Category: Politics

  • In Defence of the Defence

    Michael Laws has written a strong piece in the Sunday Star times on child abuse which pulls no punches and calls for a return of the death penalty. Most of what he says is spot on (well there is a bit of the ‘someone else should be doing something’ going on) but this statement is so far off it warrants a response:

    … stop buying the liberal excuses. Every blame-shifter, every apologist, every politically correct naysayer is, in reality, part of the problem. They are the pimps of abuse – they condone ill-treatment because they make excuses for the perpetrator.

    And I include defence lawyers in that retinue because they whore their intelligence to protect the evildoers. As a rule, criminal defence lawyers have no soul. … [emphasis added]

    Now maybe I took issue with this because of my vocation, but ‘defence lawyers whore their intelligence?’ Is Laws arguing against due process? Should every accused automatically be assigned an in-intelligent lawyer? Perhaps we should forget about a trial altogether?

    Further, ‘defence lawyers have no soul?’ Is Laws aguing against the presumption of innocence? If the court finds the accused not guilty then we must assume the defence lawyers were right.

    What’s next? A complete removal of autrefois acquit and autrefois convict (commonly dubbed “double jeopardy”) in cases where the public ‘know’ the court got it wrong?

    The defence laywer’s job is to present their client’s case. The state’s job is to present the evidence that the accused is guilty. If the public is to have faith in the integrity of the justice system we should hope that both sides are highly skilled; the standard of evidence must be so high that the court, and the public, are left beyond any reasonable doubt of the accused’s guilt, or lack thereof; expecially if we are to consider re-introducing the death penalty.

    If the state is competent, and it is patently obvious the accused did it, then the most intelligent defence lawyer in the world will not be able to combat this. When the state bungles a case the last thing we should be doing is booing and hissing at the defence, do we really want to drop the standards and make it easy for the state to get a prosecution? This will give the state far too much power and society far too much uncertainty in the justice system.

    We have to remember, as FE Smith points out in the comments section here, that it is not the defence lawyers who kill the Nia’s of this world and we must put our faith in the presumption of innocence and in due process because the alternative is worse.

    As I have previously argued, the presumption of innocence means, inevitably, that sometimes the guilty will walk and the innocent will be convicted. Whilst no one likes or condones these negative connotations the alternative is worse because the solution to ensuring that the guilty always get convicted is to imprison every accused and likewise, the solution to ensuring the innocent never get convicted is to never convict anyone. The system is balanced to make it difficult to convict, and this is where the intelligent defence lawyer is necessary, because it is generally deemed worse to send an innocent person to jail, or give them a lethal injection, than to fail to punish the guilty.

    So we are left having to accept that once a court has heard a case, weighed the evidence and ruled, that’s that. Demonising the defence lawyer because, despite the court’s assessment, the public “know” this person is guilty (good ol’ trial by media) is to give the state far too much power and to give society far too much uncertainty in the justice system. Whilst it may succeed in increasing the chances of nailing the guilty it equally runs the risk of allowing the state, with its vast resources, to hound and harass the innocent.

    None of us like the idea that the someone will not be held to account when a child is abused to death but we must be careful we are not calling for anyone to be held to account; what we want is the guilty to be held to account and for that important distinction to be drawn we need good defence lawyers.

  • The Special Votes Give a Seat to the Greens

    The Special Votes have been counted, the official result of the New Zealand 2008 Election is in; see the effect they have made on the provisional results:

    Final results in bold, (provisional results in brackets)

    National 44.93% (45.45%) – 58 (59) seats
    Labour 33.99% (33.77%) – 43 seats
    Green 6.72% (6.43%) – 9 (8) seats
    ACT 3.65% (3.72%) – 5 seats
    Maori 2.39% (2.24%) – 5 seats (overhang)
    Progressive 0.91% (0.93%) – 1 seat
    United Future 0.87% (0.89%) – 1 seat

    Basically National loses a seat, the Greens gain one. What is with kiwi’s overseas and nostalgically voting Green? Its all right for them, they don’t have to live here.

    No change to the reigns of power or anything dramatic as the confidence and supply agreements are more than adequate but as David Farrar said on applying the St Lague formula:

    National was at massive risk of losing a second seat as they hold Spot 120. Labour are in 121. National’s quotient is 9160.0 while Labour’s quotient is 9159.5.

    If Labour had 40 more voters turn up (that is less than one voter per seat), then Damien O’Connor would be back in Parliament and Aaron Gilmore would have missed out. Or if 22 people who voted National had voted Labour, then Labour would have 44 seats and National 57.

