Author: Madeleine

  • And United Future’s Baubles Are…

    National and United Future’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Peter Dunne gets Minister of Revenue and Associate Minister of Health.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • Maintain the policy, research and advocacy role of the Families Commission whilst seeking to achieve administrative efficiencies between the operations of the Families Commission and the Office of the Children’s Commissioner.
    • Reducing elective surgery waiting lists by greater utilisation of private hospital capacity, in a planned way where this cannot be met by the public hospital system;
    • Progressing the long-term medicines strategy for quality use of pharmaceuticals in the health sector, Medicines New Zealand, including the role Pharmac should play in that strategy.
    • Support Public Private Partnerships for major roading infrastructure developments where these are deemed to be the preferred options regionally and nationally, such as the Transmission Gully highway.
    • The government notes that United Future has been committed to income splitting as a key part of their tax policy and agrees to support appropriate legislation to First Reading in Parliament.
    • Proceed with the establishment of a Big Game Hunting Council as part of a national wild game management strategy with a view to it becoming a statutory authority.
    • And the government acknowledges United Future’s ongoing support and interest in the development of the Seniors’ Gold Card, the Community and Voluntary sector, and advancing the interests of the disability sector.

    Most of it is the usual centrist stuff *sigh* but I will comment of the standouts.

    The Families Commission was a dumb idea and it has been a dumb bureaucratic nanny-state money-gobbler, just like the Children’s Commission, ever since. So ugh! to that policy.

    Income splitting is a positive move to lowering taxes but it adds complexity to the tax laws and does not benefit enough people. Lowering the top tax rates as the government are planning to to 30% would make the need for income splitting largely redundant.

  • And the Maori Party gets…

    National and the Maori Party’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Two Maori Party MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:

    Dr Sharples gets Maori Affairs Minister, Associate Education Minister and Associate Corrections Minister.
    Tariana Turia gets Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector, Associate Health Minister and Associate Social Development Minister.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • National offered a review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act to see if was working and whether there were any better alternatives.
    • National will drop its opposition to the Maori seats and in turn, the Maori Party would drop its pursuit of entrenching the Maori seats and a group will be formed to look at constitutional issues including Maori representation.

    Good on the Maori Party for pushing the Foreshore and Seabed Act issue. It is a shame to see that National has not framed the issue in terms of the affront to due process and instead is talking about all New Zealander’s being able to access the beach, as if that is somehow more important than human rights.

    I am relieved to see there is no deal to entrench the Maori seats. The status quo of race based representation is abhorrent enough.

  • And the Left FIGHT BACK!

    I stumbled across this nonsense over at Socialist Aotearoa; the same old tired slogans from the student union movement are of course today’s mantra for the grown-up ex-student flunkys who now work in the state sector or for the “real world” unions. The only thing that’s changed is the number of wrinkles and the method of extracting funds from unwitting citizens.

    “take the battle to Key and Hide”

    “massive attacks on our rights and conditions as NAT-ACT implement the Shock Doctrine”

    “JOIN THE FIGHTBACK.” [Emphasis NOT mine]

    I passed Socialist Aotearoa by thinking its just the extremists talking, the moderate left surely have grown up a bit, or at least invented some new tactics, but alas… see The Standard’s latest offering in Nats step to the right with ACT, particularly check out this propaganda-pearler:

    Flatter tax. That means any future tax cuts will go exclusively to the wealthy. Most people will get nothing. [Emphasis mine]

    Really? Setting aside the fact that tax cuts to the top earners still potentially benefit everyone (as in let’s pretend they do not) lets take a look at the confidence and supply agreement between National and ACT:

    … National and ACT note that United Future favours reducing and aligning personal, trust and company taxes at a maximum rate of 30%. They agree that such a tax structure is a desirable medium-term goal.

    Yes there is stuff in the agreement about long term goals but the only thing all the parties are agreeing on right now is to aim for a maximum rate of 30%.

    So now, lets take a look at the individual income tax rates:

    Ok, so that’s a crap picture but if you squint or go here, you will see that reducing the individual tax rate to 30% will impact everyone who earns more than $40,001 per year.

    So according to The Standard, if you earn $40k + $1 you are wealthy. What planet do they live on that makes them think $40k is wealthy? Try living in a main centre with a family on that income, you might be able to get by if you are frugal but there is no way you could be called wealthy.

    I suppose if you are a single, state-servant and can tap into state sector fringe benefits $40k might keep you in chardonnay.

  • The Deal is Signed: New Zealand Has a New Government

    The hoardings have barely had time to gather dust and National have just announced they have stitched up a deal with ACT, United Future and the Maori Party. Surely this is the fastest confidence and supply stitch up in the history of NZ MMP.

