Author: Madeleine

  • Pacifism, the Bible and the Sin of Selfishness

    ‘If someone wants something from us and we do not want to give it to them that is the sin of selfishness and the Bible condemns selfishness.’ This was one of the three points a Christian pacifist speaker made in defending his stance at the panel discussion on War Ethics that Matt mentioned in Pacifism and The Golden Rule.

    Whilst there were a lot of issues raised that night that I wanted to respond to (being a member of the audience, I was only able to ask a question on one) it was this point that I woke up with in my head the next morning; I awoke with the question/statement I wished I’d have asked/said on the night fresh in my mind. Here it is:

    Mr Pacifist, you said that if someone wants something from us and we do not want to give it to them that is the sin of selfishness; if someone wants to take from us we should let them without resistance because that is what Jesus did when he let himself be crucified. Is that about right?

    Gun=Better Protection than any Pacifist Male

    So if I go out to the parking lot and a man pins me to the ground and starts raping me and my hand find a rock in the darkness next to me, is what you are saying that I should let him take what he wants, that I should not use the rock to smash him in the head but rather I should lie back and think of Jesus?

    I think the point you are missing is that Jesus let his life be taken to save humankind. If I let myself be taken I am saving no one; if I smashed the rapist in the head with a rock I could at least save the next victim. I could mount the argument that by responding with my choice to be pacifist I was selfishly not thinking of the next victim?

    And what if it was my daughter? What if I heard a noise in the night and found some man pinning my 10 year old down raping her? Should I tell her to lie back and think of Jesus too? Not call the police who might force him away in handcuffs to face a justice system that will deprive him on his liberty? Not smash him over the head with a frying pan or attack him with a kitchen knife? Because I’ll tell you what, anyone who I found doing that to my daughter would leave my house in a body bag or I would give my life trying.

    Pacifism might sound trendy but it misses the point that while Jesus might have lived a fairly pacifist looking life when he was on earth, Jesus is part of a Trinity and there are other parts of the Trinity that judge, that wage war, that strike down and destroy. Yet another part of the Trinity inspired the writing of  the whole Bible. All three elements of the Trinity’s example must be read together to understand the contexts they fall in and I believe  (more…)

  • Just Think – Matthew Flannagan Speaking for ProLife NZ @ Waikato University

    Fetus

    Student group ProLife NZ have launched a campaign entitled JustThink (you can read more about it at the link). To kick things off the Waikato branch has invited Matt to speak on their key messages:

    1. Is an unborn child a human being?
    2. Should it have a right to life?
    3. Should our views on abortion affect others?

    This is an open lecture so anyone interested can come. There will be an opportunity for Questions and Answers so bring your questions!

    The talk will be held in Lecture Theatre S.G.03 at the campus of the University of Waikato, Hamilton, New Zealand from 1-2pm on Wednesday 25 May 2011.

    Dr Matthew Flannagan is an Analytic Theologian and Ethicist. His PhD thesis “Is Historical Opposition to Feticide Defensible in the 21st Century?” was just one of many pieces Dr Flannagan has written on the ethics of feticide (abortion).

    Dr Flannagan is no stranger to the Waikato campus. He completed his undergraduate and first post-graduate degrees majoring in Philosophy at the University of Waikato where he and his wife Madeleine met, founded and led the Waikato campus branch of Students Organised to Uphold Life (SOUL). He was later elected and served as President of the Waikato Students Union.

    Click the link to access all posts on this blog pertaining to the ethics of feticide.

  • Fallacy Friday Podcast on Apologetics 315: Ad Populum (Appeals to Popularity)

    Apologetics 315 are producing an audio version of Matt’s Fallacy Friday series.

    Fallacy Friday Podcasts

    The Fallacy Friday Podcasts are released every Friday on Apologetics 315. You can subscribe using:

    • RSS Feed
    • iTunes
    • One-Click

    The Mp3 of Ad Populum (Appeals to Popularity) is here.

    To navigate the series in print, use the Fallacy Friday tag, to navigate MP3 series use the Fallacy Friday Podcast tag.

  • Guest Post: Tim McGrew defends “The Argument from Miracles: A Cumulative Case for the Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth”

    Tim McGrewA little while back we published a post linking to some talks by Tim McGrew on Undesigned Coincidences in the Gospels. For some bizarre reason this post of ours prompted fellow kiwi blogger Deane Galbraith to write a post on the Bulletin for the Study of Religion, linking to our post, on the separate topic of Tim and his wife Lydia McGrew’s article “The Argument from Miracles: A Cumulative Case for the Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth” which was published in the The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology.

    Here is a snippet of Galbraith’s post from the beginning:

    There are quite a few academic and quasi-academic studies in which statistical analysis seems to be employed as a substitute for thinking. It is, perhaps, fairly understandable why some people are tempted by the allure of numbers. Those mysteriously complex formulae, mindnumblingly boring statistics and obscure mathematical notations lend a magical aura of scientific objectivity and plausibility to even the most patently absurd claims.

