Category: Social Commentary

  • My Story: Lousy ACC Cover and Thoughts on the Proposed Changes

    Yesterday I applied for and got a one week extension on my research project as I couldn’t keep up with the necessary pace to finish it by Friday – I was getting too sore. This means that open mic week(s) needs to continue a little longer so please bear with us and do submit a guest post.

    Whilst we are trying to have blinkers on in terms of anything but study and essential day to day life, there have been some issues that have come up that we really want to blog on but lack the time. One in particular really has me going – the proposed changes to ACC.

    There is not point in repeating what most bloggers of my political persuasion have already opined, I’ll just throw down a few thoughts from my own perspective as an ACC client.

    My first point is that ACC is not welfare. It is an Accident Compensation Scheme. Accident compensation is about restoring a victim of an accident that was not their fault to as close as possible the state they were in pre-accident. Tort law is the area of law that, in the absence of state interference, covers injury caused by people’s negligence – what we call “accidents” here in New Zealand. Tort law says that you must take your victim as you find them; restoration, assessment of harm, is not to be based on the average person but on that person, the victim.

    My next point that I’d like you to keep in mind as you read this is that I think that ACC should be private and fault based. This is my ideal. My ideal is not reality as in New Zealand, accident compensation is state run. While it remains state funded, while the option to sue my injurer remains unavailable to me by statute, it must function as a just and fair accident compensation scheme, run in line with tort jurisprudence.

    “The assessor ACC sent around told me, get this, that my 8 and 9 year olds should be doing all the washing, vacuuming, dishes, etc! Unbelievable! I would, justifiably, have CYF on my doorstep if took that advice.”

    I have some criticisms of the proposed changes based on that fundamental premise ACC is built on, that it is supposed to be an accident compensation scheme. I reiterate, I support moves in the direction of privatisation e.g. rebates for those who take out private accident insurance. I agree that it should not be available to those who get hurt participating in crime. I think it should not be available to those who self-harm when they have refused treatment and are culpable for the self-harm (I think self-harm is not as cut and dried as people think). I also think, given how bankrupt ACC is, that it is only realistic that the money come from somewhere, increased levies are inevitable as is some threshold or excess level. However, that is about as far as I’ll go with the government on this one. Getting it right as to what should be cut and what must be left is crucial and ACC and the new proposals FAIL miserably on this score.

    People say that ACC is “excellent cover” and a “great scheme” but I disagree. I have lived on it for the past year and half since a car accident required the big black thing, in the middle of the below MRI scan of my neck, to be inserted into my neck. See how it is making a bulge into my spinal cord (the long dark gray thing in the middle)?

    My MRI

    Anyway, having set out my premises, disclosed my bias and established that I am, in fact, injured, now judge for yourself if you think my cover is excellent or great or even adequate.

    Pre-accident I was the main bread-winner for our family which comprises 4 children and two adults. I worked for a generous company that gave regular pay rises, gifts and outings to its staff and sometimes their families. I had access to discounted (sometimes free) cereal products and sandwich spreads which helped a lot with the family grocery bill. The company paid for my university fees, my text books and for me to attend lectures so I could complete my law degree. I had a career path set out in front of me, there was a ladder to climb. Matt worked part-time/fixed-term jobs within academia as he has struggled to find full time work as an academic within New Zealand. That worked for us as someone had to be home with the kids, though we would have preferred it the other way around, Matt full-time as an academic and me part-time but you know, life’s like that sometimes and as a family you make the best of it.

    In March 08, whilst I was lawfully stopped at traffic lights, having left work heading for Uni, a woman drove into the back of my car, smashed me into the car in front, writing off my car and destroying two of the discs in my neck which led to disc replacement surgery in Dec 08. She was never charged, I was never given an explanation as to what happened, oh and, she never even had the decency to come over to my car and see if I was alright – other people, passers by and the occupants of the car in front, called the ambulance and stayed with me. As far as I know she got to go back to her life with only her own car insurance claim to worry about and she doesn’t have a clue about what happened to me (my injuries were initially mis-diagnosed as mild whiplash).

    My employer got put through hell. All sorts of ACC nightmares ( I was officially on the clock) that took managers out of their normal jobs. My managers had to put up with temp after temp who couldn’t quite do my job because they didn’t have my institutional knowledge of the company. Nevertheless work sent me flowers, phoned me and held my job far longer than they legally had to. Eventually, when it became apparent I was not going to be fit for work for a very long time, if ever, they let me go but threw me a big party and gave me a leaving present.

    ACC’s treatment of me was a different story.

