Author: Madeleine

  • Christian Blog Ranking Report for July 09 – Tumeke

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on Tumeke’s NZ blog stats for July; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for July 09:

    Top 10 Tumeke. name of blog Tumeke rank

    Of Note:

    • Our first time in the number 1 spot on Tumeke.
    • No newcomers to the top 10, again, some position changing demonstrating the growth in the kiwi Christian blogosphere.
    • Christian News New Zealand 68, Kiwi Polemicist 71, Star Studded Super Step 92 each made the top 100 despite being outside the top 10.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s ranking descriptions. If you think your blog should be included contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings.

    Now that Tumeke’s July stats are out we will compare them with the HalfDone July report and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for July 09 shortly.

  • Dear Cabinet,

    I am a mother of 4; I am currently doing the last few papers of my law degree at Auckland Uni, I voted “no” in the referendum, I voted for you to govern at the last election. I am sure you are getting a lot of emails, however, as you deliberate as to how to respond to the results of the recent referendum, please take a moment to consider my thoughts.

    It used to be clear in New Zealand that a light smack for the purposes of parental correction was lawful. Then s59 of the Crimes Act was amended.

    Whether a light smack was lawful or not became confusing. Experts in legal interpretation agree that, as worded, the new s59 could be read either way. I have been in the same room as John Key and I have heard him concede that the new s59 was poorly worded. I have sat in the same room with Sue Bradford and heard her give contradictory answers, as to whether she intended to make smacking illegal or not and whether it is or not. When I read the law, even with my legal training, I cannot decipher it clearly – I can run conflicting arguments as to what it means. Small wonder the populace was confused.

    The government would not listen. A referendum was successfully called and the result is in, 88% of those who voted want it made clear that a light smack is not illegal; had the entire voting population voted I doubt there would have been a significant variation in that majority and I doubt that you doubt the truth of this. The majority of voting adults in this country feel very strongly about this issue and they have sent you a message.

    Now not for a moment do I expect you to simply follow the whim of the majority; as MPs I helped to elect you to parliament because I expected you to do what you, hand on your heart, truly believe is right and I recognise that sometimes that might mean standing against the majority. That said, in considering what is right, I would hope you would rely on solid research, well reasoned arguments and consider the concerns of the people you represent. If you ignore the referendum message or pretend you do not understand it, you will not only become the epitome of what was despised about the government before you but more importantly you will leave us confused as to what the law is.

    The state has a duty to ensure that the law is clear enough for the citizens to be able to understand it; if it is not then it is not just to demand their obedience to it. It is not enough to issue a clarificatory statement or guidelines to the public, police and relevant state agencies as to what the law really means as that affords us, the citizens, no certainty as to what it might mean in the future when you may no longer be governing us. If I find myself before a court or investigated by the police or a state agency it is the black letter of the law I should be able to reach for to know whether I stand on the side of guilt or innocence not some pamphlet or tv campaign or media release.

    You didn’t write this law, you tried to save it, yet it still came out poorly drafted; now you have the power to make the law clear. In doing so I would hope you would consider the peer reviewed studies that differentiate between a light smack and abuse which show the former is not child abuse as this would enable you to listen to the referendum result and act on it.

    With great respect for the very tough job you do and many kind regards,

    Madeleine Flannagan

    RELATED POSTS:
    Fisking Margaret Mayman: The Flawed Moral Theology on the Smacking Referendum
    Fisking Ian Hassall: The Arbitrary Ethical Reasoning on the Smacking Referendum
    No Defences Permitted for the Accused
    MandM Smacking Label

  • No

    The results of the anti-smacking referendum are in. In answer to the question “Should a smack as part of good parental correction be a criminal offence in New Zealand?” 87.6% of voters said “no.”

    Fairly resounding.

    Vote No seem happy. We are too. Now it is time to sit back and see how the government responds. Nothing less than a law change to clarify what is and is not legal, with regard to smacking, will make me happy.

  • The Freedom of Association Bill

    Fantastic news! Yesterday the Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment Bill 75/1 was drawn from the ballot. Sponsored by ACT’s Sir Roger Douglas, the explanatory note states:

    The purpose of this Bill is to uphold students’ right to freedom of association, by ensuring that no student is compelled to join a students association.

    Section 17 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 guarantees the right to freedom of association. This right includes the freedom from compelled association. Parliament has an obligation to ensure New Zealand legislation is consistent with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act and New Zealand’s obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

    This Bill does not seek to damage or limit students associations, but guarantees the right of students to the freedom of association. It will result in students associations being truly representative of the students who voluntarily join them.

