Author: MandM

  • Philosophers’ Carnival XCXI

    Welcome to MandM,  a New Zealand based philosophy of religion, ethics, theology, jurisprudence and social commentary blog and hosts of the XCXI edition of the Philosophers’ Carnival. We have a good selection of philosophy readings for your holiday perusal, so take a look around and enjoy.

    Epistemology
    Glenn Peoples brings us Hume on Induction and Miracles: Having a Bob Each Way? posted at Say Hello to my Little Friend. Glenn draws attention to a conflict between Hume’s stance on induction on the one hand, and the kind of argument that he uses against miracles on the other.

    History of Philosophy
    Jim S.
    brings us Thus Spoke Cratylus posted at Agent Intellect.  Jim provides critical commentary on Nietzsche’s essay “On Truth and Lies in a Nonmoral Sense.”

    Logic and Language
    Bryan brings us Where the Material Conditional gets its Truth Conditions posted at Soul Physics. Bryan discusses how to explain, in simple terms, the truth table for the material conditional, in particular, why conditionals with a false antecedant are true.

    Mind
    Gualtiero Piccinini brings us Two Kinds of Concept: Implicit and Explicit posted at Brains. Gualtiero links to a paper he has written explicating the distinction between implicit and explicit concepts.

    Jonathan Phillips brings us  Could Paris Hilton Ever Be Happy? posted at Experimental Philosophy. Jonathan sets out the results of some research on attributions of evaluative and non-evaluative mental state concepts. The discussion already begun in the comments section is also worth reading.

    Moral Philosophy
    Richard Chappell brings us Analyzing Act, Rule, and Global Consequentialism posted at PEA Soup. As the title suggests, Richard discusses the difference between act, rule and global consequentialism and offers critical comments on all three.

    Philosophy of Law
    Madeleine Flannagan
    brings us Religious Restraint and Public Policy: Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV, Part V & Part VI posted at MandM. Madeleine provides a long and comprehensive discussion of the doctrine of religious restraint, the claim that in public policy debate support for a given policy is morally unjustified unless one has secular reasons for that policy. She argues that the doctrine entails an arbitrary and unjustified asymmetrical treatment of religious and secular beliefs.

    Philosophy of Religion
    Dominic Bnonn Tennant brings us Determinism and the Authorship of Sin in Calvinism and Arminianism posted at Dominic Bnonn Tennant. Bnonn discusses issues around theological determinism and God’s culpability for sin.

    Jeremy Pierce brings us Satisficing Without Supererogation posted at Parableman. Jeremy attempts to reconcile the claim that there is no best possible world with the view that there is no supererogation. He argues that for a perfect being there is no supererogation and also that a perfect being is not required to create the best possible world as no best possible world exists.

    Matthew Flannagan brings us Tooley, The Euthyphro Objection and Divine Commands: Part I and Part II posted at MandM. Matt gives a critical discussion of Michael Tooley’s version of the Euthyphro dilemma and some attempts to defend it.

    Political Philosophy
    Aaron Powell brings us A Marble Temple Shining on a Hill: Reality and Michael Walzer posted at Aaron Ross Powell. This is a criticism of Michael Walzer’s defence of communitarianism.

    That concludes Philosophers’ Carnival XCXI. You can submit your blog article to the next edition using the Philosophers’ Carnival submission form. Past posts and future hosts can be found on the blog carnival index page.

  • Audi and the Infallibility of Religious Reasons

    In “Liberal Democracy and the Place of Religion in Politics”,[1] Robert Audi defends the liberal thesis that religious reasons should not be utilised in debate on issues of public policy. Instead he contends that “one should not advocate or support any law or public policy that restricts human conduct unless one has, and is willing to offer, adequate secular reason for this advocacy or support.”[2] Audi explains that “an adequate reason for a law or policy is a proposition whose truth is sufficient to justify it.”[3] Audi’s position is that it is immoral for a person to defend any legislation or public policy on theological grounds alone; one can only licitly defend a policy if one has secular reasons for it.

