Category: Social Commentary

  • More Swamps than Christchurch: The Liquefaction of the Left

    "Scientists say that by 1984 we'll be up to our ears in horse dung if we don't reduce our reliance on horsepower.""One of the most destructive carnards concreted into the mind of greenism and environmentalism is the proposition that natural resources are fixed, finite, and limited. Once gone, they are gone forever. Therefore, conservation of said resources is a moral imperative.

    Statists warm to this proposition reflexively, that is, without thinking. To conserve on a grand scale requires big government: to regulate, limit, control, restrict, order, prescribe, proscribe, and ban. Without such a big intrusion into the lives and endeavours of citizens, disaster will fall upon the entire race. Therefore, statists join the moral crusade. Advocating for big-brother government suddenly makes one morally good. Saving the planet and saving humanity has a nice moral ring to it, making big government itself a moral imperative.

    Socialists likewise find the proposition of limited resources needing to be conserved a convenient doctrine. It justifies pre-emptive property rights of the state over private citizens. It also gives moral cover to advocating for more government taxation and expropriation to fund things like “green industries” and “green energy”. You just have to take a glance at President Obama’s “new” energy strategy. Instead of “drill, baby drill” it is “spin, baby, spin”, referring of course to the windmills he is spending billions of dollars worth of citizen’s property to manufacture and deploy.

    So, we have the ideological Grand Coalition of our times: greenists, environmentalists, statists, and socialists. Ladies and gentlemen put your hands together for “the Left”.

    There is one small problem. This monumental intellectual and political construction is built upon a simple fallacy, known as the fallacy of composition. It beggars belief that in a world self-proclaimed to be so smart and so rational that the very same wise-in-their-own-estimation are actually operating with a grand intellectual and political edifice built on more swamps than Christchurch, or more volcanoes than Auckland.

    The fallacy of composition assumes or asserts that the attributes of the parts must sum to the attribute of the whole. In this case, since each specific natural resource is clearly finite, natural resources as a whole must, therefore, be finite. Once you explode this childish error (more…)

  • Internationalism is Dead: Boneparte’s Descendants

    OK, so we thought that you would want to hear it here first. Internationalism–the idea that nation states are subject to a higher “sovereignty”– is dead. The corpse is rotting. The Libyan “adventure”, called for by the UN, is growing madder than a March Hare. All the problems and faults of internationalism are now clearly displayed. We hear Joan Baez in the background, intoning “when will they ever learn?” Not in a hurry would be our bet.

    Muammar Muhammad al-Gaddafi

    Though internationalism may be dead, the foolishness that is bound up in the heart of unconverted man is likely to keep flogging that particular equine corpse for decades to come.

    Consider the mess that the internationalists are now in. The UN has passed a resolution directing that a no-fly zone be established in Libya. The internationalist community has spoken. Man, the universal overlord of the globe, has determined that what was happening in Libya ought not to be; some kind of nebulous higher ethic was appealed to which mean that “humanity” or “the international community” had to step up and into Libya to sort things out.

    The echoes in the UN Security Council chamber had not died away before they were drowned by arguments between those who voted over what the meaning and application of the resolution. This from Al Jazeera:

    International criticism of the coalition enforcing the no-fly zone has continued to grow, with India joining China in publicly calling for an end to the airstrikes. Jiang Yu, a spokeswoman for China’s foreign ministry, said on Tuesday that the government opposed “the wanton use of armed force leading to more civilian casualties and more humanitarian disasters”. China had already called for a ceasefire.

    S M Krishna, the Indian foreign minister, called for a “cessation of armed conflict”. His office had previously issued a statement on Monday expressing “regret” for the military intervention. Pranab Mukherjee, the country’s foreign minister, said in a speech to parliament that “no external powers” should interfere in Libya. “Nobody, not a couple of countries, can take that decision to change a particular regime,” he said

    The Sydney Morning Herald reports that the Brits cannot even agree amongst themselves as to what the resolution means: can they take Gaddafi out or not? Some say yes; others nay-say. Neither can the French agree amongst themselves. Does the resolution mean that Gaddafi can legitimately stay in power. Yes. No. Maybe. All of the above. Meanwhile, Turkey a member of NATO has announced that it will not allow its airspace to be used in enforcing the no-fly zone, if it goes beyond the UN resolution–whatever it might mean, and no-one knows.

