Category: Uncategorized

  • Sunday Study: Sodom and Gomorrah Part I

    Something I’ve been deeply disturbed about since childhood is the Sodom & Gomorrah tale – specifically, the offering of the virgin daughters to satisfy the hordes of men outside the house. On the face of it, this looks like a negation of the daughters’ autonomy (mind you, I’ve never seen this passage interpreted – Matt may have some insights). There are lots of Biblical instances where we’re exhorted to curb our autonomy for others or the greater good – eg turning the other cheek – but the Sodom & Gomorrah incident doesn’t seem like one of them.

    In response to these comments let me begin by examining a little of what is going on in the passage Anna cites. The passage occurs in the 19th chapter of the book of Genesis,

    1The two messengers arrived at Sodom in the evening, and Lot was sitting in the gateway of the city. When he saw them, he got up to meet them and bowed down with his face to the ground.2 “My lords,” he said, “please turn aside to your servant’s house. You can wash your feet and spend the night and then go on your way early in the morning.” “No,” they answered, “we will spend the night in the square.”3 But he insisted so strongly that they did go with him and entered his house. He prepared a meal for them, baking bread without yeast, and they ate.4 Before they had gone to bed, all the men from every part of the city of Sodom–both young and old–surrounded the house.5 They called to Lot, “Where are the men who came to you tonight? Bring them out to us so that we can have sex with them.” 6 Lot went outside to meet them and shut the door behind him 7 and said, “No, my friends. Don’t do this wicked thing. 8 Look, I have two daughters who have never slept with a man. Let me bring them out to you, and you can do what you like with them. But don’t do anything to these men, for they have come under the protection of my roof.”9 “Get out of our way,” they replied. And they said, “This fellow came here as an alien, and now he wants to play the judge! We’ll treat you worse than them.” They kept bringing pressure on Lot and moved forward to break down the door. 10 But the men inside reached out and pulled Lot back into the house and shut the door.

    Lot offered his daughters to the mob in exchange for the mob not having sex with his guests. Analysing various legal and mythical writings from the ancient near east, Robert Gagnon argues that in the ancient near eastern context “it was apparently regarded as degrading and shameful for a man to be penetrated as if he were a woman regardless of whether the passive partner was a voluntary participant. To be routinely penetrated by other men was to be treated as a “man-woman” and hence made inferior in honour and status to those doing the penetrating.”[1] This is reflected in the middle Assyrian laws which stipulated that the punishment for slandering a man of the same social class by claiming he had sex with men was castration.

    Similarly having sex with a man of the same social class carried the punishment of “they shall turn him into a eunuch.”[2] I noted in an earlier post that penal sanctions of this kind serve a kind of ironical hyperbolic function; however, the point of the law is clear, “the principle of lex talionis explains the punishment: just as the perpetrator deprives the penetrated man of his manhood, so to the penetrator will be denied his manhood by being castrated.”[3] The Egyptian myth of Horus and Seth has similar motifs; when Seth sodomises Horus in his sleep it is stated that the gods “screamed aloud, and belched and spat on Horus’s face.”[4] Ancient near eastern mores apparently did not condemn sex with a man of lower social standing than oneself as this person’s standing was already lowered relative to oneself.

    The men (messengers) in the passage entered Sodom as strangers. Lot showed them the required hospitality and hence brought them “under the protection of his roof” the men of Sodom’s actions, therefore, are an attempt to symbolically castrate his guests, to humiliate and degrade them and lower the social status of the outsiders relative to the community. Lot who is responsible for showing hospitality to his guests’ attempts to avert this outrage, offered his own virgin daughters to the mob. This makes some sense given the mores of the time; clearly a woman cannot be emasculated, nevertheless Anna is correct to find this deeply disturbing. After all is not handing your daughters over to be raped by men also outrageous? Who would deny that women are humiliated and degraded and treated as inferiors when they are raped by men? Lot’s priorities here are clearly selective.

