Author: Matt

  • Peter Singer on Human Dignity and Infanticide: Part One

    This is the first section of the paper I presented to the the Evangelical Philosophical Society Annual Meeting in Milwaukee two weeks ago. Several people have asked me to post it on MandM. It will appear as a two-part post series.

    Christian theism has traditionally taught that human beings have equal dignity and worth, a moral status that separates them from non-human animals. Peter Singer has famously rejected this teaching, holding that human beings are not any more special than animals and doctrines of human dignity are indefensible.  He contends that killing a new-born infant is, in and of itself, no more problematic than killing a non-human animal such as a cow or a pig and defends the permissibly of infanticide under certain conditions.

    Peter SingerThis paper will critically assess one important part of Singer’s position: his understanding of why it is wrong to kill.  In I I will sketch Singer’s “desire account” of killing and its relationship to his own preference utilitarianism and project of animal equality. Following Don Marquis, I will argue in II, that this “desire account” is subject to important counter examples. In III I note Singer’s attempts to modify his position so as to avoid these counter examples and suggest that these modifications are problematic. In IV, I will suggest that, despite this, there is an important truth in Singer’s critique, one that Christian thinkers can appropriate in developing moral arguments for Christian theism.

    I. Preference Utilitarianism and the desire account of the wrongness of killing
    Classical Utilitarianism conjoins three theses. First, the maximisation thesis; an action is right if and only if it maximises overall net benefit:  net benefit being the total amount of  benefit accruing to individuals as a consequence of the action, minus any harms resulting. An action maximises net benefit when the consequences of performing it constitute a higher net benefit than that associated with any alternative action.

    Second, , the thesis of equal consideration: a benefit or harm to any one individual is counted as having equal weight to a similar sized benefit or harm to any other individual.

    Third, the thesis of hedonism: on this account, benefits and harms are understood in terms of pleasure and pain. Something benefits an individual or is good if it causes him pleasure and harms him if it causes pain.

    Peter Singer is a preference utilitarian. Preference utilitarians accept both the maximisation and equal consideration theses however reject hedonism in favour of a desire fulfillment or preference satisfaction view of the good. Something is good for an individual if he desires or prefers it, and it is bad if contrary to his preferences or desires.

    Singer uses preference utilitarianism to reject the doctrine that human beings have equal dignity and worth, a moral status that separates them from non-human animals.  Sentient animals clearly have desires; they can suffer and feel pain and desire not to. The equal considerations thesis entails that in so far as these desires are similar to those of human beings the suffering of an animal must be considered equal with that of a human being.

    However, in terms of actual as opposed to potential psychological capacities, some human beings have a comparable mental life to that of animals.   A new born human infant’s psychology is primitive. David Boonin notes “by any plausible measure dogs, and cats, cows and pigs, chickens and ducks are more intellectually developed than a new born infant.” [1]  This means that the desires of a new born infant are similar to those of other animals.

    Singer illustrates this point in a discussion of animal experimentation. (more…)

  • Back from the USA

    The CrowdMadeleine and I flew back to New Zealand from Milwaukee on Tuesday having both attended the Evangelical Philosophical Society Annual Meeting, the Annual Meeting of the Evangelical Theological Society, and the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s Apologetics Conference. Prior to that I had spent three weeks based in Charlotte, North Carolina. I will speak about the  conferences later in this post but first I will summarise what I did in Charlotte.

    Charlotte
    My work in North Carolina can be divided into several categories.

    First, and this was the bulk of what I did, I did a bit of speaking on a lecture circuit at various campuses in North Carolina on issues relating to God and Morality for Ratio Christi. Formally, this involved, driving to a campus, delivering a lecture and then taking a Q&A.

    Speaking at UNC CharlotteI learned very quickly that there was a lot more to what I was doing than the formal activity of giving lectures; in fact, most of the more important work was the informal stuff that went on behind the scenes.  In addition to presenting lectures, there was often an equally important informal component. Often I would meet with students before the lecture  and discuss the challenges they were facing as Christian students in a secular campus. I would offer advice, counsel, support, etc. On other occasions I would, in addition to giving the lectures, meet with the supporters and financiers of the people running student ministries and discuss with them the importance of Apologetics and of developing an intellectually robust faith among students.  I found that the most important and constructive engagement and interaction with people typically occurred in these informal contexts.

