.50
    Internal flights: $648.38
    Internal train tickets: $83.19
    Conference Fees:

    Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture (includes meals): $309.30
    Evangelical Theological Society & Evangelical Philosophical Society: $37.12
    Evangelical Philosophical Society Apologetics: Free
    Society for Biblical Literature: $408.28
    *TOTAL: $4432.77
    Less money raised: $2,233
    *Target still to raise: $2199.77

    We have a few fundraising ventures planned here in Auckland which we will announce soon (if you are New Zealand based and think you could help us there let us know) but we are confident we’ll get there. If you feel so inclined you can donate via PayPal in our sidebar or using one of the options on our Support page. If you can’t donate can you Tweet? Link? Like? Share? Someone else might see this who can 🙂

    Oh and because we get asked it by everyone: the reason we have to pay to attend all but 1 conference we are speaking at is because most speakers are established academics at institutions whose institutions pay for them so the practice is for each professional organisation to charge fees – although we do get a discount for being speakers, attendees who are not speaking pay more. The EPS Apologetics Society is an exception – they granted both of us free entry because Matt is speaking, aren’t they nice?

    * We have not yet priced accommodation in Los Angeles, transfers within San Francisco and we do not yet know how long we can couch surf for and where we might need to pay for a few nights accommodation. Then there is food. The goal is to keep the total costs under $5,000.

  • “Confronting the Challenge of Secularism” Madeleine to Speak at the Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture

    The Notre Dame Center for Ethics and CultureNot too long ago I wrote a post entitled We’re Going to San Francisco! In it I announced that in November 2011 Madeleine and I will jointly be giving a paper to the Society of Biblical Literature Annual Meeting, and that I will be giving a paper to the Evangelical Philosophical Association Annual Meeting and also to the Evangelical Philosophical Association’s Annual Apologetics Conference. Well, now we are also going to South Bend, Indiana.

    The Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture recently advertised a call for papers for its 2011 Flagship Fall Conference, “Radical Emancipation:  Confronting the Challenge of Secularism.” The stated aim of the conference is:

    “… to bring together a large number of respected scholars representing all the main academic fields, from Catholic, Christian, and secular institutions, to engage in a spirited discussion of this theme from the perspectives of philosophy, theology and religious studies, law, history, the social sciences, literature and the arts, as well as other fields of intellectual inquiry and endeavor.”

    Given that the conference will be held only a few days before the San Francisco cluster of conferences, given that both Madeleine and I work in religion in public life from within our separate disciplines of philosophy of law and analytic theology and both of us draw from the writings of Notre Dame scholars, we decided to both put in papers. It seems that a lot of other people had the same idea as an announcement appeared on the website “Record number of conference abstracts submitted!” This is not surprising given the reputation and calibre of the Notre Dame Center for Ethics and Culture so when we saw this we thought neither of us stood a chance.

    So, you can imagine our delight, and how proud I was of my wife, when she received the following email notification yesterday,

    “I am pleased to accept your paper proposal for presentation at the conference to be held at the University of Notre Dame from November 10-12, 2011. Congratulations! … This year, we turned down an unprecedented number of worthy paper proposals: well over 200 individuals submitted abstracts for consideration.”

    My paper was not successful but I have been invited to chair a session 🙂

    Madeleine wrote a very good abstract:

    “No Privileges, No Penalties” and the De-Privileging of Secularism

    Madeleine Flannagan – University of Auckland, New Zealand

    The dominant Establishment Clause jurisprudence reflects a separationist reading of the First Amendment that advances and protects the hegemony of secular perspectives in public life. Each test, Lemon, Endorsement and Coercion, requires the State to place a restraint on the exercise of religion in public life that effectively privatizes religion and contributes to the radical emancipation of man from God.[1]

    I will argue that the requirement of public conformity to secular perspectives exceeds the traditional understanding of separation of church and state by privileging secular perspectives over religious ones. A clear asymmetry in the way religious beliefs are treated by the State is visible in the requirement that religious believers bracket beliefs they hold as true, important and relevant when they participate in public life while secular citizens are free to utilize the beliefs central to their perspective.

    Vincent Phillip Muñoz has argued for a move away from Separationist jurisprudence and towards a test found in the writings of Founding Father James Madison, a “no privileges, no penalties” test.[2] I will argue that a “no privileges, no penalties” test could uphold freedom of religion and separation of church and state by permitting religion to have a place in public life as long as those who engage in public religious conduct do not gain a privilege for doing so and those who do not wish to participate are both free to opt out and are not penalized for doing so. The adoption of a “no privileges, no penalties” test would ensure that those seeking to bring balance to our secularized culture would not be restrained by the State from doing so.


    [1] The Lemon Test insists that public policy have a valid secular purpose; that a non-religious rationale be offered for all state actions. The Endorsement Test prohibits the state from “endorsing” religion over irreligion. The Coercion Test provides that the state must not coerce religious practice; not only must it not be required, but in Lee v Weisman the application was shifted to what Justice Scalia, in his dissent, termed a “test of psychological coercion”. The Supreme Court held that being one of few (or the only one) to opt out of a religious practice in a public setting is a form of state coercion by peer pressure. (Notably it did not hold that the same is true in reverse.)

    [2] Vincent Phillip Muñoz documents in God and the Founders: Madison, Washington and Jefferson (Cambridge University Press, Ney York, 2009) 33  that when Madison was editing the religious freedom amendment to Virginia’s Declaration of Rights, Madison proposed the following revision: “That Religion or the duty we owe to our Creator, and the manner of discharging it, being under the direction of reason and conviction only, not violence or compulsion, all men are equally entitled to the full and free exercise of it accord[in]g to the dictates of Conscience; and therefore that no man or class of men ought, on account of religion to be invested with peculiar emoluments or privileges, nor subjected to any penalties or disabilities …” [Emphasis mine]

    If you would like to make a donation to assist Madeleine and I in getting to the US for all of the above conferences this November please visit our “Support page” or see our “Donate” button in the side-bar.