    On numerous occasions I have had interlocutors point to this passage and argue that the scriptures teach that rape is permissible. This text is cited to show that the canonical scriptures teach a misogynistic morality whereby women are seen as inferior to men. This response is too quick; for starters, those who reason this way make a straightforward error in interpretation. That of conflating what scriptures records with what it prescribes.

    Some examples can demonstrate this; in the book of Acts the martyrdom of Stephen is recorded. The passage tells us that at Stephens’s trial, “They produced false witnesses, who testified, ‘This fellow never stops speaking against this holy place and against the law.’” And the text goes on to record what happens after this event,

    they covered their ears and, yelling at the top of their voices, they all rushed at him, dragged him out of the city and began to stone him. Meanwhile, the witnesses laid their clothes at the feet of a young man named Saul…. And Saul was there, giving approval to his death. On that day a great persecution broke out against the church at Jerusalem.

    The text records perjury and judicial murder yet no one would sensibly infer from this that Acts teaches that perjury and judicial murder of Christians is justified. Similarly, the gospel of Matthew records Herod ordering the murder of John the Baptist, this does not entail that Matthew’s gospel teaches that we should kill John the Baptist. The same is correct here; the text records Lot offering his virgin daughters to a mob. It does not follow from this that the text teaches that this kind of conduct is permissible or good.

    In fact, I want to suggest that a careful reading of these narratives gives a different picture. I think one important feature of the patriarchal narratives is that they record the mistakes and failures of Israel’s patriarchs. A good example is the case of Abraham. In Gen 15 Sarah is childless. God promises Abraham that “a son coming from your own body will be your heir.” Abraham tries to get a woman other than Sarah (Hagar) pregnant and succeeds in doing so. The result is a whole lot of domestic strife and rivalry much of which continues in the Jewish/Islamic struggles in the middle east today. What we note later in the text, however, is that God gives Abraham a child through Sarah. It is interesting that when Moses delivers laws in the Torah, of which Genesis is a kind of extended preface, he proposes laws that condemn the kind of treatment Abraham gave Hagar and Ishmael.

    Noah is another. Noah experimented with alcohol and got drunk. The result is he was shamed, possibly raped. Later passages in the proverbs warn about intoxication and again drunkenness is implicitly condemned in the Torah.

    Abraham’s children display similar flaws. One example is the seduction of Dinah. Gen 34 records how “Shechem son of Hamor … was drawn to Dinah daughter of Jacob, and he loved the girl and spoke tenderly to her.” This is elaborated in the next passages as involving pre-marital sex with her. After this Shechem asks his father Hamor to, “Get me this girl as my wife.” The response of Dinah’s brothers is to negotiate in bad faith, deceive the men of the city into getting circumcised and then when they are still recovering from this (imagine circumcision of adult males prior to the development of anaesthetics) they attack the city and kill the men in it. This action is again implicitly condemned by Moses when he passed a law in Deut 22:28 that states, “If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and seduces her and they are discovered, 29 he shall pay the girl’s father fifty shekels of silver. He must marry the girl, for he has violated her.” This law actually enjoins the very opposite of what Dinah’s brothers did; moreover, the language of Deut 22:28 alludes to that of Gen 34, it is almost is if the law is commentary on the actions of Dinah’s brothers.

    Examples could be multiplied; the point is that if one reads Genesis in context with the Torah it is evident that not everything the patriarchs did is held out as a paradigm of just conduct. Frequently they serve as object lessons of errors to avoid and their conduct is implicitly condemned elsewhere in the text. I think it is plausible to see Lot’s actions in Gen 19 as a graphic example of this. In the next Sunday Study I will elaborate on this more fully.

    [1] Robert A Gagnon The Bible and Homosexual Practice: Texts and Hermeneutics (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 2001) 46.
    [2] Ibid, 45.
    [3] Ibid, 46.
    [4] Ibid, 52.

  • Christian Blog Ranking Report for April 09 – HalfDone

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on HalfDone’s NZ blog stats for April; these stats make up part of the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for April 09:

    Top 10. name of blog HalfDone Rank

    Of Note:

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that are openly identified as Christian blogs on HalfDone’s ranking list.

