Author: Madeleine

  • Bill Clinton on "Un-fertilised" Human Embryos [UPDATED]

    See this clip for yet another President of the United States who supports human embryonic stem-cell research but has no clue what he is talking about.

    Bill Clinton says he thinks the issue has become “too politicised” and we should be like him and “hand it back to science.” He says this despite having repeatedly re-assured us that the type of human embryonic stem-cell research he supports is restricted to “un-fertilised embryos.” He thinks much of the opposition to the issue would be alleviated if people realised this point.

    Worse (well not sure which is worse really) the interviewer did not bat an eyelid as his repeated use of the term “un-fertilised embryos.”

    What do you think he meant by “un-fertilised embryos,” watch the clip and share your thoughts?



    UPDATE:
    As Eastside Billie pointed out on motownsports.com,

    If this were Palin, McCain, Limbaugh, Hannity or any other right wing it would be spread all over the media. But Billy C? No way. Don’t we all know he’s brilliant. He’s a scholar. The Media will protect any liberal when they talk stupid.

    Can you say Dan Quayle?

    Hat Tip: NZ Conservative

  • The Catholic Church, Excommunication and Abortion for Child Rape

    The Catholic Church has excommunicated the mother, who arranged an abortion for her 9 year old daughter, who was pregnant with twins as a result of rape by her stepfather.

    There is a heap of controversy over this in the blogosphere, the most insane of which is the Hand Mirror claiming this is evidence the Catholic Church hates girl children I note they claim this despite the Irish Times reporting:

    The archbishop made clear that the excommunication did not extend to the young girl at the centre of the case.

    I don’t get the controversy. I honestly do not get it at all.

    Do people not know that the Catholic Church views abortion as homicide? Is this a fact that people are not aware of – is this not common knowledge?

    I am not Catholic but even I was aware of their stance on abortion and in case you missed it, they are opposed to it on the grounds it is a form of homicide. Given this, the Catholic Church has acted consistently with their beliefs in excommunicating the mother in this case. Their position is that:

    Homicide can only be justified in a narrow set of circumstances.
    Abortion is homicide.
    Therefore: Abortion can only be justified in narrow set of circumstances.

    The narrow set of circumstances that exist in law as defences to homicide do not include consideration for who the father of the victim is, what crimes he has committed against you and how traumatised you feel. This may be harsh, but it is the law. As a law student I can assure you that if you find yourself in a court of law and you say to the court “but your honour, I hired a hitman to stab them to death because their father raped my daughter” you will not get off a homicide charge. The court will sympathise with your plight, they may view it as a form of provocation, which may mitigate your sentence, but it is not a defence that will excuse homicide.

    Self-defence where a threat to life is imminent and for which there is no other alternative is a defence that will fly, however, it is not clear that this was the case here (despite the reported commentst to the contrary). As NZ Conservative pointed out, there pregnancies can be being successfully managed in children of this age, modern medicine can achieve this.

    Given all of this, please point to where the Catholic Church erred in or acted inconsistently with their reasoning. [Pointing to the step-father’s alleged lack of excommunication is a red herring as being wrong on another matter does not make you wrong on all.]

    Now, before the Hand Mirror et al can accuse me of supporting child rape or conduct some other bogus psycho-analysis as feminists of their ilk are wont to do when other women disagree with them, let me be clear.

    Rape, particularly rape of a child, especially when it is done by those whose relationship with the child is supposed to meet the threshold of ‘parent,’ warrants the death penalty.

    However, I must argue stridently that the death penalty should be carried out on the offender and not a third party.

    It is not a justification to take someone’s life because their father committed a heinous crime and another person is suffering because of it or because of how you might feel if they go on living.

    On other blogs where I have commented on this issue, I have been accused of being indifferent to the plight the mother and her child faced and of lacking emotion. The first thing I want to say to this charge is that I would hope that when dealing with an ethical issue I would lack emotion. Clear, rational thinking is vital when confronted with highly emotional issues.

    If I am honest, the minute I heard this story my reaction was of emotion. I have an almost 9 year old daughter and I would happily kill to protect her and am certain that I would struggle to limit myself to ‘proportional force’ against anyone who harmed her in that manner. Most parents reading this will be able to relate to the instinct I am speaking from.

    However, if we contemplate harming the born children of such an attacker we should immediately know that it would be wrong to direct our instinctive parental-protection-violence towards them. Why so, then, do we not have this instinct when we contemplate killing the unborn children of such an attacker? What assumptions are inherent in the different response?