    Under this Bill, all students would be able to choose whether or not to join a students association. The current Act requires councils to conduct a referendum to decide if all students should be forced to become members of an association, if petitioned by 10% of the students enrolled at the institution. If a majority of voters in a referendum support compulsory membership, then the right to freedom of association for the all remaining students is breached.

    This Bill seeks to address the negative consequences stemming from the passing of the Education Amendment Act 2000 and the referenda provisions of the Education (Tertiary Students Association Voluntary Membership) Amendment Act 1997. The current legislation fails to guarantee individual students a satisfactory opportunity to withdraw from associations, and sets the bar too high for those who wish to make membership of a students association voluntary.

    The link above will take you to a pdf of the Bill as hosted by Salient (Blogger does not permit me to upload attachments). As former President and Vice-President of the Waikato Students Union during its brief stint as a voluntary association, Matt and I are extremely pleased that this bill is on the table and we urge the government to back it.

    The only thing I would want to fiddle with is clause 6 to make sure it is really clear that the voluntary membership model at the University of Auckland, where I currently study, is not able to continue. It is effectively compulsory funding but voluntary membership and almost all the problems of compulsory associations remain as a result. It appears that clause 6 of this Bill is intended to address this,

    6 New section 229 substituted

    Section 229 is repealed and the following section substituted:

    “229 Voluntary membership of students associations

    “(1) No person, including any tertiary institution or any association of students, may require any student or exert undue influence on any student –

    “(a) to become or not become a member of any association of students; or
    “(b) to pay any money to any association of students, or to any other person in lieu of such fees.

    “(2) No person, including any tertiary institution, may act in any way which conflicts with the sprit and intent of this section.” [sic]

    However, at Auckland no student directly has to pay any money to the student association. The money is taken from student levies and payed via a service agreement to the association. I worry that as written this clause might permit that to continue. Still such things can always be fiddled with during the select committee process or via supplementary order papers if the Bill goes that far.

  • Contra Mundum: A New Column in Investigate Magazine

    MandM have officially joined the ranks of New Zealand blogs with print columns; Kiwiblog’s David Farrar writes for the NBR, Cactus Kate writes for The Dominion Post and now MandM write for Investigate Magazine – you can now get your MandM fix both online and at your magazine stand!

    Pick up this month’s edition of Investigate Magazine, available now, turn to page 28 and you will find it features a new column, Contra Mundum, authored by Matt.

    Contra Mundum is Latin for ‘against the world;’ the phrase is usually attributed to Athanasius who was exiled for defending Christian orthodoxy. September 09’s Contra Mundum is entitled “What’s wrong with imposing your beliefs onto others?” In it Matt cites feminist bio-ethicist, Leslie Cannold, frequent MandM commenter and blogger, atheist scientist Ken Perrott of Open Parachute and argues the case that it is not always wrong to impose religious beliefs onto others.

    Get your copy today or just subscribe so you don’t miss any columns (I should get commission for sales LOL!).

  • Philosophy Carnival XCV

    The Philosophy Carnival XCV is now online.

    Matt’s post on Walter Sinnott-Armstrong on God, Morality and Arbitrariness was featured, albeit with a rather questionable introductory write-up; keep an eye on the comments at both links for some interesting debate.

  • Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs – June 09

    The Top 10 New Zealand Christian Blogs for June 09 are as follows:

    1. [1.] NZ Conservative 16.5 (7 – 26 )
    2. [3.] MandM 17 (5 – 29)
    3. [2.] MacDoctor Moments 18 (21 – 15)
    4. [4.] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (HalfDone) 20 (15 – 25)
    5= [5.] Keeping Stock 31 (28 – 34)
    5= [7.] Being Frank 31 (40 – 22)
    6. [6.] Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta Blog) 32.5 (29 – 36)
    7. [8.] The Humanitarian Chronicle 36 (25 – 47)
    8. [10.] Sustain:If:Able Kiwi 47 (50 – 44)
    9. [9.] The Briefing Room 53.5 (54 – 53)
    10. [N.] Contra Celsum 62 (55 – 69)

    Rank. [previous top 10 rank] Blog MandM (Half Done – Tumeke)

    To obtain our stats we run searches on Half Done’s June 09 NZ stats and Tumeke’s June 09 NZ stats for openly Christian blogs then we average those blogs scores to obtain their overall scores. If you think your blog should make our rankings make sure you are listed on both Tumeke and HalfDone’s rankings as an identifiably Christian blog.