Author: Madeleine

  • They Just Want Your Money (and your Voice)

    My post about student association membership reminded me that just yesterday I stumbled accross this article that I wrote for Critic’s diatribe column when we were at Otago.

    Despite the fact that OUSA membership has probably increased since we were there, that NZUSA’s annual budget is now almost certainly much more than the figure I quoted below and these days the student associations tend to promote Green party policy more than the Alliance’s it is still very applicable so I have reproduced my article here.

    They Just Want Your Money

    Free education will never exist.

    Even if the government funded 100% of tertiary study costs, students would still have to pay to get an education – even if it were a fact that ‘government money’ grew on trees.

    Why? Because student association membership fees are compulsory.

    Want a tertiary education? Then you have to join the student association. No choice, no argument; if you want to get your grades then cough up the best part of $100 to OUSA.

    Apart from being a violation of the Bill of Rights – s17: “everyone has the right to freedom of association” – it smacks of hypocrisy.

    The loudest campaigners for free education, the advocates for hard-up students, are funding their campaigns, national and international flights, their catered conferences, the very handcuffs they chain themselves to government architecture with, with a total budget estimated to be around $18 million annually.

    This income is sourced entirely from the pockets of the very people they claim should not have to pay a single cent to get an education.

    So long as student association membership remains compulsory, free education can never exist.

    Effectively, NZUSA’s $400,000 annual budget – also taken entirely from students – is a total waste of money. And for what? To tell us to vote Alliance. Who? Over 90% of us did not vote for free education last election, demonstrating most of us think we should pay something substantial towards our education.

    OUSA use our money and voice for things political, controversial, environmental and occasionally student related. Maybe I would mind compulsion less if they steered clear of the political, did not comment on controversial topics, that those they allegedly represent have a diversity of views on, and provided good services. However, even if they did all this, their compulsory subscription would still be immoral.

    It’s that pesky Bill of Rights again. OUSA could be the most wonderful, student advocate and service provider in the country but they would still have no right to hold my grades to ransom unless I forked out and joined them. No more right to do so than any workers’ union has a right to garnish pay-packets, a church to forcibly extract an offering, the Salvation Army to make a benefit deduction.

    Student associations are kidding themselves if they think they are any better than any of these organisations – which, incidentally, all manage to stay afloat, be effective at what they do and who they serve by being voluntary. The only type of association that has anything to fear by giving its members a choice to join is one that knows it’s so irrelevant, unaccountable, ineffective and useless that no-one will choose to join it unless they are made to. Which begs the question; why should they be able to force you to prop it up if it is so useless? You’d join if it were good.

    Voluntary membership fosters accountability, relevance and effectiveness, because if a union is not these things it will go under. Having cash flow contingent on performance is incentive, having thousands of cash cows you can simply burden further if you blow the budget on, say, ummm, a book store, gives you no incentive to perform relevantly at all. It leaves members totally reliant on the ethics of the student politicians (did I just use ethics and politicians in the same sentence?).

    But, we’re told, students can conscientiously object (CO) so it’s not really compulsory, it’s not really a violation of your right to freedom of association. Really? Putting aside the fact that you have to first join or risk late fees and grades being withheld before you can even think about CO-ing, you have to apply to the student union for permission to be exempt from membership. If your evidence is not compelling, they don’t have to grant you a CO. Even if successful, they get to choose which charity to donate your $100 to; you don’t get it back.

    I see. I don’t have to associate with anyone as long as I first associate with the student union so I can disassociate with them, assuming they let me, and then make a donation to an ‘appropriate’ charity of their choosing?

    It’d make a good Tui billboard: “Student unions don’t violate civil rights. Yeah, right.”

    They want you to believe a lie that voluntary membership is some kind of right wing conspiracy, championed by white middle class male members of ACT, when in fact outside of tertiary institutions it’s normal.

    Student politicians want your money, they want to illegitimately use your voice to push their personal agendas – the ones they think you should hold. They want you to shut up, roll over and take it. The question is, will you?

