Author: Madeleine

  • Thinking Matters Winter Series: God, Morality and Society

    Want something to do on those wintery Tuesday nights? Thinking Matters Auckland has lined up a winter series addressing apologetic issues around God, Morality and Society.

    Dates, speakers and topics as follows:

    Semester Break

    As each event in the series approaches more information on each speaker and their topic will be provided.

    Thinking Matters

  • MandM on Opposing Views in Religion and Society

    We were contacted a while back by Opposing Views and asked if we would consider allowing them to link to us. We had a look at their site, liked what we saw and said yes. We are now featured on their Religion and Society page as a recommended site.

    “Dr Matthew Flannagan” is also officially in their pool of experts to call on for when they present their for and against articles on matters of religion and society. To suggest a topic they could use Matt on you can click on the contact link on their site and recommend him 😉

  • Don’t Forget!

    Tonight!
    Thinking Matters JP Moreland on Faith and Reason at Laidlaw College at 7pm.

    Next Thursday 7 May
    Blogger Drinks from 6.30pm at Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland.

    See you there 🙂

  • PJ O’Rourke on Perfect Form: A Review of Guidelines for Bias-Free Writing

    Given that PJ O’Rourke will be speaking in Auckland this week (see details, Invisible Hand versus Visible Fist) I thought I would share this gem with you; it is a rant by PJ O’Rourke on politically correct language, Perfect Form: A Review of Guidelines for Bias-Free Writing.

    It is so funny that it is hard to read in one go, as you can’t help but laugh so hard you can no longer read and it causes you to immediately want to read bits of it aloud to whoever you happen to be near so if you are at work and yours is not that kind of workplace, I’d wait ’til you get home to read it.

    Hat Tip: Lydia McGrew at What’s Wrong with the World (Lydia also links to another send-up of PC madness by John C. Wright in the same post.)

  • Go on and Rubberneck

    In case you have noticed and wondered at the recent flurry of arrivals from Kiwiblog in the Live Traffic Feed you might click here and then once on the page use “control f” then type in “abortion” and then read the defamatory statement about me (and Matt) and the ensuing debate that began on Friday.

    Do not think badly of David Farrar for not removing the statement. I asked him to leave it there as these statements, and variations of them, began 11 years ago when Matt and I were student politicians. They have not gone away despite us hiring lawyers, more than once, so maybe it is time to meet them head on and expose them for the lies they are.

    The person posting under the name Blockhead helpfully happened to have documentation to hand that also clarified things so look out for his/her contributions. Oh, and feel free to make liberal use of the karma buttons on the site.

  • Ahmadinejad, Tumeke, Boycotts, Blog Stats and Holocaust Denial

    A boycott has been launched of Tumeke’s blog stats. Prominent kiwi-bloggers Whaleoil, HalfDone and Keeping Stock have each set out their cases; charges range from holocaust denier to holocaust promoter.

    “the state of Israel was created ‘on the pretext of Jewish suffering’ from the second world war”The authors at Tumeke are politically hard-left activists; most notable is Tim Selwyn, who was convicted and served prison time for sedition after he threw an axe through the window of the Prime Minister’s electorate office. In addition, the Tumeke blog publishes a lot of material that we disagree with, which is routinely badly argued for and poorly supported. Not surprisingly, this site does not feature on our blogroll. The only thing that Tumeke publishes that we find of interest is their blog rankings. They helpfully publish these on a sub-blog, Tumeke NZ Blogosphere.

    The current boycott is over some inflammatory remarks Tim Selwyn made in response to the Iranian President Ahmadinejad’s remarks at the recent UN’s anti-racism conference.

    Tim cited The Guardian who reported that

    …[protestors] heckled Ahmadinejad after he branded Israel a “cruel and oppressive racist regime”. He said the state of Israel was created “on the pretext of Jewish suffering” from the second world war.

    Tim then said,

    Problem is though, what he said, it’s all true isn’t it? The Jewish State is set up for Jews – quite specifically to benefit them as a race and a religion – and they carry out massacres in refugee camps (like they did earlier this year) in order to carry out the colonial/land confiscation/occupation/subjugation template upon which Zionism has been practiced. That’s all true isn’t it – no matter how you cut it. So he said it at the right place but he said it at the wrong time – Israel’s Holocaust Remembrance Day gave the extra pressure on Poland and Germany to cave. [Emphasis added]

    We can definitely see how this is inflammatory. The phrase “it’s all true” suggests that Tim agrees with everything Ahmadinejad said, including the statement about a “pretext” of Jewish suffering. However you could read Tim as specifying the charge of Israel being a racist state as the element he agrees with (a highly questionable and extreme statement). What the all applies to is ambiguous and could be interpreted either way.

    We are left uncertain whether Tim is a holocaust denier or not; and uncertain that, if he is, what that requires us to do. We have not seen any evidence to suggest that he is a holocaust promoter. That said, we have seen enough to stand firm in our decision to not add Tumeke to our blogroll and to continue to have little time for the content of their blog; we will not be offering their authors any guest posts in the near future.

    However, we fail to see that a link between featuring on Tumeke’s blog rankings and endorsing the content on Tumeke’s site has been established; the suggestion that MandM featuring on the blog stats on the sub-blog Tumeke Blogosphere amounts to MandM being complicit in or endorsing the comments make on the political blog Tumeke doesn’t follow.

    Given this, joining the protest is not morally required although we respect the decisions made by our fellow bloggers to withdraw their blogs from his stats completely. The situation for MandM is slightly more complex as we run the Top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings. For us to join the boycott we would have to not only withdraw our stats from Tumeke Blogosphere’s rankings but also cease using them.

    The MandM top 10 score is obtained by averaging Tumeke Blogosphere’s stats with HalfDone’s. On HalfDone’s stats MandM is ranked number 1 Christian blog, on Tumeke’s stats we are usually ranked around number 3 as different formulae are used to obtain each. If we drop Tumeke’s stats from our formula then we are left with only HalfDone’s which automatically hands us the number 1 spot on our own rankings; we are concerned that joining the boycott will look like a bit of an ‘own goal’.

    On the other hand, prior to the boycott, not every Christian blog that HalfDone ranked featured on Tumeke Blogosphere’s stats and now a couple of the Christian blogs that did have joined the boycott so they too will no longer feature on Tumeke’s stats. This means that I now have too many blogs that do not feature on Tumeke’s stats to make my formula fair. The obvious solution is that I either stop using Tumeke’s stats (might as well join the boycott) or I develop my own formula or I stop doing the stats.

    So until these things become clearer or further evidence or argument is presented, we will remain with the status quo and will not be joining the boycott. Feel free to help us work through the issues in the comments.

  • Coming Events Reminder: JP Moreland on Faith and Reason

    I trust those of you who started back at Uni today survived the shock. Now that you have your thinking caps back on, make sure next week’s event is in your diary.

    Next Tuesday come to our Thinking Matters Auckland DVD screening:DVD Screening

    What: Dr JP Moreland on Faith and Reason
    When: Tuesday 28 April – 7:00pm
    Where: Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format: DVD followed by discussion (Matt will be available to fire questions at)
    Cost: Free!

    Dr Moreland is distinguished professor of Philosophy at Talbot School of Theology in California. In this DVD, he will talk about the importance of truth in religion, the evidence for monotheism and his own personal experience in coming to the Christian faith. … more