    This does raise the risk of Labour seeking a recount somewhat, though of course, there is no guarantee that’d help them.

  • Homosexuality and the Right-Wing Socialists

    Lately I have been thinking I must write a post about the sacred cow of homosexuality and how it can turn the most ardent liberal into a lefty. I am not the only person to have noticed this phenomena.

    As Matt once commented, “Christians should be very concerned with people who will sell out their commitment to liberty before they would side with a Christian [or a moral viewpoint typically ascribed to a Christian]. Such people cannot be relied upon to defend my rights at all.”

    Matt was alluding to the so called principled liberals whose principles dissipate the minute they encounter someone who shares most of their views but whose moral code differs from the narrow point of view they define their liberality by.

    If you ask them to defend their views and offer a critique they cannot. I doubt they know why they hold their views they just know they are supposed to so they just repeat their mantra.

    Their blind adherence to the “correct” moral views are not based on principle or reason, if you point out a flaw in an argument for one of their sacred cows they intolerantly froth and deem you to not be a member of the club. They will jump on the “correct” side regardless of whether the arguments used are sound.

    This bigoted intolerance from the right is not completely reserved for Christians; anyone secular daring to voice a flaw in an argument advanced by the sacred cows of the-state-must-endorse-gays-movement is also slammed as illiberal.

    Look at all the fuss and bother over David Garrett’s comments on paedophilia [note the comments were NOT on homosexuality, learn the difference between an analogy and an identity claim]. In Real Bigotry Versus Mere Opinion Blair Mulholland notes:

    Today’s Herald has two separate stories dealing, in a roundabout way, with the issue of homosexuality.

    In one, we have an elected official actively condoning violence because some of his constituents regard having their town labeled a “gay capital” as an insult.

    In the other, we have a barrister, who was not an elected official at the time, pointing out that, in his view, both homosexuality and paedophilia are unchangeable psychological phenomena.

    Guess which elected official has had their head called for?

    Seriously, this is bullsh*t. The blogosphere, and I am looking at you too David Farrar, needs to get their priorities straight… so to speak. A small town Mayor says it’s allright to give Jeremy Wells the bash for a comedy piece he did ten years ago and we shrug our shoulders. A new MP makes a crude observation about human behaviour and the crowd demands crucifixion.

    It’s not acceptable.

    Consider Lucyna’s argument in Finding Socialists in the Darndest Places, she cites Lindsay Mitchell‘s argument that one spots a socialist by their walk, not their talk or the ribbons they wave.

    Want proof of how support for homosexuality turns liberals into lefties?

    Compare Blair Mulholland, who says he is “more attuned with the Libertarianz” than ACT’s, endorsement for Wellington Central with Cactus Kate’s, one of the last, self-proclaimed, bastions of complete right-wing bias, hero worshipper of ACT’s Rodney Hide.

    Blair’s endorsement:

    Stephen Franks was worth about ten regular National MPs when he was last in parliament, so if you put him in their caucus he will kick some arse. My wholehearted endorsement for the National candidate here.

    Cactus Kate’s are here, here and here:

    Grant, You are the only Labour candidate I am endorsing at this election

    and:

    With great humour I see all the National Party candidates are now MP’s and yet none of the Labour candidates made it through. Oh dear. Crying a river. With
    such a vicious swing Nationwide to National that result was a fait accompli.

    Well done Sam, Aaron, Simon and Nikki. I hope all your dreams come true. And Grant Robertson who managed despite this massive swing to Toryism, to upset
    Stephen Franks in Wellington Central. Brought a wee glow to the cheeks.

    For the benefit of our overseas readers, Grant Robertson was the Labour (left-wing) candidate and Stephen Franks was the National (right-wing) candidate in the Wellington Central electorate in the recent NZ election.

    Robertson is a unionist and state services flunky from way back; a hard-core left wing activist. As an example of what I mean, when he was National President of NZUSA he organised an activist training conference and invited and sponsored a speaker who advocated vigilante assaults on the private property of those they disagreed with.

    Franks is a former ACT Party MP (more right-wing than National), is a Classical Liberal, has years of experience as a lawyer working in NZ’s top law firms, is considered across the political spectrum as being one of the sharpest, most competent and most ethical MP’s in recent times. Franks is secular and, from conversations I have had with him, does not share my view that homosexual conduct is immoral or that abortion, far from being liberal, is homicide.

    So, I ask you, why would the uber-right wing Cactus Kate be pleased to see Robertson trump Franks? I asked her that and as yet she has not answered. As she moderates her comments, she has seen my questions, so I must assume the silence is deliberate.

