Category: Conferences

  • Peter Singer on Human Dignity and Infanticide: Part One

    This is the first section of the paper I presented to the the Evangelical Philosophical Society Annual Meeting in Milwaukee two weeks ago. Several people have asked me to post it on MandM. It will appear as a two-part post series.

    Christian theism has traditionally taught that human beings have equal dignity and worth, a moral status that separates them from non-human animals. Peter Singer has famously rejected this teaching, holding that human beings are not any more special than animals and doctrines of human dignity are indefensible.  He contends that killing a new-born infant is, in and of itself, no more problematic than killing a non-human animal such as a cow or a pig and defends the permissibly of infanticide under certain conditions.

    Peter SingerThis paper will critically assess one important part of Singer’s position: his understanding of why it is wrong to kill.  In I I will sketch Singer’s “desire account” of killing and its relationship to his own preference utilitarianism and project of animal equality. Following Don Marquis, I will argue in II, that this “desire account” is subject to important counter examples. In III I note Singer’s attempts to modify his position so as to avoid these counter examples and suggest that these modifications are problematic. In IV, I will suggest that, despite this, there is an important truth in Singer’s critique, one that Christian thinkers can appropriate in developing moral arguments for Christian theism.

    I. Preference Utilitarianism and the desire account of the wrongness of killing
    Classical Utilitarianism conjoins three theses. First, the maximisation thesis; an action is right if and only if it maximises overall net benefit:  net benefit being the total amount of  benefit accruing to individuals as a consequence of the action, minus any harms resulting. An action maximises net benefit when the consequences of performing it constitute a higher net benefit than that associated with any alternative action.

    Second, , the thesis of equal consideration: a benefit or harm to any one individual is counted as having equal weight to a similar sized benefit or harm to any other individual.

    Third, the thesis of hedonism: on this account, benefits and harms are understood in terms of pleasure and pain. Something benefits an individual or is good if it causes him pleasure and harms him if it causes pain.

    Peter Singer is a preference utilitarian. Preference utilitarians accept both the maximisation and equal consideration theses however reject hedonism in favour of a desire fulfillment or preference satisfaction view of the good. Something is good for an individual if he desires or prefers it, and it is bad if contrary to his preferences or desires.

    Singer uses preference utilitarianism to reject the doctrine that human beings have equal dignity and worth, a moral status that separates them from non-human animals.  Sentient animals clearly have desires; they can suffer and feel pain and desire not to. The equal considerations thesis entails that in so far as these desires are similar to those of human beings the suffering of an animal must be considered equal with that of a human being.

    However, in terms of actual as opposed to potential psychological capacities, some human beings have a comparable mental life to that of animals.   A new born human infant’s psychology is primitive. David Boonin notes “by any plausible measure dogs, and cats, cows and pigs, chickens and ducks are more intellectually developed than a new born infant.” [1]  This means that the desires of a new born infant are similar to those of other animals.

    Singer illustrates this point in a discussion of animal experimentation. (more…)

  • Back from the USA

    The CrowdMadeleine and I flew back to New Zealand from Milwaukee on Tuesday having both attended the Evangelical Philosophical Society Annual Meeting, the Annual Meeting of the Evangelical Theological Society, and the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s Apologetics Conference. Prior to that I had spent three weeks based in Charlotte, North Carolina. I will speak about the  conferences later in this post but first I will summarise what I did in Charlotte.

    Charlotte
    My work in North Carolina can be divided into several categories.

    First, and this was the bulk of what I did, I did a bit of speaking on a lecture circuit at various campuses in North Carolina on issues relating to God and Morality for Ratio Christi. Formally, this involved, driving to a campus, delivering a lecture and then taking a Q&A.

    Speaking at UNC CharlotteI learned very quickly that there was a lot more to what I was doing than the formal activity of giving lectures; in fact, most of the more important work was the informal stuff that went on behind the scenes.  In addition to presenting lectures, there was often an equally important informal component. Often I would meet with students before the lecture  and discuss the challenges they were facing as Christian students in a secular campus. I would offer advice, counsel, support, etc. On other occasions I would, in addition to giving the lectures, meet with the supporters and financiers of the people running student ministries and discuss with them the importance of Apologetics and of developing an intellectually robust faith among students.  I found that the most important and constructive engagement and interaction with people typically occurred in these informal contexts.

