Author: André Z

  • Transitioning to University

    What is university like? Is it possible to be a Christian there? What does it mean to live well as a student? If you know someone heading off to university this year, they may be asking themselves these kinds of questions. If they’re not asking these, it’s definitely to be encouraged.

    To help, I’m pleased to introduce Transitions 2011: Equipping you for the Journey of Faith at University; an event organised by Scripture Union, the Tertiary Students Christian Fellowship (“TSCF”) and associated students. This is the introduction to university I wish I’d had three years ago.

    Finding community and direction at university can be daunting

    There are lots of challenges that young people face when moving into an environment of independent learning. Also, the university is a place where, at least theoretically, ‘truth’ matters. I’m convinced that Christian claims are true – given the modern environment, this raises yet more challenges. All of these are things that are best dealt with in community. There are plenty of people out there thinking about the same subjects, hoping to live as we were intended; but how to find them without being too weird about it?

    The campuses of tertiary institutions are not always associated with strong communities. A common desire to get drunk ~ once a week, have fun and do well enough to get a decent job is not much to base meaningful relationships on. Three years, to get your standard degree, is not a long time, so turnover is high (in that regard, I see the trend towards doing more post-grad study as a real positive). Large campuses filled with strangers can also be daunting. Auckland in particular has many, many, students commuting in and out of the city and not bothering or daring to build networks in their place of study, beyond those they’ve inherited through accidents of geography and prior schooling. Christian groups and Christian individuals who care about more than their own advancement are uniquely equipped to fill the gaps in friendship and exploring the deeper questions which study raises.

    Ultimately, young adults want to shape a world-view that’s big enough to include their experience of the human condition and the knowledge we have gained. Events like Transitions help to break the ice and get students talking and laughing and eating and thinking together; all ultimately for the glory of the God who cares about what we know and who we know.

    So come along, there will be pizza, sessions on “Being the same person sitting in church and sitting in class,” “Exploring how Uni is different from school,” “What are the issues for Korean students?” and a whole lot more so mark it in your calendars now:

    What: Transitions 2011
    When: Saturday the 5th February
    Time: 12-4:30pm
    Where: The University of Auckland Business School (OGGB5), 12 Grafton Rd, University of Auckland
    For: Students entering their first or second year of tertiary study

    See and pass on the flyer for more details (including how to register) and/or this Facebook page, organised by one of the TSCF groups.

  • Moving Beyond CS Lewis?

    CS Lewis still provides a great read and he has been an important figure in my own journey of working out my faith. But I cringe a little when, as repeatedly happens, Christian people hear I’m into philosophy and science and such and they recommend I read the author of the Narnia books.

    CS Lewis left a legacy - not all the answers

    I’ve been reading some of his works for quite a while and they’re great, with plenty of insights into the poverty of a purely secular life – but they’re not the only thing out there if you’re looking for a critically engaged faith. (There’s perhaps a similar deal with Francis Schaeffer, but I struggle to think of other Christian thinkers who people in the pews would tend to know. For the rest of the post, I’ll refer to Lewis, as representative and chief of a possibly larger tribe; I’m open to being convinced anyway.)

    I’m curious about what causes the phenomenon which I clumsily christen “you’re a Christian into thinking? Oh well (it’s a pity you can’t play the guitar); but quick, you better read CS Lewis!” The Church is not noted for being fast and trendy and up to date, but that’s not the whole story. I don’t have any evidence for the claim, but I suspect CS Lewis has been popular for a long time i.e. the Church hasn’t only just discovered him; and more fundamentally, that previous generations, who were more likely to read books and keep up to date with the world of literature, were better acquainted with a few defenders of the faith who were not long-dead at the time.

    I’m not advocating the sin of chronological snobbery and I know that new and shiny stuff often soon enough hits the trash pile, but in my opinion, people really need to know that God is alive in the academy today and He’s worth taking as seriously as He ever was. That’s good news, but news which may be hard to hear above the dance/trance/pop/punk/thrashmetal-indie sounds of popular Christian culture and Christianity-lite ®. I have suggested the Church is slow in some respects, but it’s fast in others – making bad copies of non-religious pop culture arguably being one of our special skills (more…)

  • False Alarm: Falsificationism and its Misapplication

    A fair number of people are fond of the claim that if one is to be able to take a claim seriously, it really ought to be falsifiable. One easy response is that it’s difficult to see how this particular claim, about how we are to go about accumulating knowledge and believing stuff, is itself falsifiable; but if that seems a bit too quick a dismissal, there are other fairly well documented reasons to be dubious of ‘falsificationism’ and its claims to epistemological kingship.

    Some ideas can be tested reasonably well e.g. with this early electron microscope. Others await the examination of evidence in different ways.

    The idea is commonly associated with the scientific method; a purportedly precise way of doing things that many (perhaps particularly scientists, surprisingly enough) are pretty sure everyone should be keen on. If you want to know something, use science – it works. Indeed, the requirement of falsifiability is sometimes seen as a shibboleth for rationality, or at least orthopraxy amongst ‘reasonable’ people. In the discipline of the philosophy of science itself however, it would appear to be considerably less popular than among certain popularisers of science; an intriguing sociological fact. Falsificationism is a dumbed-down version of the views of method which Karl Popper offered the scientific community. Yes, science involves testing claims against the evidence, but there is more to it than that. A requirement of falsifiability may be seen as a suitably sceptical approach; even (as I’ve seen) contrasted with the blind faith apparently invested by religious people in their beliefs. This is problematic for a number of reasons, some of which will become clear. Lying behind it is a conveniently selective scepticism which puts aside the complexities of science and assumes or pretends that the project of explicating the order in the universe is a natural fit with naturalism. If you want to know why science works, it’s not science and it may not be falsifiable theories which will give good answers.

    Perhaps the most pressing issue behind this post is widespread allegiance amongst many naïve people to some form of ‘scientism’. I and other Christians who decry this trend away from genuine rationality and accompany the hand-wringing with good arguments are often assured that it does not in fact exist (more…)