    The announcement came after Turkey, a member of the NATO, warned on Tuesday that it could not agree to the military alliance taking over the enforcement of the no-fly zone if their mission went “outside the framework” of the UN decision.

    Meanwhile in the US, President Obama, a committed internationalist, appeared deeply reluctant to (more…)

  • The End of State Education: Resistance is Futile

    The litany of the forces arrayed against quality state education systems is long. We believe these forces make state education’s decline inevitable. Without a thoroughgoing reformation of the fundaments of Western society itself, resistance is futile. The Borg is here.

    We know that in New Zealand roughly one third of all graduates from state schools are functionally illiterate and innumerate. They cannot read supermarket shelf labels. Nor can they compare prices. We also know that on any given school day one tenth of pupils will be absent, without a conscientious reason. Truancy is systemic.

    State Education

    Recently we sought to interview potential candidates for a teaching position in our Christian school. These candidates were committed Christians; they were currently studying at a teacher training institution; they were zealous for their prospective careers–but they were unable to write a paragraph that was grammatically or syntactically correct. Apparently they had never learned through thirteen years of state schooling what a full-stop was, or how one was to begin a sentence. Yet, they had all graduated with “flying colours” from NCEA levels 11 through 13 in English! Sadly they were unemployable in our school.

    These folk were part of another cohort of graduates from our state schools that are neither functionally illiterate nor innumerate–but they are   incompetent in even the rudiments of language and maths. This, of course, means that their ability to think, reason, encapsulate, describe, argue, and comprehend is severely curtailed. We guess that this cohort would represent another third of graduates from state schools.

    Those who think that starting a new state funded programme (for example, Early Childhood Education), or shrinking classroom sizes, or raising teacher salaries, or introducing national testing will turn the tide are naive. They have not reckoned with the barrage of the secular forces arrayed against state schools.

    Let’s name two of these secular forces. The first is statism–which arguably is the established religion of our day. By this we mean that for many the state or the government is the ultimate reality and force. Name any social, political, material, economic or cultural problem and within a nano-second the conversation will have become political–by which we mean that “the government needs to do something, or this, or that” will have been introduced into the conversation. Functionally our society looks to government as its god.

    The spin-off effect upon state education is direct. The state’s “long term” solution to any problem is to attempt to use its schools to change human nature and action to solve society’s perceived problems. Government as redeemer translates into schools as agents of socialisation and state propaganda, not education. This is a weight which schools simply cannot bear. They both stop educating and fail miserably in socialisation.

    The second secular force also has religious roots (more…)

  • Hearing the Voice of God: Tragedy and its Aftershocks

    Christchurch's Cathedral after the earthquakeThe “big one” has hit Christchurch. Few in the entire country will be untouched or unaffected, since we in New Zealand are a little village. To a man each will have relatives, friends, colleagues and mates in Christchurch. In that sense it is a national disaster.

    The meaning and significance of such disasters are always multi-dimensional and multi-faceted. The effects similarly. Some people will find new meaning, purpose and direction in life though this adversity. Others will discover afresh that the “good things” of life are mere trinkets and will become profoundly thankful again for the basics of food and clothing and shelter. With these they will be content. Others will appreciate family, loved ones, neighbours and friends in deeper ways.

    Still others will find courage that they never knew they had. Some will mourn deeply the passing of loved ones. Some will mend their lives and begin again. Others never will. Many will live in fear of further calamity until the day they die. One of the things that earthquakes do–more than any other calamity, it would seem–is shake the fundaments of life to the very core. Nothing is sure. Nothing is certain. Everything is tenuous. There is no security. If the very earth cannot bear us up and support us, nothing can.

