Category: Blog Rankings

  • November Rankings

    Tim has finally published the November blog rankings for NZ blogs on public discourse – just in time for Christmas.

    November of course the was frenzied election month so naturally blogs with a strong political bent, delivering what the punters want, did well and others saw their traffic drop off. Many bloggers hung up their keyboards shortly into the month as their sole reason for existing was complete at the close of the election, new blogs were birthed, some of which debuted very high. As such, it was always going to be interesting to see how the stats came out.

    MandM, of course, are not affiliated with any political party but we do have a classical liberal/libertarian leaning. Our political blog entries were naturally geared in that direction so when parties and candidates that fit our political viewpoint deviated from it we said so and those blog posts, particularly, were very widely read.

    John Key on Religion and Public Life, although written in September, had massive readership through November, peaking in the week after the election as many people came to it on search terms such as John Key Religion or John Key Homosexuality.

    Is Abortion Liberal? Part 1, also saw high traffic with Matt’s critique of ACT’s inconsistent liberal application of the harm principle when it came to feticide.

    Of course entries critiquing the left were also popular, most read was Fisking Grant Robertson; Matt unpacked the propaganda put out by his old student union comrade, turned professional politician, against National’s Wellington Central candidate.

    Finally our political framework or voting lens posts for Christians, such as A Voting Guide, Voting, the Role of the State…, What About the Poor? Sustenance Rights Examined also brought in high traffic given the confusion prevalent amongst Christians as to what their faith actually teaches them about the role of the state.

    It appears we did enough in November as we climbed 4 spots to rank 46th in the country.

    The numbers are fairly close through the top 40’s and 30’s we think if we work hard we should be able to crack 30-something in the New Year. We know December has been a bit stop and start for us but you all know why and it is Christmas.

    Thanks everyone for your support, your visits, your comments and your links.

  • MandM in the Challenge

    Madeleine’s top ranking of the top 10 Christian blogs has been picked up by the Challenge Weekly, a conservative, evangelical newspaper. She was interviewed for it before she went into surgery, the following is an extract from the article which was published on Dec 8, 2008.

    In the NZ Blogosphere
    by John McNeil

    His ability to exploit internet-based social networking is widely credited with being a major reason behind Barack Obama’s success in the US presidential race.

    Web logs or blogs are an integral part of that networking process, and some of the more successful New Zealand bloggers – such as David Farrar and Russell Brown – are now becoming media personalities in their own right.

    Internet users are increasingly turning to blogs as an information outlet additional to traditional sources such as newspapers and television.

    With the number of New Zealand bloggers estimated to be in the thousands, how are Christians measuring up?

    Tim Selwyn, from Tumeke Blog, measures the most popular type of blogs, those that engage in public debate, and each month issues a New Zealand ranking. Using his figures, long-time Christian bloggers Matthew and Madeleine Flannagan have discovered that writers bringing a Christian viewpoint are achieving an encouraging response.

    They say the top 10 Christian blogs fall within the 150 most read blogs. The most popular of these is New Zealand Conservative, compiled by a group of Catholic writers. The Flannagan’s own – MandM – has risen to fourth position among Christian writers, and 50th overall.

    “We are getting close to 3,000 unique visitors per month. We put the rise in visitors down to our commitment to quality, considered posts from a philosophical perspective that are relevant to a broad range of people, Christian and non-Christian alike,” Mrs. Flannagan said.

    Most of them enjoy respect from non-Christian blogs, however, she said, writers have to be strong enough to take the knocks as well. “At the moment I’m putting up with an online voting poll about who is the sexiest blogger. I have been named as one of the finalists, and people are writing in with some fairly lewd comments. There is nothing I can do about it.”

    “Christians sticking their necks out publicly on issues like abortion and homosexuality also come in for some abuse and threats that the secular blogs affirming these issues do not.”

