Author: Madeleine

  • Cultural Confusion and Ethical Relativism – Invitation to a Thinking Matters Event

    Taken from Thinking Matters – Events & Announcements:

    Cultural Confusion and Ethical Relativism

    Dr Matthew Flannagan PhD, MSocSci, BSocSci

    When: Tuesday 2nd September
    Time: 7 – 9pm
    Where: Bethlehem Community Church Center – 183 Moffat Rd, Bethlehem, Tauranga
    Cost: Free
    Event Format: Live Presentation followed by Q&A and discussions

    Christian moral obligations are often seen as bigoted and intolerant. It is widely held that it’s wrong to impose “private moral perspectives” on to others. In this talk Matthew will critically examine the arguments for relativism and look at some of its implications. He will argue that popular moral relativism is confused and incoherent, and that Christians should not be intimidated by it.

    Dr Flannagan currently teaches part time at Laidlaw College. He holds a Masters degree in Philosophy from the University of Waikato and a PhD in Theology from the University of Otago. His research interests are Ethics, Apologetics, and Philosophical Theology.

    Thinking Matters
    Thinking Matters is an inter-denominational group where you can come to analyse and discuss some of the deeper issues of the Christian faith in the areas of Philosophy, Science and Apologetics (see definitions here).

    The purpose is to make Christian truth claims more relevant to an increasingly sceptical and secular culture, showing the reasons why we believe what we believe and providing answers that simply make sense.

    More on Thinking Matters Tauranga

    Who is Welcome?
    It’s open to Christian and Non-Christian alike – anyone who is seeking the truth in philosophy, science and scripture. You don’t need a philosophy or a theology degree to be able to understand the speakers.

    More Thinking Matters Tauranga Events
    More Thinking Matters Auckland Events

  • Caller of the Week – Sexual Preference on Census Form

    When I was at work last week one of my colleagues said he thought he had heard me on the radio one Friday afternoon but he wasn’t sure if it was me. I had phoned into Newstalk ZB during the last week of the school holidays but it wasn’t a Friday, so we sort of laughed that someone else sounded like me and then he said that the person he had heard had won caller of the week – so then I knew it couldn’t have been me!

    Over the weekend my family was over and my brother in law was hassling me about my call to the radio. He and my sister are somewhat left of centre (as in, Labour are too right wing) so we often good naturedly disagree on things and sure enough he was not happy with aspects of my call. He went on to offer a critique and I offered a defence, we went back and forward and then he finished with “well anyway I was most peeved to have to listen to your call twice, the first time when you rang in was bad enough but when you won caller of the week and the announcer thought you were so onto it I got really mad because you were wrong!” He then asked where the wine from Landmark Estate was anyway and hassled me for serving substandard wine. It then dawned on me that perhaps I had been caller of the week after all.

    Despite having a blog and being rather into political debates I do not frequent talk back shows. We were driving home from Mt Albert pools and I heard the announcer say that the government were considering adding a question on sexual preference to the census form and listeners were invited to call in with their thoughts. On a whim I phoned the station, Matt was driving so what the hey!

    I commented on the methodological flaws of the government gathering this data, citing Kinsey’s report which utilised analogous methodology. The gist went basically that you are unlikely to obtain reliable results as the sort of people who volunteer to answer questions on their sexual preferences tend to be the sort of people whose sexual preferences are more ‘out there,’ those who are very private about their sexual preferences tend to be more conservative and are less likely to volunteer that sort of info. Kinsey’s study invited people to participate and as such he found there to be a much higher number of more ‘out there’ sexual practices than other studies using better methodology which led to random samples. I concluded by asking why the government felt they had a place in our bedrooms anyway? I speculated that the purpose behind the proposed move was so they could rubber stamp their social agenda and stated that they should stick to law, order and defence.