    Speaking at Appalachian State UniversitySecond, in addition to my major task of giving lectures, on the weekends I gave instruction in churches. After my first week I was part of a missions team that spent a weekend teaching at a church in a nearby Cherokee Reservation.  The weekend after that I taught an adult education class in a Community Fellowship Church of North Carolina. The  following weekend I preached from the pulpit.  One Sunday evening I attended a service at a Slavic Baptist church where almost the entire service was in Russian and we needed a translator to follow what was being said. After the service I was one of a team of people who spoke to the youth group; I spent several hours fielding their very astute and intelligent questions about the Christian faith.

    This work was very challenging. It is one thing to give lectures at a university when one has, as I have, spent years studying and working in universities. It is quite another speaking to Cherokee Native American Indians one week, Southern Americans the next and youth from Slavic Immigrant Families the next – especially when my own culture is Kiwi!

    Third, and finally, I worked with the students at Southern Evangelical Seminary. One night when I was not lecturing, I presented an academic paper to students and graduates from the seminary, which was followed by a discussion. Another night I travelled to Belmont Abbey, a Catholic Liberal Arts College to dialogue with a Catholic theologian about the relative strengths of Natural Law Theory verses Divine Command Meta- Ethics.

    Both events were focused on seminary students, to get them to be presented with new or different material to what they were familiar with so they could ask questions and be stretched in their intellectual development.  I found the work over those three weeks very taxing physically, yet I enjoyed it immensely. I was giving lectures at universities, back to back, almost every day; I was often travelling for hours to and from the university in question and sometimes I would have to stay overnight with billets. As noted above the diversity of what I did stretched me.

    Lecturing on campuses to potentially hostile audiences is challenging enough, particularly when one throws in a Q&A. It becomes more so when there are obvious cultural barriers such as my indecipherable New Zealand accident and tendency to speaK too quickly because of the speed of my thoughts!  But, in addition to this, I was required to  give a talk to theology students, to Slavic youth, adult congregants, North American Indians on Reservations, and people from a country not my own in general – these contexts forced me to adapt my material fairly quickly to these new contexts with very little prep time.

    Milwaukee
    Madeleine, Bill Craig and IThe business end of my trip however was the conference in Milwaukee. On Wednesday 16 November 2012. Both Madeleine and I presented papers at the Evangelical Philosophical Society’s Annual Meeting. In the morning I presented my paper “Peter Singer, Human Dignity and Infanticide”; this was a critical look at Peter Singer’s account of the wrongness of killing and some of his attempts to revise his position in light of criticisms by Don Marquis.

    EPS Panel DiscussionIn the afternoon, Madeleine and I were on a panel discussing the  book Being Good: Christian Virtues for Everyday Life along with Mary Jo Sharp, Cristian Mihut and the book’s Editors, Michael W Austin and Doug Geivett. Madeleine offered a response and critique of the chapter on “Courage” by Rebecca Konyndyk DeYoung and I offered a criticism of Charles Taliaferro’s chapter on “Love”.

    Madeleine did extremely well, you would never have guessed, unless you knew to look for things like how she gripped the podium, that she had flown into Milwaukee at 12.05 am the night before, had been living with a pain disability aggravated by sitting for the past 4 years which was on high alert due to almost 24 hours travelling, and that she was completely shattered from working insane hours to be able to leave her litigation schedule and our children, whilst functioning on NZ time. In her typical style she spoke in a clear, articulate and forthright manner, her content was good, and I doubt anyone present could have been aware of the fact that she alone was the only speaker on the panel with no formal philosophy qualifications without reading her bio.

    Panel on Protestant PurgatoryIn addition to our own presentations, we attended a number of sessions such as Mike Austin’s talk on “Analytic Moral Theology”, Frank Beckwith’s response to the recent  “After Birth Abortion” paper published in the Journal of Medicine and Ethics, Paul Copan’s discussion on Acts 17, Charles Taliaferro’s Lecture on Environmentalism, a very stimulating panel discussion on Jerry Wall’s new book which offers a Protestant Defense of Purgatory, among various other presentations including sessions on religious pluralism and the Evangelical Theological Society’s panel discussion on environmentalism.

