Tag: Total Depravity

  • More Mistakes: A Rejoinder to Randal Rauser

    For those who aren’t aware, there has been something of a “debate”, but what I’d prefer to refer to as an “in house discussion” between Randal Rauser (Professor of Historical Theology at Taylor Seminary) and myself.

    The discussion so far can be found here:

    My initial article was Randal Rauser’s Mistake: A Defense of Calvin’s Doctrine of Election

    Rauser’s response: Calvinism and the Arbitrary Camp Director Revisited: A Response to Andrew

    Andrew and CalvinBefore I begin, I should point out that I have been on the Kapiti coast for the last week at a TSCF (Tertiary Student Christian Fellowship, a cousin of Inter-Varsity) retreat where I was without internet. Hence it’s only in the last day that I’ve learned that Professor Rauser has kindly taken the time to respond to my initial article. So I apologize for my delayed response.

    I would also like to point out that while my intention was to provoke Rauser’s response, it was not to be rude, and I apologize if that’s the impression he has received. I have a great deal of respect for Rauser, particularly given (as I pointed out in my last article) that he is a Professor of Historical Theology with an obvious background in analytic philosophy, while I am a mere undergrad with far more ambition than actual ability. The last thing that I want is for this discussion to devolve into the kind of vitriol that plagues almost all other web based discussions of the philosophy of religion and/or theology. I say this, largely because I fear (from the tone of his response) that he has received the impression of ill intent on my part.

    Secondly, I appreciate that Rauser took the time to respond to my article, and I appreciate that he also took the time to counter my personal testimony with that of his own.

    Randal Rauser and ArminiusBut now to specifics: How does Rauser respond to my claim that the arbitrariness objection (at least if it is to be an objection) begs the question against Calvin’s doctrine of election? On the face of it, he doesn’t seem to challenge my point that God may not be acting unjustly if we are undeserving of salvation. To the contrary, Rauser seems to admit for the possibility that the tortures may be justly deserved. But if that’s the case, then, as I tried to point out in my first post, there’s no real injustice or immoral state of affairs that obtains if God so desires to instantiate those punishments. Paradoxically though, Rauser refers to my theology as “brutal” and “morally incoherent”. Both of these terms, emotionally provocative as they are, seem to suggest that there is something nasty, horrible, evil (whatever negative adjective your heart desires) about a God that selects some for salvation while selecting others for damnation. But if, as Rauser seems to allow, the tortures are justly deserved, then none of those adjectives can rightly be said to stick. After all, if the tortures are justly deserved, and God decides to carry out those tortures, then God can only be said to be doing what the demands of morality and/or justice require. So wherein does the moral incoherence obtain?

    But according to Rauser, I would still be missing the point. After all, he (Rauser) says, the Camp Director Analogy was not intended to show that God, given Calvinism, is “unjust”, but rather that He cannot be seen as “maximally loving”. I see no real reason to deny Rauser the liberty to make this distinction, but its relevance is, at best, unclear.

    Thankfully, Rauser does seem to hint at one possible way in which we could interpret this as an objection. He seems to engage in something of a pair-wise comparison between two possible scenarios that are supposed to be relevantly similar to the Arminian and Calvinist conceptions of election respectively.

    • Scenario 1: The director arbitrarily selects some children for beatings and others for loving rehabilitation.
    • Scenario 2: The director selects all children for loving rehabilitation.

    According to Rauser, were God to bring about scenario 2, we would state that He is more loving were he to bring about scenario 1. There are three things that I have to say to this (more…)

  • Slow Learners: Foolishness Bound Up in the Heart

    Sometimes we Christians find ourselves wondering at the foolishness on display in our society.  Things which to us are so self-evident and obvious appear  beyond the ken of the average Unbeliever.  Take something as basic as whether depravity and perverseness is native to the human soul, or not.  Christians, realizing that this is something about which we cannot be neutral, turn to the revelation of God to find that indeed we are all corrupt.

    The doctrine of Total Depravity is often misunderstood. The Scriptures do not teach that man is corrupt as can be, but that every part of the human being is to some extent corrupted by evil.  The “total” in Total Depravity refers to universality not degree.  The poison of sin is traceable in every part of our being.  In some times and cultures the poison is more advanced than in others.  The ante-diluvian civilization, for example, saw a maturation and flowering of evil everywhere: every intent and thought of the heart of men was only evil continually, we are told (Genesis 6:5).  But at other times the redemptive record reveals that Unbelieving cultures are a long way short of being filled up with evil (Genesis 15:16).

    This being so, it is expected that children, for example, will manifest aspects and manifestations of self-will, disobedience, contumacy, stubbornness, and selfishness from a very early age.  “I was brought forth in iniquity and in sin my mother conceived me” says the Psalmist (Psalm 51: 5).  The Borg is on-board the ship, as it were.  Experience confirms the expectation in spades.  Every parent would have to be blinded by some very opaque glasses indeed not to see this from the very earliest days of their child’s life.

    Yet the general consensus is that children are born righteous and without sin and that it is society which corrupts them.  Man is good and righteous, innocent; it is the environment which makes him evil.  Thus it is generally held that crime is a social construct: if wages were higher, education more effective, and better television programming were to be had, crime would wither on the vine.  The reason folk spend all their life on the dole is not that they are lazy or indigent, but because “society” has not presented them with the right employment opportunity.

    The child-as-innocent view has won the ideological and religious battle in our country now for over fifty years.  If society believes that children are innocent until made sinful by external conditioning parenting immediately becomes child-centric.  The challenge is to impose as little as possible, and to allow the innocence within to come forth and flourish.  Indulgence and permissiveness become the order of the day.

    ChocolateIt is no surprise to Christians that the fruits will be forthcoming generations riven with narcissism, self-indulgence, sociopathic behaviours and dissipation.  So it has come to pass–and we marvel at how society is puzzled by this, as if it were unexpected.  It has led to what is now being called the “New Zealand paradox”: high teenage injury, death rates, and national debt  in such a peaceful, ethical and developed nation.

    Solving this paradox has become urgent.  Now there are claims that (more…)