Category: Blogging

  • The NZ Herald on Cactus Kate and Priorities in Journalism Ethics

    There is an interesting story unfolding in the blogosphere. Cactus Kate published extracts of APN News and Media’s guidelines for publication on her blog in, APN Chicken Out, and inserted her own commentary and spin on them based on email correspondence from staff members working for APN’s publications. Where it gets really interesting is that the New Zealand Herald ran this piece Herald tells blogger: You’re Wrong. Anyone familiar with Cactus Kate (and probably bloggers generally) will not be surprised to hear that Cactus has published a cutting response, with the rather brilliant title, Herald Clucks On Spin Cycle.

    The whole thing is worth a read for two reasons. One it demonstrates the rise of the blog, the increasing position of the blog as a source of information and as a force to not be ignored (which is a phenomena, as a blogger, that I find very interesting). The second reason is that some aspects of the guidelines for publication that Cactus cites are alarming.

    While the Herald takes issues with some of the points in Cactus’ initial blog post, it calls them a “heavily truncated mish-mash” (I think that’s journo speak for cut and pasted extracts) and says they have been in play for a long time “Nothing secret about them and nothing new”, it does not deny that these guidelines are, in fact, in play.

    “[The guidelines] are not new (same general thoughts have been included in the training document for years) … the basic points are entirely matter-of-fact for anyone seeking to get things right and avoid legal pitfalls the media have encountered before.

    There is no new ‘conservative’ approach, no recent guidelines discussed, received or implemented, no change.”

    So the Herald says they are not new, Cactus’ sources say they are but that is not why I called your attention to them. It is that the content of the guidelines are what is revealing. Now I don’t share every aspect of Cactus’ take on what precisely is wrong with the guidelines but I do agree she is right when she says some of them are pretty awful. For example, consider this guideline:

    d. There are categories of people who are more inclined to sue if they are the subject of adverse publications, so particular care should be taken in reporting allegations of misconduct against lawyers, doctors, judges, other professionals, politicians, critics and wealthy businessmen/women.

    Cactus takes issue with this and describes it as “the worst affront to investigative journalism” contained in the document.  I too think that it is the most concerning of all of them but not as an affront to investigative journalism. My issue with clause d is the suggestion that publications only bother to take care in reporting damning allegations against people who are likely to sue them – so don’t bother being as careful writing damning allegations about people who are not likely to sue?

    I’m sorry, but I thought that the reason one should take care to not publish false, private and damning allegations about people (you tend to not be able to succeed in legal action if what is written is true and in the public interest) was something vaguely to do with respect for truth, morality, ethics, integrity, respect for other people, a desire to not misinform the public and so on. When I think of the reasons why I try to not publish anything false, damning and private on our blog, the odds of my success in the courtroom do not figure very high. I’m more concerned that I get it right simply for the sake of getting it right because that is important to me.

    Nice to have what we all thought about journalism ethics set out in black and white I guess.

  • Richard Dawkins on Thinking Matters

    According to Richard Dawkins, New Zealand apologetics blog, Thinking Matters Talk, “makes for some interesting browsing.”

    The recommendation of Rob Ward’s blog post, Sarfati reviews Dawkins’ ‘The Greatest Show on Earth’, has seen a deluge traffic arrive.

    (This pleases us because we are part of Thinking Matters and are listed as contributors to Thinking Matters Talk even though we don’t contribute there much…)

  • Guest Post: The Common Good – An Emergent Phenomenon

    This guest post comes from Nyokodo of And All These Things…. Catholic social teaching stresses that civil government should seek the common good. This post contains some critical commentary as to how to understand and apply the common good.

    The documents of the Church and the writings of most socially minded scholars are replete with exhortations for public figures to work towards the common good in all secular affairs. In response grand public works are begun, optimistic programmes launched, and a great many resources are shifted from one sector to another to achieve this lofty goal. However, it soon becomes clear that these programmes introduce further imbalances, insecurities and evils. Entire strata of society become addicted to welfare, economic protectionism make prices soar, unjust monopolies are established, and regulations are always too little too late. Some of these problems can be explained by ordinary political corruption and the general imperfection of man, however there is an even larger problem with all these methods: it’s literally impossible for them to work.

    The problem is information:

    • how to collect it;
    • how to interpret it once you have it;
    • and the time frame in which all this is done.

    Governments simply cannot aggregate enough information in a timely enough fashion, and even if they could social and economic data are largely subjective and impossible to interpret correctly when distanced from the specific situation and the particular people involved.

