Category: Social Commentary

  • Key a PC Socialist?

    Murray certainly thinks so and I am inclined to agree from what I have heard so far from the man. Of course it could all be the way the media are reporting things but Key does appear to be pulling National more centrist and last time National were over there it was disastrous for them.

    Sure, this time they are facing an incumbant govt which is steeped in scandal and so there will probably be some moderate Labour voters who might vote for what Murray has renamed National, “Labour Lite”, but what of those on the centre right and further over to the right (as in correct) position?

    It looks like we are left with voting National because its not Labour or jumping to ACT’s two man band.

  • Stadium Solution Farrar Style

    Saw this on Kiwiblog and just had to swipe it.

    The comments section is very funny in places too.

  • Only in Fiji…

    It seems the coup in Fiji has been delayed by a rugby match … only in Fiji!

    Bainimarama has put the coup so he could watch a game of rugby between Police and the Army – couldn’t let a coup get in the way of that!

    So the coup has been put on hold to ensure that the annual match between the military and the police could go ahead.

    The police kicked the military. Should we consider this ominous?

  • Real Charity is Voluntary

    A friend recently e-mailed me a link to this article.

    It points out that religious conservatives give more money to charities that assist the poor than liberals do. If the data is correct, it highlights an issue I came to realise several years ago.

    Consider two situations (a) and (b). In (a) my neighbour is in need, I take out my chequebook and give him some money; in (b) my neighbour is in need I take out a gun put it at another’s neighbours head and say to him, give that guy your money or else.

    As a Christian, I advocate the former. Those on the political left, while claiming to support the former, frequently support the latter (the gun being the force of the state and the means taxation).

    These two are clearly not the same, the first is generous, voluntary giving the second is violence against others.

    However, so often in discussing this issue with other evangelicals (a) and (b) are conflated. I am told that because we have a duty to give charitably to the poor we have a duty to support socialist welfare programs. This is a non sequitur. Failure to be attuned to this distinction means that genuine desire to assist the needy is misguidedly thrown in behind acts of state-sanctioned violence and threats against innocent people.

    Surely, the real test of virtue is what you are willing to do with your own money in the absence of a gun being held to your head and not what you want the state to force others to do with theirs.

  • Consenting Adults and Privacy

    We have all heard the slogan “what consenting adults do in privacy is their own business.” Recently Investigate alledged that one of our MP’s was getting up to dubious sexual practices where he engaged in child sex fantasies to get off. More sinisterly this is the same MP and Cabinet Minister, David Benson Pope a.k.a. Panty Slut Boy whom the police found a prima facie case against for engaging in bdsm type practices against his students when he was a teacher.

    Predictably the lefty liberals have trotted out the slogan “what consenting adults do in privacy is their own business.” Apparently anything a person, including a govt MP and Cabinet Minister responsible for CYFS, does sexually is ok providing all parties consent and it is done in private. (Of course they conveniently ignore the fact that the bdsm-type offences against the students were not consensual but since they were done against bullies its all apparently ok)

    in 2004 a real case reached the courts in Germany. A German computer technician, Armin Miewes, advertised on the internet, “If you are between 18 and 25 years old you are my boy. Come to me and I will eat your horny flesh.” His intent was to find someone who would volunteer to be killed and then eaten. Such a volunteer was forthcoming, Juergen Brandes.

    In court, Miewes testified that he and Brandes had enjoyed a final meal together. Brandes agreed to be castrated and the two sautéed his penis and testicles. After the meal Brandes willingly allowed himself to be hanged from a butcher’s hook and be slaughtered ‘like a calf’. After Brandes had died Miewes consumed his flesh. The German court found Miewes guilty of manslaughter and later this was upgraded to murder after an appeal. In this case, both parties had consented. The court had considered the evidence and documentation both parties had made prior to the event and found that consent had been legitimately obtained.

    Now I ask you, if the Minister of CYFS had done what Miewes did would that call into question his fitness to be in office? If you answer yes then clearly you do not actually believe that what consenting adults do in privacy with others who have consented is actually the be all and end all in sexual morality. Nor do you believe that what people do in private is irrelevent to the public.

    If you answer no then you are depraved.

  • Nuclear Freedom

    John Key’s statements that National has no plan to lift the nuclear free policy of New Zealand are very disapointing. While David Farrar has a good point about it being “one less stick to be beaten with,” New Zealand’s nuclear free policy is stupid.

    No I am not advocating that New Zealand enters the arms race and builds nuclear weapons – we’d need armed forces to make any sense of considering that as an option. I am talking about nuclear power.

    Nuclear power rates higher on factors such as clean, green, efficient, reliable, affordable.

    It is ridiculous that we are considering ruining our landscapes in the pursuit of noisy, native-bird-killing, ugly windfarms that produce stuff all power anyway. Hydrodams are ecologically unfriendly and coal is a bad pollutant. Geothermal again wrecks natural wonders. And none of the above is going to solve our power crisis.

    The ridiculous knee jerk reactions to the mantra “nuclear” have to stop. More people have been killed by oil and battery plant accidents and the auckland motorways are more of a menace to human life than a nuclear power plant would be.

  • Home Education

    We are fans of home education and we home educate our kids. We cop a lot of flak at times from people who assume that they will be better off in school – usually because they went to school and they have taken on the false assumptions about home education. Often it feels as if we have to justify ourselves over and over though I am sure the proof in the end will be in how our kids turn out – but that means years til they get off our backs!

    I got this in my email account today, its apparently drawn from a home educator called Dayna who featured on a Dr Phil program.

    If the child’s not interested in what they’re being taught, then basically teaching is simply somebody talking in the front of the room, its like throwing marshmallows at somebody’s head and calling it eating.”

    This cracked me up because it pin points with humour one of my big issues with how pointless the school system is. What I did learn in school that stuck in my head was the stuff I was interested in, that was interesting to learn.

    I find as we teach our kids that if we make the subject interesting it sticks. Our older two kids can seriously run rings around their schooled peers when it comes to general knowledge, english, maths, history and science basics and their logic skills and their ability to reason and think critically is so far ahead of their schooled friends its not funny.

    Our 14 year old had a group of her friends around for a movie night. She had about 10 friends there who ranged in age from 13-16 who went to various different schools around Dunedin – some private, some public, some low decile, some high. The movie they were watching was Troy. None of them knew anything about the story of Troy, one kid wondered out loud “why they made such a big horse” and several others murmered agreement that it was “weird” and that “the plot doesn’t make any sense.” Our daughter began laughing quietly to herself and shooting us looks, as did our 10 year old son – though neither had seen the movie before.

    Then, one of the friends pointed at the picture on our lounge wall, it is a print of the pointing fingers in the creation of Adam by Michelangelo. “That’s a stupid picture, why would anyone want a picture of two fingers?” one girl sniggered. The others laughed too. Our daughter said that’s Michelangelo’s Creation of Adam. She got blank looks, so she said “you know, Michelangelo? Do you not know who he was?” She got the indignant reply, “Yes of course we know, he was one of the teenage mutant ninja turtles.”

    We collapsed in hysterics and a room full of schooled kids looked blankly at us while our daughter tried to explain further “he was a famous artist, he painted the sistine chapel..” of course this just made it worse as they had no clue what the sistine chapel was.