Year: 2009

  • AUSA: ‘FREE’ Candy for your Vote

    Following on from More Evidence of Student Association Delusions of Grandeur, where I shared Auckland University Students Assocation’s (AUSA) unfathomable intentions to incorporate the UN Declaration of Human Rights into their constitution, a fellow student and reader of this blog, brought my attention to today’s email to all University of Auckland students which he described as “bribery now to get what they want.” I must concur:

    Student apathy was at its worst today when we failed to get 200 people to turn up to the quad to hold the AUSA Winter General Meeting. However, all is not lost – we are going to try again!

    So come to the quad at 1pm on Thursday the 27th of August (tomorrow) and vote in favour of putting the Universal Declaration of Human Rights into the AUSA Constitution! We were only about 20 people short so I cannot stress enough that YOU REALLY WILL MAKE ALL THE DIFFERENCE!

    Even if the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is not your thing, we will be giving out candy! FOR FREE! Maybe even a few muesli bars for the health-conscious amongst you. All you need to do is bring along your uni ID card and flash it in favour of human rights!

    SEE YOU IN THE QUAD AT 1PM, THURSDAY 28 AUGUST. DO IT.

    Again I am left wondering how on earth this move can “MAKE ALL THE DIFFERENCE” for human rights. Again we see the disregard for proper constitutional process in the statement “All you need to do is bring along your uni ID card and flash it in favour of human rights!” AUSA membership is voluntary, as such, possession of a Uni ID card does not mean that you are an AUSA member and are entitled to vote but they do not seem to care about this detail.

    So basically you can receive material benefits if you vote the way they want you to (doesn’t matter if you’re not really to eligible to vote) and all this is in the name of AUSA’s strong commitment to human rights.

    This would be funnier if I wasn’t paying for it.

  • Dear Mr McCully,

    The law criminalises smacking, the best and most faithful reading of the law deems any use of force for the purposes of parental correction criminal; experts in legal interpretation agree on this. The people have objected loudly and all you have done is issue a promise to not enforce the law; a promise that can only be kept for as long as you govern, a promise that offends the duty of a government to ensure that the law is enforced.

    Your so called “safeguards” offer no long term protection. What happens to those safeguards in the future if the Greens hold the balance of power? Or is that what is really going on – you won’t change the law because you want it to be easy to eradicate smacking long term in New Zealand?

    I am not fooled. Courts are primarily directed by the black letter of the law not promises to not enforce it made by past governments. This government has a chance to offer parents protection that a future government will find harder to undo and it will fail if these “safeguards” are all it does.

    Promises to not enforce a law that criminalises smacking are not good enough. If the government does not wish for parents who lightly smack their children for the purposes of correction to be prosecuted then it must change the law now, before the possibility of a new government arises.

    Regards,

    Madeleine Flannagan

    The Hon Murray McCully emailed me (I suspect generically) this morning in response to my first email, Dear Cabinet,. The above is a response, sent to all members of Cabinet, to Mr McCully’s email to me which is pasted below,

    The Prime Minister has announced that the Government is introducing safeguards to give parents comfort they will not be criminalised for lightly smacking their children.

    The safeguards follow the Citizens Initiated Referendum on smacking. The referendum result reinforces the message that New Zealanders do not want to see good parents criminalised for a light smack.

    To give parents comfort that this will not happen, Cabinet has agreed on a number of measures. These are:

    The Police and Ministry of Social Development chief executive will lead a review of Police and Child, Youth & Family policies and procedures, including the referral process between the two agencies, to identify any changes that are necessary or desirable to ensure good parents are treated as Parliament intended. The Commissioner of Police and Ministry of Social Development chief executive will seek an independent person to assist in the conduct of the review and will report back by 1 December 2009.

    We will be bringing forward the delivery of the report from the Ministry of Social Development chief executive on data and trends and the effect of the law change from the end of the year to late September/early October. The Minister of Social Development will table the report in Parliament.

    The Government will invite Police to continue to report on a six-monthly or annual basis for the next three years on the operation of the law, and invite Police to include data on cases where parents or caregivers say the force used on the child was reasonable in the circumstances.

