Author: Matt

  • Abortion and the Morality of Feticide: Part II

    In my last post, Abortion and the Morality of Feticide: Part I, I briefly sketched an argument against feticide,

    [1] It is wrong to kill a human being without justification;

    [2] A fetus is a human being;

    [3] In the case of feticide (at least in the majority of cases) insufficient or no justification is forthcoming.

    I argued that defenders of feticide cannot rationally reject this argument unless they reject one of the premises. I argued further that attempts to refute [3] are successful only if one assumes that a fetus is not a human being. It follows then that defenders of abortion laws cannot rationally avoid the question of whether [2] is correct, whether a fetus is a human.

    Is the Fetus a Human Being?

    Big MacThe first thing to note is that the claim that feticide is homicide has considerable prima facie plausibility. Consider this, a hunter is in the woods and notices some rustling in the bushes. Looking through his scope he sees a six-foot high, bi-pedal being with brown hair, blue eyes, wearing a red and black swanndri. He refrains from shooting. Here, the hunter makes the sensible and reasonable judgement that in firing he would risk engaging in homicide. He bases this on what the target looks like. In the absence of reasons for thinking otherwise, he has good grounds for this claim.

    This example has application to the status of the fetus; “[there is] a general consensus that the fetus is recognisably human after six weeks, and certainly after eight”[1] This fact, conjoined with the above illustration, entails that, in the absence of good reasons to the contrary, there are good grounds for thinking that feticide is homicide.

    The second thing to note is is that good reasons for thinking the fetus does not have human status are not forthcoming. Here I will focus on four common examples: viability, sentience, birth and person-hood.

    Viability
    A common argument contends that a fetus is not a human because it is not viable. Susan Sherwin argues that feticide differs from killing children because a fetus “is wholly dependent on her [the mother’s] unique contribution to its maintenance, while a newborn is physically separate, though still in need of a lot of care”.[2]

    There are several problems with this position.

    The fact that a fetus cannot survive independently of its mother does not mean it is not a human being. Fetal viability is contingent upon the medical technology of a given culture. A fetus that is not viable in (more…)

  • Fallacy Friday: The Genetic Fallacy

    The Genetic FallacyA fallacy related to the one we looked at last week (the Ad Hominem fallacy) is the genetic fallacy. One commits the genetic fallacy if one argues that a proposition is false on the basis of where the idea originated from.  Like the ad hominem, this fallacy invokes a kind of psychological transference where one transfers one’s disapproval of the source of an idea to the content of the idea itself. This kind of transference is fallacious because the content of an idea, its truth or falsity, depends on whether what it affirms about the world is the case and not on where the idea originated.

    Examples
    Consider, the ancient Greek thinker Pythagoras. Pythagoras was a religious mystic who worshipped numbers and geometrical systems as part of a broader religious scheme which included a strict diet and belief in reincarnation. Few people are aware of this; today he is best known for being traditionally credited with discovering the famous mathematical formula known as Pythagorean Theorem which affirms that, “for any right triangle, the square of the hypotenuse is equal to the sum of the squares of the other two sides”.

    Now suppose someone were to reject Pythagorean theorem on the grounds that it was discovered by a odd religious mystic. This rejection would obviously be invalid. Even if tradition were correct in identifying Pythagoras with the discovery of this theorem, this does not mean that the theorem is false; its truth is determined by what the realities of math and geometery actually are, not by who discovered them.

    A second example illustrates the same point. Some early defences of heliocentricism, the view that the planets in the solar system orbit the sun, originated in certain systems of sun mysticism. People worshipped the sun as a symbol of God and hence thought it fitting that the sun be at the centre. This fact about the origins of some beliefs about heliocentricism does nothing to show that heliocentricism is false. Its truth or falsity depends on location of different planets, not on how the idea was first formulated.

    These examples may seem fairly obvious but they often beguile people. In Theology, for example, some theologians dismiss certain ideas as false because they originated in Greek Platonism. Yet (more…)

  • Abortion and the Morality of Feticide: Part I

    Is it morally permissible to commit feticide? The abortion debate swirls around this question, a lot of rhetoric, emotion and anger gets spent on debating this question or avoiding it.

    In this series I will examine this question. First I will sketch an argument against feticide: the killing of a fetus. Then I will examine three common ways of criticising this argument and respond to them.

    The Argument Against Feticide

    Implicit, if not overtly explicit, in much historic Christian moral reflection on feticide is a simple three-premise position. Firstly, that there is a divine law prohibiting homicide – the killing of a human being without adequate justification; secondly, a fetus is a human being; and thirdly, that in all or most cases of feticide, justification for homicide is not forthcoming. This argument can be summarised as follows:

    [1] It is wrong to kill a human being without justification;

    [2] A fetus is a human being;

    [3] In the case of feticide (at least in the majority of cases) insufficient or no justification is forthcoming.

