Tag: NZ Christian Blog Rankings

  • Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs December 08

    Two New Zealand blog sites run monthly stats ranking the top New Zealand blogs on public discourse, Tumeke and Half Done. Both use different formulae so the stats don’t always come out the same.

    Previously I have accorded Tumeke’s stats as the official ones and Half Done’s as the shadow report, comparing Half Done’s stats that come out a lot earlier with Tumeke’s from the previous month. This practice seems a bit silly, it makes more sense to compare stats from the same month and as bloggers do not agree which formulae is the better, I figured we should rethink how we present the top 10 Christian stats which we run monthly.

    Going forward we will publish:

    Christian Blog Rankings for Month Year – Tumeke
    Christian Blog Rankings for Month Year – Halfdone

    And once we have both sets of stats from each:

    Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs Month Year

    The top 10 will average the rankings from each and will form the official MandM ranking.

    The following ranks the Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs (public discourse) for December 08 by comparing Half Done’s December 08 stats with Tumeke’s December 08 stats and averaging them to obtain their overall December 08 ranking.

    [Rank. Blog Average (Half Done Tumeke)]

    1. NZ Conservative 16 (10 22 )
    2. Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later 20.5 (17 24)
    3. The Briefing Room 27 (27 27)
    4. MandM 37.5 (25 50)
    5. Kiwi Polemicist 66 (61 71)
    6. Say Hello to my Little Friend 79.5 (65 94)
    7. Put up Thy Sword 82 (46 118)
    8. Samuel Dennis 90 (51 129)
    9. Contra Celsum 104 (117 91)
    10. Star Studded Super Step 116 ( – 116)

    Other Christian blogs featuring in the top 200 NZ blogs on public discourse for December 08:

    Gavin Knight 120 (109 131)
    Blessed Economist 137 ( – 137)
    Section 59 Blog 156 (137 175)
    Definitive 164 (165 163)
    NZ Debate 176.5 (159 194)
    The Voice of Reason NZ 199 ( – 199)

    The difference between Half Done and Tumeke’s stats in some instances is quite remarkable given they both measure the same month; there is more than 70 points difference each between Put up Thy Sword and Samuel Dennis yet The Briefing Room scored the same on both.

    You can go to each site and read how their respective formulae work but essentially both base their formulae on unique visits and incoming links; Half Done leaves it there, but Tumeke adds to his the average number of blog posts and comments.

    Some say you shouldn’t be awarded for volume of posts and comments, quality is what should be measured and quality is best measured by visits and links to entries. The other argument is that comments are indicative of interest and that hits alone can be unfairly influenced simply by the type of group the blog might be associated with or where it is advertised and that such blogs might get disproportionate blog hits even if they have posted very little all month.

    Although I tend to lean towards Half Done’s formula (a range of issues – nothing whatsoever to do with the fact we score considerably better on Half Done’s formula), I figure averaging both formulae gives you the best of both worlds.

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification methods.

    If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • Christian Blog Rankings for December 2008 – Tumeke

    Extrapolating from Tumeke’s December 2008 stats, the top 10 Christian Blogs on Public Discourse in New Zealand are as follows; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for December 08:

    1. NZ Conservative (22 + 1)
    2. Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (Half Done) (24 + 9)
    3. The Briefing Room (27 + 4)
    4. MandM (50 – 4)
    5. Kiwi Polemicist (71 + 1)
    6. Contra Celsum (91 + 4)
    7. Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta Blog) (94 + 3)
    8. Star Studded Super Step (116 New)
    9. Put up Thy Sword (118 – 20)
    10. Samuel Dennis (129 – 67)

    Of Note:

    • Again, no change in the number 1 spot, well done NZ Conservative.
    • Those in this month’s top 7 held their positions fairly stably however some blogs saw massive drops – probably the nature of December in play.
    • We welcome some new faces in the Christian blogosphere; Andy Moore’s Star Studded Super Step debuts at number 8 (of course this blog has been around a while but this is its first time on Tumeke’s and MandM’s rankings) and new comer, Blessed Economist.

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse are:

    (Numbers in brackets show the overall NZ ranking of each blog)

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification and ranking methods.

