Category: Blogging

  • The Point of Intellectual Engagement: Why Thinking Matters

    For some faith and reason is an anathema; Christianity is the realm of feelings and is totally separate from academia, reason and logic.

    After the Craig v Cooke debate a Christian reporter asked me “aside from people being intellectually stimulated, what was the point of having a Christian Philosopher dialogue with an Atheist Historian at Auckland University, what was gained from it? The assumption appeared to be that engaging at the intellectual level as opposed to the emotional level [a false dichotemy but that’s for another post] was not what Christianity was about – where were the immediate conversions?

    When Dominic was recently asked what the point was of Thinking Matters (an organisation dedicated we sometimes contribute to), I found his answer to have broader application to the issues of faith and reason and apologetics in general and spoke to the heart of the inherent problem found both within and without Christianity mentioned above. His comments are reproduced below.

    The purpose of Thinking Matters and Apologetics

    Darryl Burling recently asked the Thinking Matters Contributor mailing list,

    “What is the purpose of thinking matters? I know the answer that is here, but what I want to understand is what constitutes success? What is the purpose of “examin[ing] and explain[ing] the defense of the Christian faith”? I have my ideas but want to know what others think.”

    1. The purpose of Thinking Matters is primarily to provide a “common area” for New Zealand apologists. Our aim is to give some focus to the various individuals and groups in New Zealand who would otherwise be doing their own thing without much awareness of the efforts of others. In that vein, I think we’ve been fairly successful already; although admittedly we need a new injection of enthusiasm to galvanize some further action.

    2. Because of (1), the purpose of apologetics is not something that Thinking Matters, as an organization, has taken a specific position on. I think it has, so far, been sufficient simply that we all agree apologetics is necessary and important. The views of the individuals who contribute to TM may differ on the precise purpose of apologetics—some widely. Similarly, our views on apologetics methodology may differ. As you know, I’m strongly presuppositional. But to be a well-rounded apologetics organization, I think we also need some classical and evidential apologists filling out the mix.

    3. For my own part, I believe that apologetics is an important pre-evangelical, and post-evangelical discipline.

    (i) In terms of pre-evangelism, apologetics is often necessary to remove the epistemic defeaters to Christian belief. Since faith is rational, we cannot expect it to obtain in situations which would render it irrational; such as when people hold strong beliefs which contradict that faith. This is especially important given that we aren’t living in a Christian society any more, but a post-Christian one. People are increasingly skeptical of Christian faith-claims because they increasingly (a) fail to understand them, and (b) are influenced by scientism/modernism (I don’t believe post-modernism has actually had the societal effect some people think it has had). Apologetics in this context isn’t only or even perhaps primarily about laying the groundwork for evangelism itself; as you commented to me privately, the rational defense of the faith is a necessary condition for “ensuring ongoing freedom to be Christian in an increasingly hostile, left brained, rational and intellectual world.” Christianity needs champions in the academic arena to show that our faith is intellectually justified and defensible. This is very important in the universities in particular, since they are the breeding grounds for the upcoming movers and shakers in society—and they are largely secular.

    (ii) In terms of post-evangelism, apologetics is extremely important for dealing with doubts, and for growing in faith. Again, faith is rational—so where defeaters exist for it, cognitive dissonance occurs. This can be really damaging; especially for people who are converted through more emotional and less intellectual means. A lot of people have powerful conversion experiences, but then later when they start to really think about their faith, and perhaps share it with others, they encounter a lot of objections and doubts. This is especially true online, where there are lots of New Atheists who are highly hostile to Christianity, and have prima facie reasonable objections to faith, backed up by a lot of attitude which replaces the work of actual reasoning and underwrites the appearance of a righteously indignant worldview which opposes Christianity because it is so irrational. Without apologetics, this can be fatal to faith. Christians need to know that (a) doubts are not sinful; and (b) that answers do exist. And currently, I don’t believe that most pastors in New Zealand are actually equipped to provide the sorts of answers that some Christians may need. A lot of questions are not really considered seriously and addressed, so such as dismissed and swept under the rug (particularly in less conservative churches; I think Pentecostalism has a lot to answer for with its generally anti-intellectual, emotion-based faith).

    Note that none of this is to say that faith is only rational. Thinking Matters’ declaration of belief is thoroughly Reformed in its view (albeit implied) that faith is an actual ontological change caused by the indwelling of the Holy Spirit in the new believer. However, it’s important to still affirm that faith is rational; and that because it is rational, doubts will occur where certain presuppositions or beliefs conflict with it. Apologetics is a means God uses to defeat unbelief, and to then preserve the saints in faith.

  • Recent Comments

    I have been messing around with the blog of late. New colour scheme, modication of the layout to three columns, new stats counter, a recent comments widget and a favicon.
    I have tried 4 different recent comments widgets and none of them are working properly. The current one comes from Storago and yesterday it seemed to be working but today all the new comments have vanished and it is showing now comment. I think the problem is that I have to be able to FTP to my blog which given this is the freebie version I can’t but then I read other pages that said the new beta version allowed the Storago widget to be added to an HTML/Java Script gadget – it was working yesterday…. argh!

    I could try template tags but this can only parse and display comments from the page on which it is displayed and as such is not really what I am after.