    My brother in law’s issue was that on the radio I stated that Kinsey invited people to call in and in actual fact Kinsey’s study was not a phone survey, the interviews were done face to face. My brother in law was quite right to pull me up on this factual error but he was wrong to suggest that my criticisms failed because of it. Kinsey interviewed a disproportionately high number of criminals, particularly sex offenders, Laumann writes in The Social Organisation of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States (Chicago University Press, 1994):

    Kinsey roamed far and wide in selecting his subjects … Kinsey also purposefully recruited subjects for his research from homosexual friendship and acquaintance networks in big cities.

    Anyway, this led me to email Newstalk ZB and ask if indeed I was the caller of the week. I will update with their reply.

    UPDATE: Newstalk ZB have confirmed I was caller of the week. Still waiting to hear if I get the Landmark Estate wine prize given I did not call in when it was announced.

    UPDATE: A knock at the door yesterday saw the arrival of my prize along with this letter:

    Dear Madeleine,
    Congratulations
    Newstalk ZB – Caller of the Week
    2 Bottles of wine – just for you.

    One bottle of Chardonnay one bottle of Sauvignon Blanc from Landmark Estate Wines. Matt and I polished off the Chardonnay last night, very nice – not remotely vinegary like some chardonnays. The Sauv is on hold til Sunday night – I must see if the promised repairs to my cupboard doors eventuates – otherwise my brother in law just gets a toast!

  • Surgery – Car Accident Update

    I got my MRI results on Tuesday. They show damage to two discs, both are compressed. One is more compressed than the other, the other is protruding and pushing on a nerve, hence all the pain.

    I have two choices. Do nothing and see if it fixes itself (its been almost 5 months). Have surgery to remove the damaged discs and replace them with artificial ones.

    There is no choice really. I cannot stay on the drugs I am on for much longer. My quality of life is awful, everything I do is limited by “I can’ts” because of the injury. If it was going to fix itself surely it would have at least improved by now. On the other hand, surgery means I will be out of pain and will be able to do anything pretty much (including equestrian eventing eventually – though apparently I can’t consider being a front-row forward).

    Surgery on my neck is frightening. It will leave a scar on the front of my neck and as good as the results will be I will never quite be as good as I was before.

    I have three weeks to ‘decide.’ I have already decided but I am going to seek a second opinion just to be sure.

  • Next time you want to tape a politician…

    I will resist the urge the comment on the content of the recent taped conversations, well I might say *yawn* what political party does not contain MP’s that have ideas about where they would like their party to head in the future, in fact to swipe my 16 year old’s comments, there would be something wrong with an MP who didn’t have such opinions. I want to briefly comment on the legality of taping politicians at political conventions – well taping conversations in general.

    As you know I am currently completing a bachelor of law so I have some knowledge of how to find out what is legal and what is not and as it happens I have looked into this particular subject in some detail as, umm, lets just say, it has come up in conversation over the years.

    Reports that National are seeking legal advice and may seek to pursue charges are unlikely to fly because the basic rule of taping conversations is to make sure you yourself are privy to the conversation, as long as you are you can tape away to your heart’s content with no one else’s knowledge or consent. It is 100% legal. Section 216 B of the Crimes Act 1961 is your ‘how to’ guide to tape conversations legally (of course ethically and morally it can be highly questionable). So whoever the secret taper(s) are in this instance they can sleep soundly knowing there will not be any knocks on the door from the constabulary or any legal bills coming their way over this matter at least.

    For those of you who don’t want to click the link to the Crimes Act the nuts and bolts are that you get into muddy water when you tape conversation you are not privy to or that you are just close enough to overhear but those having the conversation think you cannot hear them. If you have the desire to tape those kinds of conversations, join the police force and get a warrant, otherwise steer clear.

  • Blogs We Like

    We have finally sat down and revised our list of blogs we link to. Its something we have been meaning to do forever but haven’t so tonight we made a start. I am sure that we have missed heaps of blogs we intend to link to so if you think we should link to you, drop us an email with your url.

    m_flannagan at clear dot net dot nz

  • Coming Events

    As the early bird rate expires on Friday, I registered Matt’s and my attendance at this years Forum on the Family. Being election year, the line up is mostly politicians all keen to vote catch but of the array of political parties being billed, one is most conspicuously absent.