    Mrs Flannagan said she was passionate about blogging as she found it an excellent way to get the Christian viewpoint across and to smash the false assumption that Christians had nothing of interest to offer in the public square. …

  • Shadow Report: Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs Nov 08

    The following shows how October’s Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs (public discourse) fare on Half Done’s Nov stats compared to Tumeke’s Oct stats:

    1. [1] NZ Conservative 9 (23)
    2. [2] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later 19 (34)
    3. [3] The Briefing Room 25 (35)
    4. [4] MandM 31 (50)
    5. [8] Put up Thy Sword 43 (114)
    6. [5] Samuel Dennis 55 (79)
    7. [9] Contra Celsum 71 (125)
    8. [6] Kiwi Polemicist 82 (92)
    9. [7] Gavin Knight 87 (95)
    10. [N] Section 59 Blog 116 (155)

    Top 10 Half Done [Top 10 Tumeke] name of blog Half Done rank (Tumeke rank)

    Of Note:

    • All but one Top 10 Christian blog improved on Half Done’s formula/their November performance.
    • NZ Conservative crack the top 10 in the country – well deserved.
    • No change in the top 4 spots.
    • Impressive improvement for Andrew Chesswas’s Put up Thy Sword.
    • Very good gains for Samuel Dennis, Contra Celsum and Section 59 too.

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse but outside the top 10:

    [10] Say Hello to my Little Friend (a.k.a Beretta Blog) 128 (126)
    [O] NZ Debate 164 (156)
    [O] Definitive 166 (181)
    [O] The Voice of Reason NZ N/A (184)

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification and ranking methods.If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • Shadow Stats: Half Done NZ Blog Rankings

    Half Done has been running shadow stats of the NZ Blog Rankings for a little while now utilising a different formula to Tumeke‘s that focuses more on reach; most notably, the number of posts and comments are not included. Srubone’s formula is:

    Alexa ranking*Alexa NZ ranking/Technorati authority/10000

    There is a lot of support in the blogosphere for this formula as anyone can post a bunch of silly and worthless posts and comment on their own blog or fail to delete the spam posts to drive the stats up for Tumeke’s formula but its a lot harder to self-manipulate the Alexa and Technorati stats; the best way to drive them up is to post quality content.

    We had never linked to Half Done’s stats before because Scrubone had been using our old blogspot URL which in October had us sitting at 85, compared to 50 on Tumeke, but after bringing this to Scrubone’s attention last month he has run the stats with our correct data and we are absolutely ecstatic to see we are sitting at 31. Tumeke’s November stats will not be out until around the 20th (usually) so we will not know how that score fares with his formula until then.

    My only criticism of Scrubone’s stats, and it is mean to call it a criticism given the amount of work that goes into stat gathering, is that there are no blog descriptions making it difficult for me to run a check for the top 10 Christians blogs off his stats without visiting all 199 and reading each in depth to gauge for myself. However, I can and will compile a shadow report as to how the top 10 fare on Scrubone’s stats compared to Tumeke’s so stop by later today. [I have an appt right now so check around mid morning]

  • New Zealand Christian Blog Rankings for October 2008

    Extrapolating from Tumeke’s October 2008 stats, the top 10 Christian Blogs on Public Discourse in New Zealand are:

    1. NZ Conservative (23 +1)
    2. Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (34 +2)
    3. The Briefing Room (35 -5)
    4. MandM (50 +27)
    5. Samuel Dennis (79 +1)
    6. Kiwi Polemicist (92 new)
    7. Gavin Knight (95 – 4)
    8. Put up Thy Sword (114 +1)
    9. Contra Celsum (125 -31)
    10. Say Hello to my Little Friend (a.k.a Beretta Blog) (126 +2)

    Of Note:

    • No change in the number 1 spot, well done NZ Conservative.
    • Newcomer Kiwi Polemicist debuts at number 6 (92 on Tumeke’s stats).
    • The gap between the top 4 narrows; over the past 3 months MandM have climbed 76 spots on Tumeke’s rankings.

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse are:

    (Numbers in brackets show the overall NZ ranking of each blog)

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification and ranking methods.

    If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • October Blog Rankings: MandM Crack the Top 50

    The October NZ blog rankings are out and MandM, as predicted, is one of the top 3 movers and shakers, climbing 27 places to number 50:

    Unfortunately whilst Tim did update our URL to http://www.mandm.org.nz/ he failed to do so for our Alexa and Technorati Stats and went off our old and defunct blogspot url that we left behind nearly two months ago.