    Inherent in this response is an assumption that the unborn lack some feature that the born possess. What is that feature and can it rationally justify the different responses?

    Maybe it is the fact that we are horrified that the child, not only raped, now has to deal with pregnancy and birth.

    Does abortion un-rape her? Think about the method of abortion; is it any less traumatic to have instruments inserted into her vagina, people looking and touching, pain, medical risk from the procedure?

    More importantly, though, is the trauma of having to go through pregnancy and birth and deal with all that entails, justification for homicide of people we are not making assumptions about? Could I justify killing you for that reason? No? Then, why can I kill a fetus for that reason?

    Is it the fact that these are rapists children so somehow they are less human. Just think about that one. Is it fair or just to treat a born person whose father is a rapist this way? No? Once again, the unstated assumption that a fetus is not on par with a born person is evident.

    Cases like this one, when you strip away the emotion and rationally assess them come back to the same position:

    If abortion is not homicide, then any and all abortion is morally benign.

    On the other hand:

    If abortion is homicide, then abortion must be treated the same way we treat other homicide.

    You cannot solve this dilemma by getting hysterical, accusing those on one side of hating people, pointing to other things they may be doing wrong or turning your brains off because you are justifiably horrified at child rape. Set your emotions aside and think the issues through consistently; start here.

    RELATED POSTS:
    Is Abortion Liberal? Part 1
    Is Abortion Liberal? Part 2
    Sentience Part 1
    Sentience Part 2
    Viability
    Abortion and Brain Death: A Response to Farrar
    Abortion and Capital Punishment: No Contradiction
    Imposing You Beliefs Onto Others: A Defence
    Published: Boonin’s Defense of the Sentience Criteria – A Critique
    Published: Abortion and Capital Punishment – No Contradiction

  • Dr Steve Kumar on Faith and Reason

    You are invited to a Thinking Matters Auckland event:

    What: Dr Steve Kumar speaking on Faith and Reason
    When: Tuesday 17th March – 7:00pm
    Where: Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format: Talk followed by questions, answers and discussion
    Cost: Free!

    Don’t miss hearing New Zealand’s most prominent Christian Apologist.

    For almost thirty years Dr Kumar has been actively involved in speaking and writing about apologetics, philosophy and faith. As a New Zealand Christian apologist, he is a sought-after speaker in academic and church settings around the world. He is a frequent guest on television, radio, and news media programs and is an influential voice on issues that relate to the credibility of the Christian truth claims.

    Mark it in your calendar now and tell your friends!
  • Thinking Matters Auckland: Apologetics Seminars

    Following on from the interest Dr William Lane Craig generated when he visited New Zealand last year, Thinking Matters Auckland (TMA) announce the launch of their Apologetics seminars.

    At the seminars, TMA will showcase New Zealand’s best Apologetic talents and screen DVDs of the world’s top Apologists defending the Christian Faith.

    Opportunity for analysis, discussion and questions will follow each event.

    Thinking Matters is a community of professional and lay apologists dedicated to offering credible reasons to believe and rationally answering objections to the Christian faith.

    Seminars will be held at West Auckland’s Laidlaw College in LR2 fortnightly on Tuesdays from 7-9pm starting Tuesday 17 March 2009.

    TMA seminars are free events, accessible to all and open to anyone, Christian and non-Christian alike.

    TMA’s founders are Matt and Madeleine Flannagan TMA is affiliated to Thinking Matters New Zealand
  • Christian Philosophy as Necromancy

    I believe my vocation as a Christian Philosopher and Theologian is to provoke people to wrestle with the existential questions they face regarding themselves and God and to challenge them to take Christian answers to these questions seriously.

    I was thinking about metaphors for the conversation my vocation requires me to engage in and I came up with the idea of Christian philosophy as Necromancy; Necromancy is the practice of communicating with the dead. In the religious or quasi-religious traditions of some societies it is believed that a person’s soul or spirit continues to exist after they die. The departed spirits can communicate with those still living and those still living can consult their knowledge and advice on matters of importance to them provided that the communication is done through a medium known as a necromancer. The necromancer is a person who is believed to have a special skill of discerning and interpreting what the departed spirits are saying and making this accessible to the enquirers. Similarly, the necromancer is able to put the questions of the enquirer to the departed. Necromancy is a two way conversation; the enquirers putting questions to the departed and the departed giving their answers through the necromancer.