    Me, Frank Beckwith, MadeleineBy the time the EPS Apologetics conference started both Madeleine and I were knackered. Despite this we attended sessions on God and Morality by Frank Beckwith, Jeremy Evans’ session on Theism and the Meaning and Purpose of Life, David Baggett’s discussion of Moral Scepticism, Mike Austin’s talk on “Evangelical Blogging”, Angus Menuge, the new Evangelical Philosophical Society President’s talk on Religious Language, Gary Habermas’ talk on the Resurrection, and Mary Jo Sharp’s very useful session on effective public speaking.

    Paul Copan, Madeleine and IIn addition to the papers and sessions there was a lot of general networking going on. Paul Copan, Madeleine and I and met with a prospective publisher about co-writing a book on the moral issues surrounding the conquest narrative; it looks likely that Baker Books will accept our proposal, I will keep readers posted. I signed my publishing contract with Baker for an earlier publication. Madeleine had an interesting experience with Lee Strobel, Mary Jo Sharp, Mark Mittelberg and Chad Meister dialoguing with a prospective seeker. Mary Jo Sharp and Madeleine plotted prospective joint debate projects. Frank Beckwith and Madeleine discussed their shared religion in public life/philosophy meets law interests; Frank and I discussed possible joint projects on the abortion issue. Discussions were had with Craig Hazen about the Biola Faculty, Mark Mittelberg, Mary Jo Sharp and William Lane Craig about the possibility of their visiting New Zealand. We also met with Ratio Christi regarding the possibility of  a New Zealand chapter being formed.

    Mary Jo Sharp and Madeleine

    Since we got back, I have been following up on several potential employment opportunities that have arisen from the trip, a couple in New Zealand, a couple overseas, as well as possibility of 3 further books, one co-written with Madeleine, and various other potential projects involving ministry writing and speaking.

    In addition to the scholarly stuff, I got to see the Atlantic Ocean for the first time,  I saw the New York sky line, the Statue of Liberty and the New World Trade Centre. I visited a Nascar Centre, was present in the US during the re-election of Barack Obama and Cyclone Sandy. We discovered Wisconsin Cheese, Wisconsin Frozen Custard and Madeleine got to indulge in her favourite lollie flavours (candy to the US readers): cinnamon and root beer (she is happy to receive donations of either or both via post).

    Needless to say we arrived home on Tuesday extremely tired but extremely grateful to everyone who supported us in making this trip from those who donated – we love you all – through to people like Simon Brace who organised the Charlotte leg, Paul Copan who shared his hotel room with us, Ratio Christi who shouted us meals, our eldest daughter Sheridan who took on the task of primary caregiver to her younger siblings – no mean task given the severe Autistic Spectrum Disorder and Anxiety issues of our youngest child – Mike Austin and Doug Geivett who invited Madeleine and I to speak on their Book Panel, among others (this is by no means an exhaustive list!).

  • Madeleine on Housing Shortage Public Policy and Swearing at the Boss on “The Panel” – with Bob McCoskrie

    Radio RhemaIf you tuned in to Radio Rhema at 11:45am (NZ time) on 30 October 2012 you would have heard this blog’s Madeleine Flannagan and Bob McCoskrie discuss the housing shortage, the government’s plan to fix it and the legal consequences of  swearing at the boss, on “The Panel” on Pat Brittenden mornings.

    You can listen online here.

  • My First Week in Charlotte

    Last week I flew from Auckland to Los Angeles, then to Atlanta and from Atlanta to Charlotte, North Carolina on Wednesday last week. I got in shortly after 12 am on Thursday.

    A few hours later on Thursday morning I was introduced to much of the staff at Southern Evangelical Seminary and then began attending a conference for the new campus based group Ratio Christi. This saw me attend various lectures at the seminary, have dinner with Mark Forman of Liberty University and Paul Gould, get into discussions on theological and moral problems with various students at the conference,  and hear a key note address by John Lennox.

    All day Friday to Saturday I attended the Southern Evangelical Apologetics Conference.

    Monday saw me travelling to a leading Nascar racing team headquarters with John Lennox for a talk Lennox was delivering for engineers at the centre I also attended a lecture that Lennox delivered at Davidson University.  During the trip I also travelled with and discussed God and  Morality and Islam with Keith Small  from the London School of Theology.