    What gets me talking about this at this moment is my dumbfounded reading last night of an article published by Timothy McGrew and Lydia McGrew, entitled“The Argument from Miracles: A Cumulative Case for the Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth” (2009). In this article, the McGrews utilize Bayesian probability in order to argue to the “scientific” conclusion that the probability of the resurrection of Jesus is a “staggering” 100,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,
    000,000,000,000,000 to 1.

    Are you staggered? overwhelmed? swooning? Were you previously skeptical about the Christian claim that Jesus was resurrected, but now you’re feeling pretty silly? Perhaps not.

    The post goes on in the same vein to accuse the McGrews of trying to trick people into belief in the resurrection. It is littered with terms like “flimsy basis”, “populist apologetics”, “fanciful” and “deeply and unavoidably farcical” and is illustrated complete with a giant white-robed Caucasian Jesus wistfully looking heavenward as he steps out of the tomb. It finishes with Galbraith laying out his understanding of their mathematical reasoning, the tone at this point is dripping with lashings of smug, self-congratulation at how easily he, PhD student from Otago whose research area is giants in the Old Testament narrative, had dispatched two of the top philosophers of religion working in this field, both specialists in probability theory.

    Not being qualified remotely in Bayesian probability theory myself, and therefore not wanting to presume anything beyond assessing the tone as exceedingly arrogant, I passed on Galbraith’s criticisms to the McGrews on Facebook. Well it turns out that Galbraith isn’t the only non-qualified liberal/atheist to take a punt at their reasoning on this piece. Tim McGrew explains that straw men have been popping up all over.

    Straw Men Burning: Misinterpretations of our Article on the Resurrection

    One of the hazards of writing technical philosophy is the risk that someone who lacks the appropriate expertise will attempt to critique it. In the case of the article on the resurrection that Lydia and I wrote for The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology, this has already happened. It is hard enough to correct misimpressions of this sort on a relatively neutral topic; when the subject rouses passions of the sort that, as Hume reminds us, religious disputes are apt to generate, then the difficulties are redoubled.

    But one thing that we did not anticipate is that (more…)

  • Fallacy Friday Podcast on Apologetics 315: Petitio Principii (Begging the Question)

    Apologetics 315 are producing an audio version of Matt’s Fallacy Friday series.

    Fallacy Friday Podcasts

    The Fallacy Friday Podcasts are released every Friday on Apologetics 315. You can subscribe using:

    • RSS Feed
    • iTunes
    • One-Click

    The Mp3 of Petitio Principii (Begging the Question) is here.

    To navigate the series in print, use the Fallacy Friday tag, to navigate MP3 series use the Fallacy Friday Podcast tag.

  • Fallacy Friday Podcast on Apologetics 315: False Cause & Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc

    Apologetics 315 are producing an audio version of Matt’s Fallacy Friday series.

    Fallacy Friday Podcasts

    The Fallacy Friday Podcasts are released every Friday on Apologetics 315. You can subscribe using:

    • RSS Feed
    • iTunes
    • One-Click

    The Mp3 of False Cause & Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc is here.

    To navigate the series in print, use the Fallacy Friday tag, to navigate MP3 series use the Fallacy Friday Podcast tag.

  • ACC Wars: Deja Vu? (Tribunal Result Update)

    On the eve of my hearing tomorrow [finally!] against the Accident Compensation Corporation (“ACC”) this appeared in today’s New Zealand Herald:

    “An Auckland man has won his battle against ACC after a court found its specialist diagnosed degeneration without having looked at an MRI scan of the injury.”

    Guess who the specialist was? The SAME one who did the SAME thing to ME: Mr Brian Otto. Déjà vu much?

    Roll on tomorrow. Please pray for justice to prevail. I’ll update with the results as soon as I have them, which is unlikely to be tomorrow and more likely to be within 28 days.

    UPDATE:
    I lost. The reasoning in the judgment is poor and does not follow. In my opinion the law was poorly applied. The hearing was issued by a tribunal run by ACC. A recent legislative change now sees these tribunals run independently but my case was heard prior to this coming into effect.

    Because the tribunal felt that my appeal was brought on a good faith basis I was awarded some costs and my law firm, John Miller Law, have generously written off their costs (aren’t they awesome!) so this round did not cost me the $4,000 I expected it to, it only cost me $850 in the end.

    So, because of the surprise my lawyers expressed at losing, coupled with my own surprise – both of us being fully aware of the facts, evidence and the law along with the knowledge we were not before an arbitrator who was independent and, in my opinion, said arbitrator was deficit in her legal reasoning, combined with the fact we have been generously donated $2,500 towards fighting ACC and have only spent $850 of it and because of the principles at stake and, finally, because of the raft of people being treated the same way – wrongfully being deemed to have degenerative pre-existing conditions following injuries sustained by accidents – who lack the means to fight ACC, I have instructed my lawyer to file an appeal in the very independent District Court. When I get a court date I will let you all know!

    If you want to donate to the ACC war fund, I am warned the court costs could rise to $8,000 – I have thus far paid $1850 towards the appeal – please use the Pay Pal widget in the side bar and tag the donation something to do with ACC or refer to our Support page.