Category: Social Commentary

  • Barack Obama and Martin Luther King’s Dream

    A generation ago Martin Luther King stated he had a dream: that people should be judged on the content of their character, not the colour of their skin. Fast-forward to the current day and thousands are celebrating the fulfilment of this dream in the election of Barack Obama as US President.

    There is an irony here; people are saying Obama’s election is great because he is black; it is good that a “black man” has taken office. The result is being evaluated on the basis of the “colour” of the president-elect’s skin. Everyone, who praises Obama’s ascendancy for these reasons, is in fact rejecting King’s dream.

    Ironically King’s dream is being upheld by those conservatives, like Robert George, who opposed Obama’s pursuit of the Presidency on the basis of his character. Such conservatives considered the kinds of values Obama holds to and the policies he supported on the basis of these values to be lacking.

    To celebrate Obama’s election because a black man has finally been elected to office without heeding the concerns about his character is exemplify the very racism that Martin Luther King was speaking against.

  • Rickards, Nicholas and Flaws in the Adversarial System

    As someone who intends to share the same career as Clint Rickards I have to say I am uncomfortable hearing that the NZ Law Society has granted Rickards a certificate of character to practice law. I am uncomfortable because the legal system forces us into an absurd position that everyone knows is farcical and yet it must be maintained in the name of justice. Let me explain.

    We know that:

    1. A person is innocent of a crime until proven guilty.
    2. Rickards was not proven guilty of rape.
    3. Nicholas claimed that Rickards did rape her.
    4. Perjury is a crime.
    5. Nicholas has not been found guilty of perjury (or even tried).

    The problem is that if you accept 1. then you are required (by 2.) to conclude that Rickards is innocent and therefore the allegation made in 3. is false.

    However, if you accept 1. then you are required (by 4. and 5.) to assume that Nicholas is innocent and therefore the allegation made in 3. is true.

    Therefore, acceptance of the presumption of innocence requires us to believe both that Rickards did and did not rape Nicholas and it requires us to believe both that Nicholas did and did not commit perjury.

    Obviously this is rationally impossible. We know that it cannot be true that both parties are innocent or that both parties are guilty.

    The presumption of innocence requires us to believe such nonsense. Given we are talking about serious things such as rape and false allegations thereof, we are extremely uncomfortable adopting positions we know are false (and we know it is false that he both raped and did not rape and she perjured and did not perjure).

    So I am right to not feel comfortable about accepting Rickards’ innocence even though legally I know I must and I am uncomfortable about branding Nicholas a liar because at least with Rickards he was tried, Nicholas has not been, (despite what some idiots think).

    The problems with the presumption of innocence do not stop at logical absurdities. Another problem is that to claim someone is innocent under the adversarial system, simply means they have not been proved guilty. This is not the same thing as saying they have been proved innocent. “Not guilty” means that the high evidential standard was not met; it is possible to reasonably doubt the accusation. Of course the accusation could be more probable than not, it could be highly probable, it could be completely ridiculous to entertain but it is not certain. Basically a “not guilty” verdict under the adversarial system simply tells us where the benefit of the doubt should lie; it does not remove the doubt.

    Related Posts: Labour Erodes More Human Rights: The Criminal Procedure Bill

  • Sometimes the Left are Right: The Right-Wing 5 Headed Monster

    One of the things I am loving about not being affiliated to any party is that I can criticise my own ‘side’. It is a liberating thing.

    I stumbled accross this on The Standard and I have to say I agreed with it.

    Well, most of it.

    Definately did not agree with the last line…

    And of course John Key was right that a government without a clear direction being pulled all over the show by competing agendas would not be good for the country, especially in a time of economic uncertainty and there is the fact that what he was speaking of and what the Standard are referring to do differ somewhat, in that he only needs a two headed monster to govern and one of the 5 heads is really a two headed monster in its own right, but Tane does have a point….

    Moving right along.

    Taken from: Careful of them monsters, John by Tane.

    It’s amazing to see how quickly John Key got over his fear of five-headed monsters once it came time to cobble together a government, and more amazing still how quickly the media chose to forgive and forget.

    You’ll recall that just two weeks ago the media couldn’t get enough of John’s line that having a government composed of:

    “all sorts of different parties” with “competing interests” would not be in the best interests of New Zealand during a period of “difficult economic times to manage”.

    But, silly me, they bought that one when it was Helen Clark’s coalition options in question. Now that it’s John Key, it turns out what was irresponsible just two weeks ago was actually “smart” and “inclusive” all along.