    National and ACT’s confidence and supply agreement is available here online. Highlights are:

    Two ACT MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Rodney Hide gets: Minister of Local Government, Minister of Regulatory Reform, Associate Minister of Commerce and a member of the Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee.

    Heather Roy gets: Minister of Consumer Affairs, Associate Minister of Defence and Associate Minister of Education.

    Areas of Co-Operation Are:

    • Law and Order
    • Climate Change
    • Controlling Government Expenditure
    • Tax
    • Regulation
    • Resource Management Act
    • Education

    Policy Concessions include:

    • An advisory group to look at ways of closing the income gap with Australia by 2025 with the aim of stopping the exodus.
    • Pursuit of a sustained lift in New Zealand’s productivity growth rate to 3% a year or more and the establishment of a high quality advisory group to investigate the reasons for the recent decline in New Zealand’s productivity performance
    • National will, within 6 months, send ACT’s Taxpayer Rights Bill to the Finance and Expenditure Committee of Parliament as a government measure with the aim of passing into law a cap on the growth of core Crown expenses.
    • National agrees to introduce ACT’s “Three Strikes Bill” and support it to Select Committee.
    • The implementation of the Emissions Trading Scheme will be delayed until a review of New Zealand’s response on Climate Change with agreed draft terms of reference is completed, and the thermal generation ban will be repealed.
    • An agreement that a medium-term goal be set for the top rate of tax to be 30 percent so NZ has a government that will reward and celebrate success – not punish it.
    • National will explore the concept of a New Zealand Productivity Commission associated with the Productivity Commission in Australia in order to support the goals of higher productivity growth and improvements in the quality of regulation.
    • An agreement to work together over time to increase education choices so that pupils and families have more freedom to select schooling options that best meet the individual needs of their children.
    • Ongoing discussion is agreed to on ACT’s most excellent 20 point plan.

    Sounds promising. I was worried that Key’s pursuit of Dunne and the Maori Party meant something far more centrist would be announced. I dislike all the bureaucratic committees that will be funded and set up to talk about everything but hopefully something positive will come out of it. Its better than what we had anyway.

    Details on United Future and the Maori Party’s baubles are yet to be announced – I hope the Maori Party have stood firm on some aspect of the Seabed and Foreshore as ACT should support them on that and there will be those in National who were appalled at that particular affront to due process too.

  • Rickards, Nicholas and Flaws in the Adversarial System

    As someone who intends to share the same career as Clint Rickards I have to say I am uncomfortable hearing that the NZ Law Society has granted Rickards a certificate of character to practice law. I am uncomfortable because the legal system forces us into an absurd position that everyone knows is farcical and yet it must be maintained in the name of justice. Let me explain.

    We know that:

    1. A person is innocent of a crime until proven guilty.
    2. Rickards was not proven guilty of rape.
    3. Nicholas claimed that Rickards did rape her.
    4. Perjury is a crime.
    5. Nicholas has not been found guilty of perjury (or even tried).

    The problem is that if you accept 1. then you are required (by 2.) to conclude that Rickards is innocent and therefore the allegation made in 3. is false.

    However, if you accept 1. then you are required (by 4. and 5.) to assume that Nicholas is innocent and therefore the allegation made in 3. is true.

    Therefore, acceptance of the presumption of innocence requires us to believe both that Rickards did and did not rape Nicholas and it requires us to believe both that Nicholas did and did not commit perjury.

    Obviously this is rationally impossible. We know that it cannot be true that both parties are innocent or that both parties are guilty.

    The presumption of innocence requires us to believe such nonsense. Given we are talking about serious things such as rape and false allegations thereof, we are extremely uncomfortable adopting positions we know are false (and we know it is false that he both raped and did not rape and she perjured and did not perjure).

    So I am right to not feel comfortable about accepting Rickards’ innocence even though legally I know I must and I am uncomfortable about branding Nicholas a liar because at least with Rickards he was tried, Nicholas has not been, (despite what some idiots think).

    The problems with the presumption of innocence do not stop at logical absurdities. Another problem is that to claim someone is innocent under the adversarial system, simply means they have not been proved guilty. This is not the same thing as saying they have been proved innocent. “Not guilty” means that the high evidential standard was not met; it is possible to reasonably doubt the accusation. Of course the accusation could be more probable than not, it could be highly probable, it could be completely ridiculous to entertain but it is not certain. Basically a “not guilty” verdict under the adversarial system simply tells us where the benefit of the doubt should lie; it does not remove the doubt.

    Related Posts: Labour Erodes More Human Rights: The Criminal Procedure Bill

  • Sometimes the Left are Right: The Right-Wing 5 Headed Monster

    One of the things I am loving about not being affiliated to any party is that I can criticise my own ‘side’. It is a liberating thing.

    I stumbled accross this on The Standard and I have to say I agreed with it.