    We live on 80% of the full-time salary I was earning two years ago. No pay rises, no perks, no discounted household products or entertainment. No uni fees, no text books… So in reality it is not 80% of the income I was on as part of that income was not not salary, it is less than 80%.

    How would you and your household  cope with a 20%+ drop in your income?

    Then there are the extra costs that ACC do not cover:

    Because I cannot just go to the chemist and get my pain medications without a prescription, I have to pay $20 a pop to my GP every 6 weeks to get the piece of paper that says I can get my pain meds. I tell the GP what drugs I want, how many and the GP rubber stamps it.

    Every 12 weeks my specialist wants an x-ray. These cost me $35 a pop.

    We have to purchase a tube of deep heat every week – it’s $8-10 depending on supermarket specials.

    Then there is the petrol spent driving to the GP, pharmacy and specialist (his office is a decent drive). There is also the removal of Matt from whatever work or study he is doing to attend these appointments as I often cannot drive to them. Then there is the babysitting to get rid of the kids so I can attend these.

    Add in the random stuff, MRI scans, visits to pain clinics and you get a more of these costs.

    The expensive supportive bed we had to purchase so I could sleep cost a couple of grand.

    Then there is the $200 pillow – it is a neck injury that I have afterall.

    We recently purchased a monster bean bag so I have something supportive I can sit in, it is excellent for recovering after I have overdone it and it will be vital for exams and for having something portable when I want/need to go out – I can now spend a weekend-day at the beach with my kids for example. It cost $150.

    Then there is Osteo treatment. Osteo treatment reduces the level of pain drugs I need to take by almost half. It is a very effective form of treatment. I am in less pain, I have improved function as a result of less pain, I can get more out of my life and I take less drugs. Osteo is GOOD. This costs me $35 per week. (Physio is free but physio is not effective for this injury – I have seen half a dozen different physios and none can produce the results anything like what osteo treatment can). As a family we made the sacrifices necessary to find that $35 a week. Until last week when my Osteo informed me that ACC had declined to fund their part of the treatment. I now owe my Osteo $75 for the 3 treatments that  I had after ACC decided they were not going to keep funding treatment but didn’t bother to tell me or the Osteo. If I want to continue Osteo I have to find $60 a week now.

    But see above, I don’t have $60 spare a week. ACC does not even come close to restoring me to what I had before I was the victim of an accident.

    So it is back to being a curled up ball of pain with no life or being completely fuzzed out on drugs.

    Did I mention that continually taking the drugs (before I discovered osteo) irritated my stomach and caused so much pain to my stomach that I was admitted to hospital last year?

    Apparently this decision makes sense to someone in ACC.

    How does one quantify the mental costs? The stress, the cost to my family, my children not having me able to  actively participate in the physical aspects of their lives, knowing I will probably never be able to do the sport I love again?

    But that’s not all. Then there are the battles with ACC.

    They are trying to get me off their books. Now I get that. People bludge, make claims they are not entitled to and ACC needs to work out who should be on their books and who should not. However, when you have someone on your books who is in the constant, intense pain I am in, who has their life as altered as mine is, who has doctors and specialists and osteos and physios and everyone who has examined them singing the same tune, that should tell you something. That should tell you that paying a consultant to come around to that person’s house and spend two hours plus with them and then go away and write up a report stating what potential jobs that person could do if they went back to work is a tad premature. Especially when that person is but 2 papers away from having a law degree as obtaining the law degree dramatically changes the types of jobs that person will be able to do. But no, after ACC did this they then sent me to their own specialist, just yesterday, to get him to agree that I could do said recommended jobs.

    They told me that if he said I could work 35 hours (30 hours under the new changes) then I would lose the 80% of my wage that ACC pay me and if in fact I couldn’t work that I would get sickness benefit instead (considerably less than 80% of my wage). Thankfully, the specialist on meeting with me agreed that it was extremely premature for me to be seeing him to discuss work options given the pain levels and almost seemed embarrassed at having been put in this position by ACC when it was so obvious – I have an outstanding MRI result that I have the scans for but not the result, that may or may not rule out more surgery and the pain clinic has just accepted me for their program but I am yet to do it – that I am a long way away from being able to work.

    The taxpayer footed the bill for all of the above and it was not only unnecessary but extremely worrying for us. An example of ACC working to a time-formula rather than on the file facts.

