Category: Uncategorized

  • Progressive Enslavement: The Seductions of Scientism

    One of the silly characteristics of our age is the credulous and naive veneration of science. It has led to the emergence of what we call scientism–faith in science as the ultimate source of truth and wisdom. This faith is pervasive.  How many social issues or ethical questions are falsely claimed to be resolved by the magisterium of “scientists say . . . “, or “science tells us . . . “? Consider the insinuation of “science” into the humanities: social “science”; political “science”; anthropological “science”; and “scientific” pedagogy, to name but a few.  Recall how global warming propagandists have tried to pull a swift one by asserting, “the science is settled” by which is meant that infallible truth has been discovered, and that all must now stop debating, stop questioning. Reflect on how politicians crave “scientific” warrant for crazy schemes. Consider how the adjective “unscientific” is used to bludgeon the views of opponents. It is the ultimate evisceration of an opponent’s argument.

    "Mee-mee-mee meep"How did it come to this?  Whilst not alone, probably the most influential protagonist in the English speaking realm for “science”  and the “scientification” of all of life has been John Dewey.  He moved things along a bit from the first phase of the Enlightenment which had held to the idea that Nature was governed by a collage of immutable laws.  Darwin had taught Dewey and his contemporaries otherwise.  Darwin and his popularizers had “convinced” the West that Nature was not fixed, but was changing; mankind, therefore, could not be said to have an immutable nature.  Mankind was now seen as also changing and developing.

    But, reasoned Dewey, this opened up the opportunity for mankind to seize the day.  Mankind had become so advanced and developed that he could now take charge of and manage his own evolutionary development.  “Following Bacon’s prescription, the power to manipulate nature with a view to human purposes had been exercised to remarkable effect.  But the [old] belief  in a fixed human nature meant that the power unleashed by science had not yet been applied in a thorough fashion to our essentially plastic human nature and political society.” (J. Judd Owen, Religion and the Demise of Liberal Rationalism: The Foundational Crisis of the Separation of Church and State (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2001), p.19)  If the scientific method were applied to humanity, we would be able to take effective charge of our evolutionary development.  Humanity would therefore progress more effectively and more quickly.

    Here is Dewey, writing in 1931:

    The entrenched and stubborn institutions of the past stand in the way of our thinking scientifically about human relations and social issues.  Our mental habits in these respects are dominated by institutions of family, state, church, and business that were formed long before men had an effective technique of inquiry and validation.  It is this condition from which we suffer today.  Disaster follows in its wake. (Cited by Owen, ibid, p.21)

    Note the radical nature of the claims here. We must, says Dewey learn to think scientifically about human relations and social issues.  Science alone has an effective technique of “inquiry and validation”; the verities of the past (family, church, state) are relics.  If we continue to resist the “sciencing” of society, we will face disaster.  He means by this that we will not be able to take control of our development–which opens up the possibility, if not probability, that mankind will self-extinguish, proving unfit to survive.  Because Nature is evolving, old verities are worthless.

    Dewey  went on to assert that the Great Scientific Revolution was still awaiting.  We ain’t seen nothing, yet.

    In spite, then, of all the record of the past, the great scientific revolution is still to come.  It will ensue when men collectively organize their knowledge for application to achieve and make secure social values; when they systematically use scientific procedures for the control of human relationships and the direction of the social effects of our vast technological machinery.  (Ibid, p.22)

    The hard, natural sciences had allowed man to understand and then to control and exploit nature to his own advantage.  Dewey says the same rigorous methodology, when applied to humanity and society will allow us to “secure” social values (picking out the best from the emergent changing value grid); then controlling human relationships and setting the direction of society.  “Science” will enable humanity to take control of its own destiny; control its own evolutionary development.

    Two postulates immediately follow: “science” must be elevated into a quasi-infallible status, which explains why scientism is an intrinsic part of the new idolatry.  The ultimate answer to all public and human problems becomes, What does “science” tell us? or, What is the scientific approach?  Secondly, science must control humanity–which is to say that a power nexus of science-government must be formed to order everything, which helps explain the relentless expansion of state powers in the twentieth century to “make things right”.