    Well, most of it.

    Definately did not agree with the last line…

    And of course John Key was right that a government without a clear direction being pulled all over the show by competing agendas would not be good for the country, especially in a time of economic uncertainty and there is the fact that what he was speaking of and what the Standard are referring to do differ somewhat, in that he only needs a two headed monster to govern and one of the 5 heads is really a two headed monster in its own right, but Tane does have a point….

    Moving right along.

    Taken from: Careful of them monsters, John by Tane.

    It’s amazing to see how quickly John Key got over his fear of five-headed monsters once it came time to cobble together a government, and more amazing still how quickly the media chose to forgive and forget.

    You’ll recall that just two weeks ago the media couldn’t get enough of John’s line that having a government composed of:

    “all sorts of different parties” with “competing interests” would not be in the best interests of New Zealand during a period of “difficult economic times to manage”.

    But, silly me, they bought that one when it was Helen Clark’s coalition options in question. Now that it’s John Key, it turns out what was irresponsible just two weeks ago was actually “smart” and “inclusive” all along.

    They’re a funny bunch, our right-wing media.

    [I am sorry but if the media is “right-wing” then what on earth am I? Maybe a better question is what does that make The Standard?!?!?]

  • The New Zealand Christian Blog Rankings

    In September I extrapolated from Tim Selwyn’s Tumeke Blog rankings, and published the top 10 New Zealand Christian blogs on public discourse. The post where I did this proved surprisingly popular and as other bloggers have since requested that I do this every month, I have decided that I will.

    At the moment I rank the top 10 as these fall in the top 150 of all NZ blogs on public discourse but if more Christian blogs climb the public lists then I will expand my list accordingly.

    I think it is only fair that I explain how I identify a Christian Blog as some blogs that are run by Christians did not make my list. It is simple. To be a Christian Blog you must self-identify that your blog contributes to the public blogosphere from an overtly Christian perspective and this must be recorded on Tumeke’s stats. In other words, and because I don’t have the time to replicate what Tim Selwyn does, you can’t have it both ways, you cannot appear on Tumeke’s stats as seemingly secular or “neutral” and then quietly pop up on mine as Christian; a Christian, by definition, does not hide their faith.

    That’s not to say there is anything wrong with a Christian running a blog on public discourse who chooses to not make their blog a Christian blog. If someone does not wish to overtly identify their blog as a Christian blog it does not make them any less a Christian as everything they write will naturally be coloured from their faith anyway and ultimately it is their choice as to what format their blog takes and how they pitch it to the blogosphere.

    Likewise, it is my choice as to which ones I will rank and it is easier and seems to me more fitting to rank the overtly Christian blogs.

    How to Make the Rankings
    To rank the top 10 Christian blogs I wait for the monthly blog rankings to come out, usually towards the end of the following month, then I run a search for terms such as ‘Christian’, ‘Christianity’, ‘Theology’, ‘Faith’. Any blogs that come up with those terms then get listed in the order that Tumeke ranks them.

    As such, if you wish your blog to feature in the top NZ Christian Blog Rankings do not contact me, rather observe the following as to make my rankings you have to be on Tim’s Tumeke rankings, if you think your blog meets the criteria, e.g. is NZ related and focussed on public discourse, then:

    1. Check to see if your blog currently features in Tumeke’s stats.
    2. If it does not, or if it is not described correctly, then contact Tim Selwyn and provide the following information:

      Blog Title and Blog Address
      Very short description as to what your blog is about (less than 8 words)
      The name of each blogger
      The general ideological position of each blogger e.g. right, left, centre
      The specific ideological position or political affiliation or religion of each blogger

    3. Check your site is listed with Alexa, if it is not, take 5 minutes and register it – click the link and type your blog address into “lookup website” then add your site info. You don’t have to download the toolbar or place a widget on your site though doing this will help your stats rise. (Tim’s formula uses your Alexa ranking)
    4. Is your site is listed with Technorati? If it is not, take 5 minutes to register and claim it – click the link, create an account, add and claim your blog. You do not have to do anything else though adding a widget will help your stats to rise. (Tim’s formula uses your Technorati incoming links)
    5. If you make the Top NZ Christian Blog list put one of these buttons on your site pointing to this link:
    6. Put a good free stat counter on your blog, set it to both not count your visits and to count uniques and email Tim your stats for the relevant month he is working on. (This step is not vital, but if you don’t do this, Tim will rely on Alexa’s unique count for your blog or he will assign you a guestimate and this may not be accurate.)
    7. Make sure you link to MandM (ok well, links to MandM are not part of Tim’s formula but think how cool your blog will be!)

    Now, climbing the rankings is another story entirely and while the net is full of ways to aid this the best way to climb the rankings is to make sure your content is interesting.