Author: Madeleine

  • Thoughts on Roast Guinea Pigs and Balancing Freedoms

    I have no issue with hunting those species of whale and dolphin that are not endangered for meat. I love horses but I have managed to get past the fact that some people eat them, I wouldn’t, but hey we eat cows and meat is meat. If you are not a vegetarian then eating one animal is no different to eating another animal getting hung up on the aesthetics of some animals is irrational.

    However, I had my position somewhat challenged today.

    My 8 year old daughter has for a long time wanted a pet guinea pig. As our rabbit died of old age recently we had an empty cage, so I took her to the pet shop a couple of weeks ago and we bought two guinea pigs “Abe” and “Pamarello.” Ever since, she dotes and and delights on the guinea pigs and when she is not feeding them treats and changing their water she is drawing pictures and writing stories about them. Today she got on Google images and typed in “guinea pigs” so she could create a file of guinea pig pictures.

    We have google set to “strict safe search” and we run Blue Coat K9 Web Protection. I knew it wasn’t fool proof but to date nothing “bad” has gotten through, if anything it is ridiculously over-sensitive and blocks sites and images we have no issue with. Anyway, you have probably worked out where this is leading, check out the first pic that came up on her search – roasted guinea pig complete with two roast spuds.

    guinea pig

    Needless to say you can imagine her reaction. Matt found her crying and upset. She was worried her guinea pigs were not ok, she was greatly disturbed and took some calming down.

    When I came home from work and heard about this all my sentiments about meat being meat went out the window. Parental protection kicked in to full mode. I too became angry that people ate guinea pigs and that they would put pictures like that on the net and that our filters had failed to screen that picture out and that we had been in the practice of allowing our kids to google pictures.

    As I have thought about it since I have considered changing the passwords so that our kids can only run google image searchs with us present but then that wouldn’t have changed anything in this instance as we probably would have run the search with her next to us and it was the first image.

    My thoughts went on to the fact that the person who posted that picture would probably speak to their freedom to put pictures on their site and my objection to it being unjustified on the basis of their right to free speech. The old slogan, ‘don’t like it? don’t look’ came to mind.

    But I couldn’t get past the fact that there was still something wrong here. We have done what we can to ensure our kids are not exposed to things they are not ready to handle (obviously there comes an age where children have to understand that people eat animals that are the same species as their pets) yet this image came into our home.

    So what is the solution? Censorship of the offending site? Changing passwords? Using the off switch? I am not happy with any of those. As a libertarian, I am uncomfortable with censorship. Further, I want my kids to learn how to use a computer and how to find information on topics they are interested in. However, as a parent I want to ensure they are protected.

    Putting aside the legal questions, this incident does highlight the moral point, which is sometimes articulated poorly with slogans such as “with freedom of speech comes responsibility”. The point is that just as I must respect the fact that other people have a right to express their opinion, I too have a right to not listen if I do not wish to and others need to respect that. If I decide I do not want to hear something, I shouldn’t be forced to extremes to have that right respected, especially if they do not have to run to extremes to exercise their right. In this instance I had said no on behalf of my daughter and my anger is about the fact that my choice to not have my sensitive, gentle, animal-loving 8 year old exposed to something upsetting was not respected.

    Of course the owner of the offending site never envisaged upsetting my daughter and is not culpable for what happened but rights can be inadvertently and non-culpably violated (the insanity defence is an example). There really isn’t a good solution to the problem of the clash between the freedom to speak and the freedom to not hear – I have no idea how to solve it without raising other problems – but the problem does exist and this of course is one of the places I part ways with (big L) Libertarians.

  • Electoral Finance Act Threatens Privacy and Family Home

    Imagine coming home to this on your lawn: it’s 1000 knives!

    No this isn’t something from the “only in America” files it is Bob McCoskrie’s front lawn covered in knives, complete with threatening note related to Bob’s political activities! How did they get his address? Compliments of the Electoral Finance Act; law abiding critics of the govt have to give their addresses, anonymous thugs then take advantage and attack.

    When we were prominent in student politics we had to have unlisted addresses and scrape together funds to pay for PO Boxes after Madeleine received a newspaper cut-out message threatening her to shut up or else for speaking up for freedom of association. But thanks to Labour, gone is the luxury of keeping your home safe if you want to speak up politically.

    We have these strict privacy laws, so strict we can’t even get each other’s details from government departments despite the fact we are married, but the minute you want to criticise the government you have to give your details out to the whole world!

    Bob sent us the following email outlining an attack on his home:

    Reality of Battle Hits Home

    Events over the past weekend have reminded me of just how important it is to speak up on family issues.

    Last Saturday night, four women dressed in black came to our family home in South Auckland and placed almost 1,000 plastic knives into our front lawn. They also taped an intimidating note on our front door relating to the knives (anonymous of course!).

    I am very thankful that my family and I were in Tauranga over the weekend and my children didn’t stumble across the display. The police have taken away evidence and are testing for fingerprints etc. and our neighbours kindly helped removed the offending items. My neighbours are wondering what sort of friends I have!!

