Tag: Labour Party

  • Goff on Labour’s Mistakes: What about Fixing a Few Phil?

    I have got to give it to Phil Goff, the more I hear from him the more I like.

    I grew up in a Social Credit family. I lived in Uncle Gary’s East Coast Bays electorate, my mum was even his electorate secretary at one point. I remember watching my father and uncle on the news protesting visiting nuclear ships, I went on nuclear-free marches when I was a kid, we rode on election floats waving green and yellow ribbons around the bays, my whole family would go out door to door canvassing and election days were spent working in polling offices crossing names of those who had voted off the electoral roll. I remember passionately cheering when Lange got elected and my aunt has been known to do a classic Jenny Shipley and Ruth Richardson ‘we hate the poor’ impersonation at the Christmas table. We were a left wing family and until last election, I was the only black sheep. (I voted left once, I gave the Alliance two ticks the first time I voted because I thought their tax policy was really clever [*yes I KNOW*] but then I was cured and have voted right ever since.)

    So when my father who has voted Social Credit/Alliance/Greens/Labour his whole life told me he voted ACT and my stepmother voted National in the last election, I just about dropped the phone. He’d had enough. He had grown disillusioned with the left and the reason is pretty much summed up in Goff’s comments in today’s Herald article, “Goff admits: We made mistakes.”

    So Goff is doing well. He has got my attention. Of course it will be a cold day in hell [well not really because I am a conditionalist – metaphorically speaking then] before he gets my vote, but talk is cheap; if Goff really, truly means what he is saying he might put his money where his mouth is and act (literally) he could start with backing Boscawen’s and Douglas’ Bills to select committee (though I suspect my old Waikato political adversary, colleague and fellow law student now Labour’s General Secretary Chris Flatt might have something to say about the latter).

    Hat tip: Christian News New Zealand

  • Labour Cause Car Accident (Almost)

    Whilst driving, through Labour’s Sue Moroney’s territory, on my way back from my weekly lecture at BTI in Tauranga, I laughed so much I nearly drove into a pole.

    Narrowly missing the pole, the laughter saw me nearly swerve into fence.

    This is what I saw on the side of Galloway St in Hamilton:

    I don’t agree with the vandalism of election hoardings and I prefer personal insults are left out of political debate but I did find this very funny!

    UPDATE: Its seems stuff found it funny too.

  • Labour Erodes More Human Rights: The Criminal Procedure Bill

    I was absolutely horrified to wake up this morning to hear that Parliament had passed the Criminal Procedure Bill last night.

    While there were some good things in the Bill (as there usually are) such as the district courts being able to hear P cases, I am most appalled at the attack on double jeopardy; the rule that a defendant cannot be tried more than once on the same set of facts (note: we are not talking new facts, new evidence). This law was laid down in section 26 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act:

    “No one who has been finally acquitted or convicted of, or pardoned for, an offence shall be tried or punished for it again.”

    The doctrines autrefois acquit and autrefois convict (the defendant has already been acquitted or convicted on these facts) have long been established within common law and find their place in human rights charters around the world so for the government to erode them in this manner is yet another example of their disregard for rights and freedoms.

    In the system of law we use in New Zealand a person is innocent until proven guilty. This system means inevitably that sometimes the guilty will get off and the innocent will be convicted. Whilst no one likes or condones these negative connotations the alternative is worse because the solution to ensuring that the guilty always get convicted is to imprison every accused and likewise, the solution to ensuring the innocent never get convicted is to never convict anyone. The system is balanced to make it difficult to convict because it is generally deemed worse to send an innocent person to jail than to fail to punish the guilty.

    So we are left having to accept that once a court has heard a case, weighed the evidence and ruled, that’s that. Allowing the state to keep having a go because despite the court’s assessment, the state “know” this person is guilty (or worse because of trial by media, the public “know”) is to give the state far too much power and to give society far too much uncertainty in the justice system. Whilst it may succeed in increasing the chances of nailing the guilty it equally runs the risk of allowing the state to run trial after trial after trial with its vast resources against the innocent.

    Labour undid hundreds of years of jurisprudence on human rights formulated by far greater legal and ethical minds than any of them possess in one sitting last night. Just remember that next time you decide that someone guilty got off after listening to the 8 second soundbite on the news or reading the 600 word article in the Herald; if a judge and 12 of your peers who heard all of the evidence, got to see the body-language and hear the tone of voice of the witnesses ruled the other way, maybe they were in a better position to assess the case. If the police failed to build their case then tough. If anything, knowing they can have a second crack will encourage them proceed with a lower standard of evidence.

    Of course with the passage of this Bill the government have not completely removed Double Jeopardy but have only removed it in certain circumstances which the Herald reports as:

    “when compelling evidence has been presented that is likely to lead to conviction, and when an acquittal is found to have been tainted.”

    However, the common law already allowed this following Connelly v DPP [1964] AC 1254, which allowed exceptions on the grounds of special circumstances such as so called tainted trials and new evidence but this law goes further than that.

    When you put together:

    The Doonegate affair
    The repeat failure to rosecute politicians who commit crimes
    The abolition of the Privy Council replaced with a unilateral state appointment of judges
    The passing of the Terrorism Suppression Act
    The Electoral Finance Act
    The illegitamcy of retroactive legislation
    The placing of what consistutes reaonable force in the hands of the police rather than a court
    The personal use of police resources
    The public commitment to marginalise critical viewpoints from society
    The increased presence of trial by media
    The increased growth and intrusion of the state into daily life
    (and probably more than I can think of just now)

    alongside a series of reforms, the common thread of which makes it easier for the state to successfully prosecute we realise just how scary New Zealand has become in the few short years of this Labour government.

    Madeleine

    UPDATE:

    I discovered on reading Don’t Vote Labour “The bill passed its third reading 108-11, with the Greens, the Maori Party and independent MP Gordon Copeland opposing it.”

    While I am not surprised to find myself in the same company as the Greens and the Maori Party on this one as the Greens do occaisionaly stand on the right side of these types of ethical issues (though often the reasons they give are completely bizarre) and the Maori Party I have a lot of time for on some issues of this nature such as the Seabed and Foreshore, but what was with ACT voting for it?

  • Benson-Pope

    Benson-Pope is someone that the more closely you observe him the more his slimy, smarmy, bullying, bullet-dodging just pisses you off.

    Until recently I used to live in Dunedin so I have had a few encounters with Mr Benson-Pope a.k.a. panty slut boy and have crossed swords with him politically and know other people who have too. I find him an unpleasant person and a liar.

    The hit he has taken is well deserved. About time. But what annoys me is that he escaped just desserts over so many other issues. But oh well, at least this hit didn’t bounce off.

    The beehive website is not up with the play though cause they still have him on their site as a Minister.

    Interestingly Ian Wishart has re-released his findings on Benson-Pope’s involvement in the Dunedin Bondage and Discipline scene with the rather interesting addition:

    “[Benson-Pope] went to the trouble of ringing a senior Otago Daily Times journalist at home that evening, expressly to ensure that the newspaper was not quoting him as denying the story. “

    This was always a story I felt certain should have had a lot more air time by the media than it did.

    It had the now familiar to us all ring of Benson-Pope’s dodging the truth.

    Add to that our own experience of Benson-Pope’s lies. He told the media when he used the police to collect a $35 cleaning bill (the police were his first line of request for this bill – most people would use a 45c stamp first…) that it was not him who utilised police resources as his personal debt collection service but his secretary without his permission (sound familiar?). In fact when we used the official information act to get the files on this incident whose signature was on the request to the police to do the debt collecting? NOT his secretary’s but his!