    Can anyone recommend a good, free recent comments widget that will properly function as a true recent comments widget – as in comments on old and archived posts will show up and the recent comments won’t all vanish periodically?

    UPDATE:
    I have installed a functional recent comments widget and it works and the best part was it was the least complex and quickest one I tried. It is a true recent comments widget in that it really does show the most recent comments first and it shows comments from posts that are archived – I tested it by commenting on our very first blog post and it showed up. So yay for Blogger Buster!

  • Labour Cause Car Accident (Almost)

    Whilst driving, through Labour’s Sue Moroney’s territory, on my way back from my weekly lecture at BTI in Tauranga, I laughed so much I nearly drove into a pole.

    Narrowly missing the pole, the laughter saw me nearly swerve into fence.

    This is what I saw on the side of Galloway St in Hamilton:

    I don’t agree with the vandalism of election hoardings and I prefer personal insults are left out of political debate but I did find this very funny!

    UPDATE: Its seems stuff found it funny too.

  • Reviving the Five Things Meme

    We just discovered that a year and a half ago (what! it still counts) David Farrar tagged us with the five things meme.

    This means we have to blog five things you probably don’t know about us. (We don’t really care if you don’t want to know) So here goes:

    1) Madeleine never wrote a letter to the editor or got her name in the media until she met Matt.

    2) Matt is into thrash metal and sings along as a party trick.

    3) Madeleine’s uncle is Gary Knapp of Social Credit fame.

    4) Matt is a former middle-weight, full-contact karate champion.

    5) Madeleine has a tatoo of a lilly.

    We tag: Fundy Post; Dominic Bnonn Tennant; Hitting Metal; Gman inc. ; Not PC

  • Spot the Difference

    This is a photo of me taken last weekend on my daughter’s cell phone (not the best photo of me but our camera is broken):

    This is a photo of my 16 year old daughter:

    This is a photo of me with my 16 year old daughter, also taken last weekend:Can you spot the difference?

    Why am I posting these and asking this? Because of this comment here:

    “This is a great pic as it is a reminder of you on more than one level. Big piles of chocolate chip biscuits are a good reminder that the hot photos of Madeleine on this blog are probably photos of her daughter she pretends are photos of her because she is such a big fattie (and now a big fat liar too about what she looks like).Come on Maddy show us a picture of what you really look like. But then of course no one would want to read your blog because looking at you would make them sick.

    Now this is kinda funny, kind flattering and kinda strange – whilst its nice at age 35 to get mistaken for your 16 year old daughter, what can I say its a combination of my Anew Skincare regime and my Knapp genes, but being accused of impersonating her because I am in reality ugly and fat is ridiculous!

    Whilst my daughter wrote a response, I had intended to just ignore this post but recent events on Kiwiblog have led me to change my mind. In the comments section I find myself being slammed for being fat, loving burgers and biscuits and telling porkies about what I really look like because I wrote a comment critical of the current government’s welfare programme for workers a.k.a Working for Families.

    James (207) Says: September 30th, 2008 at 7:33 pm
    We all know how much Maddy loves her burgers and chocolate biccies.
    Did you see on her blog she has been outed for using her daughter to impersonate herself?”
    Well theres a suprise….Mad woman Flanagan telling porkies….golly! Next it will be claims of sexual harrassment….oh wait…

    The photos of me on this blog are of me. Ask the bloggers I have been face to face with in recent months if my photos are lying about what I really look like – David Farrar, Dave Crampton, Ian Wishart, A. J. Chesswas, Andy Moore, Glenn Peoples, Jason Kumar to name a few. Finally if that does not convince you check out the front cover of the current Auckland University In House Short Courses brochure or ask Dr William Lane Craig who introduced me to the crowd at Auckland University debate on Is God a Delusion – watch the video, the introduction happens literally minutes into the debate, you can see me right up the front – note the date.

    Overall I suppose all of this is a complement as if the best criticism someone can level at me is that I am fat and ugly then that is a real complement to my mind and it really speaks to the reasoning ability of my critics. This is normally a tactic of the left but the James quoted above is an apologist of Jim Peron – sadly he is a member of the right.

    It also speaks to their observation skills, this photo was taken earlier this year and I am sorry if this sounds vain but I am not fat and I am not ugly and as my daughter said, where are the photos of those making the comments?

    The only people telling porkies are my critics. Now we have settled that can we get over what I look like and get back to real issues?

  • Subway and MandM

    Hey! Andy just sent me this pic he snapped at Subway that made him think of us.

  • On the Absence of Matt

    The more observant among you will have noticed that Matt has not written a blog entry for a while. It is not for lack of want but more for being completely inundated of late:

    • His teaching course load this semester is heavier.
    • His non-academic job continues to suck up his time and its hours limit the time he can stay up til.
    • He still is attending all my law lectures and tutorials as my pain levels are not up to attending in person this semester as hoped.
    • My pain levels and surgury news and the impact they have made have sucked up his energy and time.
    • Last week he had a guest lecture to prepare and give.
    • Soon he has a seminar in Tauranga to prepare and give.
    • He is working on a new and exciting project which hopefully will see him dump his non-academic job.
    • Then several of the usual distractions of life have managed to crop up too on top of a rather busy social calendar.

    So life is good and full and interesting for Matt, the future is looking bright, but blogging has taken a back seat!

    He hopes to have a little more time for it soon.