    Speaking at Appalachian State UniversitySecond, in addition to my major task of giving lectures, on the weekends I gave instruction in churches. After my first week I was part of a missions team that spent a weekend teaching at a church in a nearby Cherokee Reservation.  The weekend after that I taught an adult education class in a Community Fellowship Church of North Carolina. The  following weekend I preached from the pulpit.  One Sunday evening I attended a service at a Slavic Baptist church where almost the entire service was in Russian and we needed a translator to follow what was being said. After the service I was one of a team of people who spoke to the youth group; I spent several hours fielding their very astute and intelligent questions about the Christian faith.

    This work was very challenging. It is one thing to give lectures at a university when one has, as I have, spent years studying and working in universities. It is quite another speaking to Cherokee Native American Indians one week, Southern Americans the next and youth from Slavic Immigrant Families the next – especially when my own culture is Kiwi!

    Third, and finally, I worked with the students at Southern Evangelical Seminary. One night when I was not lecturing, I presented an academic paper to students and graduates from the seminary, which was followed by a discussion. Another night I travelled to Belmont Abbey, a Catholic Liberal Arts College to dialogue with a Catholic theologian about the relative strengths of Natural Law Theory verses Divine Command Meta- Ethics.

    Both events were focused on seminary students, to get them to be presented with new or different material to what they were familiar with so they could ask questions and be stretched in their intellectual development.  I found the work over those three weeks very taxing physically, yet I enjoyed it immensely. I was giving lectures at universities, back to back, almost every day; I was often travelling for hours to and from the university in question and sometimes I would have to stay overnight with billets. As noted above the diversity of what I did stretched me.

    Lecturing on campuses to potentially hostile audiences is challenging enough, particularly when one throws in a Q&A. It becomes more so when there are obvious cultural barriers such as my indecipherable New Zealand accident and tendency to speaK too quickly because of the speed of my thoughts!  But, in addition to this, I was required to  give a talk to theology students, to Slavic youth, adult congregants, North American Indians on Reservations, and people from a country not my own in general – these contexts forced me to adapt my material fairly quickly to these new contexts with very little prep time.

    Milwaukee
    Madeleine, Bill Craig and IThe business end of my trip however was the conference in Milwaukee. On Wednesday 16 November 2012. Both Madeleine and I presented papers at the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s Annual Meeting. In the morning I presented my paper “Peter Singer, Human Dignity and Infanticide”; this was a critical look at Peter Singer’s account of the wrongness of killing and some of his attempts to revise his position in light of criticisms by Don Marquis.

    EPS Panel DiscussionIn the afternoon, Madeleine and I were on a panel discussing the  book Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life along with Mary Jo Sharp, Cristian Mihut and the book’s Editors, Michael W Austin and Doug Geivett. Madeleine offered a response and critique of the chapter on “Courage” by Rebecca Konyndyk DeYoung and I offered a criticism of Charles Taliaferro’s chapter on “Love”.

    Madeleine did extremely well, you would never have guessed, unless you knew to look for things like how she gripped the podium, that she had flown into Milwaukee at 12.05 am the night before, had been living with a pain disability aggravated by sitting for the past 4 years which was on high alert due to almost 24 hours travelling, and that she was completely shattered from working insane hours to be able to leave her litigation schedule and our children, whilst functioning on NZ time. In her typical style she spoke in a clear, articulate and forthright manner, her content was good, and I doubt anyone present could have been aware of the fact that she alone was the only speaker on the panel with no formal philosophy qualifications without reading her bio.

    Panel on Protestant PurgatoryIn addition to our own presentations, we attended a number of sessions such as Mike Austin’s talk on “Analytic Moral Theology”, Frank Beckwith’s response to the recent  “After Birth Abortion” paper published in the Journal of Medicine and Ethics, Paul Copan’s discussion on Acts 17, Charles Taliaferro’s Lecture on Environmentalism, a very stimulating panel discussion on Jerry Wall’s new book which offers a Protestant Defense of Purgatory, among various other presentations including sessions on religious pluralism and the Evangelical Theological Society’s panel discussion on environmentalism.

    Me, Frank Beckwith, MadeleineBy the time the EPS Apologetics conference started both Madeleine and I were knackered. Despite this we attended sessions on God and Morality by Frank Beckwith, Jeremy Evans’ session on Theism and the Meaning and Purpose of Life, David Baggett’s discussion of Moral Scepticism, Mike Austin’s talk on “Evangelical Blogging”, Angus Menuge, the new Evangelical Philosophical Society President’s talk on Religious Language, Gary Habermas’ talk on the Resurrection, and Mary Jo Sharp’s very useful session on effective public speaking.

