Author: Madeleine

  • The Coming Week: Two Apologetics Forums & Bloggers Drinks

    This Thursday, 7 May, Thinking Matters Auckland Lunchtime Forum: Bringing Faith and Logic out of the Closet at Laidlaw College, 12.30 – 1.30 pm.

    This Thursday, 7 May, Auckland Blogger Drinks from 6.30pm at Galbraiths, 2 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, Auckland – if you are a blogger or a bloupie (blogger groupie) and you happen to be in Auckland on Thursday come and meet other bloggers.

    Next Tuesday, 12 May, Thinking Matters Auckland Dr Glenn Peoples on Religion in the Public Square at Laidlaw College at 7 pm.

    See you there 🙂

  • Christian Blog Rankings Report for March 09 – Tumeke

    Here are the top 10 NZ Christian blogs based on Tumeke’s NZ blog stats for March; these stats are used in the calculations for the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for March 09:
    1. MandM 35 [Incorrect uniques used due to stats going down; correct rank was 31 (score 237)]

    Top 10 Tumeke. name of blog Tumeke rank

    Of Note:

    • A change in the number 1 spot – well done Scrubbone!
    • All top 10 are well within the top 100; in fact Contra Celsum, Star Studded Super Step, Blessed Economist and True Paradigm all made the top 100 despite being just outside the top 10.

    Note: This list only includes Christian blogs that openly identify as Christian blogs on Tumeke’s ranking descriptions. If you think your blog should be on the MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blogs rankings contact Tim Selwyn of Tumeke and ask him to change your blog description to include something identifiably Christian on his rankings.

    Now that Tumeke’s March stats are out we will compare them with HalfDone’s and publish the overall MandM top 10 NZ Christian Blog rankings for March 09 shortly.

  • Bullying (Again) and Coming Posts

    Matt and I have not written much of late for MandM due to the bullying problem having arisen again. Christian was assaulted/bullied on four separate occasions at school last week. Twice during class and in both instances the teachers failed to address the matter adequately. In addition, despite the most serious incident happening at lunchtime, he was knocked to the ground and kicked by a pack of boys, the first we heard of it was after school when he came home as he was sent back to class despite repeatedly asking for us to be phoned; when he went back to class another boy punched him three times.

    We have not sent him to school since all this happened, we have been seeking legal advice and are trying to decide what to do going forward as he has Aspergers so does not want any change on top of everything else, the mere thought of another school or being home-schooled with his siblings makes him panic but neither he or us has any doubt that he will get hit again if he returns to school and none of us have any faith in the school to be able to keep him safe or have their teachers act properly against the perpetrators if it happens in class – our complaint that we are drafting to the board of trustees names 4 of his 6 teachers. Writing it takes precedence over drafting new blog posts, at least the sort of posts that require our heads to be focused and require several hours of research and writing.

    So as you can imagine our heads are not really on MandM – please chat amongst yourselves, if anyone has guest posts they want to submit that would be cool.

    Coming up though, we do have some posts in the pipeline:

    Matt has a two part response to John W. Loftus’ The Christian Illusion of Moral Superiority – it is about 1/3 edited and needs a couple of quotes checked so it is not far away; he has a response to Ken on Divine Commands and Intuitions that I think he said if I could edit today is ready to go – I will have to have a look; he has something on Tooley’s deontological argument from evil and Plantinga’s response that apparently just needs editing and a footnote to be chased up and he is writing a guest post for Debunking Christianity that we will cross post here and he still owes me the piece on Sodom and Gomorrah he promised me and Anna last weekend. There are a handful of other things on his I-must-get-to-that list too – Kaiwai posted something on our Is Abortion Liberal series on his blog that he should respond to and he has some other stuff in his head as well.