    Readers will be familiar with government economic data only coming out after the fact, often sometime after. This is because it takes time for sectors of the economy to report how they’re doing, there is always a delay requisite with the time it takes for individuals and businesses to aggregate their own data and to government requirements. Even then the data is often manipulated to make government policies look better so the reliability of the data is questionable.

    The data are also very much subjective as the needs, wants, aspirations and acceptable outcomes of economic and social activities differs per person, business, city and region. The sheer immensity of this subjective information is too vast for any government to sufficiently aggregate and essentially impossible to even attempt to collect.

    Governments who attempt this central planning of our social and economic lives are simply driving blind because they cannot have the information they would need to direct us effectively. This is why government programmes always encourage the wrong behaviour, leave certain groups and issues behind, grow stale and unresponsive, and generally spring leaks from every orifice.

    The only way for the Common Good to be achieved is to unleash the power of individuals, families and groups to work towards their own benefit. The Common Good emerges out of this chaos with the most efficient use of resources, the most timely actions taken and no interpretation being necessary. The only people who have the necessary information to achieve their good, and in chorus the common good, are the individuals directly involved. Governments need to get out of the way and enable this process to occur instead of their futile attempts to conjure the common good from the top down.

  • Philosophy Carnival XCIX

    The Philosophy Carnival XCIX is now online.

    Matt’s and my post Audi and the Infallibility of Religious Reasons is featured.

    There are a number of other interesting reads also linked to so head on over and check them out.

  • Wellington Bloggers Drinks

    As previously mentioned, we are heading to Wellington soon. We figured, since we’ll be there, we should do a Wellington bloggers drinks:

    What: Wellington Bloggers Drinks
    When: Friday 27 November from 7:00pm
    Where: Backbencher Pub, 34 Molesworth Street, Thorndon, Wellington

    Open to anyone who happens to be in Wellington. You can RSVP via facebook, leave a comment below, post this on your own blog or just turn up.

  • New Zealand Christian Blog Ranking Policy Change

    You may have noticed I have just now caught up all the blog ranking reports I was behind on due to end of year study focus (my final exam is now 6 days away). You may have also noticed we have included a new blog ranking policy in our eligibility criteria.

    From here on simply claiming to be Christian will not mean your blog automatically makes the top 10 New Zealand Christian blog rankings. In addition to being openly Christian in its blog description on Tumeke and HalfDone’s New Zealand blog ranking lists, now an eligible blog must also demonstrate adherence to the historic Christian tradition in their blog content.

    We are going to be fairly broad with this. No one is perfect in their interpretation of biblical text or in how they apply their beliefs to their actions (or the content of their blogs). We all get it wrong from time to time. We are not looking for adherence to fine points of doctrine on things like eschatology or baptism or political leaning, etc. However, we will draw a line and exclude blogs that fall outside what CS Lewis calls “mere christianity”. Lewis sums this up as “the belief that has been common to nearly all Christians at all times.” So, for example, we would exclude those who claim to be Christian but who promote atheism or deny the resurrection or believe that Jesus was a magic mushroom and so on.

  • Christian Blog Ranking Report for October 09 – HalfDone

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on HalfDone’s NZ blog stats for October; these stats will make up part of the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for October 09:

    1. MandM 3
    2. NZ Conservative 4
    3. Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta) 8
    4. Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (HalfDone) 10
    5. MacDoctor Moments 18
    6. Liturgy Worship Spirituality 34
    7. Being Frank 36
    8. The Humanitarian Chronicle 42
    9. Manawatu Christian Apologetics Society 43
    10. Brad Heap 46

    Top 10. name of blog HalfDone Rank

    Of Note:

    • A little change in position; newcomer The Dunedin School made the top 10.
    • The following Christian blogs all made the top 100 but were outside the top 10 Contra Celsum 53, Semper Vita 67, True Paradigm 71, Christian News 73, The Briefing Room 81, Paul Gardner 90, Star Studded Super Step 95, I am Jonny King 99.
    • An additional 30 Christian blogs were included in the list of 427 New Zealand blogs..
    • Another 8 were unfortunately not able to be calculated due to their not resolving in Alexa and Technorati.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that are openly identified as Christian blogs on HalfDone’s ranking list and that that demonstrate adherence to the historic Christian tradition in their blog content.

    When Tumeke’s September stats are out we will compare them with HalfDone’s and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for October 09.