    This argument is formally valid. These three premises jointly entail that feticide is wrong; premises [1] and [2] entail that it is wrong to kill a fetus without justification, this conclusion, conjoined with [3], entails that feticide is wrong in at least the majority of cases. Given the argument is formally valid, any critique of this argument must call into question the truth of either of the premises. [For more on validity see Assessing Arguments]

    Avoidance Tactics
    FetusNotwithstanding this, the most common response to this argument is some tactic seeking avoidance of the issue. It is not unusual to see attempts to denounce, insult, caricature or defame the character of those who oppose feticide. If current commentary is to be believed opposition to legal abortion comes from misogynist fundamentalist fanatics who want to impose their religious mores onto others.

    Of course, these strings of pejorative terms fail to address the argument above. Suppose everything that is said of such people is true – people who oppose feticide do have the bad character traits or motives claimed – the soundness of the argument remains untouched. A good argument does not cease to be a good argument just because someone has personal flaws or dubious motives. It is only unsound if (more…)

  • Waitangi’s Christian Heritage

    It is Waitangi Day in New Zealand today; the day where we remember the signing of the treaty of Waitangi in 1840.

    This morning at church I had the privilege of hearing a very interesting talk from my Pastor, Rev. Dr Stuart Lange about the lead up to the Treaty signing. Stuart is a church historian and something of an expert on the history of Christianity in New Zealand. When he is not being a pastor at Massey Presbyterian Church he lectures in Church History at Laidlaw College where he used to be Vice Principal.

    Samuel MarsdenStuart looked at the role of missionaries in NZ society. He pointed out some interesting facts, such as: the relationship between early missionary Samuel Marsden and William Wilberforce, the famous evangelical reformer who spearheaded the abolition of the slave trade in England; and that prior to the Treaty being signed, large numbers of Maori converted to Christianity; he touched on the role of Missionaries in brokering peace between warring tribes, and how these conversions lead to Maori tribes liberating their slaves who then carried the gospel back to their homes. He also noted that, in many respects, prior to 1840 Christianity was more prevalent amongst Maori than the colonial settlers, many of whom were fairly unscrupulous and had little time for serious evangelical commitment.

    He noted also the theological and pastoral motivations of the missionaries in pushing for the Treaty; they were concerned to see that, with colonialists arriving in great numbers, the indigenous people they worked with were protected. He also noted the role of several missionaries in speaking out against early violations of the Treaty.

    Stuart is apparently giving a 90 minute lecture on these issues at Congress 2011: 2020 Vision – The Gospel in the Decade Ahead, a Christian leadership conference in Wellington later this month – check it out if you’re in Wellington. This was a very brief snippet of that talk but it was thoroughly interesting and it was delivered with Stuart’s characteristic humour.

    I have posted on some of the moral issues around the Treaty before and I plan in the future to write some more on this topic but now  I also plan to look into some of the theological history as I found this talk fascinating.

    Anyway happy Waitangi Day fellow kiwis! Let us today all pause, consider and celebrate our country’s heritage and future together – take up Pat Brittenden’s idea and have a Waitangi Day barbeque! Kia kaha.

    RELATED POSTS:
    Maori and Pakeha are Not Partners to the Treaty of Waitangi
    Sovereignty and The Treaty of Waitangi
    View “Marae: The Great Waitangi Debate” Here
    The Foreshore and Seabed Repeal: The Inconvenience of Due Process

  • Fallacy Friday: The Ubiquitous Ad Hominem

    In my previous posts, What is an Argument? and Assessing Arguments, I spelt out some basics as to what an argument is and how to assess arguments. There I noted that a sound argument is one where the premises of the argument is true and the argument is valid. It is impossible for an argument which is sound to have a false premise, this fact means that one cannot rationally reject the conclusion of an argument unless one also rejects either one of the premises or the argument’s validity.

    These concepts are essential to understanding fallacies because fallacies frequently involve rejecting a person’s conclusion or their argument on grounds other than their lack of soundness. Thus, a fallacy is an error in reasoning.

    Logicians have characterised and named the most common mistakes. Most have Latin names due to the fact that logic was a prerequisite to studying theology in the middle ages; Latin was the language of scholarship at that time so the classifications of fallacies were done in Latin.

    The first and perhaps most infamous fallacy that I want to look at today is the ad hominem fallacy. Ad hominem means “against the man.” An argument is ad hominem when the thrust of the argument is not made at against the  conclusion one is denying and neither is it made against the soundness of the argument by challenging either its validity or the truth of its premises, an ad hominem argument is one where the attack on the argument is directed against the person who has offered the argument or who has asserted its conclusion.

    Example
    A good example on an ad hominem occurred on MandM this week. The issue as to whether New Zealand has an established religion surfaced in a comment thread. Madeleine claimed,

    “I refer you to this guest post written by lawyer David Simpkin who sets out the law showing New Zealand does have an official state religion and denomination – the Church of England (Anglican). His legal analysis is dead right. Guest Post: No Official Religion in God’s Own?.”

    Here Madeleine referred the reader to an argument, made by a lawyer, which argued from certain premises to the conclusion that New Zealand has an official religion. Julian the Apostate responded to this as follows:

    “Could I also note Mr Simpkin’s former role as a member of Youth for New Zealand, a front group for the Christian Heritage Party?”

