Author: Madeleine

  • Moving Beyond Sunday School

    On this blog we often rail against new-atheist readings of Biblical texts. Our pages are littered with expositions as to what a text is really saying when you consider the context, genre and textual evidence, all of which demonstrates that the new-atheist readings of the texts are at best wanting and at worst down-right stupid or dishonest. But, of course, it is not just atheists who sometimes fail to read Biblical texts properly.

    Joshua Fit the Battle of Jericho

    I was reminded of this recently in an exchange with someone who on considering Paul Copan’s work in Is God a Moral Monster? and Matt’s blog series God and the Genocide of the Canaanites Part I, Part II and Part III, asked me:

    “If these Biblical battles are so clearly exaggerated, why aren’t they taught to be so in churches? When I learnt in Sunday School about how “Joshua fit the battle of Jericho”, should the Sunday-School teacher have added “Of course, it didn’t really happen!”

    Aside from the fact that I thought it was an interesting observation on his part that he had never really sought to take his own understanding of those passages beyond Sunday School level, I think there is something in his question but before I go on I should make a brief qualification. Neither Copan or Matt have argued that the Battle of Jericho never happened; they have argued that the ‘genocide language’ in the earlier parts of the Book of Joshua should be read as hyperbolic hagiographic accounts of Israel’s early skirmishes in Canaan and that this language and the accounts of those battles should not be read in isolation from the rest of the Book of Joshua and the surrounding texts – especially Judges. This more Canonical approach shows that the Bible does not teach that the Canaanites were genocided by the Israelites.

    As to why Sunday School teachers don’t get into how to interpret the ‘genocide passages’ in Joshua, I expect it has something to do with the same reason the dove with the olive branch is generally not depicted flying over any floating, swollen corpses in the pictures of the happy pairs of animals floating on an ark with a rainbow in the background that dot the Sunday School walls. A Sunday School teacher should focus on the message or point of these stories and leave the realities of floods and wars and their effect on the people who don’t survive them for when a child is older.

    But this I guess is my correspondent’s point. The church seems to have produced Christians en masse whose understanding of these passages has not really moved beyond the Sunday School glossing of the story – their understanding now appears to be the Sunday School version plus, now they have lived a bit and get that floods and wars kill people, X number of dead people. If you scan the comments on the half or dozen posts Matt has published on the ‘genocide passages’ on this blog you will find Christians struggling to get their heads around the idea that perhaps instead of reading only Joshua 6-11 and forming a conclusion that is only fractionally more in touch with reality as the Sunday School stories they should instead read all 24 chapters plus a fair decent way through Judges.

    Now I am not trying to say that my fellow Christians are all stupid (or even that new atheists are) (more…)

  • Undesigned Coincidences in the Gospels – Tim McGrew

    Timothy McGrewIf we have a question on the historicity of the resurrection, Timothy McGrew is our first port of call; there is no one we would turn to before him on the subject. Tim is also highly regarded for his work on probability theory and on miracles – he is the author of “Miracles” for the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. We have previously linked to his Library of Historical Apologetics.

    I mention all this because Tim recently gave an excellent talk, which is available free as an MP3 and is entitled “Undesigned Coincidences in the Gospels.” Tim’s wife, Lydia McGrew, who first alerted us to this talk, writes:

    Undesigned coincidences in the Gospels … is an argument that was well-known in the nineteenth century but has, for no really clear reason, simply been forgotten as time has gone on. It is a cumulative case argument that the Gospels reflect, to an important extent, independent knowledge of actual events. Please note that this argument is quite independent of one’s preferred answer to the synoptic question. That is to say, even if, e.g., Mark was the first Gospel and others had access to Mark and show signs of literary dependence on Mark, the argument from undesigned coincidences provides evidence for independent knowledge of real events among the Gospel writers. There are many more of such coincidences beyond those given in the talk.

    Two of Tim’s other talks, which overlap the material in this talk but also extend it, “Beyond Minimal Facts, Part I: External Evidences” and “Beyond Minimal Facts, Part II: Internal Evidences” can be ordered for a small fee – details here. Matt and I have both of these and can highly recommend them.

