Author: Madeleine

  • Three Strikes: Proportion and Protection

    The Attorney General has identified an “apparent inconsistency” with the proposed “3 strikes bill” and the New Zealand Bill of Rights. This inconsistency is around whether the punishment inflicted by the 3rd strike would be “disproportionately severe.”

    There have been various reactions to this; the most extreme I have heard came from the bill’s proponent David Garrett “So what? Alter the Bill of Rights Act. We’ve got too hung up on people’s rights.”

    Discussions on talkback and on the blogosphere tend to include the suggestion that criminals don’t deserve the same rights as others while others seem to be getting hung up on the apparent disproportionality the bill might cause in some instances and following Garrett’s line, suggest amending the Bill of Rights which, in turn, causes some to state that a bill that requires you to amend the Bill of Rights is evidence of a flawed bill.

    The clarity many had towards the concept of a 3-strikes bill is now muddied and confused but I don’t think it has to be.

    First, Garrett is wrong. One cannot get “too hung up on human rights”, the first generation type that is, [he has a point on second and third generation rights but then these are not rights and that’s probably a discussion for another post] and they apply equally to all including criminals.

    Second, no Bill of Rights is beyond question. This means that if the Sentencing and Parole Reform Bill does, in fact, require an amendment of the Bill of Rights to be passed this is not, in and of itself, necessarily evidence that it violates human rights. It could be evidence that the Bill of Rights itself is wrong.

    I don’t see why that, in a conflict between a proposed piece of legislation and the Bill of Rights, we should always assume, a priori, that the Bill of Rights is correct. What if a piece of legislation is proposed that conflicts with the Bill of Rights and yet there are good reasons for believing the proposed legislation is just, and in fact, the fault lies with the Bill of Rights?

    Suppose that a Bill of Rights authored in one generation was legally interpreted in such a manner that it permitted slavery. A new piece of legislation was then later introduced banning slavery and this was deemed contrary to the Bill of Rights as it affronts the property rights of slave owners. One response could be that previous legal interpretations of the Bill of Rights were incorrect but it could have actually been the case that there was no interpretation error, that Bill of Rights authors and society at the time it was enacted, had no difficulty with slave ownership.

    In such a situation surely the clash between proposed legislation and the constitution cannot be dismissed simply by appealing to the fact that the new bill might conflict with the Bill of Rights? Perhaps it would be appropriate to question the action the Bill of Rights was protecting.

    That said, I am not convinced the 3-strikes bill does, in fact, conflict so badly with the Bill of Rights that the Bill of Rights would need amending for it to be passed because I don’t think that the proportionality doctrine applies to situations such as the ones identified by the Attorney General in his report on the Sentencing and Parole Reform Bill. I think appropriate force for punishment is being confused with defensive force.

    The proportionality doctrine is linked to retributivist understandings of punishment. A person is punished because he or she deserves it and to a degree no more than he or she deserves. However, there are times when we incarcerate those we know via due process to be innocent yet are a threat to society. For example, those found not guilty by reason of insanity are commonly deprived of their liberty despite the lack of culpability and therefore lack of dessert because of their future threat to others. This is also true of self-defence. We can use lethal force against another even if they lack culpability for their crime providing the threat is sufficiently serious and immediate etc. The force used in self-defence must be proportionate but not to the past actions but rather to the future threat (this is how self-defence differs from retributive punishment). Quarantine laws would be another example, there are others too.

    Clearly, then, there are accepted instances where it would be mistaken to apply the proportionality doctrine. Such cases seem to have common to them the fact that if the person’s liberty were not restrained then a serious and real future threat to life, liberty and the bodily integrity of others from the person being restrained exists.

    In the case of the 3-strikes policy the advocates are not claiming that a person who has committed a third crime deserves a harsher punishment, they are claiming that an habitual offender of particular serious violent crimes has shown him or herself to be a credible threat to others and should be incarcerated for this reason. If they are correct, then the proportionality doctrine does not apply.

  • Madeleine Playing in the Sandpit

    There is a great exchange on KiwiBlog in the comments section here where Madeleine takes to task some of the other commenters on biblical interpretation. Her ability to render the arguments to stupidity with ease and a nice dose of dry humour thrown in is very amusing and worth a look. She has a gift.

