Author: Madeleine

  • See William Lane Craig and Christopher Hitchens debate: Does God Exist?

    You are invited to a Thinking Matters Auckland, God, Morality and Society, DVD screening:

    What: William Lane Craig v Christopher Hitchens debating Does God Exist?
    When: Tuesday 21 July – 7:00pm
    Where: Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format: DVD followed by discussion.
    Cost: Free – donations appreciated.

    DVD ScreeningIf you were not one of the 4,000 people who got to see it live in April this year at Biola University’s Talbot School of Theology and you do not own a copy of the DVD, this is your chance.

    Atheist commentator, Christopher Hitchens, author of the best-selling God is Not Great and Christian Philosopher and Theologian, Dr William Lane Craig, author of too many things to list here, who packed Auckland University during his debate with Dr Bill Cooke last year, debate the topic: Does God Exist?

    Do not miss this screening – you cannot rent this debate at your video store and this debate is not available online so organise your friends, bring your youth group but most of all be there!

    Thinking Matters’ resident Philosopher of Religion and Theologian, Dr Matthew Flannagan, will be available for Q&A and discussion after the video.
  • Christian Blog Ranking Report for May 09 – Tumeke

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on Tumeke’s NZ blog stats for May; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for May 09:
    1. MandM 35

    Top 10 Tumeke. name of blog Tumeke rank

    Of Note:

    • No change in the number 1 spot – well done NZ Conservative!
    • Welcome to the top 10 Being Frank and Sustain:If:Able Kiwi.
    • The top 8 are all in the top 50 blogs in New Zealand – when we first began running this report only 2-3 Christian blogs ever featured in the top 50 so well done everyone!
    • Christian News New Zealand, Samuel Dennis, Kiwi Polemicist, Star Studded Super Step all made the top 100 despite being outside the top 10.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s ranking descriptions. If you think your blog should be included contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings. (*hint hint* MacDoctor Moments who is identifiably Christian on HalfDone but not on Tumeke)

    Now that Tumeke’s May stats are out we will compare them with the HalfDone May report and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for May 09 shortly.

  • Mount Maunganui Adventures

    Mount MaunganuiYesterday I took my youngest two kids for a walk around The Mount (as Mt Maunganui is referred to by locals) as we are staying about a 2 minute walk from it at the moment.

    As we left I told them that when I was younger and I had done this walk with my parents we had once seen an orca (killer whale) swimming offshore. Brittany and Noah at once wanted to know how many orcas I thought we’d see on our walk and I had to tell them that despite the hundreds of times I had done the walk I had only every seen an orca in the harbour once so it was highly unlikely we’d see any today.

    They didn’t believe me and began eagerly discussing how many orcas they expected to see. It turned out I should have listened to them as right between Matakana Island, the long dark island with the long white beach towards the top of the picture and the Mount itself, were two orcas swimming in the harbour!

    I didn’t have a camera with me so here is a pic that the Herald took when one of their reporters spotted orca’s at the Mount.

    Today we are climbing The Mount so hopefully they will still be hanging around and we can take some of our own pics.

  • Weight Watchers and the Historical Atrocities Argument

    We’ve all heard the slogan that atheism is superior to theism because of all the atrocities committed in the name of religion. If you flick through the pages of the new-atheist publications by the likes of Dawkins, Hitchens, Loftus, Harris, et al you’ll probably find some version of this assertion in each.

    Setting aside the dubious factual claims and the fact that I could list a stack of atheist atrocities that could outnumber the theist ones just from the last century alone, there is another way of addressing the slogan. If a person joined Weight Watchers, got the points book, the pamphlets explaining how the program works and began attending weekly meetings to fellowship with others on the same journey but instead of following the instructions began to bend the rules, invent new ones and ignore others and as a result began to gain weight, could that person justifiably claim that Weight Watchers made them fat? That Weight Watchers should be rejected as a weight-loss program, in fact, attempting to lose weight in and of itself is a bad thing, because this person gained weight whilst ostensibly being a follower of the program?

    If you can see how ridiculous it would be to blame Weight Watchers and to abandon the pursuit of weight loss because someone who cheated on the program had a bad outcome then why can’t you see it when the same reasoning is applied to atrocities committed in the ‘name of’ Christianity

    H/T Rodney Lake at Thinking Matters Tauranga

  • BOP Bloggers Drinks – Tonight!

    Ozy Mandias, Matt and I will be meeting up at Latitude 37, in Mount Maunganui tonight at 7.30pm. Any other Bay of Plenty bloggers or readers are most welcome.

  • Live Blogging from the Mount

    We are off to Mount Maunganui for a few days so we’ll be blogging from there instead of Auckland this week!

    We’ll have to have a Bay of Plenty bloggers drinks.

  • Guest Post: Why doesn’t the Bible address X?

    The following is authored by Bethyada of True Paradigm, it is particularly apt given recent comments left on this blog. Bethyada writes:

    A not infrequent complaint raised by theism sceptics is that the Bible does not address many issues the sceptics think it should address; if indeed the Bible is a divine book and not merely a human one.