  • Fallacy Friday Podcast on Apologetics 315: Division and Composition

    Apologetics 315 are producing an audio version of Matt’s Fallacy Friday series.

    Fallacy Friday Podcasts

    The Fallacy Friday Podcasts are released every Friday on Apologetics 315. You can subscribe using:

    • RSS Feed
    • iTunes
    • One-Click

    The Mp3 of Division and Composition is here.

    To navigate the series in print, use the Fallacy Friday tag, to navigate MP3 series use the Fallacy Friday Podcast tag.

  • Unbelievable? Is God a Moral Monster? Paul Copan & Norman Bacrac

    Paul Copan recently debated Norman Bacrac on the topic “Is God a Moral Monster?” on a recent episode of Unbelievable? on the UK station Premier Christian Radio.

    Matt and I just listened to it and we both thought it was worth sharing as Copan really handled himself well and very clearly articulated his position on the hyperbolic reading of the Canaanites (a position he has co-authored with Matt on). The interaction between Copan, Bacrac and the show’s host Justin Brierly was very good too.

    Unbelievable?Listen here: Unbelievable? 9 Apr 2011 – Is God a Moral Monster? Paul Copan & Norman Bacrac
    [If the link will not load the Copan v Bacrac debate directly go to the Unbelievable? page then locate the 9 April 2011 episode ]

    The blurb from the show is:

    Richard Dawkins describes the Old Testament God as “a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser” (among other things).  Paul Copan is a Christian apologist and has written a book, “Is God a Moral Monster?” aiming to show why God’s actions in the Old Testament are not immoral when taken in context.

    Norman Bacrac is an atheist humanist and part ot the South place Ethical Society. He believes that Old Testament morality was barbaric and we don’t need a God to tell us how to behave.  He holds that God’s morality is called into question if we take the Old Testament literally.

    So how do we interpret passages where the Israelites were commanded to wipe out whole towns including women and children?

    “The blog of Matthew and Madeleine Flannagan in New Zealand” rates a mention from the host, Justin Brierly, about 38 mins in 😉

  • Video: Sam Harris v William Lane Craig Debate “Is the Foundation of Morality Natural or Supernatural?”

    Sam Harris and William Lane Craig debated the moot “Is the Foundation of Morality Natural or Supernatural?” at the University of Notre Dame on 7 April 2011. We’ve already linked to the debate  MP3 but here is the video of the whole debate.

    Hat tip: Pondering the Preponderance

    See Matthew Flannagan’s:
    Debate Review: Sam Harris and William Lane Craig on Divine Command Theory Part I

     

  • Sam Harris v William Lane Craig Debate @ Notre Dame – UPDATE MP3 Online

    The debate between Sam Harris and William Lane Craig at The University of Notre Dame on the topic “Is the Foundation of Morality Natural or Supernatural?” will be streamed free and live on Notre Dame TV at 7:00pm EST on 7 April 2011 [11:00am NZ time on 8 April 2011].

    William Lane Craig v Sam Harris

    Hat tip: The Apologist

    UPDATE: The audio is now available as an MP3 over at Apologetics 315.

    RELATED POSTS: Matt has written a few posts here on MandM defending Divine Command Theory for those interested in reading a little more on the position William Lane Craig defended.

    Also see Matt’s:
    Debate Review: Sam Harris and William Lane Craig on Divine Command Theory Part I

  • Fallacy Friday Podcast on Apologetics 315: Tu Quoque (But you did it too!)

    Apologetics 315 are producing an audio version of Matt’s Fallacy Friday series.

    Fallacy Friday Podcasts

    The Fallacy Friday Podcasts are released every Friday on Apologetics 315. You can subscribe using:

    • RSS Feed
    • iTunes
    • One-Click

    The Mp3 of Tu Quoque is here.

    To navigate the series in print, use the Fallacy Friday tag, to navigate MP3 series use the Fallacy Friday Podcast tag.