    Unfortunately, under the Electoral Finance Act, any material put out by Family First has to have an ‘Authorisation Statement’ which contains the residential address of the person authorising the material. Therefore, because of our VALUE YOUR VOTE campaign, it is fairly easy to figure out where we live.

    BUT

    … the need to publish important information relating to these family issues and the upcoming General Election is too important to stay silent on. (We are aware of other groups who have had second thoughts on speaking up because of this requirement.)

    I knew that ’speaking out’ would draw criticism and labelling (and we have been certainly called a number of ‘colourful’ terms!) rather than debating the actual issues being raised – but I always hoped that the debate wouldn’t hit home as it has.THE BOTTOM LINE IS THIS-we will not be silenced.

    Whenever we speak up on issues like marriage, the breakdown of family, the anti-smacking law and the role of parents, the pornography industry and public nudity, prostitution, pro-life issues including abortion and euthanasia, and many other topics that families are concerned about, we are going to make enemies . I’m the first to admit that we don’t always get it right, but we cannot afford towalk away from the opportunity. We have to speak up from a family perspective on these crucial issues.

    What keeps us going is knowing that there are many many of you who are standing with us on these issues.

    Events like this remind me of how much we value your support, words of encouragement (and correction!), financial and moral support, and prayers. (And I would especially ask at this time that you would pray for my family’ protection.)

    William Booth – founder of the Salvation Army – said “50 years hence it will matter very little indeed how these people treated us. It will matter a great deal how we dealt with the work of God.”

    Once again, thanks for standing with us.

    It is your support and encouragement that keeps us going!

    Now we don’t agree with everything Bob stands for but we do agree with a lot and we certainly admire and respect Bob for standing for what he believes in and we absolutely think he should be able to do that without telling the whole world where he and his family live and without being subject to attacks on his home and personal threats.

    Doesn’t he rock though? He and his family are subjected to this and the first sentence he writes speaks of his increased resolve continue speaking out.

    UPDATE – Another email from Bob:

    Another anonymous note..

    This time an apology !

    We have just received this note – from ‘anonymous’.

    I see you didn’t take our little prank as it was intended, just as a little
    bit of harmless fun, just some plastic and spare time, I hope you could see the funny side of it… Never-the-less were truly sorry if this has in
    anyway, offended or scared you emotionally physically or mentally… Were Sorry, We’re very thankful that this seems to be a very badly thought out prank – especially in the light of all the concerns about knife attacks recently.

    Thank you to the hundreds of you who emailed words of encouragement . I t has been very humbling to know the level of support for Family First .

    Fortunately we can smile at this one. But we do ask for your continued prayer as we speak out on sometimes controversial issues affecting families.

    UPDATE: Media are picking up the story everywhere:

    Herald
    DominionPost
    ODT
    Stuff
    Nine News
    Yahoo
    Info News
    AngloINFO Singapore have the unfortunate title: “Knives Stabbed into Family First Leader”

  • Spot the Difference

    This is a photo of me taken last weekend on my daughter’s cell phone (not the best photo of me but our camera is broken):

    This is a photo of my 16 year old daughter:

    This is a photo of me with my 16 year old daughter, also taken last weekend:Can you spot the difference?

    Why am I posting these and asking this? Because of this comment here:

    “This is a great pic as it is a reminder of you on more than one level. Big piles of chocolate chip biscuits are a good reminder that the hot photos of Madeleine on this blog are probably photos of her daughter she pretends are photos of her because she is such a big fattie (and now a big fat liar too about what she looks like).Come on Maddy show us a picture of what you really look like. But then of course no one would want to read your blog because looking at you would make them sick.

    Now this is kinda funny, kind flattering and kinda strange – whilst its nice at age 35 to get mistaken for your 16 year old daughter, what can I say its a combination of my Anew Skincare regime and my Knapp genes, but being accused of impersonating her because I am in reality ugly and fat is ridiculous!

    Whilst my daughter wrote a response, I had intended to just ignore this post but recent events on Kiwiblog have led me to change my mind. In the comments section I find myself being slammed for being fat, loving burgers and biscuits and telling porkies about what I really look like because I wrote a comment critical of the current government’s welfare programme for workers a.k.a Working for Families.

    James (207) Says: September 30th, 2008 at 7:33 pm
    We all know how much Maddy loves her burgers and chocolate biccies.
    Did you see on her blog she has been outed for using her daughter to impersonate herself?”
    Well theres a suprise….Mad woman Flanagan telling porkies….golly! Next it will be claims of sexual harrassment….oh wait…

    The photos of me on this blog are of me. Ask the bloggers I have been face to face with in recent months if my photos are lying about what I really look like – David Farrar, Dave Crampton, Ian Wishart, A. J. Chesswas, Andy Moore, Glenn Peoples, Jason Kumar to name a few. Finally if that does not convince you check out the front cover of the current Auckland University In House Short Courses brochure or ask Dr William Lane Craig who introduced me to the crowd at Auckland University debate on Is God a Delusion – watch the video, the introduction happens literally minutes into the debate, you can see me right up the front – note the date.