    I believe in my own field at least (and in more other fields than is often realised) that what I do is analogous to Necromancy. In the analogy, the enquirers are my audience, the Necromancer is the Christian philosopher and messages of the departed spirits are the subjects under discussion. The departed spirits are the great scholars and thinkers who have gone before us.

    Let me elucidate this a bit more fully. In philosophy many of the most significant writings are by people who are dead, people like Plato, Hume and Descartes. The same is true in religious education where one is trying to encourage people to understand and inculcate a theological tradition.

    A tradition is a body of purported knowledge (in religious traditions often revealed knowledge) handed down to the current generation from its ancestors. The point of studying tradition is to appropriate the wisdom (and to winnow out the folly) of the past and apply it to a contemporary context.

    While these people are dead, the issues they faced are of relevance to us today because many of the questions they addressed are questions we still encounter and want answers to; we want to know what is truth? What is the purpose for existence? What is knowledge? Who are we? What is God’s will? Etc. These people provided, often, carefully reasoned answers to these questions and the point of studying them is to try to appropriate their insights in our own context. Studying these people’s writings, if done properly, is not just to read these people but to enter into dialogue with them.

    Why did Plato hold the views he did? What were his reasons – are they cogent? If I offered a particular objection to his position how could it be responded to? When one reads the differing views of Plato and Aristotle who was correct? Why? In the debate between them, which arguments are sound and which are not? Can Plato’s position be modified to stand up to the criticism of Aristotle? And so on. To engage this subject properly it is not enough to just passively read; one must enter the debate and contribute to the discussion oneself. We do this because we have a stake in the questions involved and because the answers to these questions are important.

    So in a very real sense, religious education and philosophy are conversations with the dead. We have existential and philosophical questions we want answered and we “consult” the teachings of our dead ancestors to help us answer these questions; in doing so we enter into dialogue between us and them.

    As I noted, a necromancer is a person skilled at interpreting the teachings of the dead. This means the Christian philosopher must also be a scholar; he or she must understand these teachings and be in a constant two-way conversation with the dead him or herself. Her or she must also be able to articulate this conversation to others. His or her job is to try and take what he or she learns about what the dead have to say and then make it accessible to contemporary people and show them how it addresses the issues and answers they are asking.

    The Christian philosopher also functions as a medium of two-way conservation with the dead. He or she is to pose questions to his or her audience on behalf of the dead. She or he is to take what they have said and place it squarely in front of the audience, demonstrating the challenges this information raises to their lives. The Christian philosopher must also defend the teachings of the dead against misunderstanding and misrepresentation, to a degree he or she plays “devils advocate,” so to speak, by taking the side of the dead, for the sake of argument, against the questions and scepticism of his audience to get them to take what is said seriously and to not just flippantly reject it as the ideas of non-modern people.

    At the same time, the Christian philosopher should pose questions to the dead on behalf of the audience; he or she should offer the objections and questions that modern people raise to the dead and ponder their writings, critically evaluating what they have said.

    There is some weakness in this analogy; not all Theologians and Philosophers are dead. Even so, they usually write standing in a tradition or their writings are informed by their own reflections on the past. Hence, it must be stressed that a Christian Philosopher is not the only necromancer that exists. She or he is part of a community of necromancers, thus it is a communal project of discernment. This means that the teacher’s discernment and interpretation of the departed messages are not just based on his or her own insights but the shared insight of the necromancer’s guild. This may involve appropriation of other necromancer’s insights as well as critical commentary and interpretation of other necromancers; the conversation with the dead has horizontal as well as vertical elements.

    Others may object that my account here is too conservative, that it sees Christian philosophy as the inculculation of tradition. This is something of a caricature; what I am talking about is not mere inculculation but also a critical appropriation of tradition. I would add that the negative stance towards tradition expressed is such sentiments is based on certain enlightenment views of epistemology that I think are mistaken. The thinkers of the middle ages were much wiser than we are here in that they did not disparage everything from the past.

    Finally, necromancy is considered, in those societies where it is practiced, as a sacred vocation and I believe this equally applies for the Christian Philosopher and Theologian; we are assisting people to wrestle with and find answers to the deep questions they face about God and this is something that must not be undertaken lightly.

  • Twitter Updates on David Bain Trial?

    MandM have just one thing to say on the David Bain trial:

    Innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

    Do not expect any commentary or speculation on the trial at MandM until the verdict is in.