  • How to Put Twitter Feeds Into Blogger

    We have just discovered Twitter. Twitter is the new thing that everyone online seems to be getting into. Its heaps of fun, free to sign up and you can communicate with a lot of people with very little effort which is always attractive with our busy lives. You can get your Twitter updates through your mobile phone and you can install a live feed in your Blogger platform very easily.

    Whenever I want to customize a Blogspot  Blog I always start with Amanda Fazani’s Blogger Buster as her instructions are very clear and simple and you don’t need a lot of tech knowledge to follow them. Amanda has written a Twitter Widget that self installs your Twitter updates into your blog – its really easy and customizable!

    Create a Twitter account

    Open this page on Blogger Buster

    Scroll about halfway down the page to the heading “Add a Twitter Widget using this Widget Installer”

    Enter your Twitter user name into the “Create Your Stylized Twitter Widget” box.

    Click “Customize”

    Click “Add to Blog”

    Once it has been added to your blog you can drag it where you want it from within the Layout Page Elements area. Remember to save.

    If you want to add a link such as “Follow Me on Twitter” you can just open it by clicking on edit, and then just copy and paste the following at the bottom of the text code:

    [a href=http://twitter.com/USERNAME” target=”0″>Follow Me on Twitter

    Replace]

    USERNAME with your Twitter user name.

    Change the [] brackets on each end to < > (respectively).

    Then save.

    If you want to remove the picture that comes with the widget then open the widget as above and delete the following from the code:

    style=”background: url(http://bloggerbuster.com/images/twitter-icon.gif)

    top left no-repeat;

    Then click save. Happy Twittering and don’t forget to sign up and follow MandM!

    Cross Posted at Coping in a Technological World

  • My Conscience Cannot be Bought with a Jelly-Shot

    On Monday a new University year begins for thousands of New Zealand students. If you are a student, you probably don’t even realise that when you paid your fees to enrol at University, most of you joined a political organisation; a political organisation with strident viewpoints on all sorts of controversial hot potatoes that speaks out publicly, lobby’s NZ and international governments and claims you share its views.

    I am talking about your campus student association and the fact that in New Zealand membership of it at most universities is compulsory.

    That “free” alcohol available during Orientation week, those free condoms and dental dams, that gay pride week, the feminist meetings promoting abortion, the of trashing Christianity, the trespassing and occupying of buildings, the protests and demands and all those posters and press releases that sound suspiciously like they were written by Green and Labour party members are all supported, paid for and made on behalf of you.

    At Auckland University yesterday, whilst on a campus tour, I was urged to go and join the Auckland University Students Association (AUSA). (AUSA is the only university student association in New Zealand for which membership is voluntary as students there managed to navigate the impossibly difficult method available at law to get rid of forced subscription. However, funding is not voluntary; AUSA’s funding is compulsory.)

    The enthusiastic recruiter told me and the group I was with that we should join because “you’ll get a free jelly-shot and it will cost you nothing.” He looked really confused when I was clearly not tempted and seemed very unimpressed when I pointed out to the group that while they wouldn’t have to hand over any cash because they had already paid, their membership enabled AUSA to ‘legitimately’ claim to speak on their behalf on any polarising political and ethical issue they choose to, such as, abortion, euthanasia, terrorism, war, environmentalism, the status of[insert terrorist/communist/liberation organisation], etc giving the false impression to the media and society that all students share their controversial viewpoint; the power they wield and its influence on society is staggering. Your membership also ensures that the University will continue to force all students to fund them if it perceived that AUSA had wide student support. The University is aware of how apathetic students are so it counts support as membership. (The recruiter was even more unimpressed when every member of the group, including those that had begun to eagerly step towards the sign-up table all immediately saw my point and refused to sign up.)