    At such times, our thoughts always turn particularly to the saints. “When one suffers, all suffer,” is the motto of the Church. It is the spiritual foundation of the secularised “all for one, and one for all”. The saints will congregate. They will once again review their lives in the light of eternity. They will remind one another that time is short and man’s days upon the earth are like grass. They will extend hospitality to the needy. They will mourn with those who mourn. They will rejoice with those who have been delivered. Their shepherds will minister the Word of God to them. They will realise afresh that though heaven and earth pass away, the Word of the Lord will abide forever. This tragedy will re-orientate and re-focus their lives in ways that few other things ever would.

    It is probable that many will become Christians; they will come to belief and a saving faith in Christ. They thought they were atheists or they lived in casual, who-cares agnosticism. But spontaneously, from the depths of their heart, they called out to God, as the very earth shook and the buildings fell. Faced with eternity, they became believers in an instant, crying out, “Remember me, Lord.” Whilst many will have cried out to God and have already since forgotten, pushing out the warnings from their mind, others will have been converted, born again by the Spirit. He moves as the wind. Who can tell whence He came, and where He goes.

    Just like the great storm and the roaring flood, earthquakes are the voice of God. He speaks in them and through them, to all who have ears to hear.

    Cross posted at Contra Celsum

  • Prayers for the victims of the Christchurch Earthquake

    We are devastated for our countrymen who were struck by a very shallow, yet very destructive, 6.3 magnitude earthquake in Christchurch, New Zealand this afternoon. While it may have been smaller than September’s 7.1 magnitude earthquake, all reports show that this one was far worse in terms of its violence and impact.

    Today many people have lost their lives, TV3 news tonight reports “at least 65 are confirmed dead” and the number is not expected to stop there; many more have been injured. Right now people remain trapped in the rubble and the city is out of ambulances and emergency services are hard to get hold of.

    There has been widespread damage to buildings and property. The Christchurch Cathedral which has stood in the city centre for so long is crumbling – people were apparently in the spire at the time it crumbled and fell. They are not expected to have survived.

    The hospital has been evacuated, the airport is closed, the roads are badly damaged, water mains and waste pipes have broken, the power is out. The military is driving people out of the central city and an international search and rescue team has been called in to New Zealand right now to help with the rescue efforts.

    Because of the time of day it hit, 12;51pm, families were separated, spread among work, school, daycare, home. For locals wanting to get news – the phones are down, the New Zealand internet news sites are down as their servers are being overloaded; the NZ Herald site at one point was getting 1 million hits per minute.

    Television footage is showing a city in shock, live rescues in progress with no time to edit the brutal truth of what that kind of force can do to people. Some of the footage…

    Map of Christchurch Earthquake Epicentre

    As with last September’s Christchurch earthquake, Matt and I are in receipt of phone calls, emails and messages from our overseas friends and families checking to see if we are ok. Whilst this earthquake was widely felt throughout New Zealand – as far north as Hamilton – Matt and I in Auckland were too far away from it to feel it. The earthquake’s epicentre was 5km away from Lyttleton, Christchurch.

    We have heard from some of our Christchurch friends – they are ok, very shaken but alive. There are others we have not heard from, they are in our prayers.

    Amidst the carnage, panic and devastation on TV that is seeing the anchormen and women reduced to tears as they report live, the steady work of all those who are able to serve, rescue and aid others is something to behold. The community of Christchurch coming together to move debris and get the injured to safety makes me proud to be a kiwi.

    Our prayers are with the victims, with those waiting for news, with those working hard to help others – with everyone in Christchurch and everyone who has loved ones in Christchurch. It is so very hard to believe this is happening in New Zealand.

    New Zealand News Sites:
    New Zealand Herald
    Stuff
    Television New Zealand
    TV3

    Donations for the Victims of the Christchurch Earthquake:
    Red Cross
    Salvation Army
    ANZ – ANZ have pledged $1,000,000.00
    Christchurch City Mission

    Christchurch Person Finder:
    Person Finder: Christchurch Earthquake, February 2011

    Please spread the link to the Christchurch person finder far and wide. Kiwis, if you want to do something useful give blood.

  • The Pretensions of Democracy and the Egypt Riots

    The secular west has a secular gospel. It is the good news of democracy. When problems assail a nation, all would be assuaged if not solved if it had more democracy. And so it has come to pass with respect to Egypt.

