A reader pointed me to this interesting post on Pacifism and Just War Theory from Baylor University Philosophy Professor, Alexander Pruss.
Interestingly Pruss offers an argument similar to the one I presented at a panel discussion on the ethics of war recently. In this discussion I suggested that traditional Christian Just War Theory follows from the contention that a government has the right and duty to use force to uphold justice within the geographical area over which it has jurisdiction. A just war is simply an extension of the government’s police powers. If a criminal attempted to rape or kill people within the geographical realm over which a government has authority then the government could justifiably use force to prevent this. It could also use force to try and punish anyone who did do these things; this is why we have a police force, court system and prisons. Just war theorists cannot see why this should cease to be the case when the person committing the offence is a soldier from another country as opposed to a domestic criminal.
Pruss gives a similar argument; he starts by defining problematic violence as “lethal violence, i.e. violence that, if successful, has a high probability of resulting in the opponent’s death, counts as problematic, even when the death is not intended.” He then argues,
“If it is permissible to use problematic violence to stop a citizen wife from murdering her citizen husband, it should also be permissible to use problematic violence to stop a non-citizen woman who sneaked into one’s country to murder her citizen husband. Moreover, this should be permissible even if the woman was commissioned by another state to kill her husband. But if we allow that it is permissible to use problematic violence against criminals acting on behalf of foreign states, then there seems to be no way to deny that it is permissible to use problematic violence to stop invaders.”
He makes this illustration,
“When the invading army marches in, burning crops and murdering citizens, they are breaking the victim country’s laws. If problematic violence is permitted to enforce the laws of one’s territory, it should be permissible to use problematic violence to stop them. But this seems to be a case of war.”
This argument is common in the Reformed or Presbyterian traditions. John Murray, in his book Principles of Conduct, notes the Pauline teaching that the “governing authorities” are “established by God.” One is morally bound to submit to rulers because “rulers do not bear the sword for no reason. They are God’s servants, agents of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer.” He then asks, “by what kind of logic can it be maintained that the magistrate, who is invested with the power of the sword, may and must execute vengeance upon evil doers within his own domain must sheath the sword of resistance when evil doers from without invade his domain.”
The Westminster confession makes a similar argument. It argues that because a Government has the authority to use force to maintain justice and peace within the realm over which it governs it can fight wars to maintain justice and peace within this realm.
I think this is one of the most important lines of argument in defence of Just War Theory. In my talk, I argued that the standard six criteria of a just war: just cause, lawful authority, last resort, the use of proportionate and discriminate force and so on simply unpack the general circumstances in which governments are permitted to us force and apply it to warfare. Here I simply want to explore one implication of this line of argument that Pruss raises. (more…)