    Here Julian does not address the premises of Simpkin’s original argument, nor does Julian claim that the argument is invalid, instead he dismisses both the argument and its conclusion on the basis that the author of the argument, was once a member of a youth group connected with the Christian Heritage Party. (more…)

  • Atheist Posters: University Intolerance is Suddenly News?

    Last night I watched a section on TV3’s Campbell Live about the treatment of a campus atheist club at the University of Lincoln entitled “Atheist uni students’ posters torn down” (follow the link to view the video). This story went into detail about how the clubs posters have been regularly ripped down and defaced.

    The presenter, Natasha Utting, was quite shocked that this could happen at a university and they suggested the club was being targeted. The story began,

    Campbell Live

    “Universities are traditionally the bastions of critical thought, champions of diversity and free expression – a melting pot of ideas where debate is encouraged. So who is trying to censor a student club at Lincoln University – and why are they being bullied for their beliefs?”

    Now, first up, I want to say whoever defaced these posters was wrong to do so, the way to respond to campus atheist clubs is to take on and refute their ideas. But what surprised me with this piece was the idea that this was news worthy of prime time mention and a more in depth analysis than the 8 second sound-bite approach of the news. The reason I say this is because in my 11 years at University I was never involved in an advertising campaign of any sort for any group (and I was involved with several) where my posters were NOT ripped down or defaced. This is the norm on New Zealand University noticeboards. The posters about the Library’s opening hours get ripped down and defaced!

    Now, I am not saying I think this is good. I am just puzzled that now suddenly when an atheist club’s posters are torn down it attracts attention of the magnitude of Campbell Live.

    In 1996 I was involved in the leadership of a campus Christian group that was asked by the student union to leave campus for the offence of handing out pamphlets. We were threatened with security by the student president. This was made abundantly clear to the media at the time and made known to the politicians. I remember Dr Liz Gordon from the Alliance Party telling me in a Select Committee hearing on the whether student union membership should remain compulsory or not telling me “this is normal campus life” when I mentioned the incident.

    In 1996 a man was asked to leave campus by Waikato University staff for preaching on campus. I witnessed it and complained to the student editor who ran a story on it.

    As to posters, when I was campaigning for election to the student union executive our campaign team had a three hourly postering shift in place which we maintained throughout each day beginning at 4am where we put up posters. Why? Because the minute we had completed a postering run of the entire campus our opponents would tear them down. We had to finish and then promptly go back to the starting point to replace the torn and defaced posters.

    I campaigned (successfully) for a position on the student union three times. I also campaigned in 3 referenda. Every time, it was the norm (more…)

  • Contra Mundum: Is God a 21st Century Western Liberal?

    World Trade Centre Terrorist AttackOn 11 September 2001 Islamic terrorists flew two planes into the World Trade Centre killing thousands of innocent people. Ostensibly they did this because they believed God commanded them to do so. This event has invigorated a fear latent in the Western psyche since the 17th century when wars of religion tore Europe apart, the fear of religious fanaticism, of people willing to murder hundreds in the name of God. These fears were centre-stage recently at a Conference held by the Centre for Philosophy of Religion at the University of Notre Dame. Sceptics presenting at the conference argued passionately that the God of the bible issues commands which are at odds with contemporary modern understandings of morality. Adultery is punished with death; on some occasions, God is portrayed as commanding the killing of non-combatants in “holy wars” against the local Canaanite population.

    There is a lot that can be said about these concerns and in a short column I cannot say everything. In many instances I think the sceptics fail to appreciate the context and genre of the passages they cite. They fail to appreciate, for example, that Ancient Near Eastern conquest accounts employ highly figurative rhetoric, which hyperbolically describe victories in terms of total annihilation of the enemy. They fail to appreciate that Ancient Near Eastern legal texts, as noted by Raymond Westbrook, “reflect the scribal compilers’ concern for perfect symmetry and delicious irony rather than the pragmatic experience of the law courts.” Or that, as JJ Finkelstein points out, they “were not meant to be complied with literally” but to “serve an admonitory function” and so probably do not command execution for the crimes mentioned. Sceptics can fail to grasp that claiming the bible is God’s word does not mean it did not come to us mediated through the writings of human beings who wrote in a particular time and place using the language, rhetoric and literary conventions of their time and so and frequently they fail to appreciate the bible is a Canon and that passages need to be read in their broader context i.e. taking into account the whole bible. A full articulation of these points, however, would take more space than I can here muster.

    Instead I will address another feature of this issue which concerns the general method in play here. In each case the sceptic takes a purported divine command and compares it to a moral belief that he takes to be correct. The conclusion he draws is that the purported command is inauthentic. This is of course a possibility; there is, however, another possibility that on at least some occasions, moral statements these sceptics are relying on are mistaken.

    This feature of the dialectic became clear to me after a public debate I had on these issues in August. A sceptic wrote to me claiming that (more…)