    Paul Copan, Madeleine and IIn addition to the papers and sessions there was a lot of general networking going on. Paul Copan, Madeleine and I and met with a prospective publisher about co-writing a book on the moral issues surrounding the conquest narrative; it looks likely that Baker Books will accept our proposal, I will keep readers posted. I signed my publishing contract with Baker for an earlier publication. Madeleine had an interesting experience with Lee Strobel, Mary Jo Sharp, Mark Mittelberg and Chad Meister dialoguing with a prospective seeker. Mary Jo Sharp and Madeleine plotted prospective joint debate projects. Frank Beckwith and Madeleine discussed their shared religion in public life/philosophy meets law interests; Frank and I discussed possible joint projects on the abortion issue. Discussions were had with Craig Hazen about the Biola Faculty, Mark Mittelberg, Mary Jo Sharp and William Lane Craig about the possibility of their visiting New Zealand. We also met with Ratio Christi regarding the possibility of  a New Zealand chapter being formed.

    Mary Jo Sharp and Madeleine

    Since we got back, I have been following up on several potential employment opportunities that have arisen from the trip, a couple in New Zealand, a couple overseas, as well as possibility of 3 further books, one co-written with Madeleine, and various other potential projects involving ministry writing and speaking.

    In addition to the scholarly stuff, I got to see the Atlantic Ocean for the first time,  I saw the New York sky line, the Statue of Liberty and the New World Trade Centre. I visited a Nascar Centre, was present in the US during the re-election of Barack Obama and Cyclone Sandy. We discovered Wisconsin Cheese, Wisconsin Frozen Custard and Madeleine got to indulge in her favourite lollie flavours (candy to the US readers): cinnamon and root beer (she is happy to receive donations of either or both via post).

    Needless to say we arrived home on Tuesday extremely tired but extremely grateful to everyone who supported us in making this trip from those who donated – we love you all – through to people like Simon Brace who organised the Charlotte leg, Paul Copan who shared his hotel room with us, Ratio Christi who shouted us meals, our eldest daughter Sheridan who took on the task of primary caregiver to her younger siblings – no mean task given the severe Autistic Spectrum Disorder and Anxiety issues of our youngest child – Mike Austin and Doug Geivett who invited Madeleine and I to speak on their Book Panel, among others (this is by no means an exhaustive list!).

  • MandM in Milwaukee

    Evangelical Philosophical SocietyI have just bought my tickets to Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA. I leave New Zealand on Tuesday 13 November 2012 to meet Matt who will be leaving Charlotte, North Carolina on the same day.

    Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life

    The day after I arrive I will be giving my contribution to the panel discussion at the Evangelical Philosophical Society (“EPS”) Annual Meeting on Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life, a book edited by Doug Geivett and Mike Austin. Being Good is a very accessible philosophical treatment of various virtues, each chapter is written by a different author and focuses on a single virtue.

    I have chosen to focus on an analysis of a virtue in the book, I have chosen the chapter on Courage by Rebecca Konyndyk DeYoung because, as CS Lewis said, “Courage is not simply one of the virtues, but the form of every virtue at the testing point.” Matt is focussing on love.

    Other panel contributors are: Doug Geivett, Mike Austin, Mary Jo Sharp, Cristian Mihut, Matthew Flannagan (I feel seriously underqualified LOL!) Our session details are:

    Wednesday November 14
    Evangelical Philosophical Society, B4
    Hyatt—Milwaukee
    4:40 pm – 6:10 pm

    View our full USA itinerary.

    I really want to say a big thankyou to everyone who donated to get us here. Once again, as in previous years, I am just blown away by your support as is Matt.

    Special thank-yous to Doug and Mike for inviting Matt and I to speak and to Paul Copan who is putting us up in his hotel room.

  • MandM in America 2012

    MandM in USARight now Matt is in the USA, well over it (he is in a plane), he will land in Charlotte, North Carolina to begin his month long speaking tour.  Provided the funds come together within the next fortnight, I will be joining him at the tail end of his tour to participate in a panel discussion at the Evangelical Philosophical Society in Milwaukee.

    We are getting a number of emails asking for our itinerary from people keen to book Matt to speak so here it is:

    North Carolina
    18 Oct Matt – Ratio Christi Syposium
    19 Oct Matt – 20th: Southern Evangelical Seminary Apologetics Conference
    21 Oct Matt – CFC Church
    22 Oct Matt – Dr John Lennox at Davidson & Chapel Hill with Veritas Forum
    23 Oct Matt – Dr John Lennox at Davidson & Chapel Hill with Veritas Forum
    24 Oct Matt – RC Queen University
    25 Oct Matt – Hickory Grove Highschool
    25 Oct Matt – University of North Carolina Charlotte
    26 Oct Matt – Cherokee Apologetics Conference
    27 Oct Matt – Cherokee Apologetics Conference
    28 Oct Matt – Cherokee Apologetics Conference
    29 Oct Matt – University of North Carolina Greenboro.
    30 Oct Matt – Billy Graham Facility
    31 Oct Matt – Belmont Abbey with Dr Grattan Brown
    1 Nov Matt – Lenoir Rhyne
    2 Nov Matt – Southern Evangelical Seminary students & alumni
    3 Nov Matt – Southern Evangelical Seminary students & alumni
    4 Nov Matt – CFC Church
    Georgia
    6 Nov Matt – with Dr Richard Howe
    7 Nov Matt – with Dr Richard Howe
    8 Nov Matt – with Dr Richard Howe
    9 Nov Matt – with Dr Richard Howe
    10 Nov Matt – with Dr Richard Howe
    11 Nov Matt – with Dr Richard Howe
    Milwaukee
    14 Nov Madeleine and Matt – Evangelical Philosophical Society
    14 Nov Matt – Evangelical Philosophical Society

    For those wanting to know if they can book Matt to speak please email me (madeleineflannagan at gmail dot com) and I will put you in touch with the organisers of the bulk of the above engagements.

    As to our fundraising efforts, we have enough for Matt to go but as for me, the sidebar widget is up to date in terms of funds received. We have been pledged an additional $500 and we know we have another donation, amount unspecified, coming. The shortfall still is beyond our means.

    Further links:
    Matt and Madeleine to speak on “Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life” at EPS Milwaukee
    Matt to speak on “Singer and Infanticide” at EPS Milwaukee
    Matt’s Oct-Nov USA speaking tour

  • Matt’s Impending Month-Long USA Speaking Tour – UPDATED

    Matt's USA TourAs you all know, Matt and I are heading to Milwaukee this November 2012 to speak at the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s Annual Meeting.

    News of this has spread, as sometimes happens when you publish things on the internet, and so now Matt is going to American early to do a speaking tour of North Carolina before heading to Milwaukee to meet me at the EPS – so far his (rather exciting!) itinerary is:

    Arrive 17th of October 2012
    18th – Ratio Christi Syposium
    19th – 20th: Southern Evangelical Seminary Apologetics Conference
    21st – Meet CFC Church
    22nd – 23rd: Dr John Lennox at Davidson & Chapel Hill with Veritas Forum
    24th: Matt to Speak at RC Queen University
    25th: Matt to Speak at Hickory Grove Highschool and University of North Carolina Charlotte
    26th – 28th: Cherokee Apologetics Conference
    29th: Matt to Speak at University of North Carolina Greenboro.
    30th: Visit to Billy Graham Facility
    31st: Matt to Speak at Belmont Abbey with Dr Grattan Brown
    1st Nov: Matt to Speak at Lenoir Rhyne
    2nd – 3rd: Speaking to Southern Evangelical Seminary students & alumni
    4th: Preaching at CFC Church
    6th – 11th: Travel to Georgia with Dr Richard Howe

    Then on 14 November:
    Matt and Madeleine to speak on “Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life” in Milwaukee
    Matt to speak on Singer and Infanticide in Milwaukee

    The logistics and financial issues around pulling this off are complicated by Matt leaving for the US in mid-October and my need to continue working in New Zealand until mid-November and care for our 2 home-schooled children and a teenager in his final year of school who will be sitting exams. I am only in the first months of being an independent contractor so when I do not work, I do not earn; the same is true for Matt with his job – neither of us accrue leave – basically we will be not earning but incurring costs both in the US and at home.

    Finding care for the children will be difficult, especially as our youngest (11) suffers from severe high-functioning austistic spectrum disorder and severe anxiety disorder and appears to be developing agrophobia – the upshot is that the number of people who capable of watching him (other than Matt and I) are numbered on 1 hand and he cannot leave the house to be cared for as he panics.

    All that aside, we have faith that we will find a way. So your prayers are asked for as we work through resolving the parental and household responsibility issues and the finances to get both of us to the US. We still need to raise about another $2,500 so if you feel inclined to donate, your support is greatly appreciated, please see the options in the sidebar and on the support page.

    If you are in the US and you want to book either Matt or I for a speaking engagement, see our about page to contact us.

    UPDATE:
    We are in receipt of a request for me to travel over a little earlier and speak.

    At this point we have raised enough funds for Matt to go, and his tickets are now all booked, but we do not have funds for me to travel at all – although I do already have an entry visa.

    So while we are very open to me speaking more than already scheduled we are not sure if that can happen yet.