    There are several problems with this demand

    1. It assumes the critic’s concerns are the same as God’s
    2. It assumes the Bible is written for the sceptical
    3. It assumes that God should dictate Scripture rather than use his servants to author it
    4. It ignores that Scripture was written into a culture
    5. It ignores what is contained within Scripture
    6. It ignores that the issues may be addressed indirectly
    7. It places an unreasonable burden on the size of the resultant text
    8. It suggests that if such was included the sceptic would be convinced of the truth of the Bible
    Whose concern is important?
    To ask that the Bible address X, Y, or Z assumes that these are the things God is most interested in recording for his people. The Bible is diverse, though there are several common themes. A major theme is right relationship with God. There is a large amount of material discussing individuals and nations in right and wrong relationship with God and the consequences of such. God is forever calling people to himself and rebuking them for going their own way. The Bible suggests that the biggest problem in men following God is not evidential, rather wilful. All Jericho were in fear of Yahweh after reports of his exploits, yet only Rahab submitted to him.

    Related to this theme is reconciliation, especially the focus on God coming to earth as a man to teach us God’s way, to receive our punishment and to establish a kingdom. Thus, much of Scripture builds up to this event, describes this event and discusses the consequences of this event.

    Who was the Bible written for?
    The Bible has information that can be used to defend the truth of God and to rebuke the mocker; that is, it does have apologetic value. However the intended audience includes and is probably predominantly, those who belong to God’s kingdom. At the time of the Old Testament that was Israel (though admittedly this included apostate Israel). In the New Testament the gospel of Luke (and Acts) are addressed to Theophilus (Friend of God). The letters are all addressed to individual Christians or churches. The biblical “inadequacies” as claimed by the sceptical may be of less concern to believers.

    The Bible was written by God’s servants
    Scripture, in the main, is not dictated by God. Thus there is freedom for the authors to write in their own style. Christians believe God had the authors include what God wanted recorded. Many also claim that God prevented them from writing error. This at least allows for difficulties in reconciling parallel passages, none of which contain exhaustive information.

    The Bible was written into specific cultures
    This fact has been misused to limit the scope biblical injunctions. Nevertheless, the authors were writing to the people who lived and thought a common culture. They addressed issues that were pertinent to the people around them. This includes who they perceived as their friends and enemies at the time. Laws related (in part) to their way of life, the types of houses they lived in, the foods they ate. The Israelites were an agrarian society. Many of the specific issues we face in the 21st century were non-existent in ancient Israel and some of them would have been barely comprehensible. However, most issues faced by diverse nationalities have some degree of commonality. Truly new concepts, such as intellectual property, are not that common. To request the Bible address specifically, issues that post-date its completion is anachronistic. The Bible may do so if God wishes but to complain of these types of deficiencies is unreasonable.

    What does the Bible discuss?
    The fact is, the Bible does discuss a wide range of issues. There may be questions we have that it is difficult to clearly answer from biblical considerations but what of that which the Bible does tell us? It tells us a lot about God, a lot about us. It tells us we are broken. It tells us our relationship with God is broken and better, how to fix it. It tells us how to treat others. It teaches about relationships with one’s spouse and with one’s children. It tells us about honesty in business relationships. It tells us to concern ourselves with the less fortunate.

    There is much we are shown about in the Bible. Is the concern about what is lacking actually about us not liking what is not lacking?

    The indirect teaching of Scripture
    It is not that difficult to apply what the Bible says within an ancient culture to our modern one. Is it really that hard? to go from “build a parapet around the edge of your [flat] roof” to “build a fence around your swimming pool.” Does one really think that if God opposes getting intoxicated with wine that he approves of getting intoxicated with marijuana? Many of the questions we have in our modern technological age are addressed indirectly through Scripture.

    How big do we want our Bible?
    It is difficult for a finite text to cover all the questions that man is capable of asking. The amount of information now known to man is vast, too much for any one person to know. Yet there are questions I can ask (that are intrinsically answerable) and not one man on earth currently knows the answer. If the Bible addressed in detail the specific answer, along with an underlying explanation of the assumptions of the questioner, of every question raised by a bibliosceptic its size would be enormous, not to mention unsustainable for the ancient scribes. For a hand-written book, the Bible is already pretty large. And even many Christians have not read it thru. How does one gain the overall themes of a book that would take a lifetime to read thru once?

    Would a different text alter the sceptic’s position?
    My considered view is that the complaint of biblical deficiencies is an empty one. Inclusion of specific issues would only mean that different deficiencies would be raised.

    As mentioned above, the problem, as the Bible sees it, is not one of knowledge; rather it is one of the will. Rahab chose to worship Yahweh. Many of those who would be willing to submit to Christ have enough information to evaluate him. If someone has a real stumbling block then it is worth addressing it with him. But there is enough clarity in Scripture for those whose hearts are good soil and there is enough concealment for the mocker to remain sceptical.