    When Tumeke’s April stats are out we will compare them with HalfDone’s and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for April 09 later in the month.

  • Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs – March 09

    The MandM Top 10 New Zealand Christian Blogs for March 09, in the category of public discourse, are ranked by identifying Christian blogs then comparing Half Done’s March 09 stats with Tumeke’s March 09 stats and averaging them to obtain their overall March 09 ranking.

    Rank. [previous top 10 rank] Blog MandM (Half Done Tumeke)

    1. [1.] NZ Conservative 18 (8 – 28 )
    2. [2.] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (HalfDone) 19.5 (12 – 27)
    3. [5.] MandM 21 (7 – 35) [if correct uniques used on Tumeke: 2. MandM 19 (7-31)]
    3. [N] MacDoctor Moments 21 (25 – 17)
    4. [4.] Keeping Stock 29.5 (26 – 33)
    5. [6.] Being Frank 42* (39 – ??)
    6. [3.] The Briefing Room 48 (40 – 56)
    7. [8.] Samuel Dennis 49 (32 – 66)
    8. [10.] The Humanitarian Chronicle 49.5 (55 – 44)
    9. [9.] Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta Blog) 57 (53 – 61)
    10. [7.] Kiwi Polemicist 68 (63 – 73)

    * For blogs that only feature on one set of stats a score for the other set is estimated by factoring in the discrepancy between the two sets of stats given their different ranking methods; any blogs this effects are marked with an asterisk. We suggest that any blog not featuring on both should submit their blog to the ranking they are not currently on as it is not always possible for us to simply calculate the score that blog would have obtained.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s ranking descriptions. If you think your blog should be on the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blogs rankings contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings. More here.

  • The Coming Week: Two Apologetics Forums & Bloggers Drinks

    This Thursday, 7 May, Thinking Matters Auckland Lunchtime Forum: Bringing Faith and Logic out of the Closet at Laidlaw College, 12.30 – 1.30 pm.

    This Thursday, 7 May, Auckland Blogger Drinks from 6.30pm at Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland – if you are a blogger or a bloupie (blogger groupie) and you happen to be in Auckland on Thursday come and meet other bloggers.

    Next Tuesday, 12 May, Thinking Matters Auckland Dr Glenn Peoples on Religion in the Public Square at Laidlaw College at 7 pm.

    See you there 🙂

  • Christian Blog Rankings Report for March 09 – Tumeke

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on Tumeke’s NZ blog stats for March; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for March 09:
    1. MandM 35 [Incorrect uniques used due to stats going down; correct rank was 31 (score 237)]

    Top 10 Tumeke. name of blog Tumeke rank

    Of Note:

    • A change in the number 1 spot – well done Scrubbone!
    • All top 10 are well within the top 100; in fact Contra Celsum, Star Studded Super Step, Blessed Economist and True Paradigm all made the top 100 despite being just outside the top 10.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s ranking descriptions. If you think your blog should be on the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blogs rankings contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings.

    Now that Tumeke’s March stats are out we will compare them with HalfDone’s and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for March 09 shortly.

  • Divine Commands and Intuitions: A Response to Ken Perrott

    Ken Perrott from Open Parachute has asked me some questions about my views on morality and divine commands. Views I have repeatedly expressed on this blog. Given that others have from time to time asked me similar questions, and given the length of my response, I have decided to turn my answers into a post. [Ken’s questions are copied and pasted from the comments section of With God Anything can be Permitted: Another Bad Argument against Theistic Morality, numbered and italicised below]

    1. I think a key issue, one which should really be spelt out in detail, is the concept of “grounding moral duties in divine commands”. What does this mean?

    Basically, I think the relationship between the moral properties of being wrong and the property of being contrary to God commands is analogous to the relationship between water and H2O. Just as we explain the existence and nature of water by identifying it with H2O. I would explain the existence and nature of wrongness by identifying it with the property of being contrary to Gods commands.