    The natural law theorists of the early Enlightenment elevated natural law to the place of God.  This meant that mankind was subject to the natural order and could only succeed as he worked in accordance with natural law or “the way the world worked”.  As Rushdoony has astutely pointed out, (more…)

  • Auckland Bloggers Drinks – This Thursday!

    On the first Thursday of every month, Auckland bloggers gather for the Bloggers Bar Bash:

    What: Auckland Bloggers Drinks
    When:
    Thursday 5 November from 6.30pm
    Where:
    Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland

    Open to anyone who happens to be in Auckland. Past attendees include bloggers and bloupies from Annie Fox, Not PC, Interest.co.nz, Lolly Scramble, State Highway One, Beretta, Kiwiblog, Whaleoil, No Minister, Roar Prawn, SOLO,  The Fairfacts Media Show, WHOAR, Cactus Kate and MandM.

  • Auckland Bloggers Drinks Feat. Pamela Anderson and John Key – This Thursday!

    Following on from the success of last week’s packed out impromptu Auckland Bloggers drinks featuring blogging celebrity David Farrar, Peter Cresswell and I have decided that we should feature celebrity guests more often.

    Anna WoolfThis week Pamela Anderson is in Auckland for Fashion Week and John Key is back from New York, fresh from his success as New Zealand’s newest comedian to appear on Letterman, so we invited them both to the Auckland Bloggers Bar Bash.

    They refused to take our calls are yet to confirm but in the unlikely event that neither will make it, and as Pamela is more woman than most, both Anna Woolf and myself will be appearing in her place and Peter Cresswell will be standing in for John Key.

    Madeleine Flannagan standing in for Pamela AndersonOpen to anyone who happens to be in Auckland. Regular blogger attendees include those from Annie Fox, Not PC, Interest.co.nz, Lolly Scramble, State Highway One and MandM. Others have been known to stop by, such as David Farrar, Whaleoil, No Minister, Roar Prawn and Fran O’Sullivan so don’t be shy.

    What: Auckland Bloggers Drinks – a social gathering of bloggers and bloupies (those who read, comment on and hang out with bloggers)
    When:
    Thursday 1 October from 6.30pm
    Where:
    Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland

    Peter Cresswell standing in for John Key

  • More Evidence of Student Association Delusions of Grandeur

    I just got this in my inbox:

    AN OPPORTUNITY HAS ARISEN:
    On Wednesday the 26th of August at the AUSA [Auckland University Students Association] Winter General Meeting there has been an opening to incorporate the UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS into the AUSA constitution.

    WE NEED 200 PEOPLE IN THE QUAD TO VOTE IN FAVOUR AT THE WINTER GENERAL MEETING!
    WEDNESDAY 26th AUGUST at 1pm.

    WHY IS THIS NECESSARY AND IMPORTANT?

    The Universal Declaration is a common statement of mutual aspirations – a shared vision of a more equitable and just world. By incorporating this into its constitution, AUSA would commit itself to these human rights norms. If you care about people and their rights, make sure your voice is heard on this issue.

    PLEASE COME ALONG! Don’t just assume that enough people will turn up without your effort – you REALLY will make a difference!

    Now one wonders what AUSA think they will achieve by incorporating the UN Declaration into their association? The mind boggles. They wrote “By incorporating this into its constitution, AUSA would commit itself to these human rights norms.” What does this mean or rather what do they think it means?

    Maybe they think that students won’t have human right protection without this move.
    Maybe they think that they, a student association, are a body in the nature of a state or that they perform a public function that places them on par with a state but even if that were true they would be obligated to uphold Human Rights regardless of whether it was in their constitution or not.
    Maybe they hope that incorporating it will make them into a state.
    Maybe they think that by them incorporating it into their constitution that action will, like some kind of butterfly effect, improve the human rights of people in other countries.
    Maybe they want to make a big gesture so they can feel all warm and fuzzy… it is raining in Auckland today so maybe that is it.

    Either way it seems a fairly pointless way to spend an afternoon especially if they think they can achieve it with “200 people” turning up; they need 200 members to turn up if they want to amend their constitution. AUSA despite their compulsory funding is the only university students association in New Zealand with voluntary membership – I received the call to come and I am not a member. It is almost tempting to turn up and see if they intend to check those voting are in fact members or not.