    If future Police data indicates a worrying trend, the law will be changed to ensure that good New Zealand parents are not criminalised for lightly smacking.

    The Government believes the law is working as intended, but we want to give parents an assurance that a National-led Government will continue to monitor the way the law is being implemented.

    RELATED POSTS:
    Dear Cabinet,
    Fisking Margaret Mayman: The Flawed Moral Theology on the Smacking Referendum
    Fisking Ian Hassall: The Arbitrary Ethical Reasoning on the Smacking Referendum
    No Defences Permitted for the Accused
    MandM Smacking Label

  • Wet Paint: Forced to Echo UPDATE

    This morning comments just would not even load in either Firefox or Explorer so I was forced to switch over to JS Kit’s Echo.

    Now now comments look awful but at least you can read them.

    I will do my best to modify the code today to make them look a bit tidier – I am supposed to be researching not mucking around re-writing code.

    If JS Kit had kept their promise to get my comments that are stuck queued in their system fixed within the one week time frame they assured me of 3 weeks ago I could have simply imported all comments to WordPress and all these problems would not be happening.

    UPDATE:
    As you can see the comments are a little tidier. I cannot work out the classes for the borders so they are not as tidy as I would like. I also cannot get CommentLuv to work or increase the size of the combox. But these are small details as JS Kit have finally sorted out all our queued comments, with these now back in Bloggers comments feed we are now clear to move to WordPress so I won’t bother fixing the issues here, we’ll just move.

  • David Lindsey on “Politics, Religion and Morality”

    You’re invited to the final event in the Thinking Matters Auckland God, Morality and Society series:

    What: David Lindsey on “Politics, Religion and Morality”
    When:
    Tuesday 1 Sept – 7:00pm
    Where:
    Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format:
    Talk followed by questions, answers and discussion.
    Cost: Free but donations are appreciated

    Decisions made by government bodies are not created in a vacuum. Policies are a consequence of the influence of ideologies and worldviews. In New Zealand an increasing preference for secular ideologies since WW2 has resulted in government policies increasingly at odds with orthodox evangelical teaching. This seminar will discuss these changes and suggest that Christianity provides a firmer foundation for governmental action than the alternatives.

    David Lindsey is uniquely qualified to speak on political issues due to his qualifications as well his career spanning both the private and public sectors. He holds an MA (First Class Honours) in Social and Economic Geography, aDWS (Diploma of World View Studies), a PGDip (Arts) (Political Studies) and is currently completing a PhD in Political Studies at the University of Auckland specialising in Governance. His thesis topic is “How Parliament Handles Moral Issues.”

    After gaining his MA, he worked for 13 years as a consultant to the property development industry and as an advisor in local government. His work in strategic urban development led him to speak on the governance issues with key decision makers at all levels, including cabinet ministers, central and local government politicians, CEOs, and foreign diplomats.

    David’s expertise in governance issues has been sought after by numerous media and he has made personal appearances on the network news for TVNZ and TV3, documentaries on Triangle TV and Shine TV, Radio NZ’s Morning Report, the BBC in Britain, bFM, the Dialogue page of the NZ Herald, articles in the Challenge Weekly, as well as many industry publications.

    He has had numerous articles published in both academic journals and the mainstream media, including a chapter on moral issues in two editions of NZ Politics and Government, New Zealand’s foremost sourcebook on NZ politics. He has been invited to lecture in both New Zealand and the United States at the University of California San Diego and Loyola Univeristy Chicago and during his professional career was a sought after public speaker speaking to many industry and academic groups.

    He is currently teaching courses on NZ Politics in both the Political Studies and Planning departments of the University of Auckland. He has presented at politics conferences in New Zealand, Australia and the United States, and for three months worked with Prof. Philip Cowley, an acknowledged world-expert on moral issues and parliament, in the United Kingdom. After making a mid-career decision to earn his PhD, he was offered four full doctoral scholarships in both New Zealand and Australia. Currently, he is the recipient of a Top Achievers Doctoral Scholarship, awarded by the NZ government to the top 5% of PhD students. David has also earned a Diploma of Worldview Studies, with a 92% grade average, from Laidlaw College.