    The West is not unique in that it has its own version of gospel. All human cultures, religions, and peoples have a gospel of some kind. The word “gospel” of course means good news. The gospel of any society is the proclamation of what that society believes will make things right. Whatever a culture looks to as the “super problem solver” is its saviour. Proclaiming and touting that “saviour” is its gospel. That gospel reaches the status of being established in a society when its promises and claims are seen as self-evident and beyond question. Whenever a culture fails to achieve a consensus view of what its saviour is, it has no gospel: fracturing is inevitable.

    In the West, under the aegis of its established religion of secular humanism, democracy is it. It is easy to understand why democracy has become the West’s established gospel of choice. The West is primarily about the glorification and celebration of man. Democracy is that form of government which does respectful obeisance to man–it is the system of government which seems to accord most closely with the idea that man is his own self-saviour. If man is his own self-saviour, then democracy is the form of government which brings man into a position of institutional supremacy in society. The will of the people is the voice of our god.

    So, if any society has problems (and all do), a system of government which institionalises and reifies the will and wisdom of man must be better, if not best. Democracy facilitates man taking control of his own destiny and this will result in the solving and resolution of all problems.

    Egypt RiotsAs the West opines and pontificates over Egypt it cannot help but project its gospel upon that country. The future for Egypt would be much more assured and all problems would be mitigated if the government were to become less authoritarian. If free and fair elections were held and the people had a voice all would be well, or at least better. How beautiful upon the mountains are the feet of those who come proclaiming the gospel of democracy. What a tingle goes up the spine when our high priests in the West proclaim our secular liturgical chants.

    Problem number one. (more…)

  • Waitangi’s Christian Heritage

    It is Waitangi Day in New Zealand today; the day where we remember the signing of the treaty of Waitangi in 1840.

    This morning at church I had the privilege of hearing a very interesting talk from my Pastor, Rev. Dr Stuart Lange about the lead up to the Treaty signing. Stuart is a church historian and something of an expert on the history of Christianity in New Zealand. When he is not being a pastor at Massey Presbyterian Church he lectures in Church History at Laidlaw College where he used to be Vice Principal.

    Samuel MarsdenStuart looked at the role of missionaries in NZ society. He pointed out some interesting facts, such as: the relationship between early missionary Samuel Marsden and William Wilberforce, the famous evangelical reformer who spearheaded the abolition of the slave trade in England; and that prior to the Treaty being signed, large numbers of Maori converted to Christianity; he touched on the role of Missionaries in brokering peace between warring tribes, and how these conversions lead to Maori tribes liberating their slaves who then carried the gospel back to their homes. He also noted that, in many respects, prior to 1840 Christianity was more prevalent amongst Maori than the colonial settlers, many of whom were fairly unscrupulous and had little time for serious evangelical commitment.

    He noted also the theological and pastoral motivations of the missionaries in pushing for the Treaty; they were concerned to see that, with colonialists arriving in great numbers, the indigenous people they worked with were protected. He also noted the role of several missionaries in speaking out against early violations of the Treaty.

    Stuart is apparently giving a 90 minute lecture on these issues at Congress 2011: 2020 Vision – The Gospel in the Decade Ahead, a Christian leadership conference in Wellington later this month – check it out if you’re in Wellington. This was a very brief snippet of that talk but it was thoroughly interesting and it was delivered with Stuart’s characteristic humour.

    I have posted on some of the moral issues around the Treaty before and I plan in the future to write some more on this topic but now  I also plan to look into some of the theological history as I found this talk fascinating.

    Anyway happy Waitangi Day fellow kiwis! Let us today all pause, consider and celebrate our country’s heritage and future together – take up Pat Brittenden’s idea and have a Waitangi Day barbeque! Kia kaha.

    RELATED POSTS:
    Maori and Pakeha are Not Partners to the Treaty of Waitangi
    Sovereignty and The Treaty of Waitangi
    View “Marae: The Great Waitangi Debate” Here
    The Foreshore and Seabed Repeal: The Inconvenience of Due Process