    If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • Shadow Report: Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs Dec 08

    The following shows how November’s Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs (public discourse) fare on Half Done’s December stats compared to Tumeke’s November stats;

    1. [1] NZ Conservative 10 (23)
    2. [3] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later 17 (33)
    3. [4] MandM 25 (46)
    4. [2] The Briefing Room 27 (31)
    5. [9] Put up Thy Sword 46 (98)
    6. [5] Samuel Dennis 51 (62)
    7. [6] Kiwi Polemicist 61 (72)
    8. [8] Say Hello to my Little Friend (a.k.a Beretta Blog) 65 (97)
    9. [10] Gavin Knight 109 (112)
    10. [7] Contra Celsum 117 (95)

    Top 10 Half Done [Top 10 Tumeke] name of blog Half Done rank (Tumeke rank)

    Of Note:

    • All Top 10 Christian blogs improved on Half Done’s formula v Tumeke’s – a few have close to 50% improvement!
    • There are now 5 Christian blogs in the top 50.
    • There is a change in the top 3 😉

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse but outside the top 10:

    [10] Section 59 Blog 137 (166)
    [O] NZ Debate 159 (151)
    [O] Definitive 165 (167)
    [O] The Voice of Reason NZ N/A (194)

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification and ranking methods.

    If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • MandM in the Challenge

    Madeleine’s top ranking of the top 10 Christian blogs has been picked up by the Challenge Weekly, a conservative, evangelical newspaper. She was interviewed for it before she went into surgery, the following is an extract from the article which was published on Dec 8, 2008.

    In the NZ Blogosphere
    by John McNeil

    His ability to exploit internet-based social networking is widely credited with being a major reason behind Barack Obama’s success in the US presidential race.

    Web logs or blogs are an integral part of that networking process, and some of the more successful New Zealand bloggers – such as David Farrar and Russell Brown – are now becoming media personalities in their own right.

    Internet users are increasingly turning to blogs as an information outlet additional to traditional sources such as newspapers and television.

    With the number of New Zealand bloggers estimated to be in the thousands, how are Christians measuring up?

    Tim Selwyn, from Tumeke Blog, measures the most popular type of blogs, those that engage in public debate, and each month issues a New Zealand ranking. Using his figures, long-time Christian bloggers Matthew and Madeleine Flannagan have discovered that writers bringing a Christian viewpoint are achieving an encouraging response.

    They say the top 10 Christian blogs fall within the 150 most read blogs. The most popular of these is New Zealand Conservative, compiled by a group of Catholic writers. The Flannagan’s own – MandM – has risen to fourth position among Christian writers, and 50th overall.

    “We are getting close to 3,000 unique visitors per month. We put the rise in visitors down to our commitment to quality, considered posts from a philosophical perspective that are relevant to a broad range of people, Christian and non-Christian alike,” Mrs. Flannagan said.

    Most of them enjoy respect from non-Christian blogs, however, she said, writers have to be strong enough to take the knocks as well. “At the moment I’m putting up with an online voting poll about who is the sexiest blogger. I have been named as one of the finalists, and people are writing in with some fairly lewd comments. There is nothing I can do about it.”

    “Christians sticking their necks out publicly on issues like abortion and homosexuality also come in for some abuse and threats that the secular blogs affirming these issues do not.”

    Mrs Flannagan said she was passionate about blogging as she found it an excellent way to get the Christian viewpoint across and to smash the false assumption that Christians had nothing of interest to offer in the public square. …

  • Shadow Report: Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs Nov 08

    The following shows how October’s Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs (public discourse) fare on Half Done’s Nov stats compared to Tumeke’s Oct stats:

    1. [1] NZ Conservative 9 (23)
    2. [2] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later 19 (34)
    3. [3] The Briefing Room 25 (35)
    4. [4] MandM 31 (50)
    5. [8] Put up Thy Sword 43 (114)
    6. [5] Samuel Dennis 55 (79)
    7. [9] Contra Celsum 71 (125)
    8. [6] Kiwi Polemicist 82 (92)
    9. [7] Gavin Knight 87 (95)
    10. [N] Section 59 Blog 116 (155)

    Top 10 Half Done [Top 10 Tumeke] name of blog Half Done rank (Tumeke rank)

    Of Note:

    • All but one Top 10 Christian blog improved on Half Done’s formula/their November performance.
    • NZ Conservative crack the top 10 in the country – well deserved.
    • No change in the top 4 spots.
    • Impressive improvement for Andrew Chesswas’s Put up Thy Sword.
    • Very good gains for Samuel Dennis, Contra Celsum and Section 59 too.