    The next day saw me travelling to one of North Carolina’s most prestigious universities, the University of Chapel Hill, to hear Lennox’s final talk.

    Wednesday kicked off my speaking tour; I gave a 60 minute talk on “God and the Canaanite Massacre” on at Queens University. The following night I gave a talk entitled “Defending Divine Commands” at UNC Charlotte on Thursday (last) night. Both events were followed by a good Q&A sessions.

    Cherokee Christian Apologetics Conference

    Today I travel out to the border between North Carolina and Georgia to present at a the Cherokee Christian Apologetics Conference.  I am presenting on the topic of “Morality and Tolerance.”

    I will keep you posted as I can.

  • “Same-Sex Marriage is not Valid Marriage” – A Potentially Convict-able Statement

    In MandM on Same-Sex Marriage and on being “sneaky” we referred to section 56 of the Marriage Act 1955 which provides:

    56 Offence to deny or impugn validity of lawful marriage

    (1) Every person commits an offence against this Act, and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding 100 pounds, who—

    (a) alleges, expressly or by implication, that any persons lawfully married are not truly and sufficiently married; or

    (b) alleges, expressly or by implication, that the issue of any lawful marriage is illegitimate or born out of true wedlock.

    (2) For the purposes of this section the term alleges means making any verbal statement, or publishing or issuing any printed or written statement, or in any manner authorizing the making of any verbal statement, or in any manner authorizing or being party to the publication or issue of any printed or written statement.

    (3) A person shall not be deemed to make an allegation contrary to the provisions of this section by reason only of using in the solemnization of a marriage a form of marriage service which at the commencement of this Act was in use by the religious body to which that person belongs, or by reason only of the printing or issue of any book containing a copy of a form of marriage service in use at the commencement of this Act by any religious body.

    Criminal OffenceLousia Wall’s Marriage (Definition of Marriage) Amendment Bill, which seeks to amend the Marriage Act to allow for same-sex marriage does not seek an amendment to this section. This suggests that if her Bill passes, then anyone who claims that a same-sex marriage is not a valid marriage or a true marriage commits an offence.

    The fairly comprehensive legal opinion by Ian Bassett, argues that the law will have this effect.

    This is, of course, concerning because this is precisely what many religious groups teach. The Westminster Confession, for example,which is the doctrinal standard for  Presbyterian and Reformed Churches, states:

    I. Marriage is to be between one man and one woman: neither is it lawful for any man to have more than one wife, nor for any woman to have more than one husband at the same time.

    II. Marriage was ordained for the mutual help of husband and wife; for the increase of mankind with a legitimate issue, and of the Church with an holy seed; and for preventing of uncleanness.

    This defines marriage as being between a man and a woman. It entails that if a union is not between a man and a woman then it is not a marriage. Moreover, the purposes of the institution explicitly exclude same-sex unions in that the purposes include the mutual help of a husband and wife and procreation which rules out same-sex unions – particularly if the biblical and theological context and basis for those affirmations is understood.

    When the Human Rights Commission was asked about this, prior to the Basset legal opinion being commissioned, it gave the following response: (more…)

  • Life and Death – Matthew Flannagan Interviewed on Shine TV

    Matt was interviewed on Life and Death issues for Shine TV’s Just Thinking show recently. The Episode aired last week.

  • Matthew Flannagan on The Sermon on the Mount Part 2 (MP3)

    Matt preaches most Sundays at Takanini Community Church. Earlier in they year he did a series on the Sermon on the Mount. We published Matthew Flannagan on The Sermon on the Mount Part 1 (MP3) at the time but then we never got around to publishing Part 2. So now, download and listen to the MP3 of Matt preaching on The Sermon on the Mount Part 2.

    Now when Jesus saw the crowds, he went up on a mountainside and sat down. His disciples came to him, and he began to teach them. He said:
    “Blessed are the poor in spirit,
    for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
    Blessed are those who mourn,
    for they will be comforted.
    Blessed are the meek,
    for they will inherit the earth.
    Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness,
    for they will be filled.

    Matthew 5:1-6 NIV

    The Sermon on the Mount

    Hat tip: TCC