    I have been working on some of the reader requests and I have a half-written post of the foreshore and seabed legislation with a jurisprudential spin – my lecturer told me yesterday that someone is submitting a shadow report to the UN on Thursday regarding a human rights complaint on this issue and it is available online currently so I need to read that first. I have in my head the why we have the Colosseum on our banner post and have gotten as far as some research on it, I also have a domestic violence post rattling around my head as well that I should be able to bring together easily enough by hacking up an old law paper and adding some thoughts from my recent reading on the matter. There will be something turning up in the next month or so on human rights, what are they are they not and a specific examination of both ‘property rights’ and ‘health rights’ (because I have to produce a 4,000 word essay on the subject to pass one of my papers so I may as well turn it into a blog post). Oh and of course Tumeke’s March rankings finally came out on Sunday so I need to do the report and run the top 10 NZ Christian blogs for March – no sign of HalfDone’s April rankings so I have a breather there for that report.

    So please bear with us and we will work on getting something online soon.

  • Lunchtime Forum: Bringing Faith and Logic out of the Closet

    You’re invited to a lunchtime forum to get a taste of what happens at Thinking Matters’ Tuesday seminars:

    What: Dr Glenn Peoples and Dr Matthew Flannagan speaking on Bringing Faith and Logic out of the Closet
    When: Thursday 7 May 12:30-1.30 pm
    Where: Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format: Brief talk followed by questions, answers and discussion
    Cost: Free but donations are appreciated

    Dr Flannagan will speak on faith and logic, their compatibility and relationship to each other and why Christians should not fear them as secular, humanistic tools. Dr Peoples will speak on how to use these tools to defend Christianity’s place in public life and provide a sample of his coming Tuesday talk.

    Drs Peoples and Flannagan both have years of experience defending the faith and dialoguing with sceptics, so bring a friend and bring your questions!

    Thinking Matters

  • April with MandM

    April April was another busy month for us. We had just over 4,500 unique visitors, another record high for us, and we had our highest ever stat day (since keeping stats) that saw us have 600 page views in one 24 hour period. Further, HalfDone’s half-April stats reported we were in the position of 6th most read New Zealand blog; we are looking forward to the official result for April coming out in the next day or so.

    Our Alexa stat continued to grow. At the time of writing this our Alexa score is 295,028, up considerably when you consider this time last month it was 365,051 a climb 170,000 spots in the past month and 6.8 million in the last year. (The Alexa number tells you how far away a website is from the position of number 1 most read website in the world – this is not limited to blogs)

    We have maintained our US traffic ranking, which varies from 10-15%. The US IP addresses suggest that most of this comes from US Universities with strong Philosophy departments, so we are absolutely delighted about that! We have also made the blogrolls of a few major US philosophy websites in the past month and would have no objection to being added to more 😉

    We have also been personally approached by three separate media websites comprising, international and local, who have asked for our feedback, participation and endorsement and our number of followers on Twitter has almost doubled.

    One of Matt’s recent publications, “Abortion and Capital Punishment,” came online; Thinking Matters Auckland, which we run, has announced its winter lineup and things are going well for all of us undertaking tertiary study. Still on the wish-list, however, is the elusive permanent, full-time lectureship for Matt; we will relocate anywhere in the world so if you have an ethics, philosophy of religion or theology vacancy please contact Matt to see his CV.

    In case you missed them, here are seven quick takes as to what was most read on MandM during April:

    Good Friday: Why Celebrate Easter?
    Matt wrote some reflections on the importance of ritual from a Protestant perspective. He shared some of his faith means to him personally alongside his cerebral insights.

    The Problem of Evil: Why does God Allow Suffering?
    Madeleine gave an overview of the problem of evil and the resources that Christian Philosophy offers to overcome it.

    How to become a Famous Blogger
    Madeleine sarcastically poked at those who insist that paying attention to blog rankings is evidence of bad motives.

    Guest Post: The Virtue of Christian Dogma
    Dominic Bnonn Tennant defended being dogmatic and rebutted the cliched and superficial epistemology that is often used to repudiate dogmatism.

    With God Anything can be Permitted: Another Bad Argument against Theistic Morality
    Matt responded to Ken Perrott of Open Parachute’s contention that because people appeal to divine commands on different sides of the same debate that it follows that theistic morality is relativistic.

    Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, William Lane Craig and the Argument from Harm
    In a two-part series Matt responded to Armstrong’s arguments for the conclusion that God is not an adequate foundation for morality because causing harm is a more plausible foundation.

    The Foundations of the Alexandrian Argument against Feticide
    In a six-part series Matt set out his Alexandrian Argument and then offered a critique of Beverly Wildung-Harrison’s claim that this argument is based on a mistranslation of the Septuagint.

  • Dr Glenn Peoples on Religion in the Public Square

    You are invited to the next Thinking Matters Auckland event in the God, Morality and Society winter series:

    What: Dr Glenn Peoples speaking on Religion in the Public Square
    When: Tuesday 12 May – 7:00pm
    Where: Lecture Room 2, Laidlaw College, 80 Central Park Drive, Henderson, West Auckland
    Format: Talk followed by questions, answers and discussion
    Cost: Free but donations are appreciated

    According to a number of influential thinkers, it is wrong for citizens to support policies because of their religious convictions because this would make those policies unjustified in a liberal democracy. Is this true?

    Dr Peoples argues that the rules used to exclude such policies are simply not workable or reasonable. He explains that more sensible and fair models of public justification do in fact permit us to promote policies that we hold on the basis of our religious convictions. However, when the architects of these improved models realise that they have now opened the door to religious participation in public life, they change the rules, shifting the goalpost and inventing special exceptions in order to maintain that those with religious convictions should keep them out of the public square.

    Dr Peoples graduated with his PhD in philosophy from the University of Otago in 2008 after completing undergrad and graduate degrees in theology. He runs New Zealand’s top Christian podcast, Say Hello to my Little Friend and is a very clear and articulate speaker.

    Religion in the Public Square

  • Compulsory Membership of Student Associations Has to End

    VUWSA (the Victoria University of Wellington Students Association) are at it again. Just last week David Farrar slammed them for their intended ANZAC day flag burning protest and this week they put Dave Crampton on notice for defamation and then retracted it at the 11th hour confessing that it was them at fault.

    I wouldn’t have a problem with these acts if they were just voicing their own left-wing pacifist opinions or wasting their own money on hiring lawyers to draft letters in the pursuit of frivolous and vexatious lawsuits but they are not. When they do these things they are doing so on behalf of every single student at the University of Victoria; they are paying for these things out of the pockets of every single student at the University of Victoria.

    There is no way every single student (and I’m confident that I remain on safe ground even if I invoke the majority) support flag burning protests being carried out at ANZAC day memorial parades or frivolous and vexatious law suits enacted purely to shut down criticism of those with different political views than their own. I am certain that had VUWSA asked students to voluntarily donate money for such activities they would not have raised any where near enough to fund them.

    The current National government, despite the fact that they did attempt to fix this last time they were in office (but their then coalition partner, New Zealand First, messed it up), do not have a voluntary student membership and funding bill even planned. Worse, they do not even see it as a priority or properly understand the extent and nature of the problem.

    The relevant bits in the New Zealand Bill of Rights are:

    13 Freedom of thought, conscience, and religion

    Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience, religion, and belief, including the right to adopt and to hold opinions without interference.

    Being forced to join and fund a political organisation that routinely expresses contrary viewpoints to your own, on your behalf and in your name, violates section 13.

    17 Freedom of association

    Everyone has the right to freedom of association.

    Being forced to join and fund a political organisation in order to obtain an education violates section 17.

    [Compulsory membership and funding also violates discrimination laws but as these are not human rights, despite the fact they are found in the Bill of Rights, I will not list them. The above real human rights are more than adequate.]

    For a brief overview as to some of what proponents of compulsory student associations have done to Matt and I see:

    Studying at Otago University no Riot
    Go on and Rubberneck

    For further reading see:

    VUWSA’s ANZAC Charade Is More Student Association Misrepresentation
    Student Choice

    If you wish to do more than read you could always email Anne Tolley (Minister of Tertiary Education) and Wayne Mapp (Minister of Defence and Associate Minister of Tertiary Education).