    To see the difference, compare both these stat-lines:

    nz 18,531 * 4,732,054 (old blogspot url stats)

    nz 1,694 * 1,783,797 (current mandm.org.nz stats)

    As you can see in the last two months we have climbed significantly; 3 months ago that Alexa traffic rank stat (the second, bigger number) started with a 7 and our NZ traffic stat (which measures our popularity within the international community) is equally strong.

    So thankyou everyone for your support. Your visits, your comments, your links have all helped us to achieve this result (of course we appreciate your contribution because of the contribution to the dialogue it makes first and foremost).

    If you are still linking to our old blogspot url, the one with all the mandmandmandmandm’s in it, please, please, please update it 🙂

  • The New Zealand Christian Blog Rankings

    In September I extrapolated from Tim Selwyn’s Tumeke Blog rankings, and published the top 10 New Zealand Christian blogs on public discourse. The post where I did this proved surprisingly popular and as other bloggers have since requested that I do this every month, I have decided that I will.

    At the moment I rank the top 10 as these fall in the top 150 of all NZ blogs on public discourse but if more Christian blogs climb the public lists then I will expand my list accordingly.

    I think it is only fair that I explain how I identify a Christian Blog as some blogs that are run by Christians did not make my list. It is simple. To be a Christian Blog you must self-identify that your blog contributes to the public blogosphere from an overtly Christian perspective and this must be recorded on Tumeke’s stats. In other words, and because I don’t have the time to replicate what Tim Selwyn does, you can’t have it both ways, you cannot appear on Tumeke’s stats as seemingly secular or “neutral” and then quietly pop up on mine as Christian; a Christian, by definition, does not hide their faith.

    That’s not to say there is anything wrong with a Christian running a blog on public discourse who chooses to not make their blog a Christian blog. If someone does not wish to overtly identify their blog as a Christian blog it does not make them any less a Christian as everything they write will naturally be coloured from their faith anyway and ultimately it is their choice as to what format their blog takes and how they pitch it to the blogosphere.

    Likewise, it is my choice as to which ones I will rank and it is easier and seems to me more fitting to rank the overtly Christian blogs.

    How to Make the Rankings
    To rank the top 10 Christian blogs I wait for the monthly blog rankings to come out, usually towards the end of the following month, then I run a search for terms such as ‘Christian’, ‘Christianity’, ‘Theology’, ‘Faith’. Any blogs that come up with those terms then get listed in the order that Tumeke ranks them.

    As such, if you wish your blog to feature in the top NZ Christian Blog Rankings do not contact me, rather observe the following as to make my rankings you have to be on Tim’s Tumeke rankings, if you think your blog meets the criteria, e.g. is NZ related and focussed on public discourse, then:

    1. Check to see if your blog currently features in Tumeke’s stats.
    2. If it does not, or if it is not described correctly, then contact Tim Selwyn and provide the following information:

      Blog Title and Blog Address
      Very short description as to what your blog is about (less than 8 words)
      The name of each blogger
      The general ideological position of each blogger e.g. right, left, centre
      The specific ideological position or political affiliation or religion of each blogger

    3. Check your site is listed with Alexa, if it is not, take 5 minutes and register it – click the link and type your blog address into “lookup website” then add your site info. You don’t have to download the toolbar or place a widget on your site though doing this will help your stats rise. (Tim’s formula uses your Alexa ranking)
    4. Is your site is listed with Technorati? If it is not, take 5 minutes to register and claim it – click the link, create an account, add and claim your blog. You do not have to do anything else though adding a widget will help your stats to rise. (Tim’s formula uses your Technorati incoming links)
    5. If you make the Top NZ Christian Blog list put one of these buttons on your site pointing to this link:
    6. Put a good free stat counter on your blog, set it to both not count your visits and to count uniques and email Tim your stats for the relevant month he is working on. (This step is not vital, but if you don’t do this, Tim will rely on Alexa’s unique count for your blog or he will assign you a guestimate and this may not be accurate.)
    7. Make sure you link to MandM (ok well, links to MandM are not part of Tim’s formula but think how cool your blog will be!)

    Now, climbing the rankings is another story entirely and while the net is full of ways to aid this the best way to climb the rankings is to make sure your content is interesting.