    If you would like to book either of us to speak whilst we are in the US please let us know asap as we will be purchasing flight tickets very shortly.

  • Society of Biblical Literature: Blogger and Online Publication

    The Society of Biblical Literature’s program book for their 2011 meeting in San Francisco is now online. The blogger and online publication session for which Matt and I have had a joint paper accepted shows who we are sharing the session with and provides links to brief abstracts for each talk.

    Society of Biblical Literature Annual Meeting

    Blogger and Online Publication
    Robert R. Cargill, University of Iowa, Presiding
    11/19/2011

    4:00 PM to 6:30 PM
    Room: Room TBD – Hotel TBD

    Robert R. Cargill, University of Iowa
    Welcome and Introduction (5 min)

    Alice Bach, Case Western Reserve University
    Can Blogging at 3 AM Be Considered Scholarship? (25 min)

    Madeleine Flannagan, University of Auckland and Matthew Flannagan, Independent Scholar
    Blogging a Short-Cut to Peer Review: How to do it Effectively (25 min)

    Juhana Markus Saukkonen, University of Helsinki
    Sense and Practicality: Building a Historical GIS Online (25 min)

    Richard Price, CEO Academia.edu
    Academia.edu: The Past, Present, and Future of Scholarly Social Networking (25 min)

    The session will conclude with: Q&A discussion with Richard Price. (25 min)

    RELATED POSTS:
    We’re Going to San Francisco!

     

  • We’re Going to San Francisco!

    San FranciscoLast year I was invited to present at the Annual Evangelical Philosophical Society Apologetics Conference in Atlanta, Georgia. This was a real surprise to me and an honour. Some of the best evangelical Christian scholars in the world presented at this conference; speakers included Alvin Plantinga, William Lane Craig, Paul Copan, Gary Habermas, Mike Licona, Frank Beckwith and numerous others.

    I felt very out of my depth. Meeting Alvin Plantinga whose writings inspired me to take philosophy as a theological enterprise seriously was truly amazing and when Al changed the standard jokes (if you’ve seen a few of his lectures you’ll know what I mean) in both his key note addresses for jokes about New Zealanders it was something else. To have the greatest living philosopher of religion acknowledge the sole kiwi in the audience was something I did not expect.

    “Last year I spoke at only the Apologetics Conference and the Society for Biblical Literature Meeting but this year I will be presenting at all three.”

    Even more humbling was being asked to speak on the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s panel presentation to the Annual Meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature, which was running at the same time. Me, the blogger from MandM, presented alongside Richard Hess one of the best Evangelical Old Testament scholars in the world, Paul Copan, the President of the Evangelical Philosophical Society, an expert on God and Morality, and Randal Rauser, a top Analytic Theologian, who has done some great work getting theologians to take analytic philosophy seriously with Notre Dame’s Michael Rea, an outstanding philosopher of religion and meta-physician as chair. It was truly unreal engaging in a discussion on the relationship between divine command ethics and the Old Testament conquest narratives with these people. I kept wondering when they were going to realise they’d made a mistake inviting me! Even more so when one considers that the audience gathered to hear us and ask questions included people like Eric Seibert, Christopher Wright, Doug Geivett and William Lane Craig – all prestigious scholars who easily should have been presenting instead of me! The experience was extremely rewarding. There were various positive reviews of the panel from the Evangelical Philosophical Society, William Lane Craig, Claude Mariottini and various observers. I learnt a lot and discovered, somewhat to my surprise, that I could intelligently contribute in discussion at this level and that these other scholars were interested in what I had to say.

    Since coming back from Atlanta, my professional employment prospects have improved; while I still do not have full-time work, I am doing work on an increasingly steady flow of short-term projects. I have been asked to (more…)

  • The Kiwi Contingent: EPS San Francisco 2011

    San FranciscoThis November the 2011 National Meeting of the Evangelical Philosophical Society (“EPS”) will be held in San Francisco, CA from November 16th-18th. The plenary speaker this year will be Dr Dallas Willard from the University of Southern California who will be speaking on moral epistemology.

    Accordingly, a call for papers has been issued for papers focussing on issues pertaining to moral epistemology or moral theory more broadly construed (although other topics will be considered). After conferring with EPS President Dr Paul Copan, I have been advised that the EPS will accept my submission for consideration despite my lack of PhD, so this post confirms that both Matt and I have both officially submitted papers for blind review on our various areas of speciality. (We’ll be more specific as to our abstracts once we know whether we have been accepted or not; we need to respect the blind review process for now).

    Fellow kiwi Dr Glenn Peoples, author of Say Hello to my Little Friend: The Beretta Blog and Podcast and frequent commenter on this blog, also hopes to be travelling with us and speaking at the EPS as well. I understand he too is putting together an abstract.

    Matt’s visit to the cluster of Christian conferences held annually in the US each November, the annual meetings of the Evangelical Philosophical Society (“EPS”) the EPS Apologetics meeting, the Evangelical Theological Society (“ETS”) and the Society for Biblical Literature (“SBL”), were so profitable in terms of academic exposure, networking and even some fixed-term employment, committee opportunities and opportunities to publish that we intend to take the advice he was given, “if you want to work in Christian academia in the US then go to the EPS every single year until you are hired.”

    So the first step will be getting through review!