    A secular reason is, roughly, one whose normative force, that is, its status as a prima facie justificatory element, does not (evidentially) depend on the existence of God (for example, through appeals to divine command) or on theological considerations (such as interpretations of a sacred text), or on the pronouncements of a person or institution qua religious authority.[4]

    Audi supplants this principle of secular reason with two others, a principle of “secular motivation” and something he calls “theo-ethical equilibrium.”[5] His principle of secular motivation goes further; “one should not advocate or promote any legal or public policy restrictions on human conduct unless one not only has and is willing to offer, but is also motivated by, adequate secular reason, where this reason (or set of reasons) is motivationally sufficient for the conduct in question.”[6] Theo-ethical equilibrium is “a rational integration between religious deliverances and insights and, on the other hand, secular ethical considerations … a mature, conscientious theist who cannot reach it [theo-ethical equilibrium] should be reluctant or unwilling to support coercive laws or public policies on a religious basis that cannot be placed in that equilibrium.”[7]

    So construed there is an obvious asymmetry in Audi’s position. In a review of a book which defends Audi’s position, Philip Quinn observes;

    These principles impose burdens on religious people that Audi nowhere suggests imposing on nonreligious people. … Audi does not propose that nonreligious people must be sufficiently motivated by adequate religious reason for their advocacy or support of restrictive laws or politicise. The lack of symmetry is striking. [8]

    The fact that Audi’s position singles religious reasons out for exclusion from public discourse in a manner which he does not apply to secular reasons, raises the obvious question of why? What’s so special or objectionable about theological reasons being used in public?

    Elsewhere in his article Audi offers some reasons for this; he notes, “[religious reasons] are special in relation to liberal democracy even by contrast with [secular reasons] … that are not accessible to any normal adult.”[9] He gives five “salient points” to support his case, all based on the idea that religious reasons are dangerous to society.[10]

    In this post we want to focus on the first of these. Audi thinks any appeal to God’s commands in public debate is dangerously divisive because “religious reasons … are directly or indirectly taken to represent an infallible authority.”[11] This line of thought strikes a chord with many, concern about the infallible nature of divine will is often the basis for criticism of appeals to theology in public discourse.

    However, as Audi defines the term ‘infallible’ any reason a person offers for their position would be infallible; according to Audi, propositions are infallible if it is “impossible that they be both endorsed or accepted by God and false”.[12] God, as Audi understands him, is omniscient. God only believes true propositions. It follows then that any proposition one can imagine, regardless of its content, will be such that it is impossible for both God to believe it and that the proposition be false. Given this it is hard to see how “religious reasons” are especially objectionable on Audi’s contention.

    Perhaps, however, this is a technical point based on a mistaken definition of infallibility. Audi’s main concern is that a person, who believes that an action is commanded by God, believes that an omniscient, infallible being has endorsed that action. Appeals to purported divine commands are therefore problematic because the authority appealed to cannot err.

    The obvious rejoinder is that many secular ethical theories face precisely the same problem. One of the most influential secular theories is the ideal observer theory, which is endorsed by ethicists as diverse as David Hume, Adam Smith, Henry Sidgwick, Richard Hare, Roderick Firth, John Stuart Mill, Tom Regan, Richard Brandt, Immanuel Kant and others. On this theory, an action is wrong, if and only if, it would be proscribed by an ideal observer, by a person who is perfectly impartial and perfectly informed on all the relevant facts. A hypothetical ideal observer is no less infallible than religious believers take God to be. It is hard to see how invoking religious reasons is not acceptable but invoking the secular reasons is.

    This is probably enough to address Audi’s concerns but there are several other points worth noting.

    Firstly, the fact that the law of God is infallible does not entail that there is or cannot be debate over what the law of God in fact is. Claiming that God’s law is infallible is not to claim that any human never errs in his or her discernment of what this law is, his or her interpretation of it or his or her application of it to particular cases. Claiming that there is debate over the interpretation of divine law and debate over how to apply various precepts of divine law to specific cases, is compatible with affirming that divine law is infallible.

    In this, the law of God is analogous to deductive reasoning. By definition, a sound argument can never have a false conclusion. It is impossible for the conclusion to be false if the argument is sound, hence sound arguments are infallible. It does not follow from this that people never err in constructing arguments that they mistakenly believe are sound or that there is no debate over which arguments are sound. Reason is authoritative; however, human reasoners are not. It is hard to see why the infallibility of the law of God means that appeals to this law are any more problematic than appeals to logic.

    A similar response is available on the immutability of divine law. The fact that God’s law is immutable does not mean that any person’s understanding of this law cannot change. He or she may find his or her particular beliefs about God’s law were mistaken or that he or she had applied it incorrectly.