    I speculate, with good reason, that the answer is Robertson is gay and that to the socialist-liberal being gay forgives every other flaw; especially when Franks, during the NZ debate to have the state endorse gay relationships through the passage of the Civil Unions Act, made some critical observations on some of the reasons advanced by the defenders of the Bill.

    This of course renders Franks a homophobic hate-filled conservative (liberals by definition are pro-everything gay, no matter how inconsistent it renders them and will turn and blacklist their own in heartbeat at the first sign of a betrayal) and elevates the statist Robertson to the position of the better candidate. [I am reminded here of Matt’s blog: Bigotry as Tolerance: Homophobia as Orwellian Double Speak.]

    Right-wing socialists loudly claim to be principled yet to avoid being associated with a perceived affront to their moral values they would sell their freedom on the basis of knee-jerk ignorance, straw-men and stereotypes.

    So now I turn to Glenn’s latest offering where he suggests that the state has no role to play in endorsing any relationships. Something liberals have always claimed on every other, non-homosexual, issue. This is a concept I endorse accross the board. Marriage existed for centuries without the help of the state. State endorsed marriage is a fairly recent phenomena.

    Extract from: Homosexuality and Socialism?

    It might seem like a very odd connection until you consider… well, actually no matter what you consider it still seems like an odd connection, but in the recent song and dance about Proposition 8 in California, that very odd connect has been reinforced yet again. I’m sure that there are plenty of homosexual people who don’t choose to identify as socialist, so don’t take me to be saying that they all do. But when it comes to the public scrap about marriage, for some of them the red comes to the surface quicker than you can drop a hat.

    As evidenced here, here, here, here and in many many other places, some outspoken homosexuals actually believe the following slogan:

    Marriage is a civil right.

    Now let me very clear what’s being said here. They’re not saying that they have the right to live together as a couple. They already have that right in California, and it was not under threat. They mean legal marriage, and I don’t mean a relationship that is legally permitted (again, they already have this, which is why Keith Olbermann is lying in the second link above when he says that all homosexuals in California who opposed proposition 8 want is the ability to be “a little less alone in the world” by having a relationship”), I mean a relationship that is created by law. What they are actually saying is this:

    I have a basic right for the government to create a type of legal relationship and to confer upon my relationship the status of being one of those relationships.

    Excuse me? There exists no such civil right, for anyone – homosexual, heterosexual…. or otherwise! What kind of nannyish rubbish is this? The government does currently create such a relationship and confer upon many heterosexual relationships the status of being one of those relationships (and it refuses to do so for others – e.g. close relatives, relationships with more than two people etc, which is why Representative Anthony D. Weiner is lying in the third link above when he says “We are not going to rest at night until every citizen in every state in this country can say, ‘This is the person I love,’ and take their hand in marriage”). It’s like thinking that the right to bear arms means that you have the right to arms, that is, the government has the duty to buy you a gun!

    If I stood up in public and said that my wife and I had a civil right to a free house from the government, what would you say? And how crazy do you think I would look if I went further and said that if the government did not provide one then it was somehow displaying hatred or contempt for me or for my relationship?

    I’m a conservative Christian, and I take very seriously the teaching of the Bible. So if you tell me that I have no choice and I must accept the fact that all marriages must be state-endorsed, then obviously I’m going to think in terms of my traditional understanding of marriage, since I don’t want the government creating and then endorsing things that are immoral. We’re going to clash and war over that. But here’s a radical thought: If you want to get married then get married, and let’s not let the government have a part of it at all!

    But what about incest, polygamy etc? Well firstly, people in the USA are already legally permitted to have sexual relations with multiple people and commit adultery. If you think that’s so horrific, then support a law banning it. And incest is already illegal, so the question of incestuous marriage isn’t an issue. The act is banned. Let’s just say that anyone can get married, as long as they don’t commit any acts that are themselves illegal (like incest or marrying a minor or any other illegal sexual practices). Enter into whatever property contracts you like, regardless of sexuality.

    Issues of sexual practices are determined on their own (e.g. the notorious “anti-sodomy law” issue in Texas). But the suggestion that you have a civil right for the government to come into your bedroom and give you a nice certificate and pat your relationship on the back (so to speak)…. Please don’t do that to my language. “Rights” are important things, and you’re dragging that word through the mud when you use it like that.

    (This is to say nothing of the misleading claim that currently, different individuals have different rights based on their sexuality. They don’t. No individual is excluded from getting married in California based on gender, race, or sexual orientation. That’s why emotive comparisons to interracial marriage being banned just have no substance.)