  • More Evidence of Student Association Delusions of Grandeur

    I just got this in my inbox:

    AN OPPORTUNITY HAS ARISEN:
    On Wednesday the 26th of August at the AUSA [Auckland University Students Association] Winter General Meeting there has been an opening to incorporate the UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS into the AUSA constitution.

    WE NEED 200 PEOPLE IN THE QUAD TO VOTE IN FAVOUR AT THE WINTER GENERAL MEETING!
    WEDNESDAY 26th AUGUST at 1pm.

    WHY IS THIS NECESSARY AND IMPORTANT?

    The Universal Declaration is a common statement of mutual aspirations – a shared vision of a more equitable and just world. By incorporating this into its constitution, AUSA would commit itself to these human rights norms. If you care about people and their rights, make sure your voice is heard on this issue.

    PLEASE COME ALONG! Don’t just assume that enough people will turn up without your effort – you REALLY will make a difference!

    Now one wonders what AUSA think they will achieve by incorporating the UN Declaration into their association? The mind boggles. They wrote “By incorporating this into its constitution, AUSA would commit itself to these human rights norms.” What does this mean or rather what do they think it means?

    Maybe they think that students won’t have human right protection without this move.
    Maybe they think that they, a student association, are a body in the nature of a state or that they perform a public function that places them on par with a state but even if that were true they would be obligated to uphold Human Rights regardless of whether it was in their constitution or not.
    Maybe they hope that incorporating it will make them into a state.
    Maybe they think that by them incorporating it into their constitution that action will, like some kind of butterfly effect, improve the human rights of people in other countries.
    Maybe they want to make a big gesture so they can feel all warm and fuzzy… it is raining in Auckland today so maybe that is it.

    Either way it seems a fairly pointless way to spend an afternoon especially if they think they can achieve it with “200 people” turning up; they need 200 members to turn up if they want to amend their constitution. AUSA despite their compulsory funding is the only university students association in New Zealand with voluntary membership – I received the call to come and I am not a member. It is almost tempting to turn up and see if they intend to check those voting are in fact members or not.

    I wonder if they know that the UN Declaration of Human Rights calls for Freedom of Association? Something that, if they had their way, they’d undermine in a heartbeat with a return to compulsory membership.

  • Top 10 NZ Christian Blogs – July 09

    The Top 10 New Zealand Christian Blogs for July 09 are as follows:

    1. [2.] MandM 13 (5 – 21)
    2. [3.] MacDoctor Moments 16 (18 – 14)
    3. [1.] NZ Conservative 18.5 (13 – 24 )
    4. [4.] Something Should Go Here, Maybe Later (HalfDone) 25 (17 – 33)
    5. [5=] Keeping Stock 26.5 (21 – 32)
    6. [6.] Say Hello to my Little Friend (Beretta Blog) 32.5 (27 – 38)
    7. [5=] Being Frank 33 (44 – 22)
    8. [7.] The Humanitarian Chronicle 43.5 (30 – 57)
    9. [8.] Sustain:If:Able Kiwi 50.5 (52 – 49)
    10. [9.] The Briefing Room 54 (55 – 53)

    Rank. [previous top 10 rank] Blog MandM (Half Done – Tumeke)

    To obtain our stats we run searches on Half Done’s July 09 NZ stats and Tumeke’s July 09 NZ stats for openly Christian blogs then we average those blogs scores to obtain their overall scores.

    If you think your blog should make our rankings make sure you are listed on both Tumeke and HalfDone’s rankings as an identifiably Christian blog.

  • Christian Blog Ranking Report for July 09 – Tumeke

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on Tumeke’s NZ blog stats for July; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for July 09:

    Top 10 Tumeke. name of blog Tumeke rank

    Of Note:

    • Our first time in the number 1 spot on Tumeke.
    • No newcomers to the top 10, again, some position changing demonstrating the growth in the kiwi Christian blogosphere.
    • Christian News New Zealand 68, Kiwi Polemicist 71, Star Studded Super Step 92 each made the top 100 despite being outside the top 10.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s ranking descriptions. If you think your blog should be included contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings.

    Now that Tumeke’s July stats are out we will compare them with the HalfDone July report and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for July 09 shortly.