    Compulsory membership and compulsory funding of student associations is another issue that this government needs to address. It is not acceptable that these organisations can falsely claim legitimacy on behalf of all students, speak on their behalf on issues that have nothing to do with education that the rest of society is split on and violate the consciences of many they ‘represent.’ When their policies include campaigns to actively educate the student body that viewpoint X is right/wrong they are forcing some students to fund and endorse campaigns against their own beliefs.

    Compulsory membership and funding of political organisations, regardless of how wonderful some of their non-political services might be, is a violation of freedom of conscience. Forced membership of a political organisation is a violation of freedom of association; both are rights protected under both New Zealand and international human rights legislation yet violated by the New Zealand government to this day.

  • Blackout Victory: s92a Stalled

    The internet blackout is at an end and the government has responded; s92a of the Copyright Act has been officially stalled and looks rather doomed. The Herald reports:

    Section 92a was to have come into force this weekend, but Mr Key said it would be delayed a month while ISPs and copyright holders continued efforts to work out a voluntary agreement on how it would be enforced.

    He said if they could not agree, the clause would be suspended.

    If they did reach an agreement, it would be reviewed in six months.

    So in other words, as written, it’s dead. Yay.

  • The Blogosphere Blacks Out

    Tumeke report that most of the NZ blogosphere has gotten behind the blackout, blacking out chunks of their pages and/or running banners highlighting the campaign. Tim made this mosaic showing the impact on the front pages of NZ’s top 50 or so blogs – you can see MandM towards the bottom right corner.
    The government really has to act on this one; it is not everyday you see so many people, commonly at odds with each other, representing pretty much the entire political spectrum, agreeing on one issue. I mean, when Not PC sings the same tune as The Standard surely the resulting blogosphere shockwave has to be able to reach the Beehive?

  • A Fairly Full Plate

    It has been for a very busy year for me so far.

    In January, I gave a lecture on Locke, Hume and Descartes to Maxim Institute’s interns. I also preached two sermons, one at Massey Presbyterian Church, the other at Riverhead Presbytarian Church.

    I have been asked to teach Critical Thinking to 11-16 year old members of a local home-schoolers group for the next couple of weeks which will help me try out some of the Critical Thinking course I have been writing for Thinking Matters.

    I have been approached by Massey Presbyterian Church to talk on Apologetics in early March.

    Also in March, as part of my Teaching Diploma, I am going on practicum at St Peters College where I will be working in their Religious Studies Department for around eight weeks. Almost immediately after this, I will be teaching a three-week block course in Philosophy at Laidlaw College.

    I was informed by The Royal Institute of Philosophy that my article “Abortion and Capital Punishment,” has been published in Think, which is a philosophical journal for lay people.

    The editorial board of Colloquium: The Australian and New Zealand Theological Review have informed me my article, “The Premature Dismissal of Voluntarism,” will be published later this year.

    Just yesterday, I just received word from the Editor of Ethics and Medicine that my article “Boonin on the Sentience Criteria” will be published in Ethics & Medicine: An International Journal of Bioethics in their Summer 09 edition.

    In addition to this, I have been informed that the proceedings from a conference on C S Lewis, at which I spoke last year, are being considered for publication so I may need to format my talk into publishable form.

    In the last week Thinking Matters have asked me to write an article on Religion and Science for the next edition of their journal and I have to chase up what is happening/has happened with the Journal of Libertarian Studies who appear to have published my article “Peron on Religion and Public Life” but the link for it does not work and they have not communicated anything for ages.

    Madeleine and I are also working with Thinking Matters and local Christian Apologists to look at setting up a regular apologetics group in Auckland and are working on organising an Apologetics conference.

    We both have a small handful of speaking engagements, debates and seminars for various campus groups and community organisations around the country to prepare for as well, as well as some research projects to complete, studies to prepare for our bible study group and, of course, blogging, ongoing publication efforts and employment applications – all of this is in addition to our studies and parenting responsibilities.

    All we need now is for one of these projects to turn into full-time, permanent, paid employment and we will be set!

    Having said that, we still have a lot of space on our calendar so if you think of us…