  • The New Lineup

    The new Cabinet has been announced:

    John Key
    Prime Minister
    Minister of Tourism
    Ministerial Services
    Minister in Charge of the NZ Security Intelligence Service
    Minister Responsible for the GCSB

    Bill English
    Deputy Prime Minister
    Minister of Finance
    Minister for Infrastructure

    Gerry Brownlee
    Leader of the House
    Minister for Economic Development
    Minister of Energy and Resources
    Associate Minister for the Rugby World Cup

    Simon Power
    Deputy Leader of the House
    Minister of Justice
    Minister for State Owned Enterprises
    Minister of Commerce
    Minister Responsible for the Law Commission
    Associate Minister of Finance

    Tony Ryall
    Minister of Health
    Minister of State Services

    Nick Smith
    Minister for the Environment
    Minister for Climate Change Issues
    Minister for ACC

    Judith Collins
    Minister of Police
    Minister of Corrections
    Minister of Veterans’ Affairs

    Anne Tolley
    Minister of Education
    Minister for Tertiary Education
    Minister Responsible for the Education Review Office

    Christopher Finlayson
    Attorney-General
    Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations
    Minister for Arts, Culture and Heritage

    David Carter
    Minister of Agriculture
    Minister for Biosecurity
    Minister of Forestry

    Murray McCully
    Minister of Foreign Affairs
    Minister for Sport and Recreation
    Minister for the Rugby World Cup

    Tim Groser
    Minister of Trade
    Minister of Conservation
    Associate Minister of Foreign Affairs
    Associate Minister for Climate Change Issues

    Wayne Mapp
    Minister of Defence
    Minister of Research, Science and Technology
    Associate Minister for Economic Development
    Associate Minister for Tertiary Education

    Steven Joyce
    Minister of Transport
    Minister for Communications and Information Technology
    Associate Minister of Finance
    Associate Minister for Infrastructure

    Georgina te Heuheu
    Minister for Courts
    Minister of Pacific Island Affairs
    Minister for Disarmament and Arms Control
    Associate Minister of Maori Affairs

    Paula Bennett
    Minister for Social Development and Employment
    Minister for Disability Issues
    Minister of Youth Affairs

    Phil Heatley
    Minister of Fisheries
    Minister of Housing

    Pansy Wong
    Minister for Ethnic Affairs
    Minister of Women’s Affairs
    Associate Minister for ACC
    Associate Minister of Energy and Resources

    Jonathan Coleman
    Minister of Immigration
    Minister of Broadcasting
    Associate Minister of Tourism
    Associate Minister of Health

    Kate Wilkinson
    Minister of Labour
    Minister for Food Safety
    Associate Minister of Immigration

    OUTSIDE CABINET:
    Maurice Williamson
    Minister for Building and Construction
    Minister of Customs
    Minister of Statistics
    Minister for Small Business

    Richard Worth
    Minister of Internal Affairs
    Minister for Land Information
    Minister Responsible for Archives New Zealand
    Minister Responsible for the National Library
    Associate Minister of Justice

    John Carter
    Minister of Civil Defence
    Minister for Senior Citizens
    Minister for Racing
    Associate Minister of Local Government

    Rodney Hide
    Minister of Local Government
    Minister for Regulatory Reform
    Associate Minister of Commerce

    Heather Roy
    Minister of Consumer Affairs
    Associate Minister of Defence
    Associate Minister of Education

    Pita Sharples
    Minister of Maori Affairs
    Associate Minister of Corrections
    Associate Minister of Education

    Tariana Turia
    Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector
    Associate Minister of Health
    Associate Minister for Social Development and Employment

    Peter Dunne
    Minister of Revenue
    Associate Minister of Health

    SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE:
    Lockwood Smith

    I will not be giving stats on the number of women or breaking down the portfolios races as this is irrelevant; ministers should be chosen on the basis of their ability.

    No major surprises really, the only thing I would comment on is the sheer number of portfolios on issues the government has no business touching or that are just dumb or paternalistic – women’s affairs is particularly grating as is broadcasting and arts, culture & heritage and the rugby world cup? does the government really have to run that?