    In this respect, the law of God is analogous to numerous things that it is unobjectionable to appeal to. Consider an appeal to facts and reason; these too are immutable. If it is a fact that the world was round at the time of Columbus then this is something we cannot change. It cannot be true 100 years from now that the world was not round when Columbus sailed. Moreover, whether an argument is sound is also immutable; we cannot repeal the laws of logic. Therefore, both facts and reason are as immutable as God’s law is.

    Moreover, consider a precept such as it is wrong to torture children for entertainment. Is this mutable so that society could repeal it tomorrow? Is the claim that rape and genocide of Jews is wrong something that is mutable, that human beings can change and repeal these things? Obviously not. Immutability is a feature of any serious, ethical viewpoint. If you cannot base civil law on immutable things, then you cannot base it on facts, reason or secular values.


    [1] Robert Audi “Liberal Democracy and the Place of Religion in Politics” in Nicholas Wolterstorff & Robert Audi (eds) Religion in the Public Square: The Place of Religious Convictions in Political Debate (Rowman and Littlefield Publishers Inc, Lanham Md, 1997) 1-66.
    [2]
    Robert Audi “The Separation of Church and State and the Obligations of Citizenship” (1989) 18 Philosophy and Public Affairs 259, 279.
    [3]
    Ibid 284.
    [4]
    Ibid 278.
    [5]
    Audi, above n 1, 25-37.
    [6]
    Ibid 284.
    [7]
    Audi, above n 1, 21.
    [8]
    Philip Quinn “Religion in the Public Square: The Place of Religious Convictions in Political Debate” (2000) 60:2 Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 486, 487 (book review).
    [9]
    Audi, above n 1, 31.
    [10]
    Ibid 31-32.
    [11]
    Audi, above n 1, 31.
    [12]
    Audi, above n 1, 62.

    This post was jointly authored. It is largely a mash of extracts from Madeleine’s  paper “Religious Restraint and Public Policy” and from Matt’s “Is Historic Christian Opposition to Feticide Defensible in the 21st Century.”

  • Wet Paint: MandM Live at WordPress

    Welcome to the WordPress version of MandM. We are now open for business, there are a few navigational things still under construction and being tweaked so please bear with us as we sort these but you should be able to read and comment with no problem.

  • November MandM Highlights

    November was a busy month; we had almost 3,000 unique visitors – 2,980 to be precise.

    We reclaimed and exceeded (yay!) all the lost stats from when we changed address. Over the coming 4 months our ranking will be increasingly more accurate when measured against other sites.

    Interestingly, the top 10 countries our international visitors come from are:

    Indonesia [12%]
    United States [10%]
    Malaysia [6%]
    Philippines [5%]
    India [5%]
    Turkey [4%]
    Romania [4%]
    Denmark [3%]
    Spain [3%]
    Australia [3%]

    While Bulgaria features further down the list, we have always wanted to say hi to our regular visitor from Blagoevgrad – so a special hi to you!

    Highlights for the month of November, in case you missed them, (we are working on installing installing a read more option to make scrolling the home page easier):

    Sentience Part 1
    Matt explores whether sentience is the property that a newborn possesses and a fetus does not that enables the liberal to be consistent in otherwise violating the non-initiation of force principle when it comes to abortion, by permitting feticide, and yet not when it comes to liberal opposition of infanticide.

    Fisking Grant Robertson
    This was November’s most read MandM post and for good reason. Matt’s fisk of the You Tube video made by Wellington Central MP Grant Robertson’s supporters prior to the election is a must read for anyone wanting to see how to take apart the gay lobby’s tactic of quoting people out of context, engaging in character assassination and falsely crying homophobia.
    It is worth checking out just for the live examples of frothing at the mouth “tolerance” in the comments section.

    In Defence of the Defence
    Madeleine takes on Michael Laws’ highlighting of the demonism of the defence lawyer so prevalent in society today arguing stridently for the due process and the presumption of innocence to be upheld despite our revulsion for child killers.

    The Myth of Left Wing Moral Superiority
    Matt highlights the lack of walk in the left’s talk about their love and support for the poor.

    Tagged
    This was another highly popular post – one commentor even called it titillating. It was really a bit of fun where you got to find out we have a sense of humour, get to see we are normal human beings and share some link-love around.

    Barack Obama and Martin Luther King’s Dream
    Matt highlights the irony of the Luther King comparisons with Obama.