    2. So what do you mean by “divine commands”? How do you get them? Do you hear voices?

    No I don’t hear voices. God is an immaterial being and hence has no vocal chords. I think it is possible for God to create an audible voice issuing a command but I think that this would be fairly atypical. In any event, I do not think that an auditory voice is necessary for issuing a command. I can communicate a command orally but I can also do it via e-mail, text, sign language, waving a flag, etc.

    In the normal and typical cases, I think divine commands are usually discerned via a person’s conscience. One intuitively sees that certain actions are right and others wrong and hence intuitively perceives certain imperatives such as “do not torture children for fun,” etc. Moreover, I think anyone whose faculties are functioning properly perceives God’s commands this way whether they believe in his existence or not.

    The H2O analogy may illuminate this. We know that the property of being water is the property of being H2O. However, people can know something is water immediately via perception even if they do not have any beliefs about molecules, atoms or contemporary science. Pre-European Maori, for example, knew about the existence of water and competently used water for centuries before they knew about the existence of hydrogen and oxygen.

    I think something analogous holds with divine commands. The property of being wrong is the property of being contrary to divine commands; however, people can immediately perceive via intuition what is wrong even if they do not believe in divine commands.

    Hence, on my view, atheists can know what is right and wrong. The real question is whether atheism can adequately explain the existence of right and wrong or whether, given atheism, it is likely that moral properties such as right and wrong exist. These are separate questions.

    A person can believe in the existence of something and yet be committed to beliefs, which if true, entail that what they believe is a fantasy. I suspect this is precisely the way Atheists view Christians.

    3. And if such a command tells you commit an act which conflicts with your moral intuitions and logic – which one do you follow?

    If I understand Ken correctly here, he is asking me what I would do if I believed that God had commanded an action that I intuitively considered to be wrong. This is actually a big topic, worthy of a post in and of itself, I do plan to post something more substantial on this in the future, here I can only summarise my current position.

    As I noted above, I agree with Ken that people can intuitively recognise certain principles of right and wrong. I would, however, point out that these intuitions are fallible. So, in contrast to what Ken appears to think, I would not assume that every time there was a clash between what I believed God’s commands are and my intuitions that the latter are correct. At the same time I also think our interpretations about what God commands are also fallible and so I would not assume that my interpretations of what God commanded were always correct either. In fact, given that I have already argued that one knows God’s commands intuitively through one’s conscience, intuitively perceiving an action is wrong is some evidence that God forbids it and that claims to the contrary are mistaken.

    My answer then to Ken’s question, what do you do if one’s interpretation of God’s commands conflicts with one’s moral intuitions? is that it depends on one’s epistemic situation. If the belief that God has commanded a particular action is something that, after critical reflection, seemed to me well established by the evidence and by contrast, the contrary intuition that the action was wrong was fairly weak, peripheral and less plausible then I would go against the intuition. If, on the other hand, the intuition was very clear and seemed extremely plausible while the rival interpretation of God’s commands was, by comparison, fairly weak and tentative then I would follow the intuition.

    To turn to one example Ken mentions, the terrorist attacks in New York on September 11, 2000, I think the intuition that it is wrong to kill innocent human beings is a very strong one. Whereas I do not believe that the case from, say, scripture or theological tradition for killing innocent people in this way is very strong at all (in fact both scripture and tradition are fairly unanimously opposed to terrorism of this sort).

    On other issues my thinking is different. For example some people appear to find it self-evident that there is nothing wrong with homosexual conduct. I myself do not have this intuition, nor do most people I know, in fact, many defenders of homosexual conduct I have spoken to admit that they personally find the idea of two men having sex disgusting but defend the “liberal” view in spite of this. Moreover, for I do not think it is implausible to conclude that much of the contemporary acceptance of homosexual conduct is due to cultural conditioning rather than a sudden direct insight gained in the mid 20th century. The arguments typically given for the permissibility of homosexual sex are fairly weak and frequently consist of no more than castigating others as bigots. On the other hand, I think the theological case against homosexual conduct from scripture and tradition is fairly strong.

    I have posted a bit more about my thoughts on this in my post Brink on Dialetical Equilibrium.