  • And United Future’s Baubles Are…

    National and United Future’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Peter Dunne gets Minister of Revenue and Associate Minister of Health.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • Maintain the policy, research and advocacy role of the Families Commission whilst seeking to achieve administrative efficiencies between the operations of the Families Commission and the Office of the Children’s Commissioner.
    • Reducing elective surgery waiting lists by greater utilisation of private hospital capacity, in a planned way where this cannot be met by the public hospital system;
    • Progressing the long-term medicines strategy for quality use of pharmaceuticals in the health sector, Medicines New Zealand, including the role Pharmac should play in that strategy.
    • Support Public Private Partnerships for major roading infrastructure developments where these are deemed to be the preferred options regionally and nationally, such as the Transmission Gully highway.
    • The government notes that United Future has been committed to income splitting as a key part of their tax policy and agrees to support appropriate legislation to First Reading in Parliament.
    • Proceed with the establishment of a Big Game Hunting Council as part of a national wild game management strategy with a view to it becoming a statutory authority.
    • And the government acknowledges United Future’s ongoing support and interest in the development of the Seniors’ Gold Card, the Community and Voluntary sector, and advancing the interests of the disability sector.

    Most of it is the usual centrist stuff *sigh* but I will comment of the standouts.

    The Families Commission was a dumb idea and it has been a dumb bureaucratic nanny-state money-gobbler, just like the Children’s Commission, ever since. So ugh! to that policy.

    Income splitting is a positive move to lowering taxes but it adds complexity to the tax laws and does not benefit enough people. Lowering the top tax rates as the government are planning to to 30% would make the need for income splitting largely redundant.

  • And the Maori Party gets…

    National and the Maori Party’s confidence and supply agreement is out.

    Two Maori Party MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:

    Dr Sharples gets Maori Affairs Minister, Associate Education Minister and Associate Corrections Minister.
    Tariana Turia gets Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector, Associate Health Minister and Associate Social Development Minister.

    Policy Concessions Include:

    • National offered a review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act to see if was working and whether there were any better alternatives.
    • National will drop its opposition to the Maori seats and in turn, the Maori Party would drop its pursuit of entrenching the Maori seats and a group will be formed to look at constitutional issues including Maori representation.

    Good on the Maori Party for pushing the Foreshore and Seabed Act issue. It is a shame to see that National has not framed the issue in terms of the affront to due process and instead is talking about all New Zealander’s being able to access the beach, as if that is somehow more important than human rights.

    I am relieved to see there is no deal to entrench the Maori seats. The status quo of race based representation is abhorrent enough.

  • The Deal is Signed: New Zealand Has a New Government

    The hoardings have barely had time to gather dust and National have just announced they have stitched up a deal with ACT, United Future and the Maori Party. Surely this is the fastest confidence and supply stitch up in the history of NZ MMP.

    National and ACT’s confidence and supply agreement is available here online. Highlights are:

    Two ACT MP’s get portfolios outside Cabinet:
    Rodney Hide gets: Minister of Local Government, Minister of Regulatory Reform, Associate Minister of Commerce and a member of the Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee.

    Heather Roy gets: Minister of Consumer Affairs, Associate Minister of Defence and Associate Minister of Education.

    Areas of Co-Operation Are:

    • Law and Order
    • Climate Change
    • Controlling Government Expenditure
    • Tax
    • Regulation
    • Resource Management Act
    • Education

    Policy Concessions include:

    • An advisory group to look at ways of closing the income gap with Australia by 2025 with the aim of stopping the exodus.
    • Pursuit of a sustained lift in New Zealand’s productivity growth rate to 3% a year or more and the establishment of a high quality advisory group to investigate the reasons for the recent decline in New Zealand’s productivity performance
    • National will, within 6 months, send ACT’s Taxpayer Rights Bill to the Finance and Expenditure Committee of Parliament as a government measure with the aim of passing into law a cap on the growth of core Crown expenses.
    • National agrees to introduce ACT’s “Three Strikes Bill” and support it to Select Committee.
    • The implementation of the Emissions Trading Scheme will be delayed until a review of New Zealand’s response on Climate Change with agreed draft terms of reference is completed, and the thermal generation ban will be repealed.
    • An agreement that a medium-term goal be set for the top rate of tax to be 30 percent so NZ has a government that will reward and celebrate success – not punish it.
    • National will explore the concept of a New Zealand Productivity Commission associated with the Productivity Commission in Australia in order to support the goals of higher productivity growth and improvements in the quality of regulation.
    • An agreement to work together over time to increase education choices so that pupils and families have more freedom to select schooling options that best meet the individual needs of their children.
    • Ongoing discussion is agreed to on ACT’s most excellent 20 point plan.

    Sounds promising. I was worried that Key’s pursuit of Dunne and the Maori Party meant something far more centrist would be announced. I dislike all the bureaucratic committees that will be funded and set up to talk about everything but hopefully something positive will come out of it. Its better than what we had anyway.

    Details on United Future and the Maori Party’s baubles are yet to be announced – I hope the Maori Party have stood firm on some aspect of the Seabed and Foreshore as ACT should support them on that and there will be those in National who were appalled at that particular affront to due process too.