Tag: Voluntary Student Membership

  • Guest Post: VUWSA’s VSM Violations

    When ScrubOne sent us this offering as a guest post we couldn’t resist. This sort of thing has been happening for years and we saw it a lot back at Waikato University but that was pre-You Tube…gotta love the internet.

    DPF links to some videos of a student meeting held at the University of Wellington where some students decided to show up and demand their association (VUWSA) support compulsory membership.

    The association insiders try to shut it down by

    • breaking rules
    • announcing lack of quorum in a packed room (wait till the camera turns around – it’s absurd)
    • ignoring the result of votes

    In other words, they employed every trick in the book legal and illegal to try and stop students having their say.

    Watch it for yourself (you may need to hunt down parts 2 and 3 as it doesn’t seem to have been set into a playlist)

    DPF reports that they’re now using similar tactics to overturn the result by scheduling a meeting…

    So an illegal meeting, in breach of their own constitution, held in a bar at 11 am on a Friday (when all good students are hungover) is the first response of the compulsion lovers.

    But it gets even better. After forceful representations about the illegality of the proposed Friday meeting (not that the forces of compulsion did the same thing at WSU – hold a vote with only a day or two’s notice) including a potential injunction, the compulsionaters have come up with an even better plan.

    They have simply declared the Wednesday meeting void  on the grounds two VUWSA people declare a quorum count of 45, less than the required 50. Now note the resolution was passed with 80 people voting and a later quorum count (with one independent person) found there to be over 60 people present, and this count was done within the 30 minutes allowed in the constitution.

    The chances of the VUWSA putting in a submission in support of VSM are roughly those of a snowball’s chance in hell. Even if they accept the legality of this vote (which they won’t) and the illegality of the new meeting (which they won’t) they will simply ignore the motion or spin it away somehow.

    But that’s the point – the more VUWSA refuse to obey their own rules, and ignore their own members, the more they demonstrate the need for students to be allowed to remove their support from the association.

  • Mentionables

    Flat out busy as the end of semester approaches and deadlines and exams loom we thought we’d link to some blog posts we’ve recently found interesting rather than actually write anything ourselves:

    Wintery Knight has a video for which his blog post title sums up the content: MUST-SEE: Megyn Kelly of Fox News exposes the truth about ACORN

    Cactus Kate has posted one of the more sensible yet moving blog posts we’ve read on the Samoa Tsunami: It’s A Long Way Back – Alofa Samoa

    Bethyada posts a timely quote from Cicero: Random quote

    The Prosblogion’s account of a recent conference at the University of Notre Dame where leading theistic philosophers and leading sceptics discussed hard texts from the Old Testament and their relationship to theistic belief: Thoughts from the Notre Dame conference, “My Ways Are Not Your Ways”

    Kiwiblog has an excellent piece on Voluntary Student Membership responding to Jacinda Arden’s account of what happened at Waikato University when membership of the campus students association briefly ceased being compulsory. Given that Matt and I were President and Vice-President respectively of the then voluntary Waikato Students Union and helped to make it voluntary, we are very glad to see that the facts are being put straight faster than the left can invent new fantasies on blogs other than our own: Fisking Jacinda

  • VSM Bill off to Select Committee

    The VSM Bill has passed its first reading and is off to Select Committee. Predictably the student associations have freaked out and David Farrar has an interesting fisk of the various press releases they’ve issued in response here.

    Given that Madeleine and I were involved in the move to make student associations voluntary in the late 90’s we will follow this debate with interest.

    UPDATE:
    The Hansards debate on the VSM Bill is now online here. It makes for interesting reading, you can really see the left/right ideologies coming through. The left MP’s rubbish the concept of freedom of association and conscience as right wing inventions and talk about collective rights, rights to free education and so on.

    We also noted Labour MP Chris Hipkins revealing objection to the Bill:

    “the real driver behind this bill—which, of course, we heard already from Roger Douglas and Anne Tolley—is that it is designed to silence critics of the Government.” [Emphasis added]

    Note the assumption that all tertiary students oppose National, ACT, United Future and Maori Party [Government] policies.

    Funny, I recall some CM Research being done when I was a student at Waikato University that showed that in fact 60% of tertiary students vote right of centre, a study that NZUSA commissioned, paid for with money taken from all students, and then refused to release the study when the results didn’t come out showing all students being lefties.