    Even more worrying is that under the proposed new changes ACC will not have to factor in my former salary level.  In the meeting with the consultant who looked at my job skill set, the fact I knew how to make coffee and run a restaurant meant that things like waitressing, barista work, etc came up. I knew how to do these things from the crap jobs that one picks up when one is a student or is going through rough patch but I hated those jobs. I absolutely never want to have to do though sorts of jobs again. I worked hard and gained skill sets and then gained a job that I loved that was using those new skills precisely so that I did not have to do, what I viewed as, crap jobs. Further it is not my fault that I lost that job. Thankfully a policy existed that meant that ACC could only push me towards jobs that paid within the ball-park of my previous job and used my skill-set so the risk of having to take a crap job in the event I recovered was minimised.

    However that policy is about to be axed.

    Amongst National’s proposed changes to ACC is the removal of that policy, if passed it will mean that if ACC find you a crap job using the skills obtained from you old after school job you have to take it, even if your pre-accident job was something much better paid and more prestigious and fulfilling. That is just not ok. It is not adequate compensation at all. If I was on unemployment benefit I would take any job I could get – in fact being unemployed is precisely how I came to get cafe and restaurant experience in the first place, I did take any job I could get. But this is different. I am not on welfare, I am on ACC.

    Then there is the home help thing. We have 4 kids. Two of our kids, our boys, have disabilities (Aspergers Syndrome and as-yet-undiagnosed-but-diabolically-behaved). Matt has this  year gone off to teachers training college so he can get a post-grad diploma in teaching (more state bollocks but that’s another post) so he can improve his chances of obtaining full-time work and get our family back above the bread-line – so he is not  home much. Mon-Fri I am at home with our 8 and 9 year olds who are homeschooled largely because of the undiagnosed condition of the youngest. I cannot do dishes, washing (we do 1-2 loads per day), vaccuming, mopping, picking up, etc. Matt and Sherry (17 year old at Uni) get home frequently, after dinner, and then have assignments and study to do as well as helping as much as they can with housework.

    ACC were giving me 6 hours a week home help to stay on top of those day-time things which meant that if Matt and Sherry got stuck into the rest around their studies we could keep on top of our housework. ACC mysteriously slashed my home help, to 2 hours a week. When I protested it I got given a review. The reviewer was really harsh. She kept saying that ACC will only pay for washing to be done once a week, vacuuming once a week, etc – though no policy proving that was shown to me and when I asked “well how did I used to get 6 hours a week, has been a policy change?” this was dodged. She kept saying other people cope, you have a husband and two teenagers they should be helping. When I pointed out that they are, that they are permanently exhausted from all they do and I feel like a bad mother for the amount Sherry helps with yet my house is still a mess as they are leaving the house at 6.30am and coming home after 6pm with assignments and doing what they can but it is not enough, also that  our 14 year old has Aspergers Syndrome and just panics and goes loopy if he is asked to do much more than a batch of dishes, he has a mental condition, it is not reasonable to expect too much from him.  In response to this, the assessor ACC sent around told me, get this, that my 8 and 9 year olds should be doing all the washing, vacuuming, dishes, etc! Unbelievable! I would, justifiably, have CYF on my doorstep if took that advice. I’m all for encouraging the kids to help out – it is part of being a family, it is how one learns to do these things for adult life but pulling the slack left by an adult incapable of running the house is going beyond too far for most, let alone 8 and 9 year olds!

    Once I am free of exam and research I am going to do a massive appeal over this, a heap of energy expended fighting for something I shouldn’t have to fight for, but in the mean-time don’t visit because my house is a tip – I am horribly embarrassed by it but short of hurting myself or treating my young children like slaves or having Matt and Sherry give up sleep – they are both exhausted – there is not much I can do about it. It is again ridiculous and another example of lousy cover. There were no medical indicators to support their decision to slash my home help, my specialist, the specialist ACC  sent me to yesterday and my GP agree that I need a good 4-6  hours a week home help but ACC will not listen to them.

    If you think I am starting to sound like a bludger who wants to get picky whilst resting on the taxpayer I remind you that ACC is not welfare, it is compensation, it is supposed to restore me to my pre-accident life because, due to no fault of my own, I was a victim of someone else’s negligence.  This policy will fall well short of that goal. If I am made to go waitressing our family will have to take a $30,000+ drop in pay and I’ll be stuck with a mind-numbing, dead-end job. Why? because I lawfully stopped at a traffic light and the state has set up the law so that the person who injured me was allowed to just walk away, I cannot sue and we are all penalised so hard via taxation that only the wealthy can afford to pay twice and get private accident insurance? How is that just?

    I am not saying that I don’t think I should have to go back to work, when/if I am recovered and able to unless I have a job every bit as excellent as the job I had before the accident (that is probably unrealistic as I had it very good) but it is reasonable to want something close surely? To want something at least in the ball-park pay wise and with a future attached it it? Is that asking too much given that several years of pain-hell will have passed before I ever/if I ever get to that point?