  • Blogging as a Supplement to Peer Review: My 2011 SBL & ASOR Paper

    At the 2011 annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature and the American Academy of Religion in San Francisco I gave a paper in the Blogger and Online Publication session entitled “Blogging as a Supplement to Peer Review“. It occurred to me today that I have never published it on MandM so here it is.

    This paper will not be a normal academic paper. Normally, when I present one of them, I have a specific thesis I try and offer an argument for it and rebut arguments against it. Today however I will present more of a narrative based on some reflections from my own experience as a blogger and scholar and someone who blends the two.

    Peer ReviewI began engaging in “biblical blogging” with great reluctance.  One of my biggest reservations was that blogs are not peer reviewed. Anyone can, and does, write anything at all and get it published on the internet – even, if it’s complete nonsense. One only has to surf the net for a few minutes to see the problem.

    Further, the readership of blogs is not restricted to scholars. Many blogs feature a person writing on a subject with little or no understanding of it who have a following of devoted readers who are equally ignorant, but nevertheless read and comment on the same topic as if they were knowledgeable. My impression was that blogs on theological topics were no less immune to this problem than blogs on other topics.

    So my first reservation was that a blog post really carried no stature; I felt it would be embarrassing to be known as a blogger – I was seeking to be a scholar.

    My second reservation based on my experience with online communication. There are subtle social constraints on face to face communication. If I have to stand up and speak in front of an audience at a conference I will be nervous.  If I say something stupid publically others will laugh at me and I will be embarrassed. If I get really nasty and cross a line someone might get physically threatening and even hit me if I provoke them. There are social consequences to what I say. Online, however, many of these social constraints are muted, one can be completely anonymous or communicate from a fictional personae. People can say things they would never say saying in public without facing the normal social consequences of such comments. This means that online discussions can be counter-productive. Most bloggers will be familiar with the phenomena of “trolls” people who enter into online discussions simply to insult, attack and distract the discussion. I could not see the attraction much less the benefit of engaging in a medium like that.

    I think both these reservations have some merit. However I now believe that, despite them, blogging can serve as a supplement to peer review. It is hard to not believe that given what blogging has done for me but before I get into that, note that I said supplement, my suggestion is that it can supplement not replace peer review.

    Some Challenges of Traditional Peer Review
    In 2006 I graduated with a PhD in Theology. The prospects in the job market were bad in New Zealand – my part of the world – particularly for an unknown fresh graduate. An immediate goal of mine was to establish myself as a credible theological scholar which, of course, meant getting my work known. I resolved that I needed to be published. If I developed a series of publications, others in my field will read my work, and as a result my work will become known. I began by following the usual route of submitting articles to journals for publication and I found it hard going.

    Let me note two challenges I found with this:

    First, almost no one reads your article until it gets published, and this can affect you (more…)

  • Madeleine and Matt to speak on “Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life” at the 2012 Evangelical Philosophical Society Meeting in Milwaukee

    Evangelical Philosophical Society

    I have had to revise my earlier statements about not going to the November 2012 academic conferences in Milwaukee on the grounds that when you are personally invited to participate in a panel discussion by Doug Geivett and Mike Austin at the Evangelical Philosophical Society (“EPS”) you do not say no 🙂

    (If I said “no” I think Andrew would throw things at me and André Z would egg him on)

    Matt has been invited to speak on the same panel too.

    Here is what we know so far:

    Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday LifeMike and Doug co-edited a book entitled Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life.  At the EPS meeting in Milwaukee in November 2012 there will be a panel discussion in one of the sessions offering critical discussion of the book and it’s themes. Matt and I are now scheduled to be participants in that panel.

    The panel will discuss different aspects of the book, such as, an analysis of a virtue in the book that a participant disagrees with by giving an extension of the book’s discussion of character in some way.

    Matt was already going anyway as his paper on Singer and Infanticide got through the blind review process and was accepted.

    I had thought I might not go as we in the process of radically changing how I earn money. I am about to swap my regular weekly income for a contract for services that will see me retain most of the money I make my firm but pay my own expenses (and still be supervised and under the umbrella of a firm as all baby-lawyers should be under the law). So this is both exciting as I will have more control over what I earn but it is also scary as there are no guarantees that I will earn consistently; imminent changes to how legal aid is to be paid make that even scarier. The theory is that in the long run I will make more than I was on my very low baby-lawyer income but it is yet to be tested. As I am the primary earner in our house there is a lot riding on this, including the extension to our mortgage to purchase this opportunity. Going to America is not a cheap exercise from New Zealand but we have providentially managed to find a way the last two years with a lot of help from our friends so I am going to stop worrying and focus on trusting in God to whom I am  grateful for this opportunity.