Last week I looked at the Straw Man Fallacy, today I want to explore the tu quoque fallacy. In latin tu quoque (too kwo-kwee) means “you too”; in fact, the phrase “you did it too” is a good, succinct account of this fallacy. A tu quoque occurs when one rebuts a particular criticism of one’s own position by showing one’s opponent’s position is subject to the same criticism; this is done instead of showing that one’s own position is not susceptible to the criticism.
A good example is the following segment of a CNN Interview with Osama Bin Laden,
Q: Now, the United States government says that you are still funding military training camps here in Afghanistan for militant, Islamic fighters and that you’re a sponsor of international terrorism. … Are these accusations true? …
Osama Bin Laden: … At the time that they condemn any Muslim who calls for his right, they receive the highest top official of the Irish Republican Army at the White House as a political leader, while woe, all woe is the Muslims if they cry out for their rights. Wherever we look, we find the US as the leader of terrorism and crime in the world. The US does not consider it a terrorist act to throw atomic bombs at nations thousands of miles away, when it would not be possible for those bombs to hit military troops only. These bombs were rather thrown at entire nations, including women, children and elderly people and up to this day the traces of those bombs remain in Japan. The US does not consider it terrorism when hundreds of thousands of our sons and brothers in Iraq died for lack of food or medicine. So, there is no base for what the US says and this saying does not affect us.[1]
Here Bin Laden was asked to respond to the claim that he has been sponsoring terrorism and training Islamic militants. Bin Laden argued that there is no basis for this claim because the United States supports terrorism and has itself engaged in activities which can justifiably be labelled ‘terrorist’. Bin Laden’s comments about the United States may or may not be true but either way it would not answer the questions as to whether Bin Laden has been sponsoring terrorism. It is possible, after all, that both Bin Laden and the United States sponsor and engage in terrorism.
The Difference Between a Tu Quoque and Internal Criticism
It is important to distinguish this argument from another similar argument, which I will call internal criticism. Internal criticism occurs when one argues against an opponent’s position by noting that one proposition the opponent holds conflicts with another proposition he holds.
An example is Alvin Plantinga’s famous argument in God and other Minds. In this book Plantinga looks at the question of whether belief in the existence of God is irrational because it cannot be proven to be true with a non-circular argument (more…)