  • AUSA: ‘FREE’ Candy for your Vote

    Following on from More Evidence of Student Association Delusions of Grandeur, where I shared Auckland University Students Assocation’s (AUSA) unfathomable intentions to incorporate the UN Declaration of Human Rights into their constitution, a fellow student and reader of this blog, brought my attention to today’s email to all University of Auckland students which he described as “bribery now to get what they want.” I must concur:

    Student apathy was at its worst today when we failed to get 200 people to turn up to the quad to hold the AUSA Winter General Meeting. However, all is not lost – we are going to try again!

    So come to the quad at 1pm on Thursday the 27th of August (tomorrow) and vote in favour of putting the Universal Declaration of Human Rights into the AUSA Constitution! We were only about 20 people short so I cannot stress enough that YOU REALLY WILL MAKE ALL THE DIFFERENCE!

    Even if the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is not your thing, we will be giving out candy! FOR FREE! Maybe even a few muesli bars for the health-conscious amongst you. All you need to do is bring along your uni ID card and flash it in favour of human rights!

    SEE YOU IN THE QUAD AT 1PM, THURSDAY 28 AUGUST. DO IT.

    Again I am left wondering how on earth this move can “MAKE ALL THE DIFFERENCE” for human rights. Again we see the disregard for proper constitutional process in the statement “All you need to do is bring along your uni ID card and flash it in favour of human rights!” AUSA membership is voluntary, as such, possession of a Uni ID card does not mean that you are an AUSA member and are entitled to vote but they do not seem to care about this detail.

    So basically you can receive material benefits if you vote the way they want you to (doesn’t matter if you’re not really to eligible to vote) and all this is in the name of AUSA’s strong commitment to human rights.

    This would be funnier if I wasn’t paying for it.

  • Compulsory Membership of Student Associations Has to End

    VUWSA (the Victoria University of Wellington Students Association) are at it again. Just last week David Farrar slammed them for their intended ANZAC day flag burning protest and this week they put Dave Crampton on notice for defamation and then retracted it at the 11th hour confessing that it was them at fault.

    I wouldn’t have a problem with these acts if they were just voicing their own left-wing pacifist opinions or wasting their own money on hiring lawyers to draft letters in the pursuit of frivolous and vexatious lawsuits but they are not. When they do these things they are doing so on behalf of every single student at the University of Victoria; they are paying for these things out of the pockets of every single student at the University of Victoria.

    There is no way every single student (and I’m confident that I remain on safe ground even if I invoke the majority) support flag burning protests being carried out at ANZAC day memorial parades or frivolous and vexatious law suits enacted purely to shut down criticism of those with different political views than their own. I am certain that had VUWSA asked students to voluntarily donate money for such activities they would not have raised any where near enough to fund them.

    The current National government, despite the fact that they did attempt to fix this last time they were in office (but their then coalition partner, New Zealand First, messed it up), do not have a voluntary student membership and funding bill even planned. Worse, they do not even see it as a priority or properly understand the extent and nature of the problem.

    The relevant bits in the New Zealand Bill of Rights are:

    13 Freedom of thought, conscience, and religion

    Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience, religion, and belief, including the right to adopt and to hold opinions without interference.

    Being forced to join and fund a political organisation that routinely expresses contrary viewpoints to your own, on your behalf and in your name, violates section 13.

    17 Freedom of association

    Everyone has the right to freedom of association.

    Being forced to join and fund a political organisation in order to obtain an education violates section 17.

    [Compulsory membership and funding also violates discrimination laws but as these are not human rights, despite the fact they are found in the Bill of Rights, I will not list them. The above real human rights are more than adequate.]

    For a brief overview as to some of what proponents of compulsory student associations have done to Matt and I see:

    Studying at Otago University no Riot
    Go on and Rubberneck

    For further reading see:

    VUWSA’s ANZAC Charade Is More Student Association Misrepresentation
    Student Choice

    If you wish to do more than read you could always email Anne Tolley (Minister of Tertiary Education) and Wayne Mapp (Minister of Defence and Associate Minister of Tertiary Education).

  • Go on and Rubberneck

    In case you have noticed and wondered at the recent flurry of arrivals from Kiwiblog in the Live Traffic Feed you might click here and then once on the page use “control f” then type in “abortion” and then read the defamatory statement about me (and Matt) and the ensuing debate that began on Friday.