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse but outside the top 10:

    [10] Say Hello to my Little Friend (a.k.a Beretta Blog) 128 (126)
    [O] NZ Debate 164 (156)
    [O] Definitive 166 (181)
    [O] The Voice of Reason NZ N/A (184)

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification and ranking methods.If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • The New Zealand Christian Blog Rankings

    In September I extrapolated from Tim Selwyn’s Tumeke Blog rankings, and published the top 10 New Zealand Christian blogs on public discourse. The post where I did this proved surprisingly popular and as other bloggers have since requested that I do this every month, I have decided that I will.

    At the moment I rank the top 10 as these fall in the top 150 of all NZ blogs on public discourse but if more Christian blogs climb the public lists then I will expand my list accordingly.

    I think it is only fair that I explain how I identify a Christian Blog as some blogs that are run by Christians did not make my list. It is simple. To be a Christian Blog you must self-identify that your blog contributes to the public blogosphere from an overtly Christian perspective and this must be recorded on Tumeke’s stats. In other words, and because I don’t have the time to replicate what Tim Selwyn does, you can’t have it both ways, you cannot appear on Tumeke’s stats as seemingly secular or “neutral” and then quietly pop up on mine as Christian; a Christian, by definition, does not hide their faith.

    That’s not to say there is anything wrong with a Christian running a blog on public discourse who chooses to not make their blog a Christian blog. If someone does not wish to overtly identify their blog as a Christian blog it does not make them any less a Christian as everything they write will naturally be coloured from their faith anyway and ultimately it is their choice as to what format their blog takes and how they pitch it to the blogosphere.

    Likewise, it is my choice as to which ones I will rank and it is easier and seems to me more fitting to rank the overtly Christian blogs.

    How to Make the Rankings
    To rank the top 10 Christian blogs I wait for the monthly blog rankings to come out, usually towards the end of the following month, then I run a search for terms such as ‘Christian’, ‘Christianity’, ‘Theology’, ‘Faith’. Any blogs that come up with those terms then get listed in the order that Tumeke ranks them.

    As such, if you wish your blog to feature in the top NZ Christian Blog Rankings do not contact me, rather observe the following as to make my rankings you have to be on Tim’s Tumeke rankings, if you think your blog meets the criteria, e.g. is NZ related and focussed on public discourse, then:

    1. Check to see if your blog currently features in Tumeke’s stats.
    2. If it does not, or if it is not described correctly, then contact Tim Selwyn and provide the following information:

      Blog Title and Blog Address
      Very short description as to what your blog is about (less than 8 words)
      The name of each blogger
      The general ideological position of each blogger e.g. right, left, centre
      The specific ideological position or political affiliation or religion of each blogger

    3. Check your site is listed with Alexa, if it is not, take 5 minutes and register it – click the link and type your blog address into “lookup website” then add your site info. You don’t have to download the toolbar or place a widget on your site though doing this will help your stats rise. (Tim’s formula uses your Alexa ranking)
    4. Is your site is listed with Technorati? If it is not, take 5 minutes to register and claim it – click the link, create an account, add and claim your blog. You do not have to do anything else though adding a widget will help your stats to rise. (Tim’s formula uses your Technorati incoming links)
    5. If you make the Top NZ Christian Blog list put one of these buttons on your site pointing to this link:
    6. Put a good free stat counter on your blog, set it to both not count your visits and to count uniques and email Tim your stats for the relevant month he is working on. (This step is not vital, but if you don’t do this, Tim will rely on Alexa’s unique count for your blog or he will assign you a guestimate and this may not be accurate.)
    7. Make sure you link to MandM (ok well, links to MandM are not part of Tim’s formula but think how cool your blog will be!)

    Now, climbing the rankings is another story entirely and while the net is full of ways to aid this the best way to climb the rankings is to make sure your content is interesting.