    Can you spot which one? Its a fairly major ommission and I bet the ommission is not on the part of the organisers.

    To save you having to squint, here is the line up from left to right (on the advertisement, obviously):

    Pita Sharples – Maori Party

    John Key – National

    Rodney Hide – Act

    Winston Peters – NZ First

    Peter Dunne – United Future

    Jeanette Fitzsimons – Green Party

    Larry Baldock – Kiwi Party

    Taito Phillip Field – NZ Pacific

    Richard Lewis – Family Party

    (The absentee I am speaking of is not Jim Anderton of Progressive who isn’t listed but really who cares that he’s not?)

    Regardless it will still be a great event, last year was very worthwhile though it is a wee bit disappointing to hear that David Farrar of Kiwiblog (a fellow Student Choicer from back in the day) will not be speaking this year as has been rumoured about the blogosphere but I am looking forward to it and have September 8 circled on my calendar.

  • Car Accident Update

    As you know I was involved in a car accident some months back and have had ongoing issues with my neck and back as a result rendering me unable to work and in pain daily. I have had a lot of support through this site and I wanted to take the time to thank those of you who have left messages and sent emails. It has been very difficult to accept that I am injured as I am someone who does not do sitting still well and I have real issues with not being able to do things because of situations beyond my control.

    Four months on I still do not have a full diagnosis as to why I live in pain and why sometimes out of the blue the pain flares up so badly I cannot function. My x-rays are clear so we know there is no bone injury but the first attempt at an MRI to look at soft tissue injuries was a bit of a disaster due to my suffering severe claustrophobia around tunnels (I am ok in lifts and cupboards, etc just nothing shaped like a tunnel) and the fact that I struggle to convince medical professionals that my body metabolises sedatives and anaesthetics freakishly fast meaning I am difficult to sedate. The drug they used for MRI attempt 1 was a drug I knew would not work on me as I have a history of it not working on me but they decided that it works on everyone and that I was just being hysterical so they gave it to me. It did not work, the claustrophobia made me move too much and they did not get a clear scan.

    It has been quite depressing at times accepting what has happened and incredibly maddening that we have this ridiculous no fault ACC system which means I cannot sue the woman who caused the accident. I am left forking out a $22 surcharge per doctors visit every second week and I have to live on 80% of my income and my law studies and my career are in jeopardy and my family has to put up with my mood swings when I am in pain not to mention was living on all these drugs is doing to my kidneys. To add insult to injury my new car is not as fuel efficient as the one that got destroyed in the accident, its stereo has stopped working for no apparent reason and it has started leaking in the rain!

    Complaining aside, things are starting to feel like they are looking up though. Today we did MRI attempt 2. This time they asked me which drug I thought they should use and we used one that had worked in the past. They told me it was heavy duty and would take me out for the day (yet here I am writing a blog entry). Again it did not work anywhere near as well as they thought it would but it did take the edge off the panic so I was able to control the claustrophobia and lie still and they are confident that this time they got the images they needed. So this time next week I should have a diagnosis – yay!

    On Friday I actually managed to sit through my lectures myself at uni. Matt has been amazing going to all my lectures and tutorials and taping them and taking notes for me, not many spouses would do that, he has been fantastically supportive even helping me swot for tests.
    Yesterday I returned to work for the first time and although I only did 3 hours it felt really good to be back. While we are still waiting for the official diagnosis I am only going to do 6 hours a week and see if I can slowly build my hours up from there as pushing it too hard runs the risk of triggering a pain flare up and these can last anything from a couple of days to a couple of weeks and leave me in rotten pain and having to take mind altering pain drugs like Tramadol which is revolting stuff.

    So in short, I think I am a little better but the progress I have made in four months is pretty frustratingly slow but I guess it could be worse.