    4. After all, I keep hearing of people who have committed murder as a result of “divine commands” and society usually locks them up.

    I am not sure what Ken intends to prove with this point. Ken is correct that some people who suffer from a mental disorder believe that God has commanded them to kill. I don’t think this proves much. I know of people who suffer from dementia who have had hallucinations that there is a river running through their lounge. Does it follow then that referring to the existence of rivers is somehow dubious? In fact, mental patients can also have faulty “moral intuitions” and moral logic quite independently of any theological beliefs they have.

    Despite this, Ken maintains, correctly, that people whose cognitive faculties are functioning properly can intuitively discern the presence of right and wrong. I agree with him, the difference is that I believe that what they discern is in fact the property of being in accord with or contrary to divine commands. Ken clearly does not. The question that some theistic critics of secular morality poses is not whether atheists can discern right and wrong, they can; the question is whether, if atheism is true, right and wrong actually exist.

    RELATED POSTS:
    With God Anything can be Permitted: Another Bad Argument against Theistic Morality
    See labels:
    Divine Command Theory
    Euthyphro

  • Bullying (Again) and Coming Posts

    Matt and I have not written much of late for MandM due to the bullying problem having arisen again. Christian was assaulted/bullied on four separate occasions at school last week. Twice during class and in both instances the teachers failed to address the matter adequately. In addition, despite the most serious incident happening at lunchtime, he was knocked to the ground and kicked by a pack of boys, the first we heard of it was after school when he came home as he was sent back to class despite repeatedly asking for us to be phoned; when he went back to class another boy punched him three times.

    We have not sent him to school since all this happened, we have been seeking legal advice and are trying to decide what to do going forward as he has Aspergers so does not want any change on top of everything else, the mere thought of another school or being home-schooled with his siblings makes him panic but neither he or us has any doubt that he will get hit again if he returns to school and none of us have any faith in the school to be able to keep him safe or have their teachers act properly against the perpetrators if it happens in class – our complaint that we are drafting to the board of trustees names 4 of his 6 teachers. Writing it takes precedence over drafting new blog posts, at least the sort of posts that require our heads to be focused and require several hours of research and writing.

    So as you can imagine our heads are not really on MandM – please chat amongst yourselves, if anyone has guest posts they want to submit that would be cool.

    Coming up though, we do have some posts in the pipeline:

    Matt has a two part response to John W. Loftus’ The Christian Illusion of Moral Superiority – it is about 1/3 edited and needs a couple of quotes checked so it is not far away; he has a response to Ken on Divine Commands and Intuitions that I think he said if I could edit today is ready to go – I will have to have a look; he has something on Tooley’s deontological argument from evil and Plantinga’s response that apparently just needs editing and a footnote to be chased up and he is writing a guest post for Debunking Christianity that we will cross post here and he still owes me the piece on Sodom and Gomorrah he promised me and Anna last weekend. There are a handful of other things on his I-must-get-to-that list too – Kaiwai posted something on our Is Abortion Liberal series on his blog that he should respond to and he has some other stuff in his head as well.

    I have been working on some of the reader requests and I have a half-written post of the foreshore and seabed legislation with a jurisprudential spin – my lecturer told me yesterday that someone is submitting a shadow report to the UN on Thursday regarding a human rights complaint on this issue and it is available online currently so I need to read that first. I have in my head the why we have the Colosseum on our banner post and have gotten as far as some research on it, I also have a domestic violence post rattling around my head as well that I should be able to bring together easily enough by hacking up an old law paper and adding some thoughts from my recent reading on the matter. There will be something turning up in the next month or so on human rights, what are they are they not and a specific examination of both ‘property rights’ and ‘health rights’ (because I have to produce a 4,000 word essay on the subject to pass one of my papers so I may as well turn it into a blog post). Oh and of course Tumeke’s March rankings finally came out on Sunday so I need to do the report and run the top 10 NZ Christian blogs for March – no sign of HalfDone’s April rankings so I have a breather there for that report.

    So please bear with us and we will work on getting something online soon.