    Overall I suppose all of this is a complement as if the best criticism someone can level at me is that I am fat and ugly then that is a real complement to my mind and it really speaks to the reasoning ability of my critics. This is normally a tactic of the left but the James quoted above is an apologist of Jim Peron – sadly he is a member of the right.

    It also speaks to their observation skills, this photo was taken earlier this year and I am sorry if this sounds vain but I am not fat and I am not ugly and as my daughter said, where are the photos of those making the comments?

    The only people telling porkies are my critics. Now we have settled that can we get over what I look like and get back to real issues?

  • The End of Musical Chairs: The Pervasiveness of Political Correctness

    Alistair told me I had to write this so its all his fault!

    Our 7 year old son Noah has a ‘girlfriend’ who he ‘is going to marry one day.’ His ‘girlfriend’ also turned 7 yesterday and had a party. His ‘girlfriend’s’ mum went to a heap of trouble to decorate the house, make the food and plan all sorts of fun activities to make sure their daughter and all her little friends had heaps of fun. She did way more games than I do, I draw the line at decorating the cake and making just one pass-the-parcel (which I make my teenagers wrap and supervise the execution of).

    Back when I was a child (did I really just use that sentence?) pass the parcel was completely random; some kids got to remove 3 layers and other kids missed out completely. The excitement and anticipation when the music stopped was all centred on getting to be the person who got to take the wrapper off and hoping you got to take the wrapper off on the very last layer. If you sulked because you missed out, you were a poor loser and got a lecture from your parents about good sportsmanship. These days, in our PC culture, for the kids its all about getting the lollipop or other goodie taped to each layer and every parent I know – including me (well my teenagers) – ‘cheats’ and makes sure that every kid gets a turn taking off a layer before letting the game run randomly.

    The party progressed to musical chairs. My kids have not really played it that much (as I am slack, see above) but they, along with the others, picked up the rules and with big smiles of anticipation got ready to play.

    Now unlike pass the parcel, musical chairs does not lend itself so well to PC-ising.

    The music stopped, they all scrambled for chairs, one kid missed out, got eliminated from the game and promptly began crying. There were cries of “Oh… poor thing… its just a practice run” and the rules were re-explained and the heat was run again. A different kid missed out this time and promptly began crying. The next round was played and each chair was removed every kid was reduced to tears when they lost, even my children!

    I know the families that were present quite well and I know that all of them despise the PC culture and have tried to raise their kids in a manner counter to it, us included, yet seeing all of our kids fall apart because they lost really gave us pause. The host parents were horrified that all the guest were in tears (barring the kid who won), they had been trying to make the party fun for everyone afterall. They categorically stated they would never play musical chairs at their parties again and apologised to the parents who by then all had at least one crying child on their laps.

    The episode was really disturbing. We all began questioning how the children of today’s culture are going to cope with real loss in life and knocks to their confidence. I wondered what it would mean for their ability to persevere, to believe in themselves when life sent them knocks, Alistair wondered about the impact long term on suicide rates – how will teenagers cope if parents shield them from ‘losing’ or always try to correct situations where their child ‘misses’ out? Obviously the musical chairs is just a symptom and not the cause but I think it made us see that despite our efforts to the contrary we are raising a generation of kids whose definition of ‘fairness’ and ‘equality’ is something quite different from what it should be.

    Last night I really felt for the host parents’ embarassment, completely empathised with it and mentally congratulated myself on my slackness of never having more than one party game and that game never being musical chairs! However, on reflection I have decided I owe it to my kids to add musical chairs to my party-games repertoire and I am going to stop allowing my teenagers to ‘cheat’ at pass the parcel – I might even take the lollipops off the wrappers too!

  • Happy Birthday Glenn

    I saw this birthday video a few months back and thought of Glenn and as today is Glenn’s birthday I just had to post it.

    Happy Birthday Glenn!

  • Subway and MandM

    Hey! Andy just sent me this pic he snapped at Subway that made him think of us.

  • On the Absence of Matt

    The more observant among you will have noticed that Matt has not written a blog entry for a while. It is not for lack of want but more for being completely inundated of late:

    • His teaching course load this semester is heavier.
    • His non-academic job continues to suck up his time and its hours limit the time he can stay up til.
    • He still is attending all my law lectures and tutorials as my pain levels are not up to attending in person this semester as hoped.
    • My pain levels and surgury news and the impact they have made have sucked up his energy and time.
    • Last week he had a guest lecture to prepare and give.
    • Soon he has a seminar in Tauranga to prepare and give.
    • He is working on a new and exciting project which hopefully will see him dump his non-academic job.
    • Then several of the usual distractions of life have managed to crop up too on top of a rather busy social calendar.

    So life is good and full and interesting for Matt, the future is looking bright, but blogging has taken a back seat!

    He hopes to have a little more time for it soon.