    What About the Poor? Sustenance Rights Examined
    In a two part series Matt examines arguments put forward in defence of the notion that the poor possess rights to sustenance when they cannot support themselves. His careful examination considers the role of the state, society and the Christian in light of this.
    This is an issue that Christians often fail to understand the subtleties of so it is little wonder that non-Christians think Christianity entails socialism.

    So What if She Wore the Same Jacket Twice?
    Madeleine flies the feminist flag over the treatment of Bronagh Key’s wardrobe tips compliments of the Herald and shares some of her own journey as a female involved, to a lesser degree, in the political sphere.

    Homosexuality and the Right-Wing Socialists
    Madeleine highlights the bigotry shown by the right towards those with viewpoints different to the party line on moral issues. Particularly under scrutiny is the practice of falling into cognitive dissonance when certain sacred moral cows come under any kind of scrutiny or what Contra Celsum refers to as “the Pavlovian dog-like response;” the most ardent liberal can switch into extremist socialist mode, selling out their commitment to liberty, simply to avoid being associated with a perceived affront to their moral values.

    Abortion and Child Abuse
    Matt highlights the flaws and focuses the latest blogosphere debate on abortion drawing from his PhD thesis on the ethics of feticide.

  • Happy Birthday MandM

    It has been 2 years today since MandM was born and our first post, In Remembrance of the Religious Right, entered the blogosphere.

    Apparently most blogs don’t make it to the 6 month mark so we are doing nicely.

    Thanks everyone for your continued support.

  • Upgrades in Progress

    We are currently working on a new layout for our blog so apologies if things seem in a bit of a disarray.

    You may notice in your feeds that we have posted new posts but they are dated for ages ago. This is so we can make use of our new links bar, there is unfortunately no way to avoid them coming up on the feeds.

    We have been working on this all day, Madeleine created the header image and that took a while as the original had blue sky and scaffolding on it, so we will take a break now and keep fiddling over the weekend.

    Please let us know what you think of the new layout and look. We have not yet had a chance to test the colours on other computers and we are aware that while out old layout looked like a pale cream on our computer on others it was a fairly loud orange brown – hence the change.

    These colours should all be complementary to the header image and the links and text should all stand out – please let us know if it does not.

  • Tagged

    We’ve been tagged by our old Free-Students Network chum Trevor Louden. The rules are:

    • Link to the person who tagged you
    • Post the rules
    • Share seven random or weird facts about yourself
    • Tag 7 random people at the end of the post with their links
    • Let each person know they’ve been tagged by leaving a comment on their blog

    [UPDATE: Mark V makes the point that we should really do 7 facts each, it is actually difficult to come up with these as many we assume people already know about us.]

    Fourteen pointless facts about us:

    1. Madeleine voted for the Alliance the first time she voted because she liked their tax policy.
    2. Before Matt went to Uni his career ambition was to be an officer in the NZ Army but he failed the psych test.
    3. Madeleine travelled the world on a boat for two years before she turned 5 and learned fluent German (as fluent as pre–schoolers get).
    4. Matt finished University with an A grade average, was awarded 7 scholarships and one of his PhD thesis markers said his PhD was one of the finest he had had the privilege of examining.
    5. “Womens’ Space Invasion Outrages” was the title of Madeleine’s first foray onto the front page of a major newspaper.
    6. Matt has never smoked a cigarette, been drunk or tried drugs. Madeleine is
      not commenting.
    7. Matt proposed to Madeleine by writing a 7 page letter arguing the case, point by point, for why getting married was a good idea.
    8. Madeleine hate seafood, shellfish, even fresh water fish – all of it.
    9. Matt does not eat grapes or strawberries.
    10. Madeleine, as an adult and not under the influence of any substance, once walked naked through the corridors of Waikato Hospital.
    11. Matt was once charged with “sexually harassing a space,” the charges were thrown out by the university mediator.
    12. Madeleine is older than Matt.
    13. Madeleine is accomplished at sewing and cake decorating.
    14. Matt is working towards his brown belt in karate.

    [If we get to write 14 facts then surely we get to tag 14 blogs…]

    We tag:

    Say Hello to my Little Friend; Crusader Rabbit; Kiwiblog; Stephen Franks; No Minister; Roarprawn; Mullholland Drive; Lost Soul; The Policy Blog; The Dim-Post; The Visible Hand; What’s Wrong With the World; Homepaddock; Hard News.