    They’re a funny bunch, our right-wing media.

    [I am sorry but if the media is “right-wing” then what on earth am I? Maybe a better question is what does that make The Standard?!?!?]

  • Two Minutes Silence

    At the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month we take two minutes silence to remember the armistice signed between the Allies and Germany at Compiègne, France for the cessation of hostilities on the Western Front, the end of World War One, effective at 11am, 90 years ago today.

    So many died that we might have freedom. As Churchill said:

    “All the great things are simple, and many can be expressed in a single word: freedom; justice; honor; duty; mercy; hope.”

    We owe those who fell our commitment to oppose tyranny and affronts to liberty in whatever guise such affronts may cross our path in our day.

  • Just How Far Will the Left go?

    We all know the left will stop at nothing to win in politics; see what they did to Stephen Franks in Wellington Central – systematic election hoarding defacement, abuse on his blog (too numerous to link to any one example), You Tube videos twisting out of context comments into scary hate filled messages against Christians and gays [note it was only called homophobic]. The threats and abuse we received for Fisking Grant Robertson, the critique of the latter You Tube Video, to name a few examples from one electorate.

    But who phones 111 when they realise, on election night, that the left have lost and that National will lead the country?!?!?

    And WHY???!!??

    What littany of lies and propaganda about the right would have had to have been put up such people by the left to make them do this? (or are they just incapable of understanding the political process and the policies of the right?)

    Liberty Scott’s comments are on the button; extract from: What DID leftwing campaigners tell some people?

    This report that some people rang the Police when the election results were coming through is alarming in several ways:

    1. That people thought their benefits would disappear because National was being elected. What sort of untrammelled nonsense have the left been spreading about such a situation? How despicable are those who promote such lies among people who are clearly rather unhinged? How many were persuaded to vote Labour or Green or else their benefits would dry up?

    2. What do people think the Police will do? Arrest John Key and Rodney Hide? Call an end to general elections? Do they think when things don’t go their way the Police should be called in? How scary is that?

    3. Most disconcerting is the helpless dependency of such people who think the only way forward is to remain dependent on money taken by force from others. How insipid has the welfare state become that there are people terrified at the prospect of having to earn themselves a living?

    Sorry folks, it’s when the word Libertarianz replaces National that you might be worried, but by then the culture would have to have changed so radically that you wouldn’t be scared anymore.

  • The Impact of the Special Votes

    I sat down to work out how the special votes, which are yet to be counted, might impact the seats with the St Lague formula and saw David Farrar had already done it so I am going to be lazy and steal his post – I am tired, went to bed around 2am got up at 6am – Sherry had a One Day Event this morning, they start early, and Troggy bit me, so my arm hurts when I type… anyway, hat tip Kiwiblog, taken from What might happen on specials?

    The allocation is:

    National 59
    Labour 43
    Greens 8
    Maori 3 (+2 overhang)
    United
    Future 1
    ACT 5

    Now who is most at risk from specials? They are the party that is in List Spot 120. And that is National.

    The quotient for National is 951145/117 = 8129.4. And who is in spot 121? Labour with 706666/87 = 8122.6.

    Very roughly if Labour pick up 600 more votes relative to National, then they get one more List MP, and National loses one. That is not at all impossible.

    But could someone else grab it off National. The Greens have spot 124, being 134622/17 = 7918.9. They would need to gain an extra 3,600 votes (on top of their existing proportion of votes) from specials. That is a bit of an ask, but they have done well on special traditionally.

    The next candidate on each relevant list is Conway Powell for National, Damien O’Connor for Labour and Kennedy Graham for the Greens.

  • The Voting is Over

    Curiablog‘s final results:

    National 59 (46.8%)
    Labour 44 (34.6%)
    Green 10 (8.1%)
    ACT 3 (2.6%)
    Maori 4 (2.4%)
    United Future 1 (0.5%)
    Progressive 1 (0.2%)

    There will be an overhang so the magic number to chase is a majority of 122 seats.

    Most likely formulae are:

    National+ACT+United Future = 63 seats
    Labour+Prog+Greens = 55 seats

    Other possibilities could happen. The next days will tell.

    Of note:

    • John Key is New Zealand’s new Prime Minister
    • Helen Clark is standing down
    • Labour will be in opposition with a new leader
    • NZ First and Winston Peters are gone
    • Roger Douglas is back
    • National List MPs include up to Conway Powell number 59
    • Labour List MPs include up to Stuart Nash number 36

    (Special votes may affect some of the above a little)