    Do not think badly of David Farrar for not removing the statement. I asked him to leave it there as these statements, and variations of them, began 11 years ago when Matt and I were student politicians. They have not gone away despite us hiring lawyers, more than once, so maybe it is time to meet them head on and expose them for the lies they are.

    The person posting under the name Blockhead helpfully happened to have documentation to hand that also clarified things so look out for his/her contributions. Oh, and feel free to make liberal use of the karma buttons on the site.

  • They Just Want Your Money (and your Voice)

    My post about student association membership reminded me that just yesterday I stumbled accross this article that I wrote for Critic’s diatribe column when we were at Otago.

    Despite the fact that OUSA membership has probably increased since we were there, that NZUSA’s annual budget is now almost certainly much more than the figure I quoted below and these days the student associations tend to promote Green party policy more than the Alliance’s it is still very applicable so I have reproduced my article here.

    They Just Want Your Money

    Free education will never exist.

    Even if the government funded 100% of tertiary study costs, students would still have to pay to get an education – even if it were a fact that ‘government money’ grew on trees.

    Why? Because student association membership fees are compulsory.

    Want a tertiary education? Then you have to join the student association. No choice, no argument; if you want to get your grades then cough up the best part of $100 to OUSA.

    Apart from being a violation of the Bill of Rights – s17: “everyone has the right to freedom of association” – it smacks of hypocrisy.

    The loudest campaigners for free education, the advocates for hard-up students, are funding their campaigns, national and international flights, their catered conferences, the very handcuffs they chain themselves to government architecture with, with a total budget estimated to be around $18 million annually.

    This income is sourced entirely from the pockets of the very people they claim should not have to pay a single cent to get an education.

    So long as student association membership remains compulsory, free education can never exist.

    Effectively, NZUSA’s $400,000 annual budget – also taken entirely from students – is a total waste of money. And for what? To tell us to vote Alliance. Who? Over 90% of us did not vote for free education last election, demonstrating most of us think we should pay something substantial towards our education.

    OUSA use our money and voice for things political, controversial, environmental and occasionally student related. Maybe I would mind compulsion less if they steered clear of the political, did not comment on controversial topics, that those they allegedly represent have a diversity of views on, and provided good services. However, even if they did all this, their compulsory subscription would still be immoral.

    It’s that pesky Bill of Rights again. OUSA could be the most wonderful, student advocate and service provider in the country but they would still have no right to hold my grades to ransom unless I forked out and joined them. No more right to do so than any workers’ union has a right to garnish pay-packets, a church to forcibly extract an offering, the Salvation Army to make a benefit deduction.

    Student associations are kidding themselves if they think they are any better than any of these organisations – which, incidentally, all manage to stay afloat, be effective at what they do and who they serve by being voluntary. The only type of association that has anything to fear by giving its members a choice to join is one that knows it’s so irrelevant, unaccountable, ineffective and useless that no-one will choose to join it unless they are made to. Which begs the question; why should they be able to force you to prop it up if it is so useless? You’d join if it were good.

    Voluntary membership fosters accountability, relevance and effectiveness, because if a union is not these things it will go under. Having cash flow contingent on performance is incentive, having thousands of cash cows you can simply burden further if you blow the budget on, say, ummm, a book store, gives you no incentive to perform relevantly at all. It leaves members totally reliant on the ethics of the student politicians (did I just use ethics and politicians in the same sentence?).

    But, we’re told, students can conscientiously object (CO) so it’s not really compulsory, it’s not really a violation of your right to freedom of association. Really? Putting aside the fact that you have to first join or risk late fees and grades being withheld before you can even think about CO-ing, you have to apply to the student union for permission to be exempt from membership. If your evidence is not compelling, they don’t have to grant you a CO. Even if successful, they get to choose which charity to donate your $100 to; you don’t get it back.

    I see. I don’t have to associate with anyone as long as I first associate with the student union so I can disassociate with them, assuming they let me, and then make a donation to an ‘appropriate’ charity of their choosing?

    It’d make a good Tui billboard: “Student unions don’t violate civil rights. Yeah, right.”

    They want you to believe a lie that voluntary membership is some kind of right wing conspiracy, championed by white middle class male members of ACT, when in fact outside of tertiary institutions it’s normal.

    Student politicians want your money, they want to illegitimately use your voice to push their personal agendas – the ones they think you should hold. They want you to shut up, roll over and take it. The question is, will you?