    If ACC cannot provide good support and restore people to something at least resembling the victim of an accident’s pre-injury life then it needs to be axed and handed over to the private sector. It cannot, see above, so axe it now.

    To those of you insisting it remain state owned and protesting raises in levies ask yourself, how would you cope if you  were injured and were in my situation? Your career cut-off, your income slashed, the treatment options that were working now just out of reach and your future bleak? Is it worth the socialist-joy of knowing that “we own it”?

    A better question, if you had to pay for accident compensation and you had the money to do so would you choose a company who gave the cover as outlined above or would shop around?

  • Common Historical Myths About the Church

    This post is part update, part recycle.

    Earlier on in this blog’s life, I ran a small series of posts last year on common historical myths about the Church that  are so pervasive in society that most Christians fall for them. Anyway, after receiving some correspondence, I have updated this post, More on the “Dark Ages” and Other Propaganda.

    [I hope I am being mysterious enough to make you want to check it out – especially you Bethyada]

    RELATED POSTS:
    The “Dark Ages” and Other Propaganda
    More on the “Dark Ages” and Other Propaganda
    Things They Don’t Teach you in Public Schools…
    The Flat Earth Myth
    Contra Mundum: The Flat-Earth Myth
    Guest Post: Dan Brown’s History of Science

  • Guest Post: Corruption Rampant in Student Unions Throughout New Zealand

    Andy Moore penned this guest post. It follows nicely on from ScrubOne’s:

    “Free hamburgers and sausage sizzle, $5 jugs of beer” read the advertisement in the student magazine CANTA, a week or so before the University of Canterbury Student Association’s (UCSA) AGM. The quorum for the AGM is 120 students as established in the constitution, and it was pitiful to read the president pleading in his weekly column for people to come along. Of course they’d already attempted to run the AGM the week before, but hadn’t made the quorum. So out with the bribes and cheap beer and let’s try this one again. And where else to host the AGM than outside the student pub, in the amphitheatre? From a compulsory membership of 18,000 students, the UCSA was struggling to make up this poorly representative quorum by offering cheap alcohol and free food, only it wasn’t free because the students paid for it in their levy – yep, even the ones who didn’t attend the meeting. Oh, but perhaps I’m coming down a bit strong – after all, the agenda for the meeting was seeking to raise the quality of life for students. Ahem. Seeking to raise the quality of life for the students on the Exec, by raising all their salaries, including bumping the president’s salary up over the $50k mark. With a budget close to $9m ($1.2m from student levy in 2008) and aprox $400k expenditure by the Exec on a yearly basis it makes you wonder where all the money is going. All the while you’ve got growing frustration from students at steadily increasing food-costs on campus with only one cafe operating that is not owned by the University or UCSA.

    Meanwhile in Wellington, pro-VSM students have got together, primarily from within the ACT on Campus and Young Nats groups, and outflanked the executive and other pro-compulsion students at Victoria University. As Jenna Raeburn says in her live-blog post, “a bunch of liberty lovers and I decide to exercise our rights as (unwilling) members of VUWSA and attend their Student Representative Council”. Ultimately, “The motion passes 45-35! [how does this work when there are only 63 people here??? where did these 35 come from?] VUWSA supports the Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment Bill.” You can read Jenna’s full account of the meeting here – as she says, “VUWSA can’t even count hands or run a meeting, and we subject tens of thousands of students to their antics and put them in charge of millions of dollars every year?” – and without consent of their constituents (students) at that! The ACT on Campus Youtube channel has full footage of the meeting which is a real eye-opener. Vice President of ACT on Campus NZ summarily congratulated VUWSA on their stance on VSM in an (albeit) tongue-in-cheek press release later that evening. However the VUWSA exec aren’t going to go down without a fight and so are attempting to illegally veto the decision made at the annual meeting that took place on Wednesday.

    Roger Douglas’s private members bill to bring freedom of association into student unions will go a long way in addressing this snapshot of problems.

  • Guest Post: VUWSA’s VSM Violations

    When ScrubOne sent us this offering as a guest post we couldn’t resist. This sort of thing has been happening for years and we saw it a lot back at Waikato University but that was pre-You Tube…gotta love the internet.

    DPF links to some videos of a student meeting held at the University of Wellington where some students decided to show up and demand their association (VUWSA) support compulsory membership.