    I wonder if they know that the UN Declaration of Human Rights calls for Freedom of Association? Something that, if they had their way, they’d undermine in a heartbeat with a return to compulsory membership.

  • No

    The results of the anti-smacking referendum are in. In answer to the question “Should a smack as part of good parental correction be a criminal offence in New Zealand?” 87.6% of voters said “no.”

    Fairly resounding.

    Vote No seem happy. We are too. Now it is time to sit back and see how the government responds. Nothing less than a law change to clarify what is and is not legal, with regard to smacking, will make me happy.

  • The Freedom of Association Bill

    Fantastic news! Yesterday the Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment Bill 75/1 was drawn from the ballot. Sponsored by ACT’s Sir Roger Douglas, the explanatory note states:

    The purpose of this Bill is to uphold students’ right to freedom of association, by ensuring that no student is compelled to join a students association.

    Section 17 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 guarantees the right to freedom of association. This right includes the freedom from compelled association. Parliament has an obligation to ensure New Zealand legislation is consistent with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act and New Zealand’s obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

    This Bill does not seek to damage or limit students associations, but guarantees the right of students to the freedom of association. It will result in students associations being truly representative of the students who voluntarily join them.

    Under this Bill, all students would be able to choose whether or not to join a students association. The current Act requires councils to conduct a referendum to decide if all students should be forced to become members of an association, if petitioned by 10% of the students enrolled at the institution. If a majority of voters in a referendum support compulsory membership, then the right to freedom of association for the all remaining students is breached.

    This Bill seeks to address the negative consequences stemming from the passing of the Education Amendment Act 2000 and the referenda provisions of the Education (Tertiary Students Association Voluntary Membership) Amendment Act 1997. The current legislation fails to guarantee individual students a satisfactory opportunity to withdraw from associations, and sets the bar too high for those who wish to make membership of a students association voluntary.

    The link above will take you to a pdf of the Bill as hosted by Salient (Blogger does not permit me to upload attachments). As former President and Vice-President of the Waikato Students Union during its brief stint as a voluntary association, Matt and I are extremely pleased that this bill is on the table and we urge the government to back it.

    The only thing I would want to fiddle with is clause 6 to make sure it is really clear that the voluntary membership model at the University of Auckland, where I currently study, is not able to continue. It is effectively compulsory funding but voluntary membership and almost all the problems of compulsory associations remain as a result. It appears that clause 6 of this Bill is intended to address this,

    6 New section 229 substituted

    Section 229 is repealed and the following section substituted:

    “229 Voluntary membership of students associations

    “(1) No person, including any tertiary institution or any association of students, may require any student or exert undue influence on any student –

    “(a) to become or not become a member of any association of students; or
    “(b) to pay any money to any association of students, or to any other person in lieu of such fees.

    “(2) No person, including any tertiary institution, may act in any way which conflicts with the sprit and intent of this section.” [sic]

    However, at Auckland no student directly has to pay any money to the student association. The money is taken from student levies and payed via a service agreement to the association. I worry that as written this clause might permit that to continue. Still such things can always be fiddled with during the select committee process or via supplementary order papers if the Bill goes that far.

  • Contra Mundum: A New Column in Investigate Magazine

    MandM have officially joined the ranks of New Zealand blogs with print columns; Kiwiblog’s David Farrar writes for the NBR, Cactus Kate writes for The Dominion Post and now MandM write for Investigate Magazine – you can now get your MandM fix both online and at your magazine stand!

    Pick up this month’s edition of Investigate Magazine, available now, turn to page 28 and you will find it features a new column, Contra Mundum, authored by Matt.

    Contra Mundum is Latin for ‘against the world;’ the phrase is usually attributed to Athanasius who was exiled for defending Christian orthodoxy. September 09’s Contra Mundum is entitled “What’s wrong with imposing your beliefs onto others?” In it Matt cites feminist bio-ethicist, Leslie Cannold, frequent MandM commenter and blogger, atheist scientist Ken Perrott of Open Parachute and argues the case that it is not always wrong to impose religious beliefs onto others.

    Get your copy today or just subscribe so you don’t miss any columns (I should get commission for sales LOL!).