In my last Friday Fallacy post, I looked at the fallacy of denying the antecedent. There I discussed conditional statements, statements of the form “if P then Q”. Examples would be statements such as “if it is raining then the grass will be wet” or “if the US had not shot Bin Laden then he would still be alive”. I noted that conditionals have an “antecedent” and a “consequent”. In the above examples the antecedent is the claim “it is raining” or “the US had not shot Bin Laden”. In a conditional statement one talks about what occurs if the antecedent is true. The consequent is what is said to be true if the antecedent is correct; in the examples above the consequent is the proposition “the grass will be wet” or “he would still be alive” respectively.
Conditionals are hypothetical statements; they affirm what would be the case, if something else were the case. They can be true even if the antecedent is false. Consider the claim that “if I had died yesterday, I would not be writing this blog post today.” This conditional is true, even though I did not die yesterday. So it is a mistake, albeit a common one, to reject a conditional because one thinks the antecedent is false. The issue is not whether it is false, it is what would be the case if it were true?
This week I want to look at another fallacy that occurs with conditionals. Whereas last time I looked at the fallacy of denying the antecedent, this week I want to look at the fallacy of affirming the consequent. To understand this we need to recap two valid argument forms I mentioned last time: modus ponens and modus tollens.
Modus Ponens
Modus Ponens has the following form:
1. If P then Q.
2. P;
Therefore:
3. Q.
To use our now belaboured example”
1. If it is raining then the grass will be wet.
2. It is raining;
Therefore:
3. The grass will be wet.
In a modus ponens one first asserts that a conditional statement is true and then affirms the antecedent of the conditional and concludes that the consequent true. As I noted, this is a valid argument. If the conditional “if P then Q” is true, and P is true, then Q must also be true.
Modus Tollens
Modus Tollens has the form:
1. If P then Q.
2’ Not Q;
Therefore:
3′ Not P.
To take our example:
1. If it is raining then the grass will be wet.
2’ The grass is not wet;
Therefore:
3’ It is not raining.
In modus tollens one first asserts that a conditional statement is true and then denies the consequent of the conditional and concludes that the antecedent is false. As I noted, this is also a valid argument. If the conditional “if P then Q” is true, and Q is false, then P must also be false.
Affirming the Consequent
This recap is necessary to focus on the fallacy I am going to discuss today. As (more…)