    The association insiders try to shut it down by

    • breaking rules
    • announcing lack of quorum in a packed room (wait till the camera turns around – it’s absurd)
    • ignoring the result of votes

    In other words, they employed every trick in the book legal and illegal to try and stop students having their say.

    Watch it for yourself (you may need to hunt down parts 2 and 3 as it doesn’t seem to have been set into a playlist)

    DPF reports that they’re now using similar tactics to overturn the result by scheduling a meeting…

    So an illegal meeting, in breach of their own constitution, held in a bar at 11 am on a Friday (when all good students are hungover) is the first response of the compulsion lovers.

    But it gets even better. After forceful representations about the illegality of the proposed Friday meeting (not that the forces of compulsion did the same thing at WSU – hold a vote with only a day or two’s notice) including a potential injunction, the compulsionaters have come up with an even better plan.

    They have simply declared the Wednesday meeting void  on the grounds two VUWSA people declare a quorum count of 45, less than the required 50. Now note the resolution was passed with 80 people voting and a later quorum count (with one independent person) found there to be over 60 people present, and this count was done within the 30 minutes allowed in the constitution.

    The chances of the VUWSA putting in a submission in support of VSM are roughly those of a snowball’s chance in hell. Even if they accept the legality of this vote (which they won’t) and the illegality of the new meeting (which they won’t) they will simply ignore the motion or spin it away somehow.

    But that’s the point – the more VUWSA refuse to obey their own rules, and ignore their own members, the more they demonstrate the need for students to be allowed to remove their support from the association.

  • Dargaville: Public Meeting on S59

    John Boscawen is holding a series of Public Meetings in various locations around New Zealand promoting his Bill to amend s59 of the Crimes Act to legalise the use of some types of reasonable force for the purposes of parental correction. Whilst the government would like everyone to think that this debate is over, Boscawen’s Bill is still alive; he has shrewdly removed it from impending vote and will re-admit it much closer to the next election. His next meeting is in Dargaville:

    When: Monday 12 October, 7.00 pm
    Where: Dargaville Town Hall, 37 Hokianga Road, Dargaville

    Speaking with him will be Larry Baldock. The local MP, John Carter, has also been invited. Other speakers to be advised.

    For more information, contact: Karen Bridgman on 09 531 5531 or kbridgman@xtra.co.nz

    See my review of the Auckland version of this event.

  • R v Field Sentencing Decision now Online

    Justice Hansen’s official sentencing notes in the case of The Queen v Phillip Hans Field (a.k.a former Member of Parliament, Taito Phillip Field) are now online and make for some interesting reading.

    To begin with, as I read through, I could see Field’s supporters angle; he helped a couple of people out, they thanked him by offering to do some work for him, seems harmless enough. However, when this pattern was repeated over and over and over by people needing immigration help who just happened to have house renovating skills and who just happened to take holidays near Field’s houses, which are scattered around New Zealand and overseas, and whilst on these holidays undertook largely unpaid work as tokens of appreciation and gratitude which then sees  Field able to make large profits on the sale of his renovated houses it starts to look suss. Especially given the immigration hassles of these people just happened to go away around the same time as their free work for Field.

    Clearly a perception grew in certain communities that the way to get immigration hassles sorted in New Zealand was to do free house renovation work for the Immigration Minister. This is not a good look and I can see why it attracted investigation and why the court found Field guilty of bribery, corruption and perverting the course of justice.

    Field’s lawyers are talking appeals so it will be interesting to see what their angle is if they proceed.

  • Mentionables

    Flat out busy as the end of semester approaches and deadlines and exams loom we thought we’d link to some blog posts we’ve recently found interesting rather than actually write anything ourselves:

    Wintery Knight has a video for which his blog post title sums up the content: MUST-SEE: Megyn Kelly of Fox News exposes the truth about ACORN

    Cactus Kate has posted one of the more sensible yet moving blog posts we’ve read on the Samoa Tsunami: It’s A Long Way Back – Alofa Samoa

    Bethyada posts a timely quote from Cicero: Random quote

    The Prosblogion’s account of a recent conference at the University of Notre Dame where leading theistic philosophers and leading sceptics discussed hard texts from the Old Testament and their relationship to theistic belief: Thoughts from the Notre Dame conference, “My Ways Are Not Your Ways”

    Kiwiblog has an excellent piece on Voluntary Student Membership responding to Jacinda Arden’s account of what happened at Waikato University when membership of the campus students association briefly ceased being compulsory. Given that Matt and I were President and Vice-President respectively of the then voluntary Waikato Students Union and helped to make it voluntary, we are very glad to see that the facts are being put straight faster than the left can invent new fantasies on blogs other than our own: Fisking Jacinda