    I particularly liked her “Bill killed Jane” analogy and intend to use it in a talk or article sometime though she says I have to footnote her. Madeleine writes:

    Just as, if you picked up a murder mystery, randomly flicked it open and read the line “Bob killed Jane” it would be wrong to conclude bob did in fact kill Jane without reading the whole book and seeing the context the statement occurred in. The statement could have been made in the context of a question: “did Bob kill Jane?” It could have been “I had a nightmare last night that bob killed Jane”, it could have been gossip “I head Mary say that Bob killed Jane.” Of course, it could have in fact been the case that Bob killed Jane or it could be a false conclusion the author wants you to think because in fact Peter killed Jane as revealed in chapter 10 – you don’t know and you shouldn’t assume without looking at the context. You cannot just say “what’s your problem, ‘Bob killed Jane’ is plane English.”

    The context that words in a text occur in is not a fall-back position, it is a legitimate point and a key component of interpreting any language including an English translation of an Aramaic sermon written using Semitic idioms thousands of years ago.

    This one was also good:

    ..your ability to exegete scripture is about as strong as my ability as a non-surgeon to tell you how to conduct a coronary bypass (without googling).

    I could give you a rough idea based on my lay-person’s knowledge of anatomy and of course the number of episodes of Gray’s Anatomy, ER and other medical dramas I watch on TV but I would look like a complete dickhead if I asserted my theory to a cardiothoracic surgeon.

    You have no idea how many times I have felt this way, it is an occupational hazard of being a theologian though I am sure many professionals have similar frustrations when lay people tell them what’s what in their specialty.

  • Christian Blog Rankings Feb 09 – HalfDone

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on HalfDone’s NZ blog stats for February; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for February 09:

    1. NZ Conservative 10
    2. Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (HalfDone) 12
    3. MandM 26
    4. Keeping Stock 28
    5. Samuel Dennis 30
    6. The Briefing Room 35
    7. Being Frank 40
    8. Kiwi Polemicist 51
    9. Put up Thy Sword 55
    10. Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta Blog) 68

    Top 10 Half Done. name of blog Half Done rank

    Of Note:

    • The top 12 made the top 100!
    • The gaps are closing and each month more Christian blogs are emerging and climbing the rankings (don’t forget to make sure you are being ranked by Tumeke as well as HalfDone)
    • Welcome to the top 10 Being Frank!

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse but outside the top 10:

    Contra Celsum 74
    Christian News 97
    The Humanitarian Chronicle 101
    Gavin Knight 105
    Semper Vita 118
    Blessed Economist 129
    Section 59 Blog 162
    Courage to tremble 168
    NZ Debate 171
    Stu’s a-Musings (Definitive) 184
    The Voice of Reason NZ N/A

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that are openly identified as Christian blogs on HalfDone’s and Tumeke’s rankings. If you think your blog should be on the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blogs rankings get on Tumeke’s rankings and ask Tim to ensure your blog description includes something identifiably Christian. More here.

    Once Tumeke’s February stats are out we will compare and average the two sets of results and publish the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for February 09.

    Consider linking to the NZ Christian Blog rankings to help people find quality Christian blogs.

  • The Name Game

    It’s meme time (again). This time it’s a name game – it’s kinda fun.

    1. YOUR REAL NAME:

    Madeleine Flannagan

    2. WITNESS PROTECTION NAME: (mother’s middle name and the name of the person who tagged you)

    Caroline Scalia

    3. NASCAR NAME: (first name of your mother’s dad, father’s dad)

    Dennis Mark

    4. STAR WARS NAME: (the first 3 letters of your last name, first 2 letters of your first name)

    Flama

    5. DETECTIVE NAME: (favorite color, favorite animal)

    Red Horse

    6. SOAP OPERA NAME: (middle name, town where you were born)

    Jane Auckland

    7. SUPERHERO NAME: (2nd fav color, fav drink, add “THE” to the beginning)

    The Black Latte

    8. FLY NAME: (first 2 letters of 1st name, last 2 letters of your last name)

    Maan

    9. GAMER NAME: (1st pet’s name, street you grew up on)

    Paddlesa Marina

    10. YOUR GANGSTA NAME: (first 3 letters of last name plus “izzle”)

    Flaizzle

    11. YOUR EMO NAME: (black, the name of one of your pets, then add any word that means “crying” to the end)

    Black Noise Weeping

    12. ROMANCE NOVELIST PSEUDONYM: (name of your fav perfume/cologne, fav candy)

    Lacroix Glow Hearts

    13. INDIAN NAME: (what is the wind doing?+ what time of day is it?)

    Still Evening

    14. NAME OF THE BLOG THAT TAGGED YOU (don’t forget the link luv)

    Scalia

    15. NAMES OF 5 BLOGGERS YOU TAG (pick people you haven’t picked for any meme before and tag them)

    Whale Oil Beef Hooked
    No Minister
    Kiwipolitico
    MacDoctor Moments
    Oswald Bastable’s Ranting

    You can play in the comments section.

  • Invitation to an MandM Event

    You are invited to the next MandM speaking engagement:

    Apologetics: Answering Objections to the Christian Faith

    Dr Matthew Flannagan BSocSci, MSocSci (Hons), PhD

    When: Sunday 8 March
    Time: 6.30 pm
    Where:
    Massey Presbyterian Church – 510 Don Bucks Rd, Massey, West Auckland
    Cost: Free
    Event Format: Presentation followed by Q&A

    In this presentation, Dr Flannagan will speak on the nature of Apologetics and will examine some common objections to the faith such as: Why does God allow evil? Isn’t it arrogant to believe your religion is the only true one? Isn’t faith in God irrational?

    Dr Flannagan is an adjunct lecturer in Philosophy for Laidlaw College, he works with Thinking Matters and writes for the MandM blog.

    Who is Welcome?
    It’s open to Christian and non-Christian alike; anyone interested in apologetics, theology and Christian philosophy. It is lay-person friendly, you won’t need a philosophy or a theology degree to be able to follow the talk.

    RELATED POST: The Point of Intellectual Engagement: Why Thinking Matters

  • Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs – January 09

    The official MandM Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs for January 09 (public discourse) are ranked by identifying Christian blogs then comparing Half Done’s January 09 stats with Tumeke’s January 09 stats and averaging them to obtain their overall January 09 ranking.

    Rank. [previous top 10 rank] Blog Average (Half Done Tumeke)

      1. [1.] NZ Conservative 17 (7 27 )
      2. [2.] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later 18.5 (14 23)
      3. [N] Keeping Stock 29 (23 35)
      4. [3.] The Briefing Room 29.5 (27 32)
      5. [4.] MandM 39.5 (25 54)
      6. [N] The Humanitarian Chronicle 58 ( – 58)
      7. [8.] Samuel Dennis 69 (51 129)
      8. [9.] Contra Celsum 73.5 (72 75)
      9. [5.] Kiwi Polemicist 76.5 (89 64)
      10. [7.] Put up Thy Sword 82 (52 112)

    Other Christian blogs featuring in the top 200 NZ blogs on public discourse for January 09:

    [6.] Say Hello to my Little Friend 82.5 (98 67)
    [10.] Star Studded Super Step 93 ( – 93)
    Blessed Economist 104.5 (127 82)
    Gavin Knight 112 (104 120)
    Section 59 Blog 157.5 (142 173)
    Definitive 173 (175 171)
    NZ Debate 174.5 (157 192)
    Backchat Cafe 187 ( – 187)
    The Voice of Reason NZ 200 ( – 200)

    Note: This list does not include Christians who blog but whose blogs are not identifiably Christian and is based on Tumeke’s classification methods.

    If you think your blog should be on the rankings click here.

  • Christian Blog Rankings for Jan 09 – Tumeke

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on Tumeke’s NZ blog stats for January; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for January 09:

    1. Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (HalfDone) 23
    2. NZ Conservative 27
    3. The Briefing Room 32
    4. Keeping Stock 35
    5. MandM 54
    6. The Humanitarian Chronicle 58
    7. Kiwi Polemicist 64
    8. Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta Blog) 67
    9. Contra Celsum 75
    10. Blessed Economist 82

    Top 10 Tumeke. name of blog Tumeke rank

    Of Note:

    • A change in the number 1 spot – well done Scrubbone!
    • All top 10 are within the top 100.
    • Welcome to the top 10 The Humanitarian Chronicle and Blessed Economist.

    Other Christian blogs making the top 200 NZ blogs on Public Discourse but outside the top 10:

    Samuel Dennis 88
    Star Studded Super Step 93
    Put up Thy Sword 112
    Gavin Knight 120
    Stu’s a-Musings (Definitive) 171
    Section 59 Blog 173
    Backchat Cafe 187
    NZ Debate 192
    The Voice of Reason NZ 200

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s rankings. If you think your blog should be on the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blogs rankings contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings. More here.

    Now that Tumeke’s January stats are out we will compare them with